tripleC 10(2): 156-170, 2012
ISSN 1726-670X
http://www.triple-c.at
CC: Creative Commons License, 2012.
1
Understanding Accumulation: The Relevance of Marx’s
Theory of Primitive Accumulation in Media and Communi-
cation Studies
Mattias Ekman
Department of Media Studies, Stockholm University, Stockholm, Sweden, ekman@jmk.su.se
Abstract: The aim of this article is to discuss and use Marx’s theory on primitive accumulation, outlined in the first volume of
Capital, in relation to media and communication research. In order to develop Marx’s argument the discussion is revitalized
through Harvey’s concept of accumulation by dispossession. The article focuses on two different fields within media and
communication research where the concept of accumulation by dispossession is applicable. First, the role of news media
content, news flows and news media systems are discussed in relation to social mobilization against capitalism, privatiza-
tions, and the financial sector. Second, Marx’s theory is used to examine how communication in Web 2.0 and the develop-
ment of ICTs could advance the processes of capital accumulation by appropriating the work performed by users of Web
2.0 and by increasing the corporate surveillance of Internet users. In conclusion, by analyzing how primitive accumulation is
intertwined with contemporary expanded reproduction of capital, the article shows that Marx’s theory can contribute to criti-
cal media and communication research in several ways.
Keywords: Marx, Capitalism, Capital Accumulation, Accumulation by Dispossession, Political Economy, News Media,
Commodification, Privatization, Web 2.0, Facebook
Acknowledgement: I would like to express my gratitude to Andreas Widholm for his helpful comments on the article.
1. Introduction
The current global crisis of capitalism has inspired numerous social theorists to both revitalize
and reinvent many of the key arguments and trails within Marx’s magnum opus Capital. Without
any other comparison to the increasing body of literature that draws on Capital, this article will be
yet one more attempt to connect to the seminal work that has been counted out so many times
before by the apologetics of capitalism.
The purpose of this article is to discuss Marx’s (1867, 1990) theory of original/primitive accumu-
lation (“ursprüngliche Akkumulation”), described in the first volume of Capital, and its relevance for
analyzing the role of (mass) media, online communication and communication systems, in the pro-
cess of capital accumulation. In order to revitalize Marx’s argument in Capital, the theory of origi-
nal/primitive accumulation is updated in relation to Harvey’s (2003; 2006; 2010a) theory of “accu-
mulation by dispossession”. Harvey draws on Marx’s discussion of primitive accumulation in order
to unfold the neo-liberal shift within the development of global capitalism.
Following a basic theoretical understanding of primitive accumulation and accumulation by dis-
possession the article addresses two key ideological aspects of news media content and media
structures in relation to the processes of accumulation by dispossession. The article examines the
media representation of social struggle against capital accumulation, and how news media content
and news media systems facilitate capital accumulation in the finance sector. Furthermore the arti-
cle taps into how surplus value is produced in the realm of Internet use, particularly Web 2.0, and
the development of communication technology. Here, some thoughts on how everyday Web surfing
could be understood as surplus labour and how users are transformed into commodities will be
addressed. In relation to the discussion on everyday online activities, Marx’s theory of origi-
nal/primitive accumulation provides an understanding of new forms of exploitation by the appropria-
tion of intellectual assets and creativity in the field of cultural production, distribution and communi-
cation in the Web 2.0. Here the article discusses how the commodification of free time, the self and
social relations, play a key part in the political economy of social media and the Internet. Included is
also a short section that discusses if Internet surveillance, and the commercial gathering, owning
and processing of personal information, could be understood as an underlying threat to subjects,
and a part of what Žižek (2008) defines as the objective violence of capitalist exploitation.
tripleC 10(2): 156-170, 2012 157
CC: Creative Commons License, 2012.
The article combines the results of empirical research on news media with examples of how the
everyday use of social media and intellectual assets and creativity in the field of cultural produc-
tion/distribution could be explained through a Marxist theory of capital accumulation in a time of
systemic crisis. Harvey’s updated version of Marx’s notion of original/primitive accumulation pro-
vides a strong argument for understanding the recent development of late capitalism.
2. The Process of Capital Accumulation
The immanent driving force of capitalism is the endless accumulation of capital, a process
where capital is accumulated for the sake of accumulation, or as Marx (1867,1990, 595) put it “ac-
cumulation for accumulation’s sake, production for production’s sake”. The very basic formula of
capital accumulation, outlined by Marx (1885,1992) in the second volume of Capital, draws on how
capital is circulated through several key phases:
M — C (Lp/Mp)…P (v/c)…C’ — M’
To put it simple - the accumulation of capital is obtained by the circulation of capital, where money
(M) is transformed into commodities (C) by the purchase of labour power (Lp) and means of pro-
duction (Mp). To secure accumulation, the money needs to be greater in the end of the process
than in the beginning, which means that the value of the produced commodity is higher than the
value of the commodities used as inputs. In the production process the value of labour power and
the means of production take the form of productive capital (P) when attached to the produced
commodity. The value of labour force (v) equals the costs of the labour power bought (wages) and
the value form of means of production (c) equals the cost of the means used (constant capital). So,
surplus value is generated when the commodity is sold at a higher price than the costs of produc-
tion, which is made possible by surplus labour (unpaid labour time). So what basically creates sur-
plus value is the amount of labour time that is not paid for by the capitalists. When the produced
commodity (C’) is sold, capital once again enters the process of circulation in the form of (new)
money (M’), and; the process of capital accumulation is thereby maintained (Marx 1867, 1990;
Harvey 1982, 2006, 156ff; Fuchs 2011, 138).
Marx’s theory of capital accumulation is highly complex and detailed (the whole second volume
of Capital is basically an outline of the trails of capital accumulation), but its still possible to simplify
it in this manner without losing too much of its inner nature. Under ordinary circumstances, capital
accumulation is secured through expanded reproduction
1
. In this process of reproduction, not only
commodities and surplus value are reproduced, but also the whole relationship between capital
and labour – between capitalists and wage labourers (Marx 1967/1990, 578). And since surplus
value relies on the exploitative relation between capital and labour force, the circulation of capital is
ultimately the reproduction of exploited wage labour by capitalists. The commodity labour power
(Lp) is subordinated to processes of absolute or relative exploitation. The former refers to the ex-
tension of the amount of time each worker needs to put in, and the latter to the intensification of the
labour process (Mosco 2009, 131).
The circulation of capital is an endless process, and given the inner contradictions of accumula-
tion, capitalism eventually faces systemic crisis. The historical Marxist debates over what type of
crises capitalism is undergoing tend to shift. Luxemburg (1913/2003) stresses the problems of un-
der-consumption to explain systemic crises, but under-consumption is hardly a sufficient explana-
tion of the crises within capitalism today. Harvey argues that capitalism is currently facing an over-
accumulation crisis
2
, because we are experiencing a situation “when both surplus capital and la-
bour exist but there are no way to bring them together” (Harvey 2006, 96). The over-accumulation
crisis manifests itself when there are superfluous commodities, money and productive capacity
form simultaneously with a surplus of labour power, but with the lack of “profitable opportunities” for
capital to expand (Harvey 2003, 88). In order to deal with an over-accumulation crisis, capital tries
to expand reproduction through temporal or spatial shifts. Harvey (2003, 89) calls these “spatio-
temporal fixes”. For example, by investing surplus capital and labour in long-term (large scale pub-
1
Marx (1867, 1990, 711ff) distinguishes between ”simple reproduction” and ”expanded reproduction” (Marx 1867, 1990;
1885, 1992). Simple reproduction is basically the reproduction of capital-labour relations without any accumulation of capi-
tal.
2
The definition of what characterizes over-accumulation crises is highly simplified here, since systemic crises tend to
inherit several dimensions (see Harvey 2003; 2006; 2010b, for a more in-depth analysis of systemic crises, & see Fuchs
2011, for an overview of different contemporary crises-explanations).
