tripleC 5(2): 37-48, 2007
ISSN 1726-670X
http://tripleC.uti.at
CC: Creative Commons License, 2007.
Information in Plant Life and Development: A Biosemiotic
Approach
Peter W. Barlow
School of Biological Sciences
University of Bristol
Woodland Road
Bristol BS8 1UG, UK
P.W.Barlow@bristol.ac.uk
Abstract: Plant cells, organs and organisms develop via a
succession of transformations of their state mediated by the
prevailing systems of metabolism and morphology. These
transformations are facilitated by the perception of, and re-
sponse to signs and signals generated either from within, or
received from an external source – the abiotic environment, for
example. The perception of signs and their subsequent trans-
formation and integration in the form of plant-specific informa-
tion, may depend upon a channel which has features of a
‘nervous’ system and which employs some of the molecular
components and organelles familiar in animals. Developmental
transformations can also be described in symbolic form by
means of L-system algorithms (after A. Lindenmayer) whose
elements have counterparts corresponding to the boundaries of
cells and multicellular societies. The cell maps resulting from
these algorithms enable retrospective inferences and future
predictions about the behaviour of the cellular systems con-
cerned. L-systems therefore offer a means of encapsulating the
elements of the ‘living algorithms’ which may be supposed to be
already embedded within an organism and which are respon-
sive to signs which are an integral part of the already formed
construction. Another class of sign system in plants is sug-
gested as being based on gradients of biochemical agents, or
morphogens, which promote cell determination and hence lead
to distinctive patterns of tissue differentiation.
Keywords: autoreproduction, development, information and
communication, L-systems, plant meristems
Acknowledgement: I am grateful to Günther Witzany for intro-
ducing me to Biosemiotics, and also there are special thanks to
my colleagues František Baluška and Jacqueline Lück for their
continually inspiring insights relating to the world of plants.
1 Introduction. Biosemiotics in the New Age
Can it be said of European Man that he has successfully passed through not only an ‘Age of Reason’
illumined by the Enlightenment (Porter 2000) but also an ‘Age of Anxiety’ fostered by two world wars
(Valéry 1919, Auden 1947), and that he is now squarely settled in an ‘Age of Communication’ (Chan
2005)? Or has European Man not made any passage at all, but has, instead, simply gathered to himself,
like a rolling snowball, the ethos of each of these ages (White 1944)? The persistence of myths and the
belief in eternal archetypes suggests that the latter proposition is more likely. Whatever the case, it is an
everyday experience for men and women to believe themselves deluged, if not suffocated, by a mass of
information from which items crucial for everyday living as well as for long-term decisions have neverthe-
less to be extracted. It is not surprising, therefore, that the study of signs and communication – semiotics –
has become a rapidly expanding field of enquiry (Hawkes 1989, Witzany 2006) not only for its own sake
but also to understand and cope with the pathologies that attend the reception of distorted or conflicting
information. And, moreover, the contact in this field of signs with biologists – behaviourists at first, but later
Barlow, P.W.
38
.
CC: Creative Commons License, 2007.
with molecular biologists also – inevitably has led to the conception and birth of Biosemiotics. However,
whether this new offspring now growing up within the world of Academia will manufacture anything more
than new bottles within which to store old wines remains to be seen. Hopefully, this will prove not to be the
case, and that biosemiotics will stimulate coherent concepts from which the varied modes of inter- and
intra-organismic communication can be formulated with a new scientific rigour.
At much the same time as developments in an area which had originally been oriented towards studies
of verbal and linguistic interactions were leading towards structuralism and semiotics (Piaget 1971,
Hawkes 1989), there was a similar surge of interest in how interrelationships between the multiplicity of
processes, informational and otherwise, which were increasingly discernable within the living world, could
be interpreted and, better still, harmonized with analogous processes recognized within those scientific
disciplines which dealt with inanimate matter. Perhaps the fundamental disquiet which lay behind this
search for logical connections was the two-fold legacy from the Ages of ‘Reason’ and ‘Anxiety’. Neverthe-
less, from this striving for an ideal representation of nature and her laws arose the General Systems The-
ory of Ludwig von Bertalanffy (1950), an important off-shoot of which was Living Systems Theory (LST).
Developed by James Grier Miller in the 1960s, and later in collaboration with his wife, Jessie Louise Miller,
LST recognised a coherent set of integrative processes, or subsystems, which were similar in character
over the span of all conceivable levels of biological organization (JG Miller 1978, JG and JL Miller 1990).
These subsystems were postulated to support and to define each of the organizational levels considered
by LST. There are three principal groups of subsystems, one of which is exclusively dedicated to the
processing of Information. The other two groups of subsystems pertain to the processing of Matter and
Energy-plus-Information. Together, the three subsystem groups cohere and thereby permit the realization
of the three major attributes of living matter namely, reproduction, metabolism and acquisition of structure.
The levels of organization which the sets of subsystems support, and are supported by – there is here a
reciprocity of functions! – range from cells, through organs and organisms, to social groupings. Whereas
JG Miller conceived of eight hierarchical levels of organization for Man and his society (Miller 1978) – an
ninth level, that of Gaia, was later added to this list (Miller and Miller 1982) – the first three mentioned here
(cells, organs, organisms) are sufficient for the present short discussion of information in plant life and
plant development.
