tripleC 5(3): 104-109, 2007
ISSN 1726-670X
http://tripleC.uti.at
CC: Creative Commons License, 2007.
Review:
Marcello Barbieri (Ed) (2007) Introduction to Biosemiotics. The
new biological synthesis. Dordrecht: Springer
Günther Witzany
telos – Philosophische Praxis
Vogelsangstr. 18c
A-5111-Buermoos/Salzburg
Austria
E-mail: witzany@sbg.at
1 Thematic background
Maybe it is no chance that the discovery of the
genetic code occurred during the hot phase of
philosophy of science discourse about the role of
language in generating models of scientific ex-
planation. The code-metaphor was introduced
parallel to other linguistic terms to denote lan-
guage like features of the nucleic acid sequence
molecules such as “code without commas”
(Francis Crick). At the same time the 30 years of
trying to establish an exact scientific language to
delimit objective sentences from non-objective
ones derived one of his peaks in the linguistic
turn.
1.1 Changing subjects of knowledge
The crucial steps of early Wittgenstein and
scholars of logical empiricism to delimitate scien-
tific sentences from non-scientific ones, the fol-
lowing failure of all trials to establish a scientific
language of theory which would be coherent with
the language of observations, or to define a sci-
entific language which could be able to depict
objective reality in a one to one fashion, lead to
the unescapeable effort to get clear how we can
define human language according to its main
principles; i.e., all three semiotic levels of rules
not only from the (objective) observer perspec-
tive but even more from the (subjective) perspec-
tive of participants. This would be coherent to the
evidence, that without utterances we can not in-
tegrate our position into any discourse. Even
without utterances we act as non-uttering indi-
viduals being dependent on the discourse de-
rived meaning processes of a linguistic (e.g. sci-
entific) community.
This position marks the primary difference to
the subject of knowledge of Kantian knowledge
theories wherein one subject alone in principle
could be able to generate sentences in which it
generates knowledge. This abstractive fallacy
was ruled out in the early 50s of the last century
being replaced by the “community of investiga-
tors” (Peirce) represented by the scientific com-
munity in which every single scientist is able the
place his utterance looking for being integrated
in the discourse community in which his utter-
ances will be proven whether they are good ar-
guments or not. Definitively the solus ipse sub-
ject of knowledge was replaced by the “indefinite
community of investigators” which doesn’t not
produce ever lasting knowledge principles about
scientific areas, but try to get forward in discur-
sive truthfulness “in the long run” (Peirce) princi-
pally ending with human species in an “ultimate
opinion” (Peirce) of the things which are dis-
cussed.
1.2 Anthropomorphistic use of language me-
tapher in early molecular biology
The code-metaphor introduced on modern biol-
ogy therefore was an escape of pure physics
and chemistry because it introduced certain fea-
tures of languages into the description of chemi-
cal structures. What seemed to be an obvious
tripleC 5(3): 104-109, 2007
105
© Vienna University of Technology 2003.
anthropomorphism was the introduction of lin-
guistic terms on biological sciences and medi-
cine when they used phrases like “communica-
tion within cells”, “communication between cells”,
“genetic code”, “genetic text sequence”, “chemi-
cal messengers”, “neuronal communication”,
“hormonal communication”, “transcription of the
nucleic acid language”, “amino acid language”,
“translation of RNA in DNA”, “Letter pairs of
DNA”, and so on.
The investigations of biological disciplines and
subdisciplines according the knowledge of the
genetic code are legendary. It led to the most
developing field of science we know today.
It started the first 3 decades that main investi-
gation focused on the “molecular syntax”
(Manfred Eigen), i.e. the combinatorial patterns
of nucleic acids and its corresponding protein
acid sequences which determined protein struc-
tures being the constituents of both of any uni-
cellular until most complex multicellular organism
and its developmental substeps. This lead to the
complete deciphering of the human genome in
late 1990ies. But immediately it became clear
that the knowledge of a complete sequence or-
der of an organism doesn’t mean to know the
complete meaning function which is really inher-
ent in the genome storage medium.
1.3 Genetic expression is no one way
This marks a development which arose in early
1980ies where it became clear more and more,
that behind the superficial grammar of molecular
syntax there is something like a deep grammar
of regulation networks which determines the
meaning function of a nucleic sequence order.
According to the general features of any real
language – a real language is a sign system
which functions according to the complementary
syntactic, pragmatic and semantic rules – there
are several levels of higher order regulatory
functions which are decisive for the expression
and replication patterns of nucleic acid se-
quences: it means that different environmental
influences, i.e. the situational context an organ-
ismic individual is interwoven, determines the
higher order regulation of replication patterns.
