tripleC 9(2): 342-346, 2011
ISSN 1726-670X
http://www.triple-c.at
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Definition and Essence of Information
Tian-qing Qiao
whhbswdx@sina.com, Hubei Provincial Administration College, Hubei Wuhan, China
Abstract: It has been 60 years since the essential attributes of information were explored in the field of philosophy, resulting
in many contentious schools of thought and a wide division of opinions. Some scholars in China and abroad have been
trying to build a new system of information philosophy from an ontological perspective, so as to explain the world. In this
paper, the author puts forward a definition of information and its mathematical expressions in order to demonstrate that
information is the collection of three kinds of attributes of things. Analysis suggests that the essence of information is the
interaction of matters and the representation of the law of causality in philosophy. The paper also explores the ways in
which information—as a noun—is a term that people have customarily used and confused. Eventually, the induction, differ-
entiation and utilization of information, as conventionally understood, should be applied into studying matters themselves.
Keywords: information, attribute, interaction, causality, Wiener
Acknowledgement: Prof. Carlos Aguilar and Prof. Lydia Sanchez have contributed a lot to polishing my article and giving
valuable suggestions so that it is smoother and more readable. I want to extend my heartfelt gratitude to them.
In 1948, Wiener, founder of cybernetics, said: “Information is information, not matter or energy. No
materialism which does not admit this can survive at the present day” (Wiener, 1948). Thus, he
introduced the concept of information in the theory of communication to philosophy. Consequently,
researchers and philosophers have been working to define the concept of information for 60 years.
Statistics shows, there were about 130 definitions of information until 1980 (Gang, 2007, p. 71). As
Claude E. Shannon (1916-2001), founder of information theory, suggested, “It is almost impossible
to count on a sole concept about information being satisfactorily responsible for every possible
application in general fields” (as cited in Gang, 2007, p. 71).
This paper puts forward a definition, as expressed mathematically, of what is customarily named
information, hoping it will be helpful in putting to rest the philosophical search for a definition of the
concept of information.
1. Definition of information and its mathematical expressions
Information, customarily understood, is the collection of three kinds of things´ attributes: things
themselves (including cause or effect formed through their interaction), the attributes of things that
someone thinks and simulates, and the attributes of tools used when one considers, expresses, or
simulates something. The first kind of attributes of things is based on facts, for example, the three
physical states of water. These are physical, chemical, biological, social or any other properties of
things, irrefutable and objective, and have nothing to do with any expressive connotations related
to the thing (such as through spoken and written languages, music or pictures). The second kind of
attribute is related to inner thoughts, or expressions through talk; namely, the second type of attrib-
utes of things is those that someone can find or that could be simulated through science and tech-
nology. Among these types of attributes, some are true to the facts and some are incomplete, while
others are not in any way. The third kind of attributes are the attributes of tools used when some-
one (or something) thinks, expresses, or simulates something, i.e. the state of brain neurons when
one thinks, the linear expression of words when one writes, the vibration frequency and intensity of
sound when one speaks, the bit of circuit devices in a computer, or the models of devices used in
an experiment, et cetera. Supposing that the sign X represents the first kind of attributes, X’ the
343 Qiao Tian-qing
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
second, and X
nlfb
the third, and info represents the information, we can simply express information
with an array as below:
info = (X Xˊ
X
nlfb
)
or detailedly,
info
m
=
In the array, P is for physical quality, C the chemical quality, B the biological quality, and S the so-
cial quality, etc., instead of part of X, the attributes mentioned in the paper. What’s more, m is the
number of various subsystems in a system, m=1, 2, 3, … and n is the number of different qualities
in every subsystem, n=1, 2, 3, …
For example: The Hindu fable “The Blind Men and The Elephant”. If one of the blind men A
speaks English, B speaks Hindi, while C speaks Chinese, D speaks Russian.