2 Information and Living Systems
Central among the information-processing subsystems of LST are those which concern sign perception,
transduction, and the transmission of the resulting encoded version of the sign (information) via a ‘channel
and net’ subsystem to a site at which the informational signal is decoded and a response (usually a motor
or tropic response of some description) evoked (Barlow 2007). However, the existence of such a se-
quence of information-processing has already been known to plant physiologists for many years (Jackson
and Barlow 1981, Mohr and Schopfer 1995), as was a ‘systems’ approach to studying the plant organism;
remarkably, this latter had been adopted nearly 125 years ago by Gottlieb Haberlandt and expounded in
his book ‘Physiologische Pflanzenanatomie’ (‘Physiological Plant Anatomy’) (Haberlandt 1884). The struc-
tural and functional attributes of the subsystems of LST has required many man-hours of research to be-
come more clearly identified and better understood. In plants, it has until recently been difficult to find cor-
respondences between the various information-handling subsystems proposed by LST and actual ana-
tomical structures and physiological processes (Barlow 1999, 2006, 2007). In particular, the ‘channel and
net’ subsystem of LST, which deals with information flow, existed hitherto largely as a theoretical supposi-
tion based on analogy with information-processing subsystems in sensate animal organisms. However,
the advent of the new science of plant neurobiology (Brenner et al. 2006) has provided valuable pointers
to the sought-after correspondences between predicted and actual structures concerned with information
flow, as well as indicating anatomical and cell-biological frameworks within which the said structures can
be integrated. Therefore, there is the prospect that, in the near future, a more complete plant information-
processing system will be revealed (Baluška et al. 2006, 2007, Barlow 2007). Unfortunately, there has
tripleC
5(2): 37-48, 2007
39
CC: Creative Commons License, 2007.
been some misinterpretation (Alpi et al. 2007) concerning the concept of plant neurobiology, and the goals
which have been set for this discipline. Plants are not animals, even though both may have channel and
net subsystems for the conveyance of information in one form or another. This ‘channel and net’ subsys-
tem is approximately analogous to an anatomically identifiable ‘nervous system’. In fact, LST provides an
objective framework for a study such as plant neurobiology (Barlow 2007) because not only is the subsys-
tem terminology self-sufficient and precisely defined but so also are the subsystem functions (Miller 1978,
Miller and Miller 1995). There is no particular necessity to search out the correspondences with anatomy,
though for practical purposes this is clearly desirable (Miller 1978). The argumentation can work in re-
verse, however, so that terms like ‘nerve’ and ‘nervous system’ become, in the objective terminology of
LST, metaphors for ‘channel and net’ at two corresponding organizational levels. ‘Nerve’ can even be-
come a generalised metaphor applied within the community of life-forms, irrespective of whether these are
also designated ‘animal’ or ‘plants’.
The processing of information by a living organism involves a relationship between the physical vari-
ables of which the organism’s external, abiotic environment is comprised, and the specialized biological
receptors which respond to them. Obviously, some heterogeneity within the environment becomes identi-
fiable as a ‘signal’ only when it invokes recognition and a subsequent response from an organism. Many
relevant examples of signals have been investigated in plants, most of which culminate, via signal trans-
duction into internal information, and thence to end-point responses (Barlow 1992). These end points in-
clude the specialized growth movements (tropisms) which become evident as a result of displacements of
organs (roots, shoots) in relation to the gravity vector (gravitropism), gradients of illumination (phototro-
pism) and other environmental variables such as temperature, oxygen levels, etc. (Jackson and Barlow
1981, Mohr and Schopfer 1995, Porterfield 2002). These causative agents of movement are the environ-
mental heterogeneities mentioned earlier. Interestingly, in plant roots, it has recently been discovered that
particular groups of specialised cells (e.g., those in the centre of the root cap) can process two or more
streams of information simultaneously – e.g., those due to stimuli from gravity, light, and also humidity
(Takahashi et al. 2003). At some stage, this processing leads to associations and decisions (both gov-
erned by two other LST subsystems) as to which motor response is the most appropriate in the prevailing
circumstances – the root movements of gravitropism, phototropism, or hydrotropism.
The sensing and integration of stimuli, or signs, may be placed under the two broad headings of extero-
ception and interoception (Barlow 2007). The former term covers the reception of the above-mentioned
external signs, while the latter, interoception, includes the sensation and response to internal signs and
signals. Both types of signal reception relate to the particular morphological configuration, or orientation, of
an entity of a certain level within its living-space. Also worth recalling is the observation that plants, as well
as animals, are unable to tolerate constant conditions (a situation of ‘sensory deprivation’) (Hillman 1956,
Highkin 1960). Constancy of ambient temperature, for example, leads to the reproductive death of pea
plants (Highkin 1958). It is as though continual variation in the intensity of stimulation is what organisms
crave in order to maintain not only the physical structure of the subsystems but also their integrated and
healthy state.
Plants seem to have exquisite sensitivities to certain types of environmental signals, often at extremely
low, near-threshold levels of detection, and have the means of capturing them and converting some sign-
related physical or chemical feature into information which can then be amplified and processed by the
subsystems, and passed between different organizational levels (Barlow 2007). However, the relevant
systems of perception and response also have upper thresholds in relation to the abiotic environment
(Went 1956, Barlow and Powers 2005). It is likely that these upper limits are related to the malfunction and
collapse of the physiological processes involved. Moreover, it is important not to forget that within the re-
sponsive zone between upper and lower thresholds a given perceptive system is ever-active, just as the
stimulus, or sign, is ever-present. Beyond the limits of this zone, sign perception and/or transduction would
Barlow, P.W.
40
.
CC: Creative Commons License, 2007.
be inactive; and this absence of activity, too, might be perceived in some circumstances as an internal
signaling state, perhaps residing as a ‘memory’ of unfavourable growth conditions (the memory becoming
retrievable when the environment ameliorates and growth resumes). However, within the perceptive zone
between lower and upper thresholds there are states of continual interoception which are registered as a
form of self-consciousness which also can be referred to as a state of ‘continual semiosis’ (Barlow and
Lück 2007a). It is interesting to speculate that Charles Darwin would have recognized continual semiosis
in consequence of his detailed observations of the intrinsically driven nutational movements of plant stems
and tendrils (Darwin 1880). For him, these organs seemed to be perpetually in search of stimuli (a self-
directed desire for the reciprocities of semiosis?) in order to initiate new modes of growth – twining and
other motions – for raising up the plant body.