This means that of the defined nucleic acid order
sequence it is possible to express a great variety
of different expression patterns which may be
even contradictory: from the same nucleic acid
order it is possible to produce different protein
meanings. And these different protein meanings
may even derive without altering the genetic
code or being inheritable. Under certain circum-
stances these alterations may even be heritable
at all.
This knowledge marked the importance of epi-
genetics, i.e. of environmental influences on pro-
tein level which can influence via second mes-
sengers the amino acid level, even in coding
functions (which would be a neo-lamarckian per-
spective). For long this view has been ignored or
in the realm of Neo-Darwinism dogmatically ta-
booed, it now becomes more and more impor-
tant. Now we know that in the human genome
only 3 % of the complete genetic data-set are
protein coding sequences. The formerly termed
“junk DNA”, the noncoding DNA sequences, is
now being recognized as higher order regulatory
functions which are crucial for an appropriate de-
termination of the protein coding sequences. The
difference in the protein coding sequence be-
tween human and mouse is only 12 %, so the
differences depend on the higher order regula-
tory functions.
1.4 Superficial and deep grammar of genome
storage medium
This different development in the awareness of
different levels of nucleic acid storage medium
DNA is important because it marks the difference
of nucleic acid language to a one to one depic-
tion of meaning functions in the genetic code.
Obviously there is a superficial grammar (which
in the case of the human genome is deciphered
since the human genome project) and a hierar-
chical network of higher order regulatory func-
tions which could be termed as a genome-editing
MetaCode (Witzany 2006) characterized by the
strong hierarchical interdependency of all higher
order regulatory modules which we are far away
to know in all details.
Interestingly this structure of language features
was detected in the early 60s also in human lan-
guage according to the change of linguistic turn
to pragmatic turn in the theory of science discus-
sion when reflecting on the validity claims being
held with any utterance in speech acts which
showed both:
a) that speech acts are apriori social ac-
tions i.e. intersubjective actions which
avoid the omnipresent problem of phi-
losophies of consciousness how to make
the move from a state of private (solus
ipse) consciousness (sender/coding-
receiver/decoding narrative) to a state of
mutual agreement and mutual coopera-
tion;
b) that pure analyses of language and lan-
guage like structures based on syntactic
or syntactic/semantic investigations are
not able to extract illocutionary meanings
hidden in the pragmatic (situational) con-
texts which determines different mean-
Witzany, Günther
106
.
CC: Creative Commons License, 2007.
ings of identical syntactic data-sets (Wit-
zany 2000).
It is obvious that the language games which are
played in recent research are not fully compati-
ble. On the one side biological sciences (which
define themselves as natural sciences investigat-
ing observations according to the universal natu-
ral laws of physics and chemistry) which now
have to deal with linguistic rules with features
which cannot be deduced of natural laws. On the
other side a coherent language and communica-
tion theory which is limited to the human self-
understanding.
2 The new player in this universal discourse:
Biosemiotics
At this point a new discipline holds validity claims
in this universal discourse: Biosemiotics.
Biosemiotics investigates rule-governed sign-
mediated interactions within and between cells,
tissues, organs and organisms. As Howard Pat-
tee (2005, pp.299) stated: “Life is distinguished
from the nonliving world by its dependence on
signs”. Biosemiotics also investigates processes
and interdependences in the realm of genetics/
genomics/proteomics which have features of
icons, indices or symbols. The first “Introduction
to Biosemiotics” has now been published.
”Introduction to Biosemiotics” combines ap-
proaches from semiotics, linguistics, semantics,
biology, philosophy, systems theory, theory of
science, physics and information theory. All con-
tributions share the conviction that the main
processes of coordination and information ex-
change within and between living organisms,
from single cell to most complex multicellular life,
are mediated by the use of signs. Every sign
process (=semiosis) is coherent with the laws of
physics and chemistry. But in difference to phys-
ico-chemical interactions in the non-living world
semioses are inherently connected with semiotic
rules. According to Charles Morris and Charles
Sanders Peirce, every sign use is characterized
by rules of combination (syntax), context (prag-
matics) and content (semantics). The comple-
mentarity of these 3 levels of rules in every sign-
process enables de novo generation of signs,
combinatorial changes, and alternative use of
the same sequences to transport different mes-
sages with different meanings. Biosemiotics, as
introduced by this book, strives to do more than
merely promote the biological disciplines from
the perspective of rule-governed sign-mediated
interactions between living organisms; its validity
claim is also to better understand the linguistic
features of nucleic acid sequences and their
regulations. Biosemiotics therefore proclaims
both a communicative approach to sign-
mediated interactions among living organisms
and a linguistic/semiotic approach to nucleic acid
language and protein language. Biosemiotics in-
tegrates these approaches by investigating a va-
riety of organic codes, which means that the de-
cisive difference between life and non-life is the
generation and use of codes.