158 Mattias Ekman
CC: Creative Commons License, 2012.
lic) projects, or by relocating the surplus of capital and labour to other geographical spaces (Harvey
2006, 96). Capitalists have a tendency to expand reproduction geographically by relocating the
purchases of labour power or means of production elsewhere, and thus creating new spaces for
the accumulation of capital. Since capitalism is a global system, expanded reproduction often re-
sults in a situation where crises are moved around geographically. The spatio-temporal fixes are
reliant on and thrive from the advancement of communication technology and systems. Advance-
ments in transport and communication that compresses time-space relations are therefore at the
heart of temporal or spatial shifts. In search for new ways to invest surplus capital, capitalists also
strive to appropriate new forms of labour and new resources, both material (such as natural re-
sources), and immaterial (such as knowledge), into the circulation of capital. By doing so, it is pos-
sible to create surplus value from previously unexploited work and resources. One way to under-
stand the process of appropriation of labour and resources, in contemporary over-accumulation
crises is by looking back at the origins of the capitalist mode of production. In order to explain the
relation between geographical imperialism and global capital, Harvey (2003; 2006; 2010a) draws
on Marx’s discussion of “ursprüngliche” or primitive accumulation in the first volume of Capital, in
order to unfold the neo-liberal shift in our contemporary societies.
2.1. Primitive Accumulation
In Marx’s (1867, 1990, ch.26) discussion in Capital, primitive accumulation is the process in
which pre-capitalist modes of production are transformed into capitalism - it is the starting point of
the capitalist mode of production. Thus it is also the process, in which the producers are separated
from their means of production and where they are transformed into wage labourers that are sold
on the market (i.e. labour power becomes a commodity). So primitive accumulation also constitutes
the very process, in which the working class is formed:
The capital-relation presupposes a complete separation between the workers and the owner-
ship of the conditions for the realization of their labour. As soon as capitalist production stands
on its own feet, it not only maintains this separation, but reproduces it on a constantly extend-
ing scale. The process, therefore, which creates the capital-relation can be nothing other than
the process which divorces the worker from the ownership of the conditions of his own labour;
it is a process which operates two transformations, whereby the social means of subsistence
and production are turned into capital, and the immediate producers are turned into wage-
labourers. So-called primitive accumulation, therefore, is nothing else than the historical pro-
cess of divorcing the producer from the means of production. It appears as ‘primitive’, be-
cause it forms the pre-history of capital and of the mode of production corresponding to capi-
tal. (Marx 1867/1990, 874-875)
In Marx’s depiction of how the old feudal system was transformed into capitalism, the liberal ver-
sion of capitalism mounting like a natural evolution of capital is confronted by a much blunter ver-
sion of reality. The transformation of the feudalist system was a process marked by a brutal and
often violent expropriation of capital. The enclosure of the commons, the colonial system, imperial-
ism, the use of slave labour, the expulsion of peasant populations forced into industrial wage la-
bour, etc., were often violent. So in Marx’s version of the “ursprüngliche” or primitive accumulation,
violence plays a central part. As Marx (1867,1990, 875) argues in a famous statement in Capital;
“…the history of this, their expropriation, is written in the annals of mankind in letters of blood and
fire”. Undoubtedly Marx’s depiction of the historical process of capital is only partly true; there were
also peaceful or at least less violent transformations (Harvey 2010a, 304f). Nevertheless, Marx
exposed the liberal myth, painting a picture of a smooth transformation originated from the shoul-
ders of hardworking men with specialized labour skills that became employers – that story was
anything but true.
For the labourer, the process of primitive accumulation was double sided, workers were set free
from the feudal oppression system, slavery, etc. just to become entrapped in a new relation of ex-
ploitation, the system of wage labour – indirect forced labour. Or as Marx argues in Grundrisse, in a
comment on the indignation of a former slave master on the fact that slaves were freed from bond-
age, but did not become wage labourers in the plantations owned by the latter:
They have ceased to be slaves, but not in order to become wage laborers, but, instead, self-
sustaining peasants working for their own consumption. As far as they are concerned, capital
does not exist as capital, because autonomous wealth as such can exist only either on the
basis of direct forced labour, slavery, or indirect forced labour, wage labour. (Marx 1857/1993,
326)
tripleC 10(2): 156-170, 2012 159
CC: Creative Commons License, 2012.
We will return to some contemporary examples of how self-sufficient peasantry and collectively
owned and organized agricultural production (mobilized in the form of social movements such as
Movimento dos Trabalhadores Rurais Sem Terra [MST] and Via Campesina) is fighting the expul-
sion and enforcements of populations into wage-labour, and how media plays a crucial part in justi-
fying the expulsions in the name of economic development.
So, if primitive accumulation is the starting point of the capitalist mode of production, how could
it help us understand processes of capital accumulation in contemporary late capitalism? Harvey
(2003; 2005; 2006; 2010a) argues, inspired by Luxemburg (1913/2003), that many of the specific
features of primitive accumulation are highly visible in today’s modern neo-liberal capitalism. For
Marx the ‘normal’ process of accumulation is expanded reproduction, but Luxemburg (1913/2003)
argued that the continuous accumulation of capital also inherited a “primitive” feature. This formed
one key argument in her theory of imperialism - capital always creates new geographical spaces of
exploitation, or “capitalism’s penetration of non-capitalist societies” (Callinicos 2009, 40). Luxem-
burg’s theory can also be used for understanding how other milieus outside the circulation of capi-
tal are colonised by capital. Marxist feminists have attached Luxemburg’s idea of colonialism to the
reproductive work done by women in the household (Hartsock 2006). Reproductive work consti-
tutes “an inner colony and milieu of primitive accumulation”, by ensuring the reproduction of (male)
wage labourer (Fuchs 2011, 282).
Harvey (2006) argues that current accumulation of capital inherits characteristics from the origi-
nal process as well. In fact, accumulation through expanded reproduction and by dispossession
“are organically linked, dialectically intertwined” with each other (Harvey 2003, 176). There are at
least two key arguments that locate specific features of primitive accumulation (embedded) in
modern capitalist reproduction. First there are numerous examples of population expulsion and
appropriations of land (particularly in Latin America and Asia), there are violent extractions of natu-
ral resources (all over the global south); and there is systematic and sometimes extreme violence
against those who struggle against these processes all over the global south. The level of violence
has also been intensified in some instances (Harvey 2010a, 308). Secondly, it seems that the on-
going reproduction of capitalism continues to involve some of the characteristics of primitive accu-
mulation, such as increasing national debt and what Marx (1867/1990, 777ff) identified as the
growing credit system. The whole endeavour of the financial credits and loans handed out by IMF
and the World Bank have a striking resemblance to the emerging credit system and the state as
actor in processes of privatization several hundred years ago. Harvey (2003; 2005; 2006; 2010a)
describes these features of primitive accumulation as “accumulation by dispossession". It could be
described as the (futile) neo-liberal answer to a continuous decline in global growth (Harvey 2003,
145; 2006, 42). Accumulation by dispossession is characterized by four key elements: privatization,
financialization, the management and manipulation of crises and state redistributions (Harvey
2006)
2.1.1. Privatization
Accumulation by dispossession is manifested by the privatization of public assets - the appro-
priation of the commons. These privatizations include everything from natural resources (water,
land, air), infrastructure (public transport, telecommunications, energy supplies), social systems of
redistribution, social services, healthcare, education, public institutions, public housing, warfare,
and so on, basically anything that is not already included in the circulation of capital. There is also a
privatization of immaterial assets such as knowledge, genetic material, and reproduction process-
es. All these areas, which previously were outside capital accumulation because they were regard-
ed as commons, public services, of national interest, etc., are appropriated to different degrees in
the neo-liberal model of capitalism. By adding them to the circulation of capital they are incorpo-
rated into capitalist property relations, thus they also transform the social relations of subjects in
society. Students, patients, water drinkers, citizens, etc., are transformed into clients, customers
and buyers of goods and services as commodities. The process of accumulation by dispossession
is therefore ultimately a process of social exploitation. The contemporary process of privatization
has been defined by Indian writer and activist Arundhati Roy (2001 in Harvey 2006, 44-45) as a
“barbaric dispossession on a scale that has no parallel in history”.