3 Novel Forms of Information Processing
Perceptions at the lower threshold of a sensory system may be so weak that the information engen-
dered has little impact beyond its immediate site of susception and processing. The information remains at
the level (say, of the cell) at which it was first registered or processed, and does not become amplified and
move up to the next higher organizational level where it can be registered by the whole organism as some
type of physiological ‘shock’ or disturbance from which a high-level response is engendered (bodily mo-
tion, for example). Such ‘low level’, or prototypic, feelings and sensations, internalized at the level at which
the initiating signals were perceived, thus give rise to what are spoken of (for animal forms, at least) as
intuitions and telepathies. It is suggested that, in plants, these same prototypic feelings are just those
which have been termed ‘primary perceptions’ (Backster 2003). Therefore, the ‘continual semiosis’ men-
tioned above may not only be converted into satisfying and gratifying sensations of a high-level self – i.e.,
as an organism either afflicted by pain or suffused with pleasure, or into sensations which goads the or-
ganism into motor activity – but this proposed autosemiosis (like a type of proprioception) also results in
subliminal sensations of which the organism is only vaguely aware. Primary perception may perhaps play
a relatively more significant part in plant life than it does in animals, especially humans. Plants often have
to rely on weak and ephemeral signals from the ambient environment for their self-maintenance and re-
production. At levels ‘lower’ than that of the whole organism (i.e. cell and organ levels), such feeble sig-
nals are experienced by correspondingly ‘low-level’ subsystems, and that these can set in motion only a
train of instinctive responses: there is no transmission to, or integration of the relevant information with
and higher organizational level.
Complementary to the systems which participate in exteroception, or the outer-to-inner capture of sig-
nals from the external environment to the interior of the plant and their conversion into information, are the
many examples of organismic components responding to interoception – that is, to their own innately-
generated information resident within the internal biotic environment. This last-mentioned environment, as
we might now anticipate in accordance with the principles of nested hierarchical levels of LST, ranges
from the components of the cellular level to the more fully realized entities at the levels of the community
and its ecological setting. Moreover, what might be observed as ‘outer’ at one level (e.g., fungal hyphae
are ‘outer’ in relation to the surface of a root) becomes ‘inner’ at a higher level (e.g., hyphae and root be-
come part of a composite mycorrhiza within a rhizosphere). However, it is behaviour at the cellular level
which informs our further discussion of the responses to internal informational signals in relation to bio-
logical development.
Interestingly, the nesting of hierarchical levels elucidates the concept of ‘emergent properties’, a puz-
zling phenomenon that is, nevertheless, part and parcel of development. For example, it is cells which
give rise to the novelty of a tissue; and, at a different level, it is the physical conjunction of two organisms
as a ‘dyad’ which gives rise to a new life-form. Familiar examples of dyads, besides the mycorrhizae al-
ready mentioned, are lichens (Sanders 2006). These are constructions which arise from the conjunction of
algal and fungal organisms. Importantly, by their association, the resulting lichen-dyad is rendered repro-
tripleC
5(2): 37-48, 2007
41
CC: Creative Commons License, 2007.
ductive, a property denied to the two independent component parts. Similarly, the pairing of animals and
plants by means of their male and female genders brings about another type of reproductively competent
dyad (Barlow 1999).
4 Development and Morphogenesis
A beautiful image is that of the penetrative plant or animal sperm informing the egg that a new organism
should now be constructed. But after this initial acceptance of external seminal information, development
is prompted by internal cues generated by the new organism itself. It is a feature of plants that their con-
struction is based on the principle of the module (Notov 2005). Development is therefore by repetitious
production of modules. And new modules arise by autoreproduction (Barlow et al. 2001; see also Wagner
1996).
A succession of reasonably well-defined states, or forms peculiar to a certain chronological stage of de-
velopment, are recognisable as organismic growth proceeds, this process being promoted by two of the
attributes of living organisation – metabolism and the acquisition of structure. The former depends upon
the acquisition of substrates and energy sources, the latter upon the inherent properties of self-assembly
and autoreproduction. In the very simplicity of a zygote, at the commencement of each new generation,
organisms have a form, and this form will be continually repeated in accordance with the condition (or
constaint) of modularity. The zygotic form, it seems, is one condition necessary to advance, or transform,
development to the next state. Admittedly, the steps of early embryogeny are relatively simple: the pro-
gression of 2, 4, 8, 16, … cells is accompanied by a parallel sequence of embryonic stages – ‘globule’,
‘heart’, and ‘torpedo’. The important point is that there seems to be an inevitability about these progres-
sions. In insect and animal embryos, these have been linked to the hypothesis of the ‘zootype’ whereby
the linear sequence of a number of homeobox genes co-locates with the body plan of the embryo (Slack
et al. 1993, Deutsch 2004). It is possible that some similar morphogenetic concept may apply to plant
embryogeny also (e.g. Paquette and Benfey 2001, Jürgens 2003).
Evidently, an appropriate metabolism and a set of active genes not only maintain the supply of ele-
ments necessary for development but they also set the rate at which this occurs. Then, structure and me-
tabolism combine to define the species-specific rates of both cell growth and cell division. In their turn,
these parameters affect cellular polarity and geometry, realms wherein operate rules which regulate the
siting of each new cell division wall within a cytokinetic mother cell (Gönczy and Hyman 1996, Barlow et
al. 2004a, Pillitteri et al. 2007). This coordinated sequence of cellular events hints at a type of develop-
ment whereby the state of a construction at a given timestep predicts, as a result of information contained
within that construction, the precise state that will emerge at the following timestep. Given the self-
similarity within the organizational hierarchy, this same principle should apply at each level of organization:
cell, organ, organism, and even at the level of a social group. Importantly, the transition from one state to
another is neither spontaneous nor chaotic, but is directed; it is facilitated by the perception of, and the
response to, a sign (or signs) inherent to the construction in its current state. This principle is at the heart
of organic autopoiesis (Varela et al. 1974) and autoreproduction
(Barlow et al. 2001); and inherently com-
municative signs may be found in the labile molecules of the plant cell wall (Nothnagel 1997). But, in order
for these events to occur, the system itself must be in the already mentioned state of self-sensing, or con-
tinual autosemiosis. Signals already within the existing construction, some of which, in the case of mobile
plant hormones (Gazzarrini and McCourt 2003), participate in quite complex configurations, have to im-
pinge upon some matching perceptive system. From the nexus of signals, information and responses,
another level of organization manifests (an emergent property), via a chain of information processing, not
only to realise the Bauplan of the organism but also to accommodate small variations upon its theme in
the form of tropisms of organs, liminal angles of branches, morphological adaptations, plasticities of de-
velopment, etc. (Barlow 1993, Walbot 1996).
