
tripleC 10(2): 752-764, 2012 757
CC: Creative Commons License, 2012.
societies change (Sztompka 1993, 274 ff.). The social class is historically determined while the
social movement has to be mobilized out of singular agents. This turn from class formations to
social movements is ambiguous. It may provide a more flexible form of analyzing social change
than the structural explanations had done, but it runs the risk of losing the big picture in the ambi-
tion to stress the agency found in the actors, it also comes close to a discourse that stresses indi-
viduality similar as can be found in neoliberalism (Haiven 2007).
Since new social movements are conscious of a symbolic dimension it is motivated to take a
more detailed look into the idea of resisting symbolic power through “challenging the codes” (Me-
lucci 1997). The idea that representational systems and symbols construe an important locus for
activism found theoretical support both in postmodern thinking about the importance of significa-
tion, and in new social movement theory. McGuigan (2005) has referred to this tactics as “radical
subversion”. He presents a quite sceptical account of culture jamming where it is questioned
whether it can present any real critical effect or political impact at all. Some of his criticism is inter-
esting to take part of as it might also have relevance for a definition of alternative media.
The reason for McGuigan’s scepticism lies not only in culture jamming being an idealistic
movement working in the realm of signification, but also because it is “élitist and, to many, either
downright offensive or simply unintelligible” (McGuigan 2005, 438). It is easy to imagine how cul-
ture jammers attacks on consumerism could be interpreted as an attack on the lifestyle of “ordinary
people” rather than on the system that makes consumerism a necessity. Since consumption is an
integral part of everyday life it is difficult to find large popular support for a movement that opposes
it. And, as Haiven (2007) has shown, the individualistic character of this kind of activism is close to
neoliberalism.
Culture jamming was a child of the 1990s and seemed to have vanished, or lost its relevance a
decade into the 2000s, but interestingly enough, Adbusters – the spearhead of the international
culture jamming movement managed to spark a new kind of anti-capitalist protest when the Occupy
Wall Street phenomenon entered the public in the fall of 2011. To many, this was seen as a return
of a political momentum from the 1990s, lost since 2001.
Various publications (Taylor et al. 2011; Chomsky 2011; van Gelder 2011) have praised the
novelty of this movement and as it spread from Wall Street over the world, the term “occupy” be-
came a new slogan for anti-capitalist resistance. The Occupy movement offers something different
than culture jamming as it takes the symbolic to the physical. It also differs from culture jamming in
that its address is populist rather than elitist. Pointing out the finance capital as the main problem
has been a successful strategy of both leftists and right-wing populists during the 20th century, and
it is perhaps easier to sympathize with a movement of “the 99%” than with people who make you
feel bad about your consumption habits.
But does this mean that the occupy-movement has resolved the contradictions of earlier ver-
sions of symbolic resistance? This is hard to say, but one could look to some interesting tenden-
cies. First, there are cases where the populism has made some traditional leftist activists nervous
because it is unclear who you are marching (camping) with. Especially in those cases where hack-
ers network Anomymous and the Occupy-movement have made common efforts.
3
Secondly, the stress on the urban makes occupy practices (as well as some recent comments
from David Harvey (2012) about the city as locus of radical social change) vulnerable to the fetishi-
sation of urban life that is at the core of gentrifying processes in contemporary society. Again, as
with McGuigan’s (2005) critique of culture jamming, the popular tendencies of the argument risk
facing the same fate as did much of the critique of the 1960s (Rancière 2010; Boltanski and Chia-
pello 2005; Heath and Potter 2004). The urban character of the occupy-movement could easily be
adopted (co-opted) by the same kind of urban development-lingo about “creative class” (Florida
2005) etc.
Alternative sources of information, knowledge and culture are indeed important in order to chal-
lenge the ideological standstill in the official media discourse and invoke a radical imagination. But
there is also a risk that the abundance in alternative voices made possible by new media technolo-
gies leads to what Dean (2009) has described as “psychotic media”: communicative capitalism’s
abundance of alternative voices and talk without response.
Dean has introduced the concept of communicative capitalism, referring to “the materialization
of ideals of inclusion and participation in information, entertainment, and communication technolo-
gies in ways that capture resistance and intensify global capitalism” (Dean 2009, 2). Dean points to
weaknesses of alternative media definitions that over-stress the participation-aspect and the trans-
formed social relation between the producer and the audience is at fore (as in Bailey et al. 2008,
3
One example from Sweden was how Anonymous fronted anti-feminist attacks on a small independent theatre’s stag-
ing of Valerie Solana’s SCUM Manifesto (see
http://anonopssweden.blogspot.se/2011/11/opscum.html).