
tripleC 7(2): 243-292, 2009 279
CC: Creative Commons License, 2009.
of natural resources. The latter are
transformed into economic goods by the
application of technologies to nature and
society in labour processes. Hence the
economy is based on a dialectic of natural
resources and labour that is mediated by
technology. We hence can argue that socially
transformed nature and technology are
aspects of the economic system.
This allows us to make a distinction
between the base and the superstructure of
society. The economic base is constituted by
the interplay of labour, technology, and nature
so that economic goods are produced that
satisfy human needs. The superstructure is
made up by the interconnection of the political
and the cultural system so that immaterial
goods emerge, which allow the definition of
collective decisions and societal value
structures. Does it make sense to speak of
base (nature, technology, economy) and
superstructure (polity, culture) in society, or
does this mean that one reduces all social
existence to economic facts? The
superstructure is not a mechanic reflection,
that is, a linear mapping, of the base, that is,
the relations and forces of production. It
cannot be deduced from or reduced to it.
Orthodox Marxism for a long time did not
realize this. That the base is not the mechanic
reflection of the superstructure has for a long
time not been realized by Idealism. All human
activity is based on producing a natural and
social environment; it is in this sense that the
notion of the base is of fundamental
importance. We have to eat and survive
before we can and in order to enjoy leisure,
entertainment, arts, and so on. We will survive
for a while without leisure, art, entertainment,
education, and decision-making, but only for a
very short time without water and food. This
shows that the economy is more fundamental
and grounding in society than the political and
the cultural system. The base is a
precondition, a necessary but not sufficient
condition for the superstructure. The
superstructure is a complex, nonlinear
creative reflection of the base, the base a
complex, nonlinear creative reflection of the
superstructure. This means that both levels
are recursively linked and produce each other;
economic practices and structures trigger
political and cultural processes; cultural and
political practices and structures trigger
economic processes. The notion of creative
reflection grasps the dialectic of chance and
necessity/indetermination and determination
that shapes the relationship of base and
superstructure. There is not a content of the
superstructure that is “predicted, prefigured
and controlled” by the base; the base, as
Raymond Williams in his famous paper on
Base and Superstructure in Marxist Cultural
Theory says, “sets limits and exerts pressure”
on the superstructure (Williams, 2001, p. 165).
Stuart Hall (1983) has in this context spoken
of a determination in the first instance exerted
by the economic system on superstructures.
What are the implications of a dialectical
model of base and superstructure for the
notion of information? If we conceive
information as an integrative notion, then it
must dialectically stretch across base and
superstructure. This means that it is neither
just an economic resource (e.g. information
technology), nor just ideas, but should best be
conceived as both objective and subjective.
This can be achieved by defining information
as a process of cognition, communication,
and co-operation (Hofkirchner, 2002; Fuchs,
2008). It is a relationship that connects agents
in a productive way so that they can produce
novelty. It is the dynamic aspect of social
systems. This then means that all three
outlined subsystems have aspects of
information, aspects of cognition,
communication, and co-operation: In order to
produce goods, humans need plans,
communicative co-ordination of production,
and co-operative labour processes. In order to
take collective decisions, political opinions,
political interaction, and actual decision-
procedures involving many actors are needed.
In order to establish collective norms,
individual worldviews, moral discourse, and
the emergence of collective identities are
needed. A critical theory of information
questions conditions, in which structural
resources such as property, decision-making
capacities, value definition-capacities are
asymmetrically distributed, certain actors are
excluded from participation, and the one
derive benefits at the expense of others.
We can speak of participation in cases,
where humans are enabled by technologies,
resources, organizations, and skills to design