Processes of privatization can be swift and clean without any particularly struggle or use of
force, this is predominantly the case in the global north where the state has been the main propa-
gator of privatizations. But the processes of dispossession in the global south are often followed by
harsh or violent expulsions of rural populations and appropriations of everyday natural resources
(Harvey 2006, 45). Sometimes the outcome of dispossessions is open social struggle and some-
times capital even loses. This was the case during the water wars in Cochabamba, Bolivia, in the
160 Mattias Ekman
CC: Creative Commons License, 2012.
late 1990s. During a wave of privatizations orchestrated by the IMF, the city’s public drinking water
was sold to the US-owned company Bechtel, which resulted in increasing water prices and a limita-
tion of supplies. The dispossession of water resulted in a hard struggle for the right to water as
basic human asset, which ultimately forced the city to re-buy the water rights (Olivera and Lewis
2004). So processes of privatization can also sharpen class struggle and class-consciousness in
various ways.
Privatization also includes warfare. War is in fact an increasingly commodified endeavour,
where private companies make huge profits in security and torture. Warfare is simply a process in
which huge transfer of government funding to private owned capital takes place. Luxemburg’s
(1913, 2003, 434) discussion of “militarism as a province of accumulation” of the early 20th-century
could basically be an explanation of today’s late capitalist imperialism, in which the military-
industrial complex plays a key role in facilitating expanded reproduction of capital and ‘creating’
new spaces of exploitation by violence and destruction (Žižek 2009).
The appropriation of public assets by dispossession creates the appearance of a growing ac-
cumulation because new areas of exploitation and processes of surplus value are added to the
circulation of capital.
2.1.2. Financialization
The second characteristic of accumulation by dispossession is financialization. The enor-
mous increase in financial capital is intertwined with deregulations of markets, a rapid development
of information and communication technology and the processes of privatization. Speculation in the
capitalist financial system has contributed to an apparent economical growth through major capital
redistributions. The financial system holds a particularly important position in the “thievery” of public
assets such as pensions (Harvey 2006, 45). The on-going build-up of fictitious capital, through
hedge funds, ponzi schemes and asset stripping, together with an overall emphasis on stock value,
generates an apparent economical growth. These processes were depicted as one main factor
when the global economic crisis set in 2008. Financialization, and the increasing importance of the
financial sector, also mark the stagnation phase in the so-called Kondratiev cycles that distinguish
growth and stagnation within the capitalist world system over historical periods (Arrighi 2010). Marx
(1867, 1990, 920) stressed the importance of the credit system in order to understand the growing
power of capital over states and the rapid (spatial) centralization of capital. As an example the IMF
and the World Bank are doing the job by setting “up micro-credit and micro-finance institutions to
capture what is called ‘the wealth at the bottom of the pyramid’ and then suck out all that wealth to
support ailing international financial institutions...and use that wealth to pay the asset and merger
games…” (Harvey 2010a, 272). Media researcher Almiron (2010) highlights the growing relation-
ship between financial capital and news media organizations. News media are increasingly de-
pendent on financial actors, such as banks, and therefore financialization has profound conse-
quences on news practices and content (Almiron, 2010).
2.1.3. The Management and Manipulation of Crises
Third, the neo-liberal turn in capitalism has resulted in orchestrated economic crises. Cri-
ses permit rapid redistribution of assets and economic shock therapy in the form of structural ad-
justment programs. Orchestrated crises were more or less the rule in Latin America during the
1980s and the 1990s. Debt crisis in single countries enabled quick changes to the IMF's structural
adjustment programs, and thereby transformed the national economies according to the neo-liberal
model propagated by transnational institutions such as IMF and the World Bank. These provoked
crises resulted in a massive relocation of capital and created an apparent accumulation of capital.
The crises produced a large population of unemployed labour force that created “a pool of low
wage surplus labour convenient for further accumulation” (Harvey 2006, 47). These crises also
expose the use of violence that is applied in order to secure the interest of capital. The violence
emanating in the intersection of capital and states is manifested through brutal suppression of pro-
tests, labour organizing and social movements all over the global south.
2.1.4. State Redistribution
In neo-liberal capitalism, the state is transformed into the most central actor in the redistribution
(privatization) of public assets. The privatization of the public sector, or large cuts in the funding of
public services, constitutes the fourth key element in accumulation by dispossession (Harvey 2006,
48). There are numerous examples of how the state, despite the political character of the ruling
government, has played a key role in processes of privatization. For example; the privatization of
tripleC 10(2): 156-170, 2012 161
CC: Creative Commons License, 2012.
the pension system under fascist dictatorship (in Chile 1980), during social-democratic govern-
ments (in Sweden in the late 1990s) and during the Peronist rule in Argentina (in the 1990s), privat-
ization of public housing in the UK during Thatcher’s government in the 1980s, during both social-
democratic and centre-right wing (local) governments in Sweden over the past fifteen years, and
the privatization of agricultural land during the nationalist rule [PRI] in Mexico in the 1990s. The list
of privatizations is almost endless. In the greater perspective, state redistributions spawn massive
relocations of public assets to private ownership. The transfer of public assets into the private sec-
tor is not only about the privatization of social services such as education, health care, social work,
infrastructure, pensions, etc., but it also involves pure money transfers to the business sector in the
form of bank rescue programs and government investment in the private sector. In the U.S. the
“corporate welfare programs” which signify the neo-liberal turn, have resulted in an enormous re-
distribution of taxpayer’s money into the hands of the private sector (Harvey 2006, 49).
The effects of state redistribution are sometimes violent. There are several cases of direct war-
fare against social mobilization, for example against social movements in Chiapas and Oaxaca,
Mexico, trade unionists in Colombia, the organized landless rural workers in the MST in Brazil, the
Adivasi in India, and so on. State redistribution may also involve a more latent symbolic violence
against people who are forced from their homes due to property speculation that surfaced in the
aftermath of the large privatization of public housing (as in London), or the expulsion of large popu-
lations caused by the private expropriation of natural resources (everywhere in the global South).
The formation of such indirect violence is a key attribute in several processes in late capitalism. We
will now tap into what distinguishes the violence of original/primitive accumulation in relation to our
contemporary era of new imperialism through accumulation by dispossession.
2.2. The Role of Violence in the Process of Accumulation
In order to understand the neo-liberal turn in capitalist accumulation and the processes that
mark the global expansion of capital, we must consider how global capital is connected to territorial
geo-politics in a neo-imperialist manner. Primitive accumulation or accumulation by dispossession
is basically a form of imperialism (Harvey 2003). Capitalism inherits a contradiction between the
global expansion of capital, and a territorial logic of power (geopolitical behaviour of nation states)
(Harvey 2006, 105). Harvey's (2003) analysis of imperialism shows that geopolitical rivalry and
global capital accumulation coincide and reshape the basis of accumulation. The analysis of capital
accumulation and the geopolitical development that consists of both primitive accumulation and
expanded reproduction reveal that violence plays a central role in the expansion of the capitalist
world system. Violence is simply part of the inner logic of accumulation, it surfaces when its needed
as a necessary component in securing the “right” of capital. Wallerstein (2001:29) argues that the
problems of expansion in a period of systemic crisis will be accompanied with potentially more vio-
lent capital expansion. Parallel to the political decline due to the weakening position of nation states
in relation to transnational institutions such as the IMF/WB, the process will undoubtedly increase
the amount of daily violence in the world system. Violence emerges at the intersection of global
capital accumulation, especially in the accumulation by dispossession, and the territorial geopolitics
of the U.S. as the leading hegemon in the world. So violence is inevitably part of a system that
breeds further economic and social inequality, and thus it can be understood as an intra-systemic
necessity.
