tripleC 9(2): 305-315, 2011
ISSN 1726-670X
http://www.triple-c.at
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Exploring the Notion of Information: A Proposal for a
Multifaced Understanding
Miranda Kajtazi
*
and Darek M. Haftor
**
*
miranda.kajtazi@lnu.se, School of Computer Science, Physics and Mathematics, Linnaeus University,
Växjö/Kalmar, Sweden
**
dh@fek.su.se, School of Business, Stockholm University, Stockholm, Sweden
Abstract: The notion of ‘information’ is essential as it guides human thinking, planning, and consequent actions. Situa-
tions such as the Haiti earthquake in 2010, the financial crisis in Greece in 2010, and the oil slick in the Gulf of Mexico
in 2010 are just a few instances of constant growing empirical dilemmas in our global society where information plays a
central role. The meaning of what information is has clear implications for how we deal with it in our practical lives, which
in turn may give rise to situations that we would prefer to be without. In this sense, the notion of information has
evidently pre-sented the need to question what it really means and how it dominates the functioning of our global society.
To address this fundamental issue of information, two questions are explored and presented in this paper: What notions of
information are dominating the scholarly literature? And what are the differences between these notions? To answer
these questions, we have conducted a comprehensive literature survey of more than two hundred scholarly publications.
Detailed analyses of the content of these publications identified four kinds of forms of information notions. The results show
that these four forms present diverse and opposing views of the notion of information, labelled as the ‘quartet model of
information’. These ad-dress different foci, contexts, and challenges. In addition, we propose an alternative and novel
understanding of the notion of information, associated with how information functions in our global society. This
understanding offers a new perspective intended to address significant needs of the information society.
Keywords: Information notion; Information society; Literature survey; Content analysis
Acknowledgement: We would like to thank Professor Anita Mirijamdotter for her valuable comments and support for this
research paper.
This paper presents some preliminary findings from an ongoing research into the notion of infor-
mation and its human, industrial, and societal implications. In this, a novel understanding of infor-
mation is presented as associated with how information is functioning in our global society. Situa-
tions such as natural disasters like the Haiti earthquake in 2010, financial crisis like that of Greece
in 2010, and environmental disasters like the oil slick in the Gulf of Mexico in 2010 are just a few
instances of constantly growing empirical dilemmas in our global society where information plays a
central role. In these and many similar situations a pattern seems to recur in which there is a lack
of needed information and/or there is an information overload (e.g. Castells, 1996; 2010).
Not surprisingly, various scholars have given attention to this central and crucial role of informa-
tion in our human, industrial, and social affairs. Two examples follow. The 1978 Noble Laureate
Herbert Simon undertook an evolving approach to construct a new notion of information, which has
possible explanations for such situations as those mentioned above. For him, in one way, informa-
tion is a complex form of human construct; hence, humans’ particular reactions can depend largely
on information that is available to them (Simon, 1996). Similarly, another Noble Laureate of 2001,
George Akerlof, predicted how information has become the main cause of some societal failures,
by addressing the economic and political systems that deal with asymmetric information created
between interacting actors (Akerlof, 1970). These and other explorations seem to point in the same
directions: the meaning of what information is has clear implications for how we deal with it in our
practical lives, which in turn may give rise to situations that we would prefer to be without – such as
when a surgeon amputates the wrong leg of a patient, because the given information instructed so
…
306 Miranda Kajtazi and Derek M. Haftor
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
In this way, the notion of information has evidently presented the need to question what it really
means and how it dominates the functioning of our global society. Subsequently, the key questions
of investigation in this paper are as follows: What notions of information are dominating the schol-
arly literature? And what are the differences between these notions? To answer these questions,
we have conducted an extensive and comprehensive literature review on the notion of ‘informa-
tion’. Results derived from this first present a historical development of many notions of information,
mainly evolved during the last century. This has identified that many key notions of information
have been proposed, such as information is an ‘inward-forming’ (e.g. Boland, 1987); information is
an ‘interpretation’ with some attached meaning (e.g. Ackoff, 1989; Bateson, 1972; Checkland &
Scholes, 1990; Langefors, 1993; Mingers, 1995); information is a ‘fundamental reality’ (e.g. Floridi,
2010; Fuchs, 2008; Hofkirchner, 2009); information is ‘physical’ (e.g. Brillouin, 1962; Stonier, 1990;
1996); or information is ‘transmittable’ (e.g. Shannon, 1948), among others. Second, the outcome
from these analyses on the information notions has led to a novel categorisation and presentation
of four kinds of forms of information (i.e. fundamental, meaningful, quantifiable, transmittable). We
introduce a theoretical framework based on these four forms, which we label as the ‘quartet model
of information’. As a consequence of this new understanding of the diversity of information notions,
we were able to develop an alternative and novel notion of information. This study is intended to
contribute to a positive management of human, industrial, and social affairs where and when infor-
mation plays a crucial role.
