572 Vincent Mosco
CC: Creative Commons License, 2012.
tion on the long march to Capital, a point missed by one of the first scholars to bring the Grundrisse
to an English-speaking world. The critical difference between this work and Capital is not the differ-
ence between the creative display of a work in progress and a fully formed creation, as Nicolaus
maintains. Rather, the Grundrisse is, however dishevelled or even delirious, a substantive creation
in its own right and a touchstone for vital developments in critical communication research. It con-
tains ideas that Capital never got around to addressing but which matter considerably to scholar-
ship and politics today.
In the Grundrisse, Marx focuses explicit attention on the significance of information for capital.
This is expressed in numerous different ways roughly signifying, at different times, social
knowledge, the state of scientific and artistic knowledge, and the general intellect. In essence, one
of the most important consequences of a developing capitalist economy is that it provides free time
to think, create, and advance the general state of scientific, technical and artistic information. Capi-
talism aims to incorporate this expansion of individual and social capacity into the production pro-
cess, but faces the resistance of increasingly knowledgeable and empowered workers. In the very
process of its development capitalism produces the conditions for its expansion and for resistance
from workers who increasingly have the opportunity to advance their own creative ability. In the
emphasis on technology, on the material machinery of production that is understandably derived
from a reading of Capital, one can miss a central point made in the notebooks: the most important
embodiment of fixed capital is not the assembly line but “man himself”.
In the Grundrisse, as nowhere else, the source of value is information, the creative worker, what
some would today call human capital: “Nature builds no machines, no locomotives, railways, elec-
tric telegraphs, self-acting mules etc. These are products of human industry; natural material trans-
formed into organs of the human will over nature, or of human participation in nature. They are
organs of the human brain, created by the human hand; the power of knowledge, objectified. The
development of fixed capital indicates to what degree general social knowledge has become a
direct force of production, and to what degree, hence, the conditions of the process of social life
itself have come under the control of the general intellect and been transformed in accordance with
it” (Marx 1973, 706). The determination of value, a concept central to Marx’s political economy,
comes to be based firmly on the creative individual: “it is neither the direct human labour he himself
performs, nor the time during which he works, but rather the appropriation of his own general pro-
ductive power, his understanding of nature and his mastery over it by virtue of his presence as a
social body – it is, in a word, the development of the social individual which appears as the great
foundation-stone of production and of wealth” (Marx 1973, 705).
As capitalism comes to be based increasingly on control over creative ability, and therefore over
information, it must mobilize all social institutions involved in producing information. Hence the
need for the commodification of the entire creative apparatus, something that can only be achieved
“when large industry has already reached a higher stage, and all the sciences have been pressed
into the service of capital.” As result, “Invention then becomes a business, and the application of
science to direct production itself becomes a prospect which determines and solicits it” (Marx 1973,
704).
Because information becomes increasingly central to capitalist development, it is important to
consider what Marx means by information. This is difficult because Marx uses a multiplicity of ex-
pressions to encompass it. Nevertheless, it is clear that he means more than merely technical
knowledge because he uses words that connote both artistic and experiential knowledge. For ex-
ample, in discussing the contradiction between capital’s need to reduce labour time and the need
to use it as a measure of social wealth, he refers to the importance for capital of the “artistic, scien-
tific etc. development of individuals in the time set free” (Marx 1973, 706). Again, in a rousing con-
clusion to a section on economic history, Marx asks what is left of the bourgeois concept of wealth
once its limited form is stripped away: “… the universality of individual needs, capacities, pleasures,
productive forces, etc. created through universal exchange. … The absolute working-out of his
creative potentialities, with no presupposition other than the previous historic development, which
makes the totality of development, i.e., the development of all human powers as such, the end in
itself, not as measured on a predetermined yardstick?” (Marx 1973, 488).
This and the accompanying passages demonstrate that while scientific and technical knowledge
are important components of an expanding sphere of information, the point of raising its signifi-
cance does not end there. That is because information is more significantly a marker for the devel-
opment of full human capacities, including the scientific but also the artistic, the experiential and,
certainly, the creative.
Undoubtedly those familiar with Marx’s Economic and Philosophical Manuscripts, will note dis-
tinct similarities. But a key difference in the Grundrisse is that the discussion of the full develop-