Let us now turn to the specific role of violence in the accumulation by dispossession. The capi-
talist system relies on both active and underlying violence, as means of securing accumulation and
the private control over the means of production. Žižek (2008) distinguishes between subjective
and objective violence. Subjective violence, such as interpersonal aggression, crime, terror or the
repressive apparatus of the state, is overt and exercised with a specific intent of some sort (patho-
logical, political, patriarchal, religious, etc.). Objective violence is on the other hand built into the
practices of capitalism, and manifested in overt discrimination, structural racism, economic destitu-
tion, or other forms of more subtle exploitation. The two forms of violence are relational. Subjective
violence, for example the suburban riots in cities like Paris and London, can be comprehended in
its relation to objective violence, the annihilation of social trust caused by economic exploitation,
expulsion, racism and discrimination. Subjective violence is just the more visible of the two (Žižek
2008). As objective violence could be viewed as a consequence of the exploitative social relations
in capitalism, it also appears as an underlying threat of violent acts against those who contest it. In
this sense, the objective violence is part of what Gramsci defines as the consent of hegemony, a
form of violence that intertwines the two forms of capitalist dominance, force and consent, or to put
it in Gramsci’s (1929-35, 1971, 263) words: “hegemony protected by the armour of coercion”. Sub-
jective and objective violence are two different manifestations of systemic violence constituted in
162 Mattias Ekman
CC: Creative Commons License, 2012.
relation to socio-political power and economic exploitation. The global capitalist accumulation by
dispossession is often marked with overt systemic violence in the form of crisis therapy, physical
destruction of traditional means of production, and material expropriation through warfare and oc-
cupation, as we have seen in Iraq (Žižek 2009,17), and by an increasingly violent, economic im-
poverishment of subjects in the global South (Ekman 2011). Violence becomes a common feature
of capitalist exploitation processes, much so because the system tends to increase an extreme
asymmetry in the distribution of assets during processes of expropriation. Objective violence also
includes symbolic violence, or what Galtung (1990) defines as “cultural violence”. It refers to those
aspects of culture that “can be used to justify or legitimize direct or structural violence” (Galtung
1990, 291). So in relation to Žižek’s model, cultural violence could include those aspects of news
media that legitimize the use of force against social mobilization and protests, or to news media
that justifies war.
So, in conclusion, we can view the historical processes of primitive accumulation preceding the
capitalist mode of production, i.e. as a historical formation, characterized by colonialism, imperial-
ism, mass expulsions of populations, the creations of mass industries, the working class and capi-
talists. But we can also consider primitive accumulation as a continuation of characteristics that are
embedded in the capitalist mode of production. The never-ending appropriation of labour and re-
courses through time and space, forced into capitalist property relations, are undoubted tainted by
many of the features described by Marx (1867, 1990). At the end, the main feature of primitive ac-
cumulation is the forced separation of means of production from the producers.
3. The General Role of Media and Communication in the Accumulation of
Capital
There is a bundle of theoretical and empirical work that draws on Marx’s theory of capital in or-
der to understand the role of media and communication in the accumulation of capital (cf. Mosco
2009; McChesney 2007). Fuchs (2011, 141ff) distinguishes between several aspects, both internal
to media and communication (as industries) and external to media and communication (as general
accounts) that might illuminate its specific role in the processes of capital accumulation. I will only
touch upon a couple of aspects that could be useful in order to understand media and communica-
tion in relation to primitive accumulation or accumulation by dispossession. The first aspect deals
with the ideological dimension of media content and the structural relations between news systems
and the financial sector. The ideological element is crucial to the reproduction of capitalism in vari-
ous ways, economically, politically, juridical and so forth. For example, the media have a powerful
position in reifying social relations by normalizing and facilitating the privatization of everyday life.
For example, media content produces the audiences as consumers of goods and services. The
aim here is not to evoke too much of the historical discussion of ideology critique, but to distin-
guishes some core ideological elements in relation to accumulation by dispossession. Second, the
discussion on how the free time of individuals is appropriated and transformed into surplus labour,
touches upon the notion of how social media work as an infrastructure for advertisement that ad-
vances capital accumulation (cf. Fuchs 2011, 149). Social media and modern information technol-
ogy are crucial in the compression of time and space in the everyday circulation of commodities.
We are, when using smart-phones, going online, and so on, constantly targeted as consumers. In
fact, most parts of the Internet have been commercialized, and processes of commodification con-
stantly subjugate users. There is not much that separates commercial from non-commercial con-
tent on the Internet (Hesmondhalgh 2007, 259).
3.1. News Media and the Naturalization of Accumulation by Dispossession
I would like to address a couple of cases, in which both structural and ideological dimensions
of news media could be pinpointed in relation to processes of primitive accumulation and accumu-
lation by dispossession. The first case discusses the role of news in relation to the privatization of
public services and how news media coincide with the interest of, and facilitates the practices of,
the financial sector (cf. Almiron 2010; Hope 2010). The second example deals with the media rep-
resentation of the global justice movement, global protests and the World Social Forum in Swedish
mass media (Ekman 2011).
3.1.1. Endorsing Privatization and Facilitating Financialization
In the 1980s and the 1990s most of the countries in the world were swept along the wave
of privatizations that mark the neo-liberal turn in the global capitalist system. In Sweden, where the
tripleC 10(2): 156-170, 2012 163
CC: Creative Commons License, 2012.
public sector previously was well developed and economically prioritized, processes of deregula-
tion and privatization transpired in an increasing speed. The situation in Sweden reflected, more or
less, the tendencies that were visible in the rest of Western Europe. In correspondence to the rapid
wave of privatization in the 1990s the noun “market”
3
emerged as one of the most prominent
agents in the news on economical matters (cf. Mårtenson 2003; Viscovi 2006). The representation
of the “market” as a unified actor, which reacts on political decisions, declares which political actors
are good or bad, and decides on how to view the overall economic condition, changed the dis-
course of news reporting on economical matters (Mårtenson 2003). The mediated notion of the
“market” emerged as an ideological element to the neo-liberal turn and the massive deregulation of
the capitalist economy. In correspondence to the emergence of the “market”, news turned to the
financial sector, and the stock market became a prevailing feature. This also meant that actors
from the financial sector tended to dominate as experts in the everyday news flow. The representa-
tion of economic issues were signified by a shift from labour markets, unions, etc. to the financial
markets and the construction of the mediated citizen as a private-economic subject (as opposed to
wage-labourer, or someone outside the realm of finance speculation) (Viscovi 2006). Almiron’s
(2010, 167) study on two leading Spanish newspapers in 2006 shows a similar result. Financial
actors and indicators dominate the news, and Almiron (2010, 167) conclude that: “the lack of inde-
pendent journalistic investigation in most of the information was almost absolute”. The paradigm
shift within the news, identified by Mårtenson (2003) and Viscovi (2006), corresponded with the
process of financialization in accumulation by dispossession.
Let’s consider one specific Swedish case that signifies the role of news media in endorsing pri-
vatization by facilitating the transfer of ordinary people’s savings into the financial market, and one
truly global phenomenon that shows how news flows become intertwined with financial flows and
how the interests of financial news coincide with the interests of financial actors.
In June 2000 the publically owned telecommunication company Telia was partly privatized (30
percent was sold to the public). Almost one million Swedes became shareholders after substantial
commercial advertising (in television, newspapers and in the public space) and after a political
campaign (the whole privatization was endorsed on a personal level by the minister of finance)
aided by news media. In the process of privatizing part of the company, the stock was promoted as
a “people’s-share”
4
in the news. This ideological noun was used in order to smoothen out the fact
that the public now could buy something that was already in their possession, and with the oppor-
tunity to make a profit
5
. For example, a couple of weeks prior to the privatization, the second larg-
est tabloid, Expressen, published several articles endorsing the readers to purchase shares. One
article used the luring headline: “Eight reasons in favor of Telia…This is why the share might be-
come a winner” (Bolander 2000a). Articles, both in tabloids and dailies, used financial actors to
boost the privatization and the opportunity to make a quick profit: “Stock market experts believe in
a killing on the market” (headline in Bolander 2000b), “Telia is predicted a good start. Experts ad-
vise to purchase the new people’s-share” (headline in Magnusson, 2000). Some articles were just
plain buyers guides: “How to purchase Telia – the new people’s-share” (headline in Norlin, 2000),
“How you can purchase the people’s-share” (headline in Wedel, 2000). The list of articles aiding
the privatization could be extended. The whole construction of a “people’s-share” is very much a
media phenomenon interlinked to the increasing focus on the financial sector. When searching the
largest Swedish press archive Mediearkivet, it reveals that the term “people’s-share” appeared in a
total of 186 articles prior to the privatization of Telia. But from the year 1999, when the privatization
process started, and onwards, it has appeared 1113 times, peaking at 400 articles in the year
2000. The seven biggest Swedish newspapers published 220 articles containing the word “peo-
ple’s-share” in the year 2000 alone.