This paper is structured in the following way: we first introduce the methodological approach that
has been employed in this research. Then we present a historical overview of the notions of infor-
mation. Thereafter we present the quartet model of information notions. Next, we introduce a novel
notion of information. We end with a discussion of the implications for theory and practice.
1. Methodological Approach
Two types of methodological features have been employed in this study. Firstly, we have con-
ducted a comprehensive literature survey of more than two hundred scholarly publications, starting
from the year 1900. The review of these publications was driven by the need to find explicit notions
of information. As a result, we have selected around fifty information notions.
Secondly, the analysis conducted on this comprehensive literature review was guided both by
Heidegger’s necessity of explicit interpretations of universal notions (Heidegger, 1962) and by
Husserl’s system of propositions that are interlinked and have better overviews of different manifes-
tations in the real world (Husserl, 2001). With the former we intend to lead this enquiry by what is
sought: to interpret the notion of information conceptually for what it signifies for the information
society. With the latter, we intend to conduct this enquiry with an explorative nature and with a
multifaced understanding of the notion of information. This may be more explicitly understood by
developing a new notion of information. These two methodologies have driven phenomenological
descriptions in our study.
2. A Historical Overview of the Notion of Information
The discussion about the notion of information has been present in all scientific disciplines. How-
ever, this literature survey identified those discussions as rather diverse and opposing (e.g. Bates,
2006; Bateson, 1972; Boland, 1987; Brier, 1998; 2008; Floridi, 2005; Hofkirchner, 1999; Parker,
1973; Pervez, 2009; Qvortrup, 1993; Rapoport, 1953; Shannon, 1948; Wiener, 1948). Thus, infor-
mation is viewed as an infinite of its characteristics, such as data or knowledge, signal or com-
munication, symbol or meaning … (e.g. Bateson, 1972; Boland, 1987; Brier, 2008; Checkland &
Scholes, 1990; Hartley, 1928; Langefors, 1993; Shannon, 1948). Furthermore, these diversities
have been used in different fundamental forms of information’s very existence, namely: information
is physical, biological, psychical, mechanical, social, digital … (e.g. Bateson, 1972; Bates, 2006;
Brier, 1992; 2004; 2008; Floridi, 2010; Maturana & Varela, 1980; Mingers, 1995; 2001). Above all,
information has long been understood as a universal notion (Heidegger, 1962), and it has been
given freedom to be used without consensus in different scholarly domains (e.g. Adams, 2003;
Floridi, 2005; Losee, 1998; MacKay, 1969).
tripleC 9(2): 305-315, 2011 307
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
In addition, we intend to systematically understand the diversities between information notions
that derive from two Cartesian doctrines, which govern the practice of defining information:
• The ‘subjective’ orientation towards human communication of the meaning of information (Bel-
kin, 1978; Luhmann, 1990).
• The ‘objective’ orientation towards external physical components of the universe that comprise
information (Brillouin, 1962; Landauer, 1991; Stonier, 1996).
Many scholars have devoted effort to distinguishing these two doctrines (Bates, 2006; Brier, 1992;
2008; Capurro & Hjørland, 2003; Floridi, 2010; Hofkirchner, 2009; Pervez, 2009).
Regardless of the growing awareness of this dilemma, little work has been done to address the
understanding of the many differences among the existing notions of information. From previous
contributions, we have noticed that they mostly concentrate on defining information through one of
this tripartite: ‘philosophically’ (through philosophy of information, the physical and the semantic
nature of information) (e.g. Floridi, 2010; Mingers, 1995; Qvortrup, 1993), ‘mathematically’ (through
information theory, the measurable and quantifiable information) (e.g. Brillouin, 1962; Hartley,
1928; Landauer, 1991; Shannon, 1948), or more ‘universally’ (through the unified theory of informa-
tion, the evolutionary information, the dependency on dissipative and living systems) (Fuchs, 2008;
Hofkirchner, 1999; 2009). Contrarily, the quartet model of information notions proposed below can
help us to unify this presented diversity.
3. The Quartet Model
The historical review and analysis of the various information notions conducted here may be sum-
marised in terms of four kinds of forms of information notions, or the quartet model. These four
kinds of forms are: information is ‘fundamental’, information is ‘meaningful’, information is ‘quantifi-
able’, and information is ‘transmittable’. All of the notions that are used to build the quartet model
belong to the era of investigations from industrial revolution to information society (e.g. Castells,
2010). This presents the era of immense research on bringing the meaning of fundamental notions
of our existence into discussions and debates.