3 The contributions
The book is divided into three parts.
Part 1 – “Historical Background” with contribu-
tions by Donald Favareau (The Evolutionary His-
tory of Biosemiotics), Tuomo Jämsä (Semiosis in
Evolution), Marcello Barbieri (Has Biosemiotics
Come of Age? and Postscript).
Part 2 – “Theoretical Issues” with contributions
by Howard Pattee (The Necessity of Biosemiot-
ics: Matter-Symbol Complementarity), Stanley
Salthe (What is the Scope of Biosemiotics? In-
formation in Living Systems), Jesper Hoffmeyer
(Semiotic Scaffolding of Living Systems), Kalevi
Kull (Biosemiotics and Biophysics – The Funda-
mental Approaches to the Study of Life),
Marcello Barbieri (Is the Cell a Semiotic Sys-
tem?), Stefan Artmann (Computing Codes ver-
sus Interpreting Life), Anton Markos and co-
workers (Towards a Darwinian Biosemiotics. Life
as Mutual Understanding), Tommi Vehkavaara
(From the Logic of Science to the Logic of the
Living. The Relevance of Charles Peirce to
Biosemiotics), Marcel Danesi (Towards a Stan-
dard Terminology for (Bio)semiotics), Gérard
Battail (Information Theory and Error-Correcting
Codes in Genetics and Biological Evolution).
Part 3 – “Biosemiotic Research” with contribu-
tions by Marcella Faria (RNA as Code Makers: A
Biosemiotic View of RNAi and Cell Immunity),
Luis Emilio Bruni (Cellular Semiotics and Signal
Transduction), Stephen Philip Pain (Inner Rep-
resentations and Signs in Animals), Johannes
Huber and Ingolf Schmid-Tannwald (A Biosemi-
otic Approach to Epigenetics: Constructivist as-
pects of Oocyte-to-Embryo transition), Dario
Martinelli (Language and Interspecific Communi-
cation Experiments: a Case to Re-open?).
4 The editorial
In an Editorial, Marcello Barbieri gives a short in-
troduction on biosemiotics. He distinguishes 4
major approaches or schools in biosemiotics.
The first is based on the model of Peirce, pro-
posing that interpretation is a crucial element of
semiosis and that every semiotic system is char-
acterized by a triad (sign, object and interpre-
tant).
In 1974, Marcel Florkin proposed a second
model for biosemiotics, namely the dualistic sys-
tem of Saussure, i.e. that a “signifier and signi-
tripleC 5(3): 104-109, 2007
107
© Vienna University of Technology 2003.
fied” are equivalent to “genotype and pheno-
type”. Thomas Sebeok adopted the Peircian nar-
rative for zoosemiotics. The Peirce-Sebeok
school was the first to be fully accepted by most
biosemioticians, especially the Copenhagen-
Tartu School (Claus Emmeche, Jesper
Hoffmeyer, Kalevi Kull). That the Prague school
of Anton Markos also derived from this model as
suggested in this editorial seems to be risky be-
cause the biohermeneutic approach (first devel-
oped by Sergej Chebanov: Chebanov 1999) de-
rives from hermeneutic science founded by
Hans-Georg Gadamer, whose methodological
aim differs fundamentaly from that of the Peirce-
Sebeok school.
As a third model, Barbieri introduces his se-
mantic theory. It states that the cell is a triad of
genotype, phenotype and ribotype, wherein the
ribotype is the “codemaker”, i.e. the generator of
the molecular syntax of the nucleic acid lan-
guage. He furthermore suggests that, in his con-
cept, the rules of the genetic code do not depend
on interpretational processes.
As a further (fourth) approach, Barbieri names
the model of Howard Pattee and his concept of
epistemic threshold. It differentiates between (i)
physical preconditions for the organic codes and
symbolic regulations and (ii) some kind of emer-
gentism.