Barlow, P.W.
42
.
CC: Creative Commons License, 2007.
In order to further the argument for directed development, and to relate structure and form with semio-
sis, the principal element in plant organogenesis will be taken to be the individual cell. Except for gametic
cells and in-vitro cultured somatic cells which have been released from the constraints of their neighbours,
plant cells are usually seamlessly joined together in three-dimensionally constructed societies (or ‘cell-
works’) where not only are their developmental potentialities regulated in ways appropriate to cellular posi-
tion within an organ, but also the boundary walls of cells exhibit non-random spatial arrangements and
states of maturation, all of which may serve as signs and signaling systems. It seems that the intimate
contact of cell upon cell (and any one cell usually has about 14 or more contacts with neighbouring cells)
and the exchange of information therefrom, are crucial in the generation of form. It is at the growing points
of plants – the apices and apical meristems – where cellworks and their signaling systems display their
most intriguing properties (Lück and Lück 2000). During steady-state plant growth an ever-changing cell
population maintains a constancy of behaviour out of which shape and form are developed in accordance
with the mysterious processes of morphogenesis. The familiar hooked shape of seedling plumules, for
example, is maintained even though the cells from which the plumules are constructed are continually
being exchanged for new cells derived from the shoot apex (Silk and Erickson 1978). But besides this
constancy of form
1
, there are resident within root and shoot apices generative centres which consist of
self-maintaining stem-cells and their immediate descendents. The generative centres may then proceed to
develop the germs of new centres from which new organs arise by a branching process (Barlow et al.
2001, Barlow and Lück 2004a, Barlow et al. 2004b). As mentioned, this process of autoreproduction is
characteristic of living modular constructions.
Can the signals which drive forward the transformations characteristic of plant development be de-
scribed in such a way that the symbols employed for its representation would make sense if presented (in
a suitable language, of course) not only to an individual cell and the cellular society which houses it and
grows up from it, but also to a biologist who might study them? Or, put another way, can algorithms for
development be discovered whose symbolic elements have, on the one hand, counterparts within the
respective constructions themselves (i.e., could there be cell-based ‘living algorithms’?) and which can be
recognized as signals for development, as well as being able to convey to an external observer enough
information for him to infer past and present patterns of development as well as predict its future course?
We shall now try to answer this question.
5 Structuralism and L-systems
While semiotics and biosemiotics have many correspondences with the discipline of structuralism, and
together they have become combined within a discipline of ‘communication’ (Hawkes 1989), structuralism
itself came more clearly into focus, as Jean Piaget discovered, by contact with advances in the analysis
and understanding of the biological world (Piaget 1971). It may also be ventured that the focus of structur-
alism was further sharpened in the light of General Systems Theory, as well as from insights gained
through the development of L-systems (Lindenmayer 1971). These last-mentioned systems (due to Aristid
Lindenmayer – hence the ‘L’ of ‘L-systems’) offer one possible means of representing the soi-disant ‘living
algorithm’, conceived of as being embedded within the very structure of the organism itself and which offer
signs whose interpretation furthers development.
Because it is of interest to explore the extent to which a single cell (though not one isolated from neigh-
bouring cells) can reproduce, and by its productions develop a society of similarly reproducing cells from
which various subsidiary patterns of activity can come about, minimal interactionless algorithms have
been devised (Barlow et al. 2001, Barlow and Lück 2004a). These are of the D0L-system type (Lück and
1
As Heraclitus wisely observed nearly three millennia ago, “You never step into the same river twice, as fresh water is always flow-
ing towards you.” So it is for the cells of the plumular hook.
tripleC
5(2): 37-48, 2007
43
CC: Creative Commons License, 2007.
Lück 1987), where D indicates deterministic, 0 designates the absence of interactions, and L is as men-
tioned above.
D0L-system algorithms are transformation rules which employ a triadic form of symbolism, for example,
A → B, or B → B. In the first case, the A state evidently has the potential to transform to the B state. The A
state may even be considered as exhibiting ‘biosemiotic readiness’ – continual semiosis – anticipating a
change of state upon completion of a timestep, as implied by the transformation symbol ‘→’. The arrow
also suggests that there might be a direction to development. Due to its biosemiotic readiness, the A state
cell has the potential to make a forward movement and thereby attain state B. In the second case, the
transformation B → B is likewise indicative of continual semiosis: before the conclusion of a timestep,
when rule-governed state transformations are implemented simultaneously throughout the cell population,
each B-type cell actively assesses, within the context of its semiotic environment (or ‘semiosphere’),
whether to remain in B state or not. In the case of B → B, however, the state is unchanged, indicating that
the sensitive components of B which are active in continual semiosis have not encountered sufficient in-
formation to secure a transformation to some other, non-B, state. Some threshold has not been crossed.
Thus, as long as such a semiotic environment persists, cell-type B will appear to be a terminal state. Nev-
ertheless, the cell’s self-maintenance in B state might be challenged by, say, a pathogenic infection, or a
wound, in which case further state transformations, e.g. B → D or B → A, could be facilitated. The B cell
may not, therefore, be so terminal after all, and may even have the ability to marshall the conditions in the
surrounding semiosphere so that they lead to its own death via apoptosis (say, state D). Can any state
therefore ever be considered as final? Continual semiosis would suggest a condition of ‘continual becom-
ing’, even if this requires the occasional return to the initial state (B → A).