Our position is that the proposed quartet model has generated some interesting and useful re-
sults as the classification of information notions draws on four initial accounted forms of informa-
tion. All these notions are based on philosophical implications of the doctrines of objectivism and
subjectivism. Thus, the following four forms of the notion of information are introduced:
• ‘Information is Fundamental’. These notions are primarily concerned with the concept of informa-
tion as something that is equal to the basic substances or insubstances of the universe. (Elabo-
rated in Section 3.1.)
• ‘Information is Meaningful’. These notions are primarily concerned with knowledge and human
capabilities, which are able to interpret and give meaning to something that is or becomes infor-
mation. (Elaborated in Section 3.2.)
• ‘Information is Quantifiable’. These notions are not concerned with whether information is related
to the fundamentals or its meaning given by human beings. Rather, they are only concerned with
the technical sphere; they are concerned with the finding of technical possibilities to measure in-
formation. (Elaborated in Section 3.3.)
• ‘Information is Transmittable’. These notions are only concerned with how information is trans-
mittable, possibly in the same quantity, from one point to another. These notions are strongly re-
lated to a composition of what would be ‘quantifiable information’ and ‘communicated information
communicated to its destination’, the latter in terms of human values. (Elaborated in Section
3.4.)
Various scholars have had a rather fascinating look into the notion of information. Their notions
have been exclusive for their environments and thoughts (e.g. Bateson, 1972; Fuchs, 2008; Israel
& Perry, 1990; Sebeok & Danesi, 2000; Shannon, 1948; Wiener, 1948), among many others. Our
308 Miranda Kajtazi and Derek M. Haftor
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
focus is on classifying these different notions of information by restructuring the discussions that
compelled no consensus. Other research has explored information that occurs as a companion
entity for other essential concerns, in the context of calculations in mathematical theory (e.g. Lan-
dauer, 1991; MacKay, 1969; Rapoport, 1953; Shannon, 1948; Wiener, 1948), semantic information
(e.g. Bar-Hillel & Carnap, 1953; Dretske, 1981; Floridi, 2005), information as a form: autopoietic
and semiotic (e.g. Bateson, 1972; Brier, 2008; Britz, 2007; Madden, 2004; Maturana & Varela,
1980; Qvortrup, 1993; Peirce, 1958), and information as meaning (e.g. Bawden, 2007; Boland,
1987; Checkland & Scholes, 1990; Langefors, 1993).
We use this diversification to distinguish our intention of presenting why there is a need to bal-
ance these forms of information, and we argue that the application of each form in our current sur-
roundings is useful for what each signifies.
In reflection to the presented classification of notions, we illustrate below a historical overview of
some key authors that have guided us to develop the presented quartet model.
The basis of our enquiry to develop this approach is focused on the classifications as presented
in Figure 1. The proposed classification is mainly developed on the basis of practices among
scholars who have been subject to diverse scientific influences on defining the notion of informa-
tion.
We illustrate the application of those selected information notions within this framework by de-
veloping some theoretical understandings (contexts, challenges, dimensions). As a result of this
development, the tendency has been to re-conceptualise the notion of information. For that, not
only has information become significant for someone in its indefinite understandings, but also we
consider that information as a notion has become more explicit to everyone in its quartet appear-
ance.
Finally, since we have tackled this dilemma at length, we argue that the quartet as our approach
may possibly change the theoretical understanding (of being equivocal) of the notion of information.
Figure 1: The presentation of the quartet model: historical developments of the notion of
information
tripleC 9(2): 305-315, 2011 309
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
The next four sub-sections present an overview of each of these identified forms. Due to limited
space, we only mention some key selected notions in each of these forms. To strengthen our over-
view, we also discuss more specifically one selected notion under each form. In this way, we intend
to clarify how such selected notions are related to these four forms.
3.1. Information is Fundamental
This kind of information form presents the developments and understandings on the notion of in-
formation as being ‘fundamental’. Here, information is regarded as one of the essential elements
that constitute our world (Floridi, 2003, 2010). There are several independent approaches that tried
to explain at least information’s role as a constitutive element so far, but not concisely its meaning.
Some of these approaches come from the trans-disciplinary influence. They define information in
this context: “information is a difference that makes a difference” (Bateson, 1972, p.459); “informa-
tion is information, not matter and energy” (Wiener, 1948, p.132); “information has arisen as a con-
cept as fundamental and important as ‘being’, ‘knowledge’, ‘life’, ‘intelligence’, ‘meaning’, or ‘good
and evil’, all pivotal concepts with which it is interdependent” (Floridi, 2001, p.16); “Information is
that part of the process of self-organization that is responsible for generating new features in the
system’s structure, state or behavior" (Hofkirchner, 2010, p.62); “information is different from mean-
ing. Information is an objective, although abstract, feature of the world in the same way as are
physical objects and their properties” (Mingers, 1995, p.295).