The privatization of public infrastructures such as telecommunication services corresponds to
similar processes of marketization within news production (Almiron 2010). The mounting commer-
cialization of news and the increasing symbiosis between financial news and the financial sector,
paralleled by limited economic recourses and increasing time limits within journalistic production,
results in a very uncritical journalism (of course with notable exceptions). The harsher conditions of
news journalism as a result of increasing demands of higher profit margins (obtained from what
Marx defines as relative surplus value, 1867, 1990, 429ff), simultaneously with a decrease in sales,
make financial news an easy target for economically well-situated actors in the financial markets.
3
The ”market” will be used in brackets to signify its ideological status.
4
The noun “people’s-share”, corresponds to the concept of the “people’s-home”, a term used to explain the Swedish
welfare model that prevailed in Swedish society during the post WW II-period. The concept of a people’s-home, was first
used in 1928 in a speech by Swedish Prime Minister Per Albin Hansson (Meidner 1993, 212).
5
However, this was not the case. The share became a huge disappointment, and by 2010 the value was reduced to half
the launching price in 2000 (Dalarnas Tidningar 2010).
164 Mattias Ekman
CC: Creative Commons License, 2012.
So apart from the obvious role of information and communication technology in facilitating the cir-
culation of capital in the financial markets, the equivalent role of traditional news media should not
be overlooked (cf. Hope 2010).
So, let us now look at a more global phenomenon where news media coincide with the interest
of, and facilitates the practices of, financial markets. We now move to the accumulation of capital
that Marx defines as M-M’, money generated out of money (Marx 1867, 1990, 248). The relation-
ship between news media and the financial sector is not new; on the contrary it goes back to the
very first European newspaper, owned by a banking family (Almiron, 2010, 68). However, as a
consequence of the massive deregulations of the financial sector (banking, credit flows, etc.) and
the emergence of new means for financial speculation through information and communication
technology in the 1990s, information within news media flows and financial flows started to overlap
in real time (Hope 2010, 654). Broadcasters such as Bloomberg and CNBC became engines in the
mounting flow of asset transfers within the financial sector, generating a massive speculative finan-
cial economy. In the 1980s and 90s large television networks fused with the world of financial
transactions, providing vast amounts of financial information to journalists all over the world (Hope
2010). One could argue that finance broadcasting provided the raw material (in the form of digits,
index, rates, financial “expert” discourses, etc.) to news outlets all over the world. This raw material
was then used in producing news in different media settings in different economic and geographical
contexts. A rapid movement on the stock markets somewhere in the global financial system had a
direct impact on both actors in the financial sector as well in the media sector. In the mid 1990s
these media/finance flows of information were also transferred online, creating an instant flow of
financial information on the Internet. The merger of interests between the field of finance capital
and news journalism that was visible to a certain extent in the 1980s became more or less standard
after the rapid development of information and communication technologies in the 1990s (Hope
2010). In the beginning of the 21
st
century “most of the top news-media conglomerates have expe-
rienced a huge increase in their financial links and dependencies” (Almiron 2010, 152). So consid-
ering the instant flow of information through communication systems, the growth within the financial
sector exploded in the first years of the past decade. The increase in Web-based financial actors
flourished alongside computer generated algorithmic trading, secrete hedge funds, derivative trad-
ing, asset-stripping, and so on, creating an enormous build-up of fictitious capital. In all this, the
relationship between actors within journalism and in the financial sector became even more
blurred, both in case of ownership and personal interests among journalists. For example, high-
prolific journalists became advisers on financial blogs and the blogosphere “helped to constitute the
informational environments of financial print media and business television channels” (Hope 2010,
660).
The mutual interest between news and the financial sector was a great factor in the (almost) to-
tal failure of journalism in the build up to the economic crisis in 2008 (Almiron, 2010). The general
oblivious attitude among journalists and news producers towards the preceding financial break
down in 2008 have rendered some internal criticism (see for example Schechter 2009; Fraser
2009), but the overall discussion of the political economy of financial news is still marginal outside
critical media research.
So considering the role of financial news outlets and economical journalists, news media have
without a doubt contributed to the increasing speculation in the financial system, by aiding the pro-
cesses of financialization. The ‘superfluousness’ of financial information, instantly transferred
through communication systems, has together with an increasing dependency on, and ownership
by, financial actors, contributed to uncritical news flows on economic issues. You could even argue
that a major part of the financial news is mere an informational infrastructure of finance capital in-
terests. In relation to what Marx (1867/1990, 920) identified as the emerging credit system (what is
basically today’s finance system), the role of banks, credit institutions and other financial actors
could not be understated in relation to the compression of time and space through communications
systems. Undeniably, the function of ICT’s and financial news flows in facilitating the rapid centrali-
zation of capital in the hands of financial institutions, establishes them as key actors much as the
banks and the credit system in the historic processes of primitive accumulation (Marx 1867, 1990).
3.1.2. The Global Justice Movement: Violence and Politics
The global justice movement is at the forefront of the struggle against accumulation by dispos-
session. It is a diverse but socially and politically coherent movement of movements that addresses
the specific relation between capital and processes that resemble the features of primitive accumu-
lation described by Marx. The struggles fought by different social movements are aimed at ongoing
processes of peasant expulsions, privatization of natural recourses, the thievery of land and means
tripleC 10(2): 156-170, 2012 165
CC: Creative Commons License, 2012.
of production, the suppression of indigenous people, the financial system of debts and structural
adjustment programs, all coerced by national and global capital aided by brute state power. In con-
clusion, the global justice movement could be seen as a social and political reaction to the pro-
cesses that constitute capital accumulation by dispossession (Harvey 2010a, 313).
The mobilizations against a series of global summits towards the end of the last millennium be-
came visible to a transnational public during the WTO-meeting in Seattle in late November 1999.
Following an explosion of protests around the world at similar events, the Global Justice Movement
made headline news all over the world (Klein 2001). Through the creation of the World Social Fo-
rum (WSF) in 2001, the diverse political resistance generated by the dispossession of labour, re-
sources and land, constituted a common ground. The World Social Forum facilitates a unique
space for discussions, meetings, seminars, and social contacts that generates diverse political
collaborations, platforms, campaigns, and decisions (Sen and Waterman 2009). In short - the WSF
and the global justice movement represent the first step in organizing global resistance against
capital in an age that has been characterized as post-political (Mouffe 2008).
So, how did the social mobilizations of the global justice movement come to the fore in (Swe-
dish) mainstream news? On the one hand, the more moderate political issues connected to the
features of accumulation by dispossession such as debt relief, financial speculation and the conse-
quences of deregulations, did make it into the news flow. The demand for debt relief, taxes on fi-
nancial speculation and the right to certain basic goods (particularly water), were addressed in the
mainstream, and sometimes even endorsed by political commentators and actors outside the glob-
al justice movement. On the other hand, at the end, it also became clear that most of the represen-
tation focused on the social and political impossibilities of achieving any larger changes within the
global economic system. When political action was represented in the news media, such as in the
mobilization for a total debt relief, the framing neglected the long-going struggle among social
movements against the structural adjustment programs of the IMF and the World Bank. Instead
representatives of Western governments were given credit for putting the issue on the agenda of
global summits (Ekman 2011). A similar conclusion could be drawn from research made on US
news media. As Lance Bennett and colleagues conclude from their study on US news media: “Per-
haps the greatest irony in the journalistic construction of the globalization debate is that WEF elites
were given disproportionate credit for issues that activists had long before defined and attempted to
get into the news on their own terms” (Bennett et al. 2004, 450). The struggles of large social
movements against accumulation by dispossession were mostly ignored and when they did come
to the fore in the news, their struggles were often depicted as obsolete. In the dominating liberal
discourse on globalization, peasant mobilization and struggle were framed as something that
stalled wider economic progress and prosperity in the global south. At least this was the case in the
mainstream reporting on the political agenda of the World Social Forum (Ekman 2011).