L-systems, as sequences of state transformations, thus prove useful simulators of morphological
change in plants and algae (Lindenmayer 1971, Lück and Lück 1987). In circumstances where state trans-
formations operate at the edges of cells, cellular maps are the preferred means of graphically representing
the progressively altering form of the resultant cellular arrays (Lück and Lück 2000, Barlow et al. 2001,
Barlow and Lück 2004a, 2007a). Each edge may correspond to a wall, or to a segment of wall, accompa-
nied by its underlying cytoplasm; and each state of a wall may be defined by some time-dependent prop-
erty. Transformation of state implies a preceding phase during which information required for this trans-
formation becomes active as a signal. Thus, the states that correspond to the make-up of the wall (say)
are not informational per se; they become informational and, hence, contribute the ‘living’ counterparts of
an L-system algorithm, only when there is a higher level of organization within which they are interpreted
following their interoception. To paraphrase H. Pattee in relation to the cell edges mentioned above, ‘an
edge does not become a message because of any shape or structure or behavior of the edge. It becomes
a message only in the context of a larger system of physical constraints’ (Pattee 1969). In the case of the
‘living algorithm’, this ‘larger system’ of constraints is the cell division system. It should not be forgotten
that L-systems also apply to the transformations of cellular states (Barlow and Lück 2004a). These states
are elements resident in a higher level of organization (that of the organ) than that in which the edge re-
sides (at the level of the cell). In both cases, edge state and cell state are signs, but they feature at differ-
ent levels.
Extending the algorithmic terminology to that of a double-wall (dw)L-system permits the state of one
wall to be considered in relation to the state of a connected wall belonging to a neighbouring cell (Lück
and Lück 1987).
It can be imagined that both walls are attached to a common, but invisible, membrane
(hence the idea of the double wall and the corresponding labeling of each of the two faces). Thus, cellular
groups, whether in 1, 2, and 3 dimensions – filaments, arrays, and cellworks, respectively – are linked by
a set of symbols that refers to the states of the connected cell edges. Suitable transformation rules then
allow the cellular ensembles to coordinate their development in time and space (Lück and Lück 2000). No
exchange of information between cells takes place, however. In fact, a number of developing cellular sys-
Barlow, P.W.
44
.
CC: Creative Commons License, 2007.
tems (plant and algal idioblasts) were recently proposed (Barlow and Lück 2007b) to arise on account of a
cessation of information flow. Again, a particular type of wall state transformations was invoked as the
agent of cellular change.
Examples of the usefulness of L-systems not only in the analysis of cellular autoreproduction at the
generative centres of a shoot of the whisk-fern, Psilotum nudum, but also in showing how variations upon
their self-maintaining, autoreproductive condition lead to cellular differentiation, have been set forth else-
where (Barlow et al. 2001, 2004b, Barlow and Lück 2004a, 2007a). In all cases described, the cellular
activities derived from an algorithm that commenced with a 3-sided cell and a wall cycle, denoted as (1 2
3). The state transformation rules then led to a developmental map. In the case of unrestricted develop-
ment of the theoretical cell division system for the Psilotum apex, the real-life counterpart in real life would
be a succession of dichotomous branchings expressed as clusters of telomes, terminal structures arrived
at during evolution for gaining a competitive advantage (overtopping) over neighbouring plants and their
telomes
2
. However, actual Psilotum apices achieve only about 16 branches. In the algorithm for apical
development, the limit to branching is set by a cell division counter referred to as λ, but how this counter
operates is not known; there could be some feedback between old cells (those produced λ generations
ago) and the stem-cell population at the apex, or there may be more subtle ways of limiting proliferation,
such as by the progressive loss of telomeres – these are special sequences of DNA bases associated
with the ends of chromosomes (McKnight 2004) – at each division step in the initial cell population.
The deterministic D0L-system algorithm of unlimited development produces an ‘ideal’, or ‘stereotypic’,
cellular pattern. But whereas complex and invariant cellular constructions obviously do arise, and without
them there could be no consistent morphology for a given plant species, inherent disturbances (chance
events?) to the otherwise stereotypic division system can serve to bring about new pathways of cell be-
haviour and differentiation.
Whatever the explanation for the ‘accidental’ divergence of division pathways, the continual semiosis
operating within 3-sided cells provides a suitable vehicle for evolutionary selection. The induction of vari-
ants of a given developmental pathway as a response to disturbed external or internal conditions, can
become fixed as a result of genetic assimilation. In this way, new patterns of cellular development and
morphogenesis arise (which in terms of the alphabet of L-system symbols may involve only small
changes), and with them the formation of new species (see Morelli et al. 1991).
6 Cellular context as semiotic signal
In relation to the semiotics of morphogenesis, a further consideration is the context within which the cell
division systems for cellular autoreproduction and differentiation are embedded. As discussed elsewhere
(Barlow and Lück 2007a), the cycle of wall edges provides not only a set of semiotic signs, but also the
semiotic context for sequences of cell division and the development of different cell types which diverge in
their properties.