Our understanding of this information form is that its constituting notions attempt collectively to
conceive of information as being fundamental and independent of anything else that constitutes our
world. Furthermore, for this information form, information can be insubstantial, which defines the
differences between the substances (the tangible) and the differences between the imperceptible
(the intangible). Information can also be considered as an independent complex element for how it
comes to existence, how it is interpreted by human context, or how it dissolves in the objective and
subjective nature, and how it recurs.
In this regard, for us, perhaps the most profound notion of information, in this category of infor-
mation being fundamental, is Bateson’s proposal that information is a “difference that makes a
difference” (Bateson, 1972, p.459). However, a critical question then asks whether this notion is
meaningful and elementary, and in practice, this is the preparatory investigation for one to start
thinking about what is deeply meant by the notion of information.
For Bateson, the infinity – of the differences – is what truly matters in whatever we experience in
this world as information. It is ‘us’ – the living beings – and it is the ‘objects’ – the physical entities –
that in the way ‘we’ or the ‘objects’ continually transform (change through time) experience an infi-
nite range of differences. This, according to Bateson (1972), is a journey that is first made possible
through hard sciences. Indeed, this is the way in which the basis of our creation, the matter and
energy, trigger every chance to experience a difference. Thus far, this has only illustrated the broad
nature of the Batesonian philosophy of information. Our question ‘what is really meant by these
differences of information?’ is yet to be explicated. For what is really meant by Bateson’s differ-
ence, he clearly points out that ‘we’, or the ‘objects’, exist around infinite differences, that is, be-
tween the ‘object’ and the ‘moon’, between ‘us’ and the ‘moon’, between the ‘object’ and the ‘us’,
and so on. Even more, for every ‘us’ or for every ‘object’ there are molecules, which have infinite
differences between their current locations, past locations, or the locations in which ‘we’ or the ‘ob-
jects’ might be. Thus for every one of ‘us’ there is a different way of perceiving information, in fact,
very different in terms of how this is conceived for every ‘object’. For ‘us’, it can be from the inside,
the sensory input from our mental abilities. It can also be from the outside, in the propagation of
light and sound, the matter and energy. Be that as it may, this contrast is not absolute, Bateson
points out (1972, p.460). As a matter of fact, this contrast must be mentioned and understood;
otherwise it can lead one to problems. If it is necessary to pronounce this, then this is truly the
greatest (yet too broad) meaning of the notion of information.
310 Miranda Kajtazi and Derek M. Haftor
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
3.2. Information is Meaningful
This form of information presents a growing scholarly orientation in the last three decades. Informa-
tion here is defined as something that must be interpreted by human-beings. Many of the selected
notions derive from diverse areas of research, such as: personal worldviews, individual experi-
ences; human knowing and human management; human social values, and the like. Hence, they
define information as: “information equals data plus meaning” (Checkland & Scholes, 1990, p.303);
“information is an inward-forming. It is the change in a person from an encounter with data. It is the
change in the knowledge, beliefs, values or behavior of that person” (Boland, 1987, p.363); “infor-
mation is interpreted data, it is something we get to know, it is knowledge of some sort” (Langefors,
1993, p.111); “information is understood as potential until somebody interprets it” (Brier, 2004,
p.629); “information is data that are processed to be useful, providing answers to ‘who’, ‘what’,
‘where’, and ‘when’ questions” (Ackoff, 1989, p.5); “information-as-expressed-meaning” (Basden,
2010, p.18).
From our understandings, the developments in this area suggest that there has been a broad
view on defining information as meaningful (from social aspects to individual aspects), although
each of them regards human values as critical, by putting the human understanding and human
interpretation as the main source of creating information.
Every scholarly discipline uses the concept of information in a variety of contexts. A critical yet
interesting debate on this pattern is introduced by Boland (1987) in his attempt to examine the most
crucial issues that concern information systems (Boland, 1987). In particular, he focuses on the
issue of how information has become a common dominator. For him, information is a notion which
is capable of bringing together the basic elements of our existence simply into a single framework
of analysis. His concern, which is to investigate the use of the notion of information in a variety of
forms, is due more to its use as a metaphor than to what information is in reality. In this aspect, he
argues that there are some central information aspects of our social world. Boland’s conception of
information has been intruded by the five most popular dictum fantasies of our time. He divided
them on the basis of various research initiatives that took the responsibility to define information for
their interests – the dictum. In spite of this investigation, for Boland, each of them has failed to
realise that the necessary condition of defining information is the interpretive system. In other
words, it is the mental state of the human knower. His five identified fantasies were presented in
sequence, and his intention was to highlight the focus of each: the removal of the human factor. It
is through his accomplishments on research that he identified these fantasies: (i) information is
structured data; (ii) an organisation is information; (iii) information is power; (iv) information is intel-
ligence; and (v) information is perfectible.