More radical political issues that confronted the very rationale of global economic and political
structures were less visible; instead much of the news coverage tended to focus either on what
was framed as a political and social incoherence of the global justice movement or at the violence
occurring during the protests. In the case of the global protests against summits, the political di-
mension in the news flow was totally subordinated to reports about violence, or even reports about
potential violence. The latter was manifested by news reports on upcoming protests as violent
threats, as unavoidable violent confrontations, and even as non-present violence (through com-
ments on the surprisingly peaceful character of demonstrations) (Ekman 2011, 136). When political
matters were addressed, the global justice movement was described negatively in relation to the
dominant institutional practices and processes in summits (Ekman 2011).
A closer look at the representation of violence reveals that it constitutes one of the primary ex-
pectations in the news reporting. The focus on violence forms an element in a far-reaching histori-
cal understanding of protests, which is naturalized in the discursive practices between journalism
and state/police institutions (cf. Halloran, Elliot and Murdock 1970; Murdock 1981; Carter and
Weaver 2003; Doyle 2003; Cottle 2006). Mediated violence tends to reproduce a police-based law
and order discourse, and works as a rationalization of power, in which journalism first and foremost
reproduces the image of systemic violence as necessary for protecting citizens and for maintaining
general order in relation to organized violent protests (cf. Wahl-Jorgensen 2003). So, mediated
violence could be viewed as a double-edged sword in relation to the social mobilization of the glob-
al justice movement. On the one hand, news media dismiss part of the protests and the protesters
for being violent. On the other hand, news media legitimize and justifies systemic violence by main-
ly disseminating a police discourse of law and order (cf. Galtung 1990). For example, in the news
representation of the mobilization against the WTO-meeting in Cancún 2003, news media natural-
ized the militarization of the meeting by framing it as an issue of “security” (Ekman 2011). Several
166 Mattias Ekman
CC: Creative Commons License, 2012.
news articles depicted the massive presence of military and police (more than 20.000), military
helicopters, military vessels and police barriers as “protection” for the WTO-delegates (Ekman
2011, 157). Simultaneously, the demonstrations were depicted as threats to “free trade” (Ekman
2011, 156). This form of objective violence emerges at the intersection of state/capital militarization
and news media (cf. Zizek 2008).
In conclusion, the news representation of the global justice movement is dominated by hege-
monic discourses on globalization, economics, social protests and politics. The rationale of neo-
liberal ideology is manifested in the dominant discourse of “globalism” (cf. Fairclough 2006). It
holds a preferential position in explaining how social change takes place in mediated public political
debates during the period of contested neo-liberal hegemony (between 1999-2007, Ekman 2011).
News coverage of global mobilization and resistance are ultimately reified as a result of the ab-
sence of any larger discussions or explanations of the global economic system that are not intra-
systemic. Instead the reality is truncated, simplified and packaged, and complex social relation-
ships are reified in relation to dominant discourses of the global economy (Ekman 2011). As media
scholar Berglez (2006, 180) argues: journalism “partly embraces and ‘shows understanding’ for the
political struggle against the capitalist system, although in terms of neutralizing the radical dimen-
sion of the political struggle (making it less leftist and class-located), thereby paving the way for the
transformation of the radical political struggle into another (normal) everyday life practice“. So,
huge global social mobilizations against accumulation by dispossession, do not gain any significant
political legitimization through conventional media exposure.
3.2. Dispossession of Everyday Online Activity
The second part, in which Harvey’s theory of accumulation by dispossession could be used in rela-
tion to media and communication research, is by examining the specific role of online communica-
tion systems and platforms. Here Marx’s (1867/1990, 668ff) discussion on how surplus value is
generated could explain how work performed by users of social media are appropriated by capital
and transformed into surplus labour. So here we will tap into the ongoing discussion of how to un-
derstand the activity performed by everyday users of social media on Web 2.0 (often refer to as
produsers) in relation to capitalist interests (cf. Fuchs 2009; Jakobsson and Stiernstedt 2010). The
production of surplus value by exploiting the activity performed on social media sites such as Fa-
cebook, YouTube, etc. is made possible by selling users, and more specifically, the output of their
work, to advertisers. The concept of media audiences as commodities is well debated within the
research field of political economy of communication (cf. Smythe 1982; Mosco 2009, 136ff). The
main element in Smythe’s (1982) argument is that the audience constitutes the main commodity of
the mass media (Mosco 2009, 136). Smythe’s concept highlighted the role of media producers in
the construction of audiences in relation to advertisers. The idea of audience commodification also
located media organizations into the “total capitalist economy” (Mosco 2009, 137), as an integrated
part in the circulation of capital. However, the idea of audiences performing work for media owners,
for example by watching television, have been largely debated within the field of political economy
(Mosco 2009, 137). Media scholar Bolin (2011, 37) suggests that viewing television could be un-
derstood as “a part of the recreation of the worker’s labour power”. Watching TV is not an activity
that produces something, but instead a process that could be defined as a raw material in the pro-
duction process undertaken by advertisers and media companies. Thus, watching television is part
of the means of production (viewer as statistics), but it can’t be considered labour (Bolin, 2011, 37).
In the first phase of the circulation of capital, when the capitalist acts as a buyer of commodities,
companies purchases statistic on viewer demographics (Mp) used in producing advertisements (cf.
Marx 1867/1990). However, Mosco (2009, 137) argues that whether Smythe’s idea of audiences
constituting labour is useful or not could be left aside. Instead the main insight of the materialist
approach in Smythe’s theory is the concept of a reciprocal relationship in the triad of “media com-
pany-audience-advertiser” (Mosco 2009, 137). The idea that mass media are not only ideological
producers or transmitters, but also totally integrated in the circulation of capital is unquestionably
useful when analyzing the political economy of mass media.
In the case of users of Web 2.0, the process of appropriation is indeed a process of appropriat-
ed labour. The work dispossessed by capital is everything users do when they are communicating
through various commercial platforms and sites on the Internet. For example, in the case of Face-
book and other networking platforms, this process of transferring surplus labour of online activity by
everyday users into the circulation of capital, is refined by providing to advertisers specific seg-
ments of users, based on the information obtained from Web traffic, preferences and activities on
networking sites and other places on the Internet. Here the appropriated labour consists of every-
thing we do when we are online. Most parts of the work performed by users are monitored and
tripleC 10(2): 156-170, 2012 167
CC: Creative Commons License, 2012.
enclosed by different networking sites, search engines, e-mail services, etc. Here you could actual-
ly speak about a process that separates the means of production (intellectual, communicative and
creative) from the worker (produsers) (Marx 1867/1990:875). It is not a direct forced separation, but
an indirect one. The indirect forcing factors are basically the disadvantages that you might experi-
ence when being outside a network platform such as Facebook, for example the loss of job-
opportunities, personal connections, social relations, and other immaterial assets. The price of
being outside could be measured against the fact that you “sell” all your information and activities
to a commercial actor to be able to participate. As a consequence, everyday online activity consti-
tutes a dynamic field of potential surplus labour ready to be transformed into surplus value. This is
refined by surveillance systems that track user behaviours and monitor activity by categorizing
what is uploaded, “liked” (in the case of Facebook), what your e-mails contains (in the case of
Gmail), what Websites you visit on a regular basis, and basically everything that you do when surf-
ing the corporate part of the World Wide Web (Fuchs 2011; Jakobsson and Stiernstedt 2010).
However it is not only the time and the work, in the form of texts, images, videos, and other as-
pects of personal information (in the form of unpaid labour) that are dispossessed by capital. Net-
work sites such as Facebook also transform the social relations between users and business cor-
porations. When users integrate companies, brands, and other commodities into their everyday
social networks, the producer-consumer relationship becomes just another personal relationship,
much like the one you have in your everyday social life. For example, Coca Cola has almost 40
million fans on its Facebook page
6
. Since companies, brands and products have their own pages in
networking sites such as Facebook, the interaction between business and consumers is, potential-
ly, instant and never ending. The activities on social networks sites also advance commodified
individualism by transforming inter-personal communication in relation to products and consump-
tion (cf. Fuchs 2011, 315). The marketing strategies of big multi-national companies aim to capti-
vate the social being in itself, creating milieus that colonize every lasting part of private and per-
sonal life. This reflects, or indeed advances, what Jhally (2000, 29) refers to as the “overwhelm-
ing…commercial colonization of our culture”. The most ultimate appearance of this reification pro-
cess is probably the ideology and practice that indulges the construction of the individual self as a
brand, or as a platform for commercial branding. This is a phenomenon that is highly visible in the
blogosphere. In the anticipation of catching the eye of advertising firms, in order to get some reve-
nue from the business sector, thousands of bloggers act like advertising posters for brand names
and products by incorporating and mediating their consumption in communication platforms in Web
2.0. Consequently communication platforms and infrastructures constitute a highly dynamic arena
for dispossession of labour and the “life” outside ordinary wage-labour. When free time and the
social conditions of every-day life become integrated in the production-consumption relation of
capital accumulation, users are reified simply by being unpaid producers of images, texts, videos,
stories, etc., that transform them into commodities that are sold to advertisers and companies. All
the user-generated content on commercial platforms such as Facebook are owned, stored and
processed with the purpose of generating surplus value, this is of course the whole idea of corpo-
rate investments. In fact, the Internet is overflowed by capital interests, so you could primarily char-
acterize it as a “space…dominated by corporations (Fuchs 2011, 337).