Another instance of context was recently proposed in an attempt to understand the recurrent patterning
of the secondary phloem tissue of coniferous and deciduous trees in relation to the behaviour of the vas-
cular cambium from which this tissue derives (Barlow and Lück 2004b, 2005, 2006). In this case, the theo-
retical context was a radial gradient across the tissue of a putative chemical morphogen whose source
was in the cambium (Kramer 2001). The gradient constitutes a signal and forms an integral part of a
model whereby uncommitted meristematic cambial cells are guided towards particular pathways of differ-
entiation as they move centrifugally across the secondary phloem domain. Particularly gratifying was the
realization that these putative gradient-directed developments within a plant tissue were similar to those
2
This overtopping characteristic of telomes is like that of the four-wheel-drive ‘people-carrier’ automobiles where new models con-
tinually overtop not only the more modest family saloon-type cars but also the older models of their own type (as was the case with
successive species of dinosaurs)!
tripleC
5(2): 37-48, 2007
45
CC: Creative Commons License, 2007.
discovered, or inferred, in animal systems (gradients of morphogens regulating segmentation in vertebrate
embryos, for example) (summarized in Barlow and Lück 2004b, 2005). Moreover, since gradients of me-
tabolites abound in plants (van Fleet 1948), it would not be surprising if they, too, conferred positional
information for use in cell determination and differentiation. The other key component of the secondary
phloem system is the spatio-temporal pattern of periclinal cell divisions in the cambium. In correspon-
dence with the examples from Psilotum, a given division system may arise from deterministic transforma-
tions of a particular cambial cell wall cycle. Because of the geometric complexity of cambial anatomy (Bar-
low 2005), the potential for the presence of signs inherent to the configurations of the cell walls and the
respective cell contacts is likely to be high.
7 Evolution of an L-system-based semiosis
Within the present context of Biosemiotics, it seems appropriate to speculate upon the evolution of the
plant meristem’s ‘living algorithms’ of which L-systems are the symbolic representations. It may be pre-
sumed that, as one of the first steps in plant evolution, the apical type of meristem superceded meristems
of both the intercalary and the diffuse types. In contrast to the two last-mentioned types, the apical type of
meristem is a site where more possibilities for the regulation of morphogenesis can be tried out. But in
order for any one of all the possible division pathways to become established and acquire relevance for
cellular differentiation and for organ development, many experiments must have been made during the
vast expanse of evolutionary time. Division pathways that were either abortive or stable in terms of the
output of cell patterns would have been trials to find those which were productive of an emergent property.
As witness to this, it has been found (Bugnicourt 1983) that during the embryogeny of certain French spe-
cies of Hypericum even the smallest errors of cell division lead to the death of the embryo. It is as though,
at this critical stage, the self-assembly of information for developmental progress has to be unswervingly
precise in relation to the whole, otherwise the growing system will be aborted. At length, however, living
algorithms would have been selected, and they would have been the ones to communicate sufficient in-
formation, via self-organising structures, to forge robust division pathways that then led to repeated
branching and modularity of shoot and root apex (Barlow et al., 2004b). Thus, during this experimental era
early in plant evolution, not only was it necessary for the structure of walls to be such that cells could di-
vide in particular planes, but that the resulting cellular patterns could generate viable organ-forms, and
that these forms in their turn could cohabit with other similar organ-forms, and then with the life-forms of
other species.
The L-system algorithms derived for plant constructions suggest an analogy with the vocal language of
animals, especially primates and hominids, even though with respect to each type of construction quite
different levels of organization are involved. Here, the selection of a living plant algorithm could have pro-
ceeded in much the same way whereby the continuous vocalizations of primitive hominids coalesced into
particular sound clusters, again after an experimental stage, which established the consensual phonemes
by which groups of individuals could collectively begin to name objects, communicate ideas, and thence to
cooperate in the construction of societies (Novak and Krakauer 1999, Kirby 2001, Walsingham 2006).
That phonemes can be considered as ‘consensual’ implies that a sufficient number of individuals of
equivalent intellectual development exists during this period of linguistic experimentation; these individu-
als, then, are the context in which the phonemes are cognized.
The respective algorithms or phoneme clusters became the means whereby the entities to which they
belong – cells or individual organisms – were diverted from self-sufficient solitude and acquired compan-
ionable neighbours with whom they may have been able to communicate. But at the same time, the newly
developed ability of hominids living in this ‘Age of Palaeolithic Reason’ to differentiate ‘this’ from ‘that’ led,
paradoxically, to an ‘Age of Prehistoric Anxiety’ where there was a sense in each individual of a separa-
tion, or an apartness, from the matrix of their natural environment. The development of a continual semio-
Barlow, P.W.
46
.
CC: Creative Commons License, 2007.
sis, of a self-awareness and environmental consciousness, would certainly have been one way (maybe
the only way) in which contact within and between organisms, animal or plant, as well as the organisms’
contact with the environmental continuum of which they themselves were also a part (the ‘Umwelt’ of J.J.
von Uexküll), could have been maintained, and the primordial ‘anxiety’ assuaged. However, as indicated,
there may be another, more prototypical way of sensing via primary perception. But this, perhaps, is a
research area not yet within the reach of Biosemiotics and communication studies for the foreseeable
future.
8 Conclusion
Plants grow and develop in accordance with information gained from external and internal signals which
are captured by the processes of exteroception and interoception, respectively. The passage of informa-
tion, and the subsequent activation of a response, can be understood in the framework of J.G. Miller’s
‘Living Systems Theory’ (LST). There is increasing evidence for the existence in plants of a type of nerv-
ous system which includes synaptic structures. Its counterpart in LST is the ‘channel and net’ proposed as
being one of the subsystems involved in information transfer.
With respect to plant cell division and the building of cellular constructions, Lindenmayer-systems have
provided useful algorithms for modelling the steps involved. The symbolic forms of the L-system algo-
rithms presumably have counterparts within the organism itself, perhaps associated with the cell walls and
underlying cytoplasmic structures. Their changing states can be sensed by interoception, and this then
permits the further transformation of the cellular arrays and morphological states, both of which drive for-
ward the process of development. An open question is whether either of the approaches, LST or L-
systems, which have been employed in the study of information processing and transfer in relation to plant
development, can be incorporated into Biosemiotics.
References
Alpi, A., Amrhein, N., Bertl, A., Blatt, M.R., Blumwald, E., Cervone, F., and 30 other authors (2007) Plant neurobiology: no brain, no
gain? In: Trends in Plant Sciences, 12. pp 135-136.
Auden, W.H. (1948) The Age of Anxiety. London. Faber and Faber.
