tripleC 9(2): 358-366, 2011 365
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Let us now consider the even more complex case of the animal vision, for instance, perceiving
that what we are seeing is an apple. If we formulate it very simplistically it might exhibit a digital
form in Dretske’s sense. However, when we are seeing what we have in front, we might actually
perceive what has the formality of the apples as we have been dealing with till now. If somebody
would ask us: is it really an apple? Then we would appeal to the openness that we also feel: we
would like to see it closer, from a different angle, touch it, and so on. Whenever we go forward in
our inquest, on the one hand, we complete the previous percepts, but on the other hand, we also
feel the need for further notes (opening, tasting, planting its seeds, etc.). As we have previously
analyzed, the object will never manifest completely, and we cannot indefinitely defer our asserts,
for obvious pragmatic reasons (in other words, we may prefer having a fresh apple to being com-
pletely sure that it was an apple).
What we wish to stress is that Dretske’s “nomic regularities” among types of events supporting
the informational content and the digital perception of the world (i.e. establishing a sure univocal
relation between facts and signals, what we intentionally have named manifestation of the object)
do not exist (Dretske, 1985, p. 185). Instead of such de re perception (§1.2) there is rather a fuzzy-
, de dicto perception, by means of which living beings (and we among them) grasp its environment
in a fuzzy-digital formality mediated by conventional regularities. This fuzzy-digital formality can be
synthetically expressed as: s is F with a confidence degree. At best there is no better assert about
the sensed reality given the notes grasped from it and the pragmatic situation in which we are im-
mersed (included eventual inquests for finding out if something is the case). Whereas the challenge
in the Dretskean world of nomic regularities and informational relations would be the cleaning of
communication channels, here our challenge is to find the optimal way of describing reality giving
the attained evidences and our pragmatic objectives (in a much broader sense of pragmatism than
the circumscribed to a close-, short-term finality), and – mutatis mutandis the example of figure 3 in
part 2 – we must be ready to accept that what we are feeling might be something else that what we
previously thought, which is coherent with the sensed open character of reality.
It is not that there is no real and direct relation between reality and its manifestation; it is not that
our asserts are disconnected from reality. Quite on the contrary, there is a real relation between
reality and its manifestation, but – in mathematical terms – it is surjective; there is a close connec-
tion between our asserts and reality, since it is the complex structure of our intellective sensation
what provides us a truthful apprehension of reality.
In other words, from the first posed bi-horned dilemma of sense or intellection, we rather prefer
to grab both horns.
References
Ascoli, C., Barbi, M., Frediani, C., & Mure, A. (1978). Measurements of Euglena motion parameters by laser light scattering.
Biophysical Journal, 24, 585-599.
Bekenstein, J. D. (2003). Information in the holographic universe. Scientific American Magazine, 289(2), 58-65.
Brier, S. (2008). Cybersemiotics: Why information is not enough. Toronto, CA: University of Toronto Press.
Cherny, V. V., Markin, V. S., & DeCoursey, T. E. (1995). The voltage-activated hydrogen ion conductance in rat alveolar
epithelial cells is determined by the pH gradient. Journal of General Physiology 105(6): 861–896, 1995-06.
Díaz Nafría, J. M. (2010). What is information? A multidimensional concern. tripleC, 8(1), 77-108.
Díaz Nafría, J. M. & Al Hadithi, B. (2009). Are ‘the semantic aspects’ actually ‘irrelevant to the engineering problem’? tripleC,
7(2), 300-308.
Díaz Nafría, J. M. & Al Hadithi, B. (2010). Fuzzy logic. In Díaz Nafría, J. M., Salto Alemany, F., & Pérez-Montoro, M. (Eds.),
Glossarium BITri: Glossary of concepts, metaphores, theories and problems regarding information. León, ES:
Universidad de León. Retrieved from http://glossarium.bitrum.unileon.es/Home/logica-borrosa/fuzzy-logic.
Díaz Nafría, J.M. & Salto Alemany, F. (2009). Introduction to the special issue “What is really information? An interdiscipli-
nary approach. tripleC, 7(2), i-vi.
Dretske, F. I. (1981). Knowledge and the flow of information. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
European Bioinformatics Institute (EPI). (2010). Ligand-gated ion channel database. Retrieved from
http://www.ebi.ac.uk/compneur-srv/LGICdb/LGICdb.php.