The rapid development of information and communication technology also has implications for
the commodification of public space. For example, in relation to the research on the privatization of
public space (cf. Harvey 1989; Sennett 1992), contemporary mobile phone technology has new
and dynamic ways of luring subjects into the production-consumption relation of capital accumula-
tion. The traditional debate on the privatization processes of public space has focused on how pub-
lic spaces are transformed into shopping malls, corporatized areas, gated communities and so on,
creating what Sennett (1992) refers to as “dead public spaces”. These sanitized and corporately
controlled commodified spaces are increasingly visible all over the globe. The most striking feature
of these spaces is how they affect social relations and behaviours, by incorporating and naturaliz-
ing patterns of consumption into the organization of everyday life.
However, with the rapid development of mobile phone technology, all public spaces become po-
tentially commodified. The mere fact that a person may well be constantly logged in to her/his Fa-
cebook account through the mobile phone opens up for a whole new dimension of the commodifi-
cation of public space. This suggests that you are, at least potentially, submitted to constant corpo-
rate surveillance, monitored by several actors integrated in your online networks, and thus perform-
ing unpaid labour that is appropriated by capital. This has serious implications for the very idea of
privacy (cf. Fuchs 2011, 313) and in fact the whole notion of what constitutes free time, what con-
stitutes work and public space. Since smart phones enable the interaction between conventional
6
In the form of “likes” (Facebook 2012).
168 Mattias Ekman
CC: Creative Commons License, 2012.
advertisement (billboards, posters, etc.) and online activities by the use of Quick response-codes
(QR) etc., the activities in physical public space (whether in the subway on your way to work or at
the billboard posted on the wall in your neighbourhood) are integrated with your activities in your
virtual space. The “apps” that seems to facilitate individual communication patterns, also colonize
private subjects and alter patterns of social behaviour in everyday life by transferring them into the
production-consumption relation of capital accumulation. The “apps” have a double-commodified
character, they are goods that users are purchasing, and they also engage users in more consum-
er-based activities. Needless to say, the development of mobile phones and the massive disloca-
tion of space when performing online communication also open up for a more positive and creative
non-commercial communicative behaviour. It can enable political and social mobilization and re-
sistance to capital and the political structures that uphold the exploitation of labour (Fuchs 2011).
The problem is of course not rapid development of communication technology, but the colonization
of communicative social relations by capital.
In relation to the features of accumulation by dispossession, the surveillance and invasion of
privacy by corporate Internet owners such as Facebook, MySpace, Gmail, YouTube, and so on,
could be understood as means to expand the reification of social relations and the self. But I will
also like to stress the possibilities of one other factor immanent in the processes of primitive accu-
mulation – violence. If we accept Žižek’s (2008) idea of systemic violence as inherited by a subjec-
tive (physical) and an objective (structural or symbolic) dimension, we could argue that corporate
surveillance of private subjects through technologies that monitor the information we upload, and
the activities we participate in our online activities, constitute a potential objective violence. The
ownership of such a great amount of information on the private being of individuals and groups,
without any transparency of how this huge bundle of information is stored or used, could be com-
prehended as a potential threat to subjects. Besides the fact that advertised based networks and
platforms already censor and forbid certain content and activities in order to satisfy advertisers
(Fuchs 2011), the information of private subjects could potentially be sold to anyone. This implies
that information regarding political issues or other socially sensitive oriented matters (how private
the user may think they are in respect to privacy settings and person-to-person communication)
could be gathered and used for purposes other than commercial advertising. So, in this respect,
the surveillance of the corporate Internet could be comprehended as a potential threat simply be-
cause there is no guarantee what the information will be used for, who is buying it and to what ex-
tent private/personal information is circulated. Sensitive information, owned, gathered and pro-
cessed by companies like Facebook, could be sold as commodities to actors within the military-
industrial complex, or to political actors. Since surveilled subjects, and the constant flow of infor-
mation emanating from users, are commodities in the market place, objective violence appears as
an underlying threat to those whose personal/private information contests the current interests of
the ruling political and economical powers.
4. Conclusion
In order to identify the role and function of news media and communication systems in the ongoing
accumulation of capital, I have argued that Marx’s (1867/1990) concept of primitive accumulation
and Harvey’s (2003; 2006; 2010) theory of accumulation by dispossession could contribute to criti-
cal media and communication research. The concept of primitive accumulation as a continuing set
of characteristics within the expanded reproduction of capital is useful in order to understand some
distinctive elements in contemporary news media content, news flows and news media systems,
and within the development of online communication platforms. The processes that distinguish
capital accumulation in the time of neo-liberal global expansion, coincide with many of Marx’s de-
scriptions of how pre-capitalist modes of production were transformed into capitalism. The ongoing
global crisis reveals that expanded reproduction of capital is facing many constrains, and thus the
search for new ways to secure the accumulation of capital indicate that more and more aspects of
our societies are, and will continue to be, relocated into capital property relations. In these trans-
formation processes, new areas of commodification are located and new ways of appropriating
unpaid (free time) labour are developed. In these processes news media systems and online com-
munication play a considerable dynamic part. This article has targeted two areas in which primitive
accumulation/accumulation by dispossession could contribute to the research field of the political
economy of media and communication.
First, I have addressed the specific ideological dimension of news and the function of financial
news flows and systems in relation to capital accumulation. Second, I have discussed various as-
pects of how surplus value is produced in relation to everyday Internet use and in relation to the
rapid advancement of communication technology.
tripleC 10(2): 156-170, 2012 169
CC: Creative Commons License, 2012.
The first aspect that can be summarized here is how news media facilitate the privatization of
the commons, endorse the transfer of public assets into private property relations and depoliticize
and delegitimize social mobilization against capital. Furthermore the article shows how news flows
and news media systems coincide and interlink with financial flows and actors, thus constituting a
close relationship between financial news and the finance sector. This relationship is also attached
to the rapid changes within information and communication technology and the compression of
time and space in capital accumulation.
The second aspect dissects the political economy of Web. 2.0 with a specific focus on how pro-
dusers are commodified and sold to advertisers and how the work performed by users in network
platforms such as Facebook is appropriated by capital. The commodification of social media and
Internet use has potentially far-reaching possibilities. The colonization of free time, the total com-
mercialization of recreation, personal social relations and even the self, by capital, is made possible
by the corporate control over the user dimension in social networks and other social media plat-
forms. Internet surveillance, in which commercial gathering, owning and processing of private in-
formation, is one of the major assets in the circulation of capital and could be viewed as a potential-
ly threat to users, and even a part of the objective violence constituted in capitalist exploitation.
Undeniably this article has focused on the negative aspects of how mainstream news media fa-
cilitates and reproduces the exploitation of capital, how the use of new information/communication
technology become colonized by capital, and how commodification processes tend to dominate the
flow of information in global media and communication systems. However, there are also several
aspects of media production and communication technology that point in an opposite direction and
open up for counter-hegemonic formations in a global context. The dynamic production and circula-
tion of alternative and radical media and the ongoing struggle for a commons-based Internet are
important aspects to highlight within critical media and communication research. The realm of news
media production and communication technologies is never monolithic, thus it also needs to be
theorized and analyzed from the perspective of emerging alternatives (cf. Fuchs 2011). After all,
the seminal theory of Marx on capitalism also points out alternatives to the total exploitation of capi-
tal.