In all these five forms, Boland intends to remain sceptical of how each utilises information. He
purposely refers to them as fantasies, or as imaginative devices that are not capable of describing
the reality but can only suggest a possibility. However, his conception of fantasy is related to cre-
ativity versus delusion, composed of two faces: the productively imaginative face, and the self-
deluding face (Boland, 1987, p.367). This idea of fantasies is primarily concerned with stressing the
intention to remove the human aspect, together with the human action and human meaning. The
sequential presentation of the five fantasies is designated to fail, argues Boland, because informa-
tion is prima facie a human element. Thus, information for him is not structured data. It is not an
object with potential to design organisations. It is not an object that possesses intelligence, it does
not give or bring power, and it is not perfectible (Boland, 1987, p.370).
As a substitute for the five fantasies, for Boland information is an inward-forming. It can be a part
of sense making for human beings and their lived experiences that allow them to understand the
world, even if, on the contrary, information could be regarded as an object that does not invoke the
necessary meaning of a particular situation within our world but can in fact delude our understand-
ings.
tripleC 9(2): 305-315, 2011 311
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
3.3. Information is Quantifiable
It is evident that the era when understandings of this form of the notion of information developed
presents the era when technology started to flourish. The understanding of information in the form
of being quantifiable comes from the Bell Systems Laboratory, primarily starting with Hartley’s no-
tion that “information is a measurable quantity” (Hartley, 1928, p.536). His influence has spread to
his research stream; however, the use of the notion of information in his context has since been
very weak. Thus, his contribution today is re-interpreted as signals or digital inputs, rather than
information. There are very few such notions. Similar notions put the role of information as some-
thing tangible, such as “information can have attached measure to it” (Bar-Hillel & Carnap, 1953,
p.149) or “information is physical” (Landauer, 1991, p.23). Indeed, such understandings of informa-
tion are related to quantum physics and thermodynamics with developments of entropy and negen-
tropy, which are concerned with creation of physical patterns that carry energy and that in turn
generate information (Bar-Hillel & Carnap, 1953; Landauer, 1991).
Here, we purposely elaborate more on the notion first stated by Hartley (1928), to gain a better
insight on his view. It is clear that he put effort into trying to attach quantity to information, in terms
of the engineering aspect of electrical communications. His understanding of information came to
mean something that appears in telegraphic or telephonic forms of communication. His interest
was to explore a system’s capacity to transmit information signals and symbols, by simply adding
some sort of measurable quantity. What is important in this understanding is that Hartley clearly
states that information is an elastic term; therefore it is necessary to set up a specific meaning,
which addresses his view. Hence, Hartley’s intention was to quantify the use of information as
symbol representation, which for someone (here putting the human context) would mean some-
thing. He says: “in any given communication the sender mentally selects a particular symbol and by
some bodily motion, as of his vocal mechanism, causes the attention of the receiver to be directed
to that particular symbol” (Hartley, 1928, p.536). Further to this understanding, Hartley explores the
human meaning aspects of information (here, he presents a well-elaborated example of how
someone would interpret the sentence ‘apples are red’), for which he concludes that such an
understanding would be of psychological factors. Thus, for him, it is desirable to eliminate such
implications while establishing a measure of information in terms of pure physical quantities.
3.4. Information is Transmittable
The last form of information identified in this literature survey presents the most debated research.
This form also comes from the Bell Systems Laboratory developments.
It starts from the pioneering work of Shannon and Weaver (1949) in the late 1940s, when Shan-
non first argued that “information is transmittable … the fundamental problem of communication is
that of reproducing at one point, either exactly or approximately, a message selected at another
point” (Shannon, 1948, p.379). In more detail, they introduce the notion of entropy in relation to the
notion of information, but very vaguely defined.
Information regarded as transmittable comes from the aspect of transmission of information with
noisy communication, which would largely affect the final destination of information (here, Shannon
means the final input to a human being). For Shannon and Weaver, the transmission of information
that conveys some message may be of importance for humans. This is what they had in mind
when they stated: “the destination of information transmission can be a person or it can be a thing
for whom the message is intended” (Shannon, 1948, p.2).
Nevertheless, Shannon and Weaver have been unclear on why and how they put into the con-
text the human understanding of transmitted information, because for them the semantic aspects
remain irrelevant to engineering problems. However, entropy is the fundament of information, de-
fined via the mathematical theory of communication, primarily considering Boltzmann’s meaning of
entropy. This form of entropy, for Shannon, is put in terms of improbability of inspecting noise in
communication of information, implying that meaning will be disordered at its final destination – the
human being. Hence, this differs from thermodynamic perspectives of Boltzmann’s entropy, which
312 Miranda Kajtazi and Derek M. Haftor
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
is concerned with changes in physical energy. In spite of this, Shannon states: “it is important to
emphasize, at the start, that we are not concerned with the meaning or the truth of messages; se-
mantics lies outside the scope of mathematical information theory” (Shannon, 1948, p.2).
