tal. Informal identity labor is integrated with formal labor, with the predominant form of work rooted
in informational services and the promotional industries.
Fordist (routinized) labor, meanwhile, is effectively expanded through the collapsing and conver-
gence of job descriptions or expectations in which promotional performance is appended to jobs
that in the past did not include them, such as the scripted speech of chain-store cashiers (“Did you
find everything you were looking for?”), customer relations employees, technical support and other
call-center operators, and wait staff who in their transactions with consumers suggest additional
purchasing options (“Would you like a drink with that order?” and the like). Similarly, TV sportscast-
ers and radio talk show hosts are now expected to plug products on-air. Promotional behavior un-
der the new work requirements is intended to increase exchange value, thus enabling an intensifi-
cation of exploitation (the surplus value appropriated and valorized under such ultra-commodified
“labor power”).
In the neoliberal promotional economy, with the infrastructural support of digital technology, capi-
tal has undergone a major restructuring, driven by both organizational and technological opportuni-
ties and necessities – and characterized by deregulation, privatization, deterritorialization, cutbacks
in government social spending, technological and institutional convergences, union-busting, ero-
sion of the public sphere, manufacturing and service sector outsourcing, and a deepening of con-
sumerist ideology. When not long ago, one could still imagine the separation of the workplace and
home life, work and leisure, public and private space, producer and consumer, formal and informal
labor, today with corporate capital at the forefront of social and political changes, these and other
such dichotomies are converged and subsumed under a corporate aegis. Before entering and after
departing the formal workplace, workers routinely submit their identity data, through covert surveil-
lance and institutionalized identity theft, but often through “voluntary” means as well, for the produc-
tion and marketing of goods and services. In such surplus value-generating opportunities,
“prosumers” are employed consciously or unconsciously as free informal labor,
13
undertaking such
labor using their own equipment and software (computers, programs, and internet connections).
The intensification of labor extraction in a system in which informational aspects of production have
become increasingly possible and necessary has led to a changing form and composition of labor
in material and immaterial goods production
14
.
Creative industries also regularly announce, usually online, the outsourcing of problem-solving
activities to amateurs or specialists willing to participate without standard pay, perhaps in hopes of
a prize or status of some sort, in finding solutions that profit the company – a system of free or very
modestly compensated labor the industry calls “crowdsourcing”
15
. Inasmuch as such work contrib-
utes to the creation of exchange value, people at large and outside the formal workplace have
come to constitute a major source of informal labor (in the crowdsourcing example via the liberal
use of their knowledge for software production). As one study noted, “the co-creation economy is
about experimenting with new possibilities for value creation that are based on the expropriation of
free cultural, technological, social, and affective labor of the consumer masses” (Zwick, Bonsu and
Darmody 2008, 166). The principal form of labor involved in commercial crowdsourcing or surveil-
13
One form of crowdsourcing is local television stations’ use of their websites, blogs, Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, and
special apps for soliciting news tips, photos, video, and feedback from prosumer audiences, in some cases on an exclusive
(quasi-contractual) basis. Certain high-end cameras are marketed as “prosumer” quality.
14
The formal workplace is not by any means the sole locus of value creation. There is in fact a presumption of free labor
that now prevails in many spheres of daily life: self-checkout at shopping centers, submission to various kinds of polling and
consumer surveys, consumer data profiling created through “cookies” and credit card surveillance, registration for the use of
websites, the use of ATM machines instead of tellers, and many other, often inconspicuous, acts that convert consumer
behaviors and information into factors of production, further mystifying (fetishizing) the nature of the commodity.
15
The willingness of workers to supply their free intellectual labor to a private entrepreneur represents the power of reifi-
cation of commodities disassociated from their social relations of production. Informal labor that contributes aesthetic, social,
or affective appeal to commodities or that helps establish their marketable potential is in most instances free labor, not wage
labor, sometimes offered voluntarily, more often captured by stealth. It demonstrates what Hardt and Negri (2001) have
argued about the intensification of capital’s internalized direction, though, I would contend, this does not mean that capital
has abandoned its spatially aggrandizing ambitions.