5 Two examples of the main chapters
Here, I briefly review two examples within the
main chapters: Certainly, one of the key contri-
butions is Barbieri’s chapter “Is the cell a semi-
otic system?”, in which he attempts to give rea-
sons for his concept of organic codes. He de-
fines a semiotic system as a system “made of
two independent worlds that are connected by
the conventional rules of a code.” (181) These
are two distinct entities for Barbieri, and he re-
places the Peircean semiosis triad (sign, object,
interpretant) by his own triad (sign, meaning,
convention). Important in Barbieri’s concept are
the “copying” and “coding”-processes that repre-
sent crucial differences to the non-living world.
Here, the codemaker is the ribosomal RNA,
which generates chromosomal sequences ac-
cording to the molecular syntax of the nucleic
acid language. This initially involved simple copy
functions. “The first protein-maker had to bring
together three different types of molecules (mes-
senger, ribosomal and transfer RNAs) and was
therefore much more complex than copymak-
ers.” (184) Accordingly, gene sequences differ
from randomly assembled molecules in the non-
animated world because they are a real artefact
produced by “molecular machines based on
RNAs.” (185) This makes the cell a trinity of
genotype, phenotype and ribotype. And the early
RNA world appeared spontaneously. “Eventu-
ally, evolution replaced the ribogenes with genes
and the riboproteins with proteins but the syn-
thesizing ribosoids of the ribotype have never
been replaced. They are the oldest phylogenetic
molecules that exist on earth and they firmly re-
main at the heart of every living cell.” (186)
In this thesis, Barbieri is a forerunner not only
in biosemiotics: his approach gives a coherent
explanation of fundamental processes of life with
its connection to early stages of evolution. This
yields a quasi-subject of linguistic competence:
the ribotype, which throughout the history of life
is able to produce codes by code-making. “The
codemaker is the agent, whereas signs and
meanings are the instruments of semiosis.” (187)
Signs come into life in the coding process of this
code-maker. Thus, signs/meaning and code-
maker/coding are true organic entities.
But the organic code of the ribotype is not the
only conventional organic code – other natural
conventions share the three basic characteristics
of all codes “(1): a correspondence between two
independent worlds, (2) the presence of molecu-
lar adaptors and (3) a set of rules that guarantee
biological specificity.”(190) Barbieri identifies the
splicing codes, the signal transduction codes, the
compartment codes (which are crucial for the
“geographical” destination of a cell), the cy-
toskeletal codes responsible for the necessary
dynamic instability because the number of “dif-
ferent structures that cytoskeleton can create is
potentially unlimited.”(193) Also important are
the sequence codes (such as transcription
codes, gene splicing codes, translation pausing
codes, the DNA structure code, the chromatin
code, the translation framing code, the modula-
tion code and the genome segmentation code).
In a third chapter, Barbieri explains why these
codes are actually physical entities: they are ob-
jective, reproducible and defined by operative
procedures. So “organic information and organic
meaning are both the result of natural processes.
Just as it is an act of copying that creates or-
ganic information, so it is an act of coding that
creates organic meaning. Copying and coding
are the processes, copymakers and codemakers
are their agents, organic information and organic
meaning are their results.” (199) (In this context
see also the interesting contribution of Marcella
Faria in part 3 of this book)
One of the leading positions in biosemiotics is
represented by the Prague-school. A contribution
by its founder Anton Markos and his co-workers
“Towards a Darwinian biosemiotics. Life as mu-
tual understanding” investigates, in a first part,
the preconditions of understanding processes.
This is the only investigation the book contains in
this field. It aims to understand our understand-
ing of sentences, meanings, codes and utter-
ances, which is not definable by formalistic pro-
Witzany, Günther 108
.
CC: Creative Commons License, 2007.
cedures or operationalistic theory of science
definitions. This is a crucial contribution for
biosemiotics if this new discipline desires to be
methodologically coherent. In a second part, the
authors demonstrate an actual biosemiotic inves-
tigation on “corporeality, life and language”,
which is indeed one of the outstanding biosemi-
otic applications. Here, the authors find a defini-
tion for a phenomenon observable in all life
processes: homoplasy. “From the biosemiotic
perspective, homoplasy is not newly derived:
rather, it is a result of the persistence of a
morphogenetic system which became reawak-
ened or re-invented in an unusual context.
Hence, if organisms need to evolve a new adap-
tive structure, they may activate remote morpho-
genetic systems and, under the current circum-
stances, an unexpected shape will appear. From
the biosemiotic point of view, such “realization”
refers both to understanding (becoming aware of
a “knowledge” – of the existence of an engram),
recognition of its significance (acknowledgement
of a mute sign) and its bodily interpretation (to
know the how of the developmental process).”