This controversy led to immense discussions and debates from trans-disciplinary views.
4. Introducing an Alternative Understanding of the Notion of Information
So, what is really information? Can we contextualise information as being fundamental? Is informa-
tion really meaningful? Does it exist out-there, without attaching to it the human interpretation? Or
is it necessary to bring a complete new reductionist approach, minimising its role as being quantifi-
able or transmittable? And, how is it possible to have information about information?
The preliminary results of this ongoing research have provided us with an alternative under-
standing of the notion of information. The diversity of notions of information presents information as
a universal notion – in the sense of Heidegger’s understanding – and as a complex element – that
which Akerlof (1970) and Simon (1996) indicated.
Our understanding of the notion of information is rooted in the quartet approach. Moreover, we
intend to give critical value to the notion of information by associating it with its central functioning
in our global society. Thus, we propose to understand ‘information’ as: ‘representation of principles
that guide humans’ understanding to utilise the meaning of data in handling their needs in a par-
ticular situation at a particular moment in time’. Insofar as information is presented here simply as
an entity of our existence, it clearly requires that there shall be a right way to access this entity,
which must be obtained and secured in advance for the human well-being. Information here lies
across the intended meaning and the conveyed meaning, formed of principles that guide choosing,
conceiving, or accessing information. This new understanding of information is a concrete proposal
that relates to the subjective nature of our existence as much as it relates to our objective sur-
roundings, and thereby attempts to bridge the Cartesian subject–object gap dominating the various
notions of information. Our intention is to explore the role of information by offsetting the principles
that determine how human interpretation has come to play a critical role in situations where infor-
mation becomes the main source of cause. The implication of this understanding is that information
is an independent factor that plays a central role in our cognitive and material world.
5. Discussion
This paper presents a study where some of the most central notions of information are presented.
While the various previous contributions to the understanding of information have already given
some insights and also some new ideas regarding the meaning of information, the research pre-
sented here suggests that the notion of information is still an elusive concept, yet it also seems to
be one of the most central concepts of our present civilisation; “indeed, as an explicandum, it can
be associated with several explanations” (Bar-Hillel & Carnap, 1953, p.9); “information is said to
remain vague, while the confusion continues to reign” (Britz, 2007, p.33); “information is still a tricky
concept” (Qvortrup, 1993, p.3); and “information is a popular term that has complicated its theoreti-
cal definitions” (Pervez, 2009, p.1).
Certainly, these abovementioned views present the only unified understanding of the notion of
information, and thus in this context they have consensus. Nevertheless, these references are just
samples taken from the literature. Almost every contribution that has taken for granted the notion of
information introduces the reader to how this notion is thoughtfully regarded as equivocal. Now this
remains critical for this research. Yet, and apart of finding ourselves in that consensus, we have
presented our view of the notion of information in the quartet of its forms. Furthermore, we have
demonstrated the application of our theoretical framework by introducing an alternative understand-
ing of this notion. The latter is a proposal which may not have precisely given a specific under-
standing of the notion of information – that would rather be an unfruitful reduction. This has rather
given a generic understanding of the most basic information forms, ‘the quartet’, which we brought
together in the context of this understanding.
tripleC 9(2): 305-315, 2011 313
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
5.1. Implications for Theory and Practice
Our theoretical framework – the quartet approach – can be used to further develop theoretical and
meta-theoretical views, in regard to our analyses and results, together with all other developments
in this area of research. We focused on previous contributions that have dealt with the notion of
information explicitly. This, the response to our research questions is to theorise about the role of
the notion of information in its diversity. Subsequently, this requires specifying how information is
understood. We have argued that our understanding of the nature of information helps to better
specify the four forms of the quartet model. There are some important differences between the four
forms of information presented in the quartet model. This contribution indicates a more concrete
theoretical understanding, which is likely to significantly reform the ideas behind the notion of in-
formation in the near future. Even if this approach has common features with what has been said
before, it differs in some important ways. The notion of information is understood in four ways.
Based on this, we conceptualise the relationship between each of these forms as dynamic and
intertwined, where, for example, the act of sharing information requires the use of the quartet ap-
proach to complete a sequence of activities that give meaning to information, as indicated in each
of the information forms of the quartet.
The presented quartet model and the introduced novel understanding of the notion of informa-
tion also have important implications for its practice in the information society. The results provide
an analytical tool for human beings, who many times become the victims of unwanted causes and
consequences of societal failures and fatalities. To follow up on one of our situations presented in
the introduction, that of the recent financial crisis in Greece, information is regarded as the source
of generating such a crisis. In our understanding, if information had been utilised appropriately, and
if information had been interpreted correctly for the needs of human beings, it would have been
unnecessary for the bailout to occur, especially now in the time when the current global crisis is
creating extreme depression in our economic and societal environments.
