.
CC: Creative Commons License, 2007.
The relations between ontogeny and phylogeny are not of cause/effect but rather of mutual entailment.
If it were merely a matter of breaking up this logical loop, as mainstream science has done by placing
variation prior to selection, and genetic information prior to form, then following the same logic ontogeny
should be considered prior to phylogeny. This priority expresses the fact that ontogeny is the source of
individual evolutionary variations and also is a process in which a digital text is translated into an analog
representation. Therefore one would be forced to assert that ontogeny is the causal agency of evolution.
However, in keeping with the self-reference between ontogeny and phylogeny, I would rather justify the
idea of a general transformative tendency that manifest at two different time frames. The model I have
presented facilitates the formalization of Developmental Systems Theory, so highlighting Oyama’s (2001)
valuable contribution.
Taborsky’s cartography of Peirce’s six relations (Taborsky 2002, 2004) not only helps to understand
how the discourse of biology came to be structured but also provide the ontological framework for the in-
terpretation of empirical data. The physical organization of EDA is encoded in the analog [2-1] and [2-2]
modes but its agency is associated to [3-1] and [3-2] relations. EDA are the phenotypic interface where
environmental and genetic information are instantly interpreted; the interaction with the environment pro-
vokes physiological, behavioral and EIS adjustments that switch on and off existing genes while creating
condition for further assimilations of new genes.
Newman and Muller (2000) assert that the relationship between genes and form is a derived condition,
a product of evolution, genes came late and became the informative source that open up new possibilities,
some of which will be actualized by EDA’s semiotic elections. This model explains also why there is a ten-
dency to retrieve developmental programs that are as short as they can be, and which minimize incre-
ments of developmental steps. This phenomenon explains why strict recapitulation cannot happen, though
the core of this hypothesis is preserved, that is to say, that novel evolutionary variation arose as organ-
isms’ reaction to the environment in free living ancestors in their juvenile stages through changes in be-
havior that paved the way for the genetic fixation of some modifications. To conclude, natural selection
favors EDA phenotypic plasticity as factors that minimize the risk of implementing semiotic choices with
insufficient information.
References
Andrade, E. (2000) From external to internal measurement a form theory approach to evolution. In: BioSystems, 57. pp 49-62.
Andrade, E. (2002) The organization of Nature: Semiotic agents as intermediaries between digital and analog informational spaces.
In: SEED Journal (Semiosis Evolution Energy Development), 2(1). pp 56-84.
Andrade, E. (2004) On Maxwell’s demons and the origin of evolutionary variations: and internalist perspective. In: Acta Biotheoretica,
52. pp 17-40.
Arthur, W. (1997) Animal Body Plans, A Study in Evolutionary Developmental Biology. Cambridge University Press.
Arthur, W. (2002) The emerging conceptual framework of evolutionary developmental biology. In: Nature, 415. pp 757-764.
Balbin, A., Andrade, E. (2004) Protein folding and evolution are driven by the Maxwell demon activity of proteins. In: Acta Biotheo-
retica, 52. pp 173-200.
Burkhardt, R.W. jr. (1995) The Spirit of System. Lamarck and Evolutionary Biology. Cambridge/Massachusetts, London/England.
Harvard University Press.
Darwin, C. 1838 Notebook E, MS pp 83-84, In: P. Barret, P. Gautrey, S. Herbert, D. Kohn and S. Smith (Eds.) (1987) Charles Darwin
Notebooks, 1836-1844: Geology, Transmutation of Species, Metaphysical Enquiries. Ithaca. Cornell University Press. pp 418.
Darwin, C. 1836-1844. Red Notebook, MS pp. 127-130 and Notebook B, MS pp. 163, In: P. Barret, P. Gautrey, S. Herbert, D. Kohn
and S. Smith (Eds.) (1987) Charles Darwin Notebooks, 1836-1844: Geology, Transmutation of Species, Metaphysical Enquiries.
Ithaca. Cornell University Press. pp.61-62, 211.
Darwin, C. (1959) The origin of species, First edition. London. John Murray.
Darwin, C. (1888) Animals and Plants under Domestication. 2nd edition, Vol. 2. Londres. John Murray.
Ekstig, B. (1994) Condensation of developmental stages in evolution. In: BioScience, 44. pp 158- 164.
Fontana, W., Schuster, P. (1998a) Continuity in Evolution: On the Nature of Transitions. In: Science, 280 (1998). pp 1451-1455.
Fontana, W., Schuster, P. (1998b) Shaping Space: the Possible and the Attainable in RNA Genotype-Phenotype Mapping. In: Jour-
nal Theoretical Biology, 194 (1998). pp 491-515.