References
Almiron, Núria. 2010 Journalism in Crisis. Corporate Media and Financialization. New Jersey: Hampton Press.
Arrighi, Giovanni. 2010. The Long Twentieth Century. London: Verso.
Bennett, W. L. Pickard, V. Iozzi, D. Schroeder, C. Lagos, T. and Caswell, E. 2004. Managing the public sphere: Journalistic
construction of the great globalization debate. Journal of Communication 54: 437-455.
Berglez, Peter. 2006. The Materiality of Media Discourse - On Capitalism and Journalistic Modes of Writing. Örebro: Örebro
Studies in Media and Communication 4.
Bolander, Hans. 2000a. Åtta skäl som talar för Telia. Expressens Hans Bolander: Därför kan aktien bli en vinnare. Ex-
pressen, May 21. 6.
Bolander, Hans. 2000b. Börsexperterna tror på klipp. Expressen, May 31. 6.
Bolin, Göran. 2011. Value and the Media. Farnham and Burlington: Ashgate.
Callinicos, Alex. 2009. Imperialism and Global Political Economy. London: Polity Press.
Carter, Cynthia. and Weaver, C. K. 2003. Violence and the Media. Buckingham and Philadelphia: Open University Press.
Cottle, Simon. 2006. Mediatized conflict: developments in media and conflict studies. New York: Open University Press.
Dalarnas Tidningar. 2010. Så mycket har Teliaaktien fallit. Dalarnas Tidningar 14 June 2010. Accessed 25 February 2012.
http://www.dt.se/nyheter/dalarna/1.3086140-sa-mycket-har-teliaaktien-fallit
Doyle, Aaron. 2003. Arresting Images: Crime and Policing in Front of the Television Camera. Toronto: Toronto University
Press.
Ekman, Mattias. 2011. The Global Justice Movement in Swedish Media: Hegemonic formations in the relation between
journalism and capitalism. (English title) Stockholm: JMK.
Facebook. 2012. Facebook CocaCola. Accessed 20 February 2012. http://www.facebook.com/cocacola
Fairclough, Norman. 2006. Language and Globalization. New York: Routledge.
Fraser, Matthew. 2009. Five reasons for crash blindness. British Journalism Review 20(4): 78-83.
Fuchs, Christian. 2009. Some reflections on Manuel Castells’ book Communication Power. tripleC – Cognition, Communica-
tion, Co-operation: Open Access Journal for a Global Sustainable Information Society 7(1): 94-108. Accessed 27 Feb-
ruary 2012. http://www.triple-c.at/index.php/tripleC/article/view/136/90
Fuchs, Christian. 2011. Foundations of Critical Media and Information Studies. New York: Routledge.
Galtung, Johan. 1990. Cultural Violence. Journal of Peace Research. 27(3): 291-305.
Gramsci, Antonio. 1929-35, 1971. Selections from the Prison Notebooks. New York: International Publishers.
Halloran, James. D. Elliot, Philip. and Murdock, Graham.1970. Demonstrations and Communication: A Case Study. Har-
mondsworth, England: Penguin Books.
Hartsock, Nancy. 2006 Globalization and Primitive Accumulation: The Contributions of David Harvey’s Dialectical Marxism.
In David Harvey. A Critical Reader. Edited by Castree, N. and Gregory, D. Malden, MA: Blackwell.
Harvey, David. 1982. 2006.The Limits to Capital. London: Verso.
Harvey, David. 1989. From Managerialism to Entrepreneurialism: The Tansformation of Urban Governance in Late Capital-
ism. Geografiska Annaler. 71B: 3-17.
170 Mattias Ekman
CC: Creative Commons License, 2012.
Harvey, David. 2003. The New Imperialism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Harvey, David. 2005. A Brief History of Neoliberalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Harvey, David. 2006. Spaces of Global Capitalism: A Theory of Uneven Geographical Development. London: Verso.
Harvey, David. 2010a. A Companion to Marx’s Capital. London: Verso.
Harvey, David. 2010b. The Enigma of Capital: And the crises of Capitalism. London: Profile Books.
Hesmondhalgh, David. 2007. The Cultural Industries. London: Sage.
Hope, Wayne. 2010. Time Communication, and Financial Collapse. International Journal of Communication 4 2010: 649-
669.
Jakobsson, Peter. and Stiernstedt, Fredrik. 2010. Pirates of Silicon Valley: State of exception and dispossession in Web 2.0.
First Monday Volume 15, Number 7. Accessed February 25,
http://firstmonday.org/htbin/cgiwrap/bin/ojs/index.php/fm/article/view/2799/2577
Jhally, Sut. 2000. Advertising at the edge of the apocalypse. In Critical studies in media commercialism. Edited by R. An-
dersen and L. Strate. New York: Oxford University Press.
Klein, Naomi. 2001. Reclaiming The Commons. New Left Review nr.9
Luxemburg, Rosa. 1913, 2003. The Accumulation of Capital. London: Routledge Classics.
Magnusson, Karl. Erik. 2000. Telia spås en bra start. Experterna råder till köp av den nya folkaktien. Göteborgs-Posten,
May 22. 35.
Marx, Karl. 1857,1993. Grundrisse: Foundations of the critique of political economy. London: Penguin Classics.
Marx, Karl. 1867,1990. Capital: Volume 1: A Critique of Political Economy. London: Penguin Classics.
Marx, Karl. 1885,1992. Capital: Volume 2: A Critique of Political Economy. London: Penguin Classics.
McChesney, Robert. W. 2007. Communication Revolution. London: The New Press.
Mediearkivet. 2012. Accessed on February 25. https://web.retriever-info.com/
Meidner, Rudolf. 1993. Why did the Swedish Model Fail? Socialist Register Vol. 29: 211-228.
Mosco, Vincent. 2009. The Political Economy of Communication. Second Edition. London: Sage Publications.
Mouffe, Chantal. 2008. Om det politiska. Hägersten: Tankekraft.
Murdock, Graham. 1981. Political Deviance: the press presentation of a militant mass demonstration. In The Manufacture of
News: social problems, deviance and the mass media. Edited by Cohen, S. and Young, J. London: Constable.
Mårtenson, Bo. 2003. Den televiserade ekonomin- Nyheter om statsbudgeten 1980-1995. Stockholm: JMK.
Norlin, Arne. 2000. Så köper du Telia – Den nya folkaktien. Aftonbladet, April 15. 5.
Olivera, Oscar, and Lewis, Tom. 2004. Cochabamba! Water Rebellion in Bolivia. Boston: South End Press.
Schechter, Danny. 2009. Credit crisis: How did we miss it? British Journalism Review 20(1): 19-26.
Sen, Jai, and Waterman, Peter. (eds.) 2009 World Social Forum Challenging Empires. Montreal/New York/London: Black
Rose Books.
Sennett, Richard. 1992. The Fall of Public Man. New York: W.W. Norton.
Smythe, Dallas. W. 1982. On the Audience Commodity and its Work. In Media and Cultural Studies Keyworks. Edited by
Durham, M. G and Kellner, D. M. 2006. Malden, MA: Blackwell.
Viscovi, Dino. 2006. Marknaden som monster och monster. Ekonomiska experter och nyheter om ekonomi i Rapport 1978-
1998. Göteborg: JMG.
Wallerstein, Immanuel. 2001. Liberalismens död. Stockholm: Vertigo.
Wahl-Jorgensen, Karin. 2003 Speaking Out Against the Incitement to Silence: The Brittish Press and the 2001 May Day
Protests. In Representing Resistance- Media, Civil Disobedience and The Global Justice Movment. Edited by Opel, A.
and Pompper, D. Westport/CT: Praeger Publishers.
Wendel, Per. 2000. Så köper du folkaktien. Expressen. May 21. 6.
Žižek, Slavoj. 2008 Violence. Six sideways reflections. New York: Picador.
Žižek, Slavoj. 2009 First as Tragedy, Then As Farce. London: Verso.
About the Author
Mattias Ekman
Mathias Ekman is working as a lecturer in the department of Media Studies at Stockholm University. He has
contributed to a chapter in the Sage Encyclopedia of Social Movement Media (2011).