Therefore,
info
A
= ( elephant a pipe in English)
info
B
= ( elephant a pillar in Hindi)
info
C
=( elephant wall in Chinese)
info
D
= ( elephant a rope in Russian)
The four pieces of information, the X is the same, however, the X’ or X
nltb
is different. Further ex-
amples include: the ingredients indicated on the packaging of a generic product are identical with
those printed on the packaging to the same product produced by a well-known brand. A consumer,
unaware that the sets of ingredients represent two different products, would think that the two sets
belong to the same product. However, many of the physical, chemical, biological, social and other
properties of the fake product will be entirely different from those of the brand-name product. Al-
though the ingredients are all the same, the X of the former product differs entirely from the X of the
latter, even though the fake and real products are alike in the X’ and X
nlfb
.
In order to make clear the conception of information described above, the expression of informa-
tion, which is a natural phenomenon, are listed below:
info
m
=
But the expression of information imparted in a lie Aesop’s Fable “wolf is coming” should be as
follows:
tripleC 9(2): 342-446, 2011 344
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Info = (no wolf wolf! In Hellenic)
Information, as expressed in the transmission of words to the illiterate, as well as through abstract
art and animals’ sound for the vast majority of people, is expressed here:
info
m
=
Or words for the illiterate, abstract art and animals’ sound can be shown as:
info
m
=
In the above two arrays, X
mn
= X
nlfbmn
.
If you accept the above expressions, you can avoid a difficult position when attempting to define
information in philosophy.
2. Several worthwhile discussions
Some scholars hold that it is necessary to distinguish “information in the sense of ontology” from
“information in a sense of theory of knowledge” (Zhong, 2002).
Within the domain of philosophy, information should not have two definitions with different mean-
ings, namely, definition in the sense of ontology and definition in a sense of a theory of knowledge.
If one admits that information is an inconsistently used term, one will not attempt to treat it in phi-
losophical or categorical terms..
Further, information in the domain of philosophy is not, as has been suggested, simply the indi-
rect indication of existence, as the self-manifestation of matter’s existence (direct existence) and its
state (Kun, 2005).
If information is just the indirect indication of existence and matter’s self manifestation, how can
information produce a strong material force? Additionally, why does the power of information vary
from person to person, and in its connection with objects? And why do people often fail to distin-
guish true information from false information and be deceived?
Some Chinese scholars have suggested that information has thus arisen as a concept as fun-
damental and important as “being”, “knowledge”, “life”, “intelligence”, “meaning” or “good and evil”
(Floridi, 2002).
Body, being, substance, are different terms for the same reality. It is impossible to separate
thought from matter that thinks. This matter is the substratum of all changes going on in the
world (Engels, 1844, p. 164).
There seems an inclination of dualism in the author’s viewpoint, which we do not agree with and as
an account cannot explain why there exists a great deal of insignificant and boring junk messages.
345 Tian-qing Qiao
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
3. Essence of information and correct research direction
Those languages we can understand (including words we can read) convey information. But one
cannot say that languages we cannot follow (including words we cannot read) have conveyed the
same information, nor can one say the interpretations of such languages have conveyed the same
information. Therefore, there is different interpreted information when we can understand a lan-
guage or not.
When reading a book, seeing a movie, attending a lecture, or listening to music, someone may
be moved or stirred, then one cannot say he does not communicate information with words, pic-
tures and languages. When you explore the substances of words, pictures and languages, you
may be aware that this is the changes between man and natural phenomena, and the communica-
tion between man and his social activities, but not the communication of information between the
lines of words, the vibration frequency and intensity of sound in a language. If the same information
is expressed in strange words and languages, or so-called aliens’ art which man does not know,
nobody is certainly moved or inspired.
Therefore, we can infer a conclusion: information, conventionally understood, is in fact the inter-
action among man, other beings and various matters. When they interact, different things have
different information.
Information can be both material and mental, existing or conscious, produced or received, true
or false, real or fictitious, right or wrong, remembered or forgotten, known or unknown; it can exist
objectively but cannot be perceived subjectively, or vice versa; and it can be powerful or weak,
have tangible or intangible value, and so on. True information is mingled with false, and sometimes
it appears while sometimes it disappears. So, here is another conclusion: information, convention-
ally understood, is self-contradictory.