(252)
6 Conclusions
Ultimately, I try to evaluate the validity claim held
with this “Introduction to Biosemiotics” in the
landscape of modern biological sciences.
(1) Is there any advantage which suggests using
biosemiotics instead of established disciplines
such as biolinguistics or bioinformatics?
Whereas biolinguistics and bioinformatics are
established sciences which are applied for in-
formational and bioengineering purposes by
several biological disciplines, this is not (yet) the
case for biosemiotics. Applied biosemiotic re-
search is less developed, although the research
contributions in this book are interesting and
useful. Biosemiotics in its present status has a
strong focus on theoretical investigations about
the role, function and interpretation of signs ac-
cording to the concepts of Charles Sanders
Peirce, Jakob von Uexküll, Stuart Kauffman,
Howard Pattee and the more recent publications
of Jesper Hoffmeyer, Anton Markos and Marcello
Barbieri. Although this broader view is helpful to
understand the whole dimension of sign proc-
esses in living nature, biolinguistics and bioin-
formatics are without doubt currently the more
practical tools.
(2) Is there a coherent method which serves as a
powerful tool for investigations within all domains
of biological research?
A unique coherent method of biosemiotics
does not yet exist. Biosemiotic investigations rely
on ontological, systems theoretical, naturalistic,
physicalistic, mechanistic, idealistic, metaphysic,
hermeneutic foundation and background knowl-
edge. A theory of science discussion about the
status of language and communication in
biosemiotics, or about the scientific foundation
and justification of sentences within biosemiotics
according to the linguistic and the pragmatic
turn, is missing in this book. The same holds true
for the integration of a post-metaphysical (non-
solus ipse) subject of knowledge.
(3) Is this discipline merely an additional view on
biological phenomenon, or does it have the
paradigmatic power to redefine our understand-
ing of living nature?
The recent main deficit of biosemiotics – the
lack of a uniform method for applied investiga-
tions – may turn out to be its driving force be-
cause it needs to integrate very different aims,
traditions, paradigms. Especially the approach of
Marcello Barbieri (and Marcella Faria) and his
differentiation between “copying” and “coding”-
functions in the evolution of life gives an out-
standing interpretation of recent biological re-
search: In genome rearrangements it is a usual
phenomenon, that in a first step parts of the ge-
nome are simply duplicated (copying) and in a
second step the molecular syntax is recombined
(coding) by a set of small RNAs, microRNAs and
higher order regulations inherent in the non-
protein coding and repetitive elements of the ge-
nome (Witzany 2007). This power of a coherent
explanation biolinguistics or bioinformatics are
lacking.
“Introduction to Biosemiotics” is a key step for-
ward into this dynamic process of creating a new
scientific view on a language-like structure of the
genome organization and storage medium as
well as on rule-governed sign-mediated interac-
tions within and between cells, tissues, organs
and organisms. Should this integration prove
successful in the long run, then biosemiotics
could develop to a major discipline in biology.
References
Barbieri, M. (ed.) (2007) Introduction to Biosemiotics. The
new biological synthesis. Dordrecht: Springer.
Barbieri, M. (2007) Is the Cell a Semiotic System? In: Bar-
bieri, M. (ed.) (2007) Introduction to Biosemiotics. The new
biological synthesis. Dordrecht: Springer.
Chebanov, S. (1999) Biohermeneutics and the Hermeneutics
of Biology. Semiotica 127: 215-226.
Markos, A. Grygar, F; Kleisner K., Neubauer Z. (2007) To-
wards a Darwinian Biosemiotics. Life as Mutual Under-
standing. In:
Barbieri, M. (ed.) (2007) Introduction to
Biosemiotics. The new biological synthesis. Dordrecht:
Springer.
Pattee, H. (2005) The Physics and Metaphysics of Biosemi-
otics. Journal of Biosemiotics 1:281-301.
tripleC 5(3): 104-109, 2007
109
© Vienna University of Technology 2003.
Witzany, G. (2000) Life: The Communicative Strucure. A
New Philosophy of Biology. Norderstedt, Libri Books on
Demand.
Witzany, G. (2006) The Logos of the Bios 1. Contributions to
the Foundation of a three-leveled Biosemiotics. Helsinki,
Umweb.
Witzany, G. (2007) The Logos of the Bios 2. Bio-
Communication. Helsinki, Umweb.