
tripleC 10(2): 683-691, 2012 685
CC: Creative Commons License, 2012.
In the analysis of privacy and Facebook, both aspects should be taken into account. My data
comes from seventeen semi-structured face-to-face interviews and five online interviews with users
of Facebook, as well as from ethnographic observation made through a three year period (from
2009 till 2012). My main emphasis during the interviews was on the subjective thoughts and feel-
ings of participants versus Facebook. While privacy was not the main question during the inter-
views, opinions about it emerged during all interviews. The process of interviewing was ongoing:
with some emerging themes derived from initial interviews I contacted my participants again with
additional questions and asking for clarifications. The fact that my research is entirely qualitative
and is based on a small sample of interviews limits the possibility of generalisations. However,
opinions of participants were the 'truth' for those people. These opinions might be fragmentary, but
when they are put together, they present a nominal truth about the phenomenon. While the focus
has been on the subjective thoughts, feelings and interpretations of social actors, this does not lead
to mere relativism, making generalisations impossible, but rather to a careful examination of more
general emerging themes which underpin individual perceptions and are analysed based on the
current theoretical knowledge within the field of privacy and Facebook.
1. Facebook as a Surveillance Tool
Facebook is first of all a capitalistic organisation, whose main drive is profit accumulation. Profit
is mainly made through advertisements, which are targeted to users of Facebook. The privacy pol-
icy of Facebook, called “data use policy”, is long, ambiguous and confusing. It is unlikely that many
users will read it while signing up. However, if you do want to read it, one needs to go through dif-
ferent links, pages and the like, to get the overall impression of the fact that Facebook collects quite
a substantial amount of data on its users and shares most of it with advertisers.
For instance, when you start reading the page where Facebook talks about how it shares infor-
mation with advertisers, you are greeted with a reassuring paragraph: "We do not share any of your
information with advertisers (unless, of course, you give us permission)". This is followed by the
following paragraph: "When an advertiser creates an advert on Facebook, they are given the op-
portunity to choose their audience by location, demographics, likes, keywords and any other infor-
mation we receive or can tell about you and other users" (
www.facebook.com, accessed on April
18, 2012).
The catch is to click on the link provided under “any other information we receive”, which then
will send you to the page with a very long text, describing exactly what kind of information you give
to Facebook. This includes your name, location, pictures, as well as your IP address, pictures you
upload, texts you write, time when you took the picture, etc. In fact, by reading this page carefully, it
is not that difficult to realise that Facebook collects every possible piece of data about its users.
What exactly is sold to advertisers is not clear at all from all the texts the company has posted
about its data use policy. It looks like, though, that almost any user data that can be obtained is
sold to advertisers.
Fuchs (2011) argues that privacy in the age of capitalism is an antagonistic value, which on the
one hand, is celebrated as a universal value which protects private property, and, on the other
hand, is a value which is undermined by surveillance from corporations into private lives of indi-
viduals in order to accumulate profit. "Capitalism protects privacy for the rich and companies, but at
the same time legitimises privacy violations of consumers and citizens. It thereby undermines its
own positing of privacy as a universal value […]. An antagonism between privacy ideals and sur-
veillance is therefore constitutive of capitalism" (Fuchs 2011, 144).
Facebook is a typical example case, where privacy is an antagonistic value. On the one hand,
users expect that their privacy should be protected, and Facebook reassures them that they can
adjust their privacy settings at any time, but, on the other hand, Facebook as a corporation, collects
data on its users and sells it to advertisers for profit accumulation. Thrift (2005) talks about knowl-
edge economy, or “soft capitalism”, which underlines the current capitalistic society, where capital-
ism has become knowledgeable in unprecedented ways and where, as David Beer argues,
"knowledges that are transmitted through gossip and small talk which often prove surprisingly im-
portant are able to be captured and made into opportunities for profit" (Beer 2008, 523).
On Facebook, we engage constantly into gossip and small talk and this can be used by many
companies to target their advertisements. And this leads to the following question. Are we indeed
customers of Facebook or are we simply its product, as Andrew Brown asks rightly in his article
"Facebook is not your friend". "Anyone who supposes that Facebook's users are its customer has
got the business model precisely backwards. Users pay nothing, because we aren't customers, but
product. The customers are the advertisers to whom Facebook sells the information users hand
over, knowingly or not" (Brown 2010, 1).