tripleC 5(2): 75-81, 2007
ISSN 1726-670X
http://tripleC.uti.at
CC: Creative Commons License, 2007.
The Origin and Evolution of Language and the Propagation of Or-
ganization
Robert K. Logan
Department of Physics - University of Toronto
60 St. George St.,Toronto M5S 1A7, Ontario, Canada
E-mail: logan@physics.utoronto.ca
Abstract: In this presentation we will study propagating
organization. We begin by examining the evolution and origin
of language by briefly reviewing the impact of the phonetic
alphabet (Logan 2004a), the evolution of notated language
(Logan 2004b), the origin of language and culture (Logan
2006, 2007), the role of collaboration in knowledge manage-
ment (Logan and Stokes 2004), the impact of “new media”
(Logan in preparation). We will then connect this work to the
propagating organization of all living organisms (Kauffman et
al. in press) where we will show that information in biotic
systems are the constraints that instruct living organisms how
to operate. We will demonstrate that instructional or biotic
information is quite different than the classical notion of
information Shannon developed for addressing engineering
problems in telecommunications. We also will show that
biosemiosis is in some sense equivalent to propagating
organization (Kauffman et al. in press). We then conclude our
presentation with the speculation that there exist at least
seven levels of biosemiosis.
Keywords: propagating-organization, evolution, language,
biosemiosis, culture, new-media
1 The Alphabet Effect (Logan 2004a)
Joseph Needham (1956, 1979) claimed that the Chinese contribution to the development of abstract
science in the West was significant. He argued that many practical inventions were transferred from China
to the West that stimulated European science. His claim led naturally to the question: Why did abstract
theoretical science begin in the West and not in China itself?
I explained this paradox by suggesting that monotheism and codified law, two features of Western cul-
ture absent in China, led to a notion of universal law, which influenced the development of abstract sci-
ence in ancient Greece. I first shared this hypothesis with Marshall McLuhan at a lunch in 1974. He
agreed with me but pointed out that I had failed to take into account the phonetic alphabet, a feature of
Western culture not found in China. The alphabet, McLuhan claimed, had also contributed to the devel-
opment of Western science. Realizing that our explanations complemented and reinforced each other, we
combined them in a paper entitled "Alphabet, Mother of Invention" (McLuhan and Logan 1977) to develop
the following hypothesis:
Western thought patterns are highly abstract, compared with Eastern. There developed in the West,
and only in the West, a group of innovations that constitute the basis of Western thought. These include
(in addition to the alphabet) codified law, monotheism, abstract theoretical science, formal logic, and indi-