Backster, C. (2003) Primary Perception. Anza, CA. White Rose Millenium Press.
Baluška, F., Volkmann, D., Hlavacka, A., Mancuso, S., Barlow, P.W. (2006) Neurobiological view of plants and their body plan. In:
Baluška, F., Mancuso, S., Volkmann, D. (Eds.) (2006) Communication in plants. Berlin. Springer. pp 19-35.
Baluška, F., Barlow, P.W., Volkmann, D., Mancuso, S. (2007) Gravity-related paradoxes in plants: Plant neurobiology provides the
means for their resolution. In: Witzany, G. (Ed.) (2007) Proceedings of the 6
th
Gathering in Biosemiotics, Salzburg, July 2006). Tartu.
Umweb (in press).
Barlow, P.W. (1992) A flowchart of processes responsible for the gravitropism, nutation and other growth movements of roots. In:
Naturwissenschaften, 79. pp 34-37.
Barlow, P.W. (1993) The response of roots and root systems to their environment – An interpretation derived from an analysis of the
hierarchical organization of plant life. In: Environmental and Experimental Botany, 33. pp 1-10.
Barlow, P. W. (1999) Living plant systems: How robust are they in the absence of gravity? In: Advances in Space Research, 23/12.
pp 1975-1986.
Barlow, P.W. (2005) From cambium to early cell differentiation within the secondary vascular system. In: Holbrook, N.M., Zwieniecki,
M.A. (Eds.) (2005) Vascular Transport in Plants. Amsterdam. Elsevier/Academic Press. pp 279-306.
Barlow, P.W. (2006) Charles Darwin and the plant root apex: closing a gap in living systems theory as applied to plants. In: Baluška,
F., Mancuso, S., Volkmann, D. (Eds.) (2006) Communication in plants. Berlin. Springer. pp 37-51.
Barlow, P.W. (2007) Plant neurobiology and Living Systems Theory. In: BioEssays (submitted).
Barlow, P.W., Lück, J. (2004a) Deterministic cellular descendance and its relationship to the branching of plant organ axes. In: Pro-
toplasma, 224. pp 129-143.
Barlow, P.W., Lück, J. (2004b) Cell division systems that account for the various arrangements and types of differentiated cells within
the secondary phloem of conifers. In: Plant Biosystems, 138. pp 1179-1202.
Barlow, P.W., Lück, J. (2005) Repetitive cellular patterns in the secondary phloem of conifer and dicot trees, and a hypothesis for
their development. In: Plant Biosystems, 139. pp 164-179.
Barlow, P.W., Lück, J. (2006) Patterned cell development in the secondary phloem of dicotyledonous trees: a review and a hypothe-
sis. In: Journal of Plant Research, 119. pp 271-291.
tripleC
5(2): 37-48, 2007
47
CC: Creative Commons License, 2007.
Barlow, P.W., Lück, J. (2007a) Structuralism and semiosis: Highways for the symbolic representation of morphogenetic events in plants. In:
Witzany, G. (Ed.) (2007) Proceedings of the 6
th
Gathering in Biosemiotics, Salzburg, July 2006. Tartu. Umweb (in press).
Barlow, P.W., Lück, J. (2007a) Rhythmic plant morphogenesis: recurrent patterns of idioblast cell production. In: Russian Journal of
Plant Physiology (submitted).
Barlow, P.W., Powers, S.J. (2005) Predicting the environmental thresholds for cambial and secondary vascular tissue development
in stems of hybrid aspen. In: Annals of Forestry Science, 62. pp 565-573.
Barlow, P.W., Lück, H.B., Lück, J. (2001) The natural philosophy of plant form: cellular autoreproduction as a component of a struc-
tural explanation of plant form. In: Annals of Botany, 88. pp 1141-1152.
Barlow, P.W., Volkmann, D., Baluš ka, F. (2004a) Polarity in roots. In: Lindsey, K. (Ed.) (2004) Polarity in Plants. Oxford. Blackwells.
pp 192-241.
Barlow, P.W., Lück, H.B., Lück, J. (2004b) Pathways towards the evolution of a quiescent centre in roots. In: Biologia (Bratislava),
59, supplement 13. pp 21-32.
Bertalanffy, L. von (1950) Outline of a general system theory. In: British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 1. pp 134-165.
Brenner, E., Stahlberg, R., Mancuso, S., Vivanco, J., Baluška, F., Van Volkenburg, E. (2006) Plant neurobiology; an integrated view
of plant signaling. In: Trends in Plant Sciences, 11. pp 413-419.
Bugnicourt, M. (1983) Embryogénie des Hypericum de France. In: Bulletin de la Société Botanique de France 130, Lettres
Botaniques. pp 195-205.
Chan, A. (2005) Communication Technology: Main Arguments. http://www.gravity7.com/articles_arguments.html
Darwin, C., assisted by Darwin, F. (1880) The Power of Movement in Plants. London. Murray.
Deutsch, J.S. (2004) Segments and parasegments in Arthropods: a functional perspective. In: BioEssays, 26. pp 1117-1125.
Gazzarrini, S., McCourt, P. (2003) Cross-talk in plant hormone signaling: what Arabidopsis mutants are telling us. In: Annals of Bot-
any, 91. pp 605-612.
Gönczy, P., Hyman, A.A. (1996) Cortical domains and the mechanisms of asymmetric cell division. In: Trends in Cell Biochemistry,
6. pp 382-387.
Haberlandt, G. (1884) Physiologische Pflanzenanatomie. Leipzig. Englemann.
Hawkes, T. (1989) Structuralism and Semiotics. London. Routledge.
Highkin, H.R. (1958) Temperature-induced variability in peas. In: American Journal of Botany, 45. pp 628-631.
Highkin, H.R. (1960) The effect of constant temperature environments and of continuous light on growth and development of pea
plants. In: Cold Spring Harbor Symposia on Quantitative Biology, 25. pp 231-238.