6. Summary
Information, understood as ‘representation of principles that guide humans’ understanding to utilise
the meaning of data in handling their needs in a particular situation at a particular moment in time’
shows its importance in empirical dilemmas when societal failures or fatalities caused by the lack of
needed information lead to unwanted consequences: the Haiti earthquake in 2010, the Greece
Crisis 2010, or the oil slick in the Gulf of Mexico in 2010. In this paper we present a literature sur-
vey of scholarly research that explicitly addresses the need to understand and/or define the notion
of information. The results show that the notion of information is highly diversified, ill-defined, and
with no consensus, which presents a typical universal notion that is hard to understand. Thus, the
research presented in this paper intends to classify this diversity by introducing four forms of the
notion of information, labelled as the “quartet model of information”. Moreover, this classification
introduces an alternative and novel understanding of the notion of information, still in its infancy,
but regarded as highly relevant in empirical dilemmas. This calls for joining the efforts and aiming
to shift the notion of information to a whole new perspective by addressing significant needs of the
information society.
References
Adams, F. (2003). The informational turn in philosophy. Minds and Machines, 13(4), 471-501.
Ackoff, R. L. (1989). From data to wisdom. Journal of Applied Systems Analysis, 16, 3-9.
Akerlof, G. (1970). The market for ‘lemons’: Quality uncertainty and the market mechanism. Quarterly Journal of Economics,
84(3), 488-500.
Basden, A. (2010). On using spheres of meaning to define and dignify the IS discipline. International Journal of Information
Management, 30(1), 13-20.
Bar-Hillel, Y., & Carnap, R. (1953). Semantic information. British Journal of Science, 4, 147-157.
Bateson, G. (1972). Steps to an ecology of mind. New York: Ballantine Books.
314 Miranda Kajtazi and Derek M. Haftor
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Bates, M. J. (2006). Fundamental forms of information. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Tech-
nology, 57(8), 1033-1045.
Bawden, D. (2007). Information as self-organized complexity: A unifying viewpoint. Proceedings from the Sixth International
Conference on Conceptions of Library and Information Science: "Featuring the Future". Retrieved from
http://informationr.net/ir/12-4/colis/colis31.html.
Belkin, N. J. (1978). Information concepts for information science. Journal of Documentation, 34(1), 55-85.
Boland, R. J. (1987). The in-formation of information Systems. In R. J. Boland & R. A. Hirscheim (Eds.), Critical Issues in
Information Systems Research (pp. 364-379). New York: John Wiley & Sons.
Brier, S. (1992). Information and consciousness: A critique of the mechanistic concept of information. Cybernetics and
Human Knowing, 1(2/3), 1-24.
Brier, S. (1998). Cybersemiotics: a transdisciplinary framework for information studies. BioSystems, 46, 185-191.
Brier, S. (2004). Cybersemiotics and the problems of the information-processing paradigm as a candidate for a unified
science of information behind library information science. Library Trends, 52(3), 629-658.
Brier, S. (2008). Cybersemiotics: Why information is not enough! Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Brillouin, L. (1962). Science and information theory. New York: Academic Press.
Britz, J. J. (2007). Definition of information. Research Report. South Africa: University of Pretoria Publishing.
Capurro, R., & Hjørland, B. (2003). The concept of information. In B. Cronin (Ed.), The Annual Review of Information Sci-
ence and Technology, 37, 343-411.
Castells, M. (1996). The rise of the network society. Malden: Basil Blackwell.
Castells, M. (2010). The power of identity: The information age: Economy, society and culture. Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell.
Checkland, P., & Scholes, J. (1990). Soft systems methodology in action. Chichester: John Wiley and Sons.
Dretske, F. I. (1981). Knowledge and the flow of information. Oxford: Blackwell.
Floridi, L. (2001). What is the philosophy of information? Metaphilosophy, 33(1/2), 123-145.
Floridi, L. (2003). Two approaches to the philosophy of information. Minds and Machines, 13(4), 459-469.
Floridi, L. (2005). Is information meaningful data? Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, 70, 351-370.
Floridi, L. (2010). Information: A Very Short Introduction. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Hofkirchner, W., Fuchs, C. & Klauninger, B. (2005). Informational universe: A praxo-onto-epistemological approach. In E,
Martikainen (Ed.), Human approaches to the universe: Interdisciplinary studies (pp. 75-94). Finland: Bookstore Tiede-
kirja.
Fuchs, C.. (2008). Towards a critical theory of information. In D. Nafria, J. M. Salto & A. Franciso (Eds.), Qué es Informa-
ción? (What is Information?). Proceedings from the First International meeting of Experts in Information Theories. An
Interdisciplinary Approach. León: Universidad de León.
Hartley, R. V. L. (1928). Transmission of Information. Bell System Technical Journal, 7, 335-363.
Heidegger, M. (1962). Being and time. London: Harper & Row.
