tripleC 10(2): 555-569, 2012 565
CC: Creative Commons License, 2012.
This diagnostic challenge calls for an intergenerational dialogue of theory-formation, in which the
means of orientation and communication, of control and self-control, of reproduction and destruc-
tion inter-depend with those of production. The variety of culture-specific, transcultural and even
globalizing alternative actions, processes, and structures and of criteria for their specification and
agreement is so wide that no conscious consensus can be reached. Such models of orientation
and communication clearly point beyond individual, short-term perceptions and must allow continu-
ous feedback from the intended and unintended consequences of interactions and “inter-
passivities” for various classes, groupings and time horizons. Thereby common standards emerge,
which contribute to new behaviour patterns and mentalities. Consciously communicated alterna-
tives always are embedded in less conscious horizons and frameworks (cp., e.g., Honneth 2011,
540-567).
Habermas (2011, 33-38) proposes human rights as a regulatory institution, which Ludes (2011,
chapter 8) puts into the context of traditional print, broadcast and web media, symbolically general-
ized media of communication of money, power, truth or love, and the long-term means of orienta-
tion, space, time, and alternatives. Since the historically new global crisis of financial capitalism
with its repercussions of economic fragilities and state bankruptcies, Habermas (2011, 100-129)
sees a re-shuttling of “political alternatives”, which would have been deemed unrealistic before. He
calls for the right for unbiased political communication, especially concerning communication about
the weapons of mass destruction employed by the global financial markets. The continuous inter-
ventions of state regulations in the crisis made transparent that capitalism cannot reproduce itself
autonomously from the state, but rather drives the state to collect taxes that are used for resolving
capitalism’s state of emergency.
Yet: “The evolution of humankind is a contingent, open-ended process, driven primarily through
five fields of forces of the mode of livelihood, of demographic ecology, of distributions of recogni-
tion, rank and respect, of cultures of learning, communication and values, and of politics” (Therborn
2011, 84). Only self-critical re-conceptualizations of traditional concepts can serve as driving forces
for radical transformations of informational capitalism, which, however, tends to monopolize rank-
ings of valuable information and knowledge (cp., e.g., Halavais 2009). Therefore, the appropriation
of ICTs in the service of alternative commons has become a major means of revolting against the
oligopoly of the means of production and destruction via new means of cognition, communication
and cooperation (cp. Fuchs 2011a, section 5). “Given that alternatives frequently do not want to
build their organizations on commodities and advertising because they think this will corrupt their
political goals, they are frequently facing problems like lack of resources, precarious self-
exploitative labour, lack of attention/visibility, etc” (Fuchs 2011b).
Yet, in addition to these and the impediments to Marx’s trajectories towards an alternative,
classless society sketched above, we must see clearly that the very base of Marx’s diagnosis has
become obsolete: More than two thirds of the world were almost completely outside of Marx’s re-
search (despite a few reflections in newspaper articles on India), namely almost all of Asia, Africa,
Latin America. In globalizing socio-economic, military, terrorist, ecological, communication pro-
cesses in the 21
st
century, these previously excluded regions and populations will shape also the
rules of globalizing capitalism.
A recent “Citizen’s Guide to Capitalism and the Environment” (Magdoff and Foster 2011, all fol-
lowing quotations will refer to this book) may exemplify the projection of analyses from one country,
i.e., the United States, to a global theory. A rhetorical device is the unqualified use of “we”, e.g.:
“We are constantly being told” (7), “we have an economic system” (12), “our economic system [… ]
we must look” (30), “We must also recognize” (38) and so on till the call for collective actors, which
are even more vague that previous conceptions of a class in and for itself, e.g., “people organizing
and fighting” (131), “society decides” (135), or “We the people” (151). Similarly, the political eco-
nomical analyses, mainly based on developments in the United States and exclusively on publica-
tions in English, not taking into account any of the above theories from, e.g., Elias, Habermas,
Hobsbawm, or Therborn, reify “the economic system” (12, 30), the “present system” (36), “capital-
ism” (7, 56, 101), “the capitalist system” (59), “the system” (83-85), “the democratic system” (91),
“the current system”, “the logic of the system” (93), “system”, “the system”, “the capitalist economic
system” (96f) “capitalist society” (111) or “society” (66, sometimes referring to the US alone, some-
times to the whole world without clear distinctions). Based on these generalizations, even more
universal “realistic alternatives” are proposed, “Creating an entirely different system […] a truly
revolutionary form of change – the transition to a new system altogether”: The simplifying “plan-
ning” proposed becomes evident in the metaphor of “what the house is to be like […]. Similarly,
once society decides that it is critical to fulfil the basic needs of people, then – after some general
agreement is reached as to what these needs are – a system that plans production and distribution