Hillman, W.S. (1956) Injury of tomato plants by continuous light and unfavorable photoperiodic cycles. In: American Journal of Bot-
any, 43. pp 89-96.
Jackson, M.B., Barlow, P.W. (1981) Root geotropism and the role of growth regulators from the cap: a re-examination. In: Plant Cell
and Environment, 4. pp 107-123.
Jürgens, G. (2003) Growing up green: cellular basis of plant development. In: Mechanisms of Development, 120. pp 1395-1406.
Kirby, S. (2001) Spontaneous evolution of linguistic structure – An iterated learning model of the emergence of regularity and irregu-
larity. In: IEEE Transactions on Evolutionary Computation, Vol. 5. pp 102-110.
Kramer, E.M. (2001) A mathematical model of auxin-mediated radial growth in trees. In: Journal of Theoretical Biology, 208. pp 387-
397.
Lindenmayer, A. (1971) Developmental systems without cellular interactions, their languages and grammars. In: Journal of Theoreti-
cal Biology, 30. pp 455-484.
Lück, J., Lück, H.B. (1987) From 0L and IL map systems to indeterminate and determinate growth in plant morphogenesis. In: Lec-
ture Notes in Computer Science, 291. pp 393-410.
Lück, J., Lück, H.B. (2000) A classification of plant meristems based on cellworks (3D L-systems). The maintenance and complexity
of their cellular patterns. In: Carbone, A., Gromov, M., Prusinkiewicz, P. (Eds.) (2000) Pattern Formation in Biology, Vision and
Dynamics. Singapore. World Scientific. pp 199-216.
McKnight, T.D. (2004) Plant telomere biology. In: Plant Cell, 16. pp 794-803.
Miller, J.G. (1978) Living Systems. New York. McGraw-Hill.
Miller, J.G., Miller, J.L. (1982) The Earth as a system. Behavioral Science, 27. pp 303-322.
Miller, J.G., Miller, J.L. (1990) Introduction: The nature of living systems. In: Behavioral Science, 35. pp 157-163.
Miller, J.L., Miller, J.G. (1995) Greater than the sum of its parts III. Information processing subsystems. In: Behavioral Science, 40.
pp 171-269.
Mohr, H., Schopfer, P. (1995) Plant Physiology. Berlin. Springer.
Morelli, R.A., Walde, R.E., Akstin, E., Schneider, C.W. (1991) L-system representation of speciation in the red algal genus Dipterosi-
phonia (Ceramiales, Rhodomelaceae). In: Journal of Theoretical Biology, 149. pp 453-465.
Nothnagel, E.A. (1997) Proteoglycans and related components in plant cells. In: International Review of Cytology, 174. pp 195-291.
Notov, A. (2005) Functional organization and individual development of modular objects. In: Wulfenia, 12. pp 65-85.
Novak, M.A., Krakauer, D.C. (1999) The evolution of language. In: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA, 96. pp
8028-8033.
Barlow, P.W.
48
.
CC: Creative Commons License, 2007.
Paquette, A.J., Benfey, P.N. (2001) Axis formation and polarity in plants. In: Current Opinion in Genetics & Development, 11. pp 405-
409.
Pattee, H. (1969) How does a molecule become a message? In: Lang, A. (Ed.) (1969) Communication in Development. New York.
Academic Press. pp 1-16.
Piaget, J. (1971) Structuralism. London. Routledge and Kegan Paul.
Pillitteri, L.J., Sloan, D.B., Bogenschutz, N.L., Torii, K.U. (2007) Termination of asymmetric cell division and differentiation of stomata.
In: Nature, 445. pp 501-505.
Porter, R. (2000) Enlightenment. Britain and the Creation of the Modern World. London. Penguin Books.
Porterfield, D.M. (2002) Environmental sensing and directional growth of plant roots. In: Waisel, Y., Eshel, A., Kafkafi, U. (Eds.)
(2002) Plant Roots. The Hidden Half. New York. Marcel Dekker. pp 471-487.
Sanders, W.B. (2006) A feeling for the superorganism: expression of plant form in the lichen thallus. In: Botanical Journal of the
Linnean Society, 150. pp 89-99.
Silk, W.K., Erickson, R.O. (1978) Kinematics of hypocotyl curvature. In: American Journal of Botany, 65. pp 310-319.
Slack, J.M.W., Holland, P.W.H., Graham, C.F. (1993) The zootype and the polytypic stage. In: Nature, 361. pp 490-493.
Takahashi, N., Yamazaki, Y., Kobayashi, A., Higashitani, A., Takahashi H. (2003) Hydrotropism interacts with gravitropism by de-
grading amyloplasts in seedling roots of Arabidopsis and radish. In: Plant Physiology, 132. pp 805-810.
Valéry, P. (1919) The Crisis of the Mind. In: Lawler, J.R. (Ed.) (1977) Paul Valéry: An Anthology. Princeton. Princeton University
Press.
van Fleet, D.S. (1948) Cortical patterns and gradients in vascular plants. In: American Journal of Botany, 35. pp 219-227.
Varela, F.J., Maturana, H.R., Uribe, R. (1974) Autopoiesis: The organization of living systems, its characterization and a model. In:
Biosystems, 5. pp 187-196.
Wagner, G.P. (1996) Homologues, natural kinds and the evolution of modularity. In: American Zoologist, 36. pp 36-43.
Walbot, V. (1996) Sources and consequences of phenotypic and genotypic plasticity in flowering plants. In: Trends in Plant Sciences,
1. pp 27-32.
Walsingham, Lord John (2006) On the Origins of Speaking. Oxford. Trafford Publishing.
Went, F.W. (1956) The role of environment in plant growth. In: American Scientist, 44. pp 378-398.
White, L.L. (1944) The Next Development in Man. London. Cresset Press.
Witzany, G. (2006) The Logos of the Bios 1. Tartu. Umweb.