Hofkirchner, W. (Ed.) (1999). The quest for a unified theory of information. Proceedings from the Second International Con-
ference on the Foundations of Information Science. Amsterdam: Gordon and Breach.
Hofkirchner, W. (2009). A unified theory of information: An outline. Creative Commons License.
Hofkirchner, W. (2010). Twenty questions about a unified theory of information: A short exploration into information from a
complex systems view. Litchfield Park AZ: Emergent Publications.
Husserl, E. (2001). Logical investigations. Volume 1. London: Routledge.
Israel, D., & Perry, J. (1990). What is information? In P. Hanson (Ed.), Information, language and cognition (pp. 1-19). Van-
couver, BC: University of British Columbia Press.
Landauer, R. (1991). Information is physical. Physics Today, 44, 23-29.
Langefors, B. (1993). Essays on infology: Summing up and planning for the Future. In B. Dahlbom (Ed.), Gothenburg Stud-
ies in Information Systems (Report 5), Gothenburg: University of Gothenburg Press.
Losee, R. M. (1998). A discipline independent definition of information. Journal of the American Society for Information
Science, 48(3), 254-269.
Luhmann, N. (1990). Essays on self-references. New York: Columbia University Press.
MacKay, D. M. (1969). Information, mechanism and meaning. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Madden, A. D. (2004). Evolution and information. Journal of Documentation, 60(1), 9-23.
Maturana, H. R., & Varela, F. J. (1980). Autopoiesis and cognition. Dordrecht: Reidel.
Mingers, J. C. (1995). Information and meaning: Foundations for an intersubjective account. Information Systems Journal,
5, 285-306.
Mingers, J. (2001). Embodying information systems: the contribution of phenomenology. Information and Organisation, 11,
103-128.
Parker, E. (1973). Information and society. Proceedings from the Conference on the Needs of Occupational, Ethnic, and
other Groups in the United States (pp. 9-50). USA: Library and Information Needs for the Nation.
Peirce, C. S. (1931-58). The Collected Papers (edited by C. Hartshorne & P. Weiss (Volumes 1-6) & A. Burks (Volumes 7-
8) Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press.
Pervez A. (2009). Information as form. tripleC: Cognition, Communication, Co-operation, 7(1), 1-11.
Qvortrup L. (1993). The controversy over the concept of information. An overview and a selected and annotated bibliogra-
phy. Cybernetics & Human Knowing, 1(4), 3-24.
Rapoport A. (1953). What is information? Etc., 10, 247-260.
Stonier, T. (1990). Information and the internal structure of the universe: An exploration into information physics. London:
Springer.
Stonier, T. (1996). Information as a basic property of the universe. Bio Systems, 38(2-3), 135-140.
Sebeok, Th. A., & Danesi, M. (2000). The forms of meaning: Modeling systems theory and semiotic analysis. Berlin: de
Gruyter.
tripleC 9(2): 305-315, 2011 315
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Shannon, C. E. A. (1948). Mathematical theory of communication. Bell System Technical Journal, 27, 379–423 & 623–56.
Shannon, C., & Weaver, W. (1949). The mathematical theory of communication. Illinois: The University of Illinois Press.
Simon, H. A. (1996). The sciences of the artificial. Cambridge: MIT Press.
Wiener, N. (1948). Cybernetics or communication and control in the animal and the machine. Cambridge: MIT Press.
About the Author
Miranda Kajtazi
Miranda Kajtazi is a PhD candidate in Informatics, at the School of Computer Science, Physics and Mathematics, at Lin-
naeus University in Sweden. She received a Master’s degree in Computer Science from Växjö University and a Bachelor’s
degree in Computer Science from South East European University. Her research interest concerns one of the most crucial
resources of our human and social affairs: information. Thus, Miranda explores the interplay of social dynamics and tech-
nology by focusing on the causes and consequences of information inadequacy in our global society. She has also worked
in industry as a software engineer and a database administrator.
Darek M. Haftor
Darek M. Haftor, PhD (prev. Darek M. Eriksson), is currently an associate professor at the Stockholm University School of
Business, Stockholm, Sweden. He has studied the sciences and arts at various universities in Europe and North America,
and received his doctorate in Industrial Organization at Chalmers University of Technology, Sweden. He has spent fifteen
years in various managerial positions in the private industry sector, and has worked in Europe and the Middle East. Previ-
ously, he has held several academic positions in Sweden, including at the Mid Sweden University, the Luleå University of
Technology, and the Linnaeus University, where he is currently affiliated as a senior researcher. Darek is now mainly occu-
pied with research and teaching, and is also the Director of Executive Education at the Stockholm University School of
Business. His research addresses two main frontiers: the structure and dynamics of information-based organisations and
their operations, and the normative conditions inherent in the design, development, and change of any human affairs.