Wiener introduced the concept of information in the theory of communication to philosophy, a
move that has been considered a breakthrough. However, he failed to anticipate complicated new
ideas and technologies (emerging one after another in today’s society) that have ultimately chal-
lenged our conception and definition of information. His ideas have been diluted by the myriad (and
often confusing) ways in which people have used the concept of information. I am afraid that the
study of information could be placed in the same difficult position as when people were seeking
“the ether” at the end of the 19th century. As a result, the academic community has been unable to
reach a consensus as to the meaning and definition of information.
Focusing on the attributes of things (including beings), we are able to resolve the contradiction
inherent in information, as commonly understood, by distinguishing information from the various
attributes of things. For example, the instruction of a generic product is the same as that of a
brand-name product, but the function of the generic product is not the same as the brand-name
one.
Presently, the concept of information remains self–contradictory and confusing. One is certain to
run into problems while trying to give a philosophical or scientific definition of information. It is im-
possible to state the precise ontological meaning of “information”, just as one language, English or
Esperanto, is unable to unify 4300 languages in the world.
Information, customarily understood, is essentially the most ancient interaction in nature, so, as
in Hegel (1976, pp. 203-223), interaction is the ultimate cause of matter and interaction happens
only between attributes of things.
Languages and words are tools to distinguish between things themselves or connections be-
tween them. Customarily-stated information which languages and words convey lags behind the
attributes of things which result in customarily-stated information. A thing is cause whereas a lan-
guage is effect. Viewed from causality according to time priority order, effect certainly lags behind
cause, too. When someone speaks, his sound is not the thing it expresses or describes. Language
functions to express matters only when it forms the corresponding mechanism in man’s brain.
Language exists both as an artifact in the external world —a collection of symbols in admissible
combinations—and as the embodiment in the brain of those symbols and the principles that deter-
tripleC 9(2): 342-446, 2011 346
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
mine their combinations. The brain uses the same machinery to represent language that it uses to
represent any other entity. As neuroscientists come to understand the neural basis for the brain`s
representations of external objects, events and their relations, they sill simultaneously gain insight
into the brain`s representation of language and into the mechanisms that connect the two. (Dama-
sio & Damasio, 1992).
All in all, there is only the interaction between (attributes of) things. Information is just a noun
people have customarily used and abused. Eventually, the induction, differentiation and utilization
of customarily named information will be applied into studying things themselves. The sole criterion
for testing truth is practice.
References
Crick, F. (1994). The astonishing hypothesis: The scientific search for the soul. New York, NY: Charles Scribner's Sons.
Damasio, A. R. & Damasio, H. (1992). Brain and language. Scientific American, 267, 89-95.
Floridi, L. (2002). What is the philosophy of information? Metaphilosophy, 33, 123-145.
Engels, F. (1844): Socialism: Utopian and scientific. In K. Marx & F. Engels (1965), Complete Works of Marx and Engels
(Vol. 2). Beijing: People's Publishing House.
Gang, L. (2007). An inquiry into the origin of the philosophy of information. Beijing: JinCheng Press.
Hegel, G. W. F. (1976). Logic (Vol. 2). Beijing. Commercial Press.
Shannon, C. E. (1993). Collected Papers. N. J. A. Sloane & A. D. Wyner, (Eds.). Los Alamos, CA: IEEE Computer Society
Press
Wu, K. (2005). Information philosophy: Theory, system, method. Beijing: Commercial Press.
Zhong, Y. (2002). Principles of information science. Beijing: Beijing University of Posts and Telecommunications Press.
About the Author
Tian-qing Qiao
Retired teacher of Hubei Provincial Administration College; former professor in philosophy of science and tutor for master
degree gainer; leader of the project “Computer Endues Dialectical Materialism with New Meaning of the State” funded by
the Social Science Fund in 1999 (Confirmation No:99BX018); gave special lectures entitled “What Is Information?” in
Hubei Library and Wuhan Library.