tripleC 9(2): 286-294, 2011 287
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
and neuroscience) and social systems (sociology)? How can we preserve all practical interests
regarding information (from the governing of nature or the implementation of technology to the
preservation of social rights, cultural life, human dignity…)?
From the mid 20th century, the endeavour to delve into the nature of information has followed
many paths with a certain tendency to be interdisciplinary (for instance, in cybernetics, system the-
ory, cognitive science, aesthetics, etc) but also with a frequently restrictive scope, just only ac-
counting for some aspects of information (syntactic, semantic or pragmatic ones) (Díaz, 2009).
While the Mathematical Theory of Information only gave account of the syntactic aspects, many
other approaches attempted to give a better account of the multifaceted reality of information.
These endeavours developed with a relative independence, obtaining significant achievements in
their respective (and somehow separate) fields, but leaving aside an overarching understanding of
information.
The state of the art regarding information theories includes distinct ongoing paradigms, such as:
complexity (Algorithmic Information Theory, info-computation); entropy vs. order (physics, chemis-
try); situated (infon theory); intentional (cognitive science, decision theory); semantic (linguistics,
communication theory); system (cybernetics); evolution (biology, social theory, etc. Thus, on the
one hand, different disciplines presuppose distinct paradigms; on the other hand, the information
phenomena that have been addressed by each discipline sometimes overlap, while others leave
significant gaps among them (Capurro, 2009; Lyre, 2002; Díaz & Salto 2009).
In the evolution of the information society, especially since the 1990s, it has become clear that
many pragmatic and ethical problems have arisen, indicating that many interests concerning infor-
mation were left aside by science and technology, or could not be achieved solely by their own
means. In order to examine these matters, several groups were constituted, for instance the Inter-
national Center for Information Ethics (ICIE, 2002), or the Center for Information Policy Research,
(CIPR, 2010), to name but a few.
This segregation of scopes is to some extent related to what Brier calls the informational- and
the semiotic view, corresponding respectively to bottom-up and top-down approaches. According to
the author: “it may be impossible to unite the two paradigms by manipulating basic definitions into
unifying compromises” (see fig.1.a). Hofkirchner considers this non-reducible confrontation in terms
of the “ways of thinking” such as reductionism and projectionism (Hofkirchner, 2009). He states the
problems in terms of the so called Capurro-trilema, which embraces the non-reachable sinonimity
among information concepts in different contexts (related to reductionism), the non-sufficiency of
analogy (related to projectionism) and the unavoidable equivocity among theories (related to a
disjuctivism way of thinking, as for example, that adopted by a hermeneutical approach). This
author puts forward a further approach he calls integrationism (see Figure 1.b). This is not so far
from what Gregory Bateson considered as a hierarchy of logic types inherent to informational proc-
ess phenomena, which is also at the core of second order cybernetics (Bateson, 1979).
In the trend of erecting a global understanding of information, several international meetings gath-
ered the most eminent scientists in the field, from quantum physics to humanities: the Conferences
on the Foundations of Information Science (celebrated in 1994, 1996, 2002, 2005 –cf. FIS, 2009),
the meetings held in Duino, Italy (2007) and León, Spain (2008) (Luhn, Kornwachs, & Grassmann,
2007; BITrum, 2009). In these gatherings, it was stated that the damaging effects of mixing syntac-
tic and semantic aspects of information have not yet been overcome, and a road must be found
which intersects both science and common sense. In other words, the overlapping of the two direc-
tions pointed out by Brier (Figure 1.a) has mainly generated confusion in the field. However, an
effort can be made to reach mutual understanding in essential aspects. In different stages, the
unified view has been outlined - following Hofkirchner’s integrationism, cybernetics or the systemic
approach - but, as Marijuán has argued, the complexity of theories makes mutual understanding an
arduous task that should be carefully examined through what he calls recombination, which - in a
more affordable horizon - may “offer a new panoramic view on the sciences themselves and con-
tribute to achieve social adaptability & sustainability” (Marijuán, 2009).