tripleC 9(2): 520-530, 2011 523
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
If subjectivization emerges in the formation of identities through the encounter of integrities as
signs for an open-ended contour, then the production of meaning as standing-reserve, as the en-
counter with fixed identities, is, in fact, the self-alienation of the human from the humane, the con-
tour that is expressed in our various integrities and subjectivities.
3. The Cultural Syntax of Museums
Edwina Taborsky describes the historical evolution of the museum in terms of the manner in
which it takes up, as part of a sociocultural system, the objects with which it inter-acts. The evolu-
tion she points to is consistent with trends described elsewhere. (Foucault, 1972) (McSherry, 2001,
p. 41) Her argument is that the museum, and museum-making cultures, are constituted by a spe-
cific cultural syntax that produces similar object-relations in the museum system, as well as the
industrial system and the literacy system. Respectively, their objects are: objects and images,
goods and services, and knowledge. (Taborsky, 1981, p. 1) For her, the museum begins to emerge
in a recognizable form beginning in the 14
th
Century.
The museum development of the 14
th
, 15
th
, and 16
th
centuries in Europe…was part of a total
structural change involving the whole society and its relations with its environmental units. In
the 14
th
century, society in Europe as a whole began to relate to its environment in a different
way from previous eras. This new method, which I could call an ‘abstract-and-define’ method,
involved the removal of environmental units from their natural setting, their collection and
storage in a different setting, and their specific naming, definition and analysis (pp. 28-29).
We recognize here the beginning of the Heideggerian trend in the severance of excessive contour
and the establishment of fixed identity by means of the production of new integrities, or at least the
highlighting of integrities as part of new orders not apparently coordinated with their emergence out
of their natural situation.
In the 17
th
Century, Taborsky points to the collection of John Tradescent as an example indica-
tive of a further development in an overarching trend. The catalogue of this collection from 1656
describes the collection as the “Museum Trandescantianum, or a collection of Rarities preserved at
South-Lambeth near London by John Tradescent.” Noting several aspects of this description in-
volving authority and history, the idea of a collection as such, the singularity of owner and collector,
and the concept of preservation, Taborsky cites an interesting section from further on in the cata-
logue: “…that the enumeration of these rarities (being more for variety than any one place in Eu-
rope could afford) would be an honour to our Nation, and a benefit to such ingenious persons as
would become further enquirees into the various modes of Natures admireable workes, and the
curious imitations thereof.” (p. 31) Taborsky notes, among other points of interest, “the concept that
copies could exist of the environmental units.” (p. 32) We see here the concept that natural objects
are of interest for the sake of their integrities and reproducible identities, rather than for the sake of
what Luciano Floridi might point to as an intrinsic value. (Floridi, 2002) Indeed, Taborsky notes that
“The origin of the objects and the date of their entry into the collection are not noted.” (Taborsky, p.
32)
By the late 17
th
and 18
th
Centuries, the trend had moved even further along the trajectory.
The new taxonomic and classifying approach to the world, advocated by such as Bacon,
Hobbes, Descartes, Linnaeus and their like, was revealed in the new actions and rights of
man to collect, define, and name the environment. Collections were no longer simply con-
glomerations of mixed units, as had been those of the early individuals, but were being ar-
ranged and developed to show particular environmental phenomena, either as defined by
man, as in his art works, or as analyzed and created by man, as in the natural and mechani-
cal environment. Collections were being developed to show the environment as something
which man could name, define and control…. The collections were now selective and specific,
for the objects were collected with a functional goal in mind – as an observable empirical aid
to develop and explain scientific theories, not simply as unique curiosities. The units were now