tripeC 9(2): 278-285, 2011
ISSN 1726-670X
http://www.triple-c.at
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Towards a New Science of Information
Dail Dewitt Doucette
daildd@comcast.net, Science of Information Institute, Washington, DC USA
Abstract: This paper suggests a New Information Paradigm and recommends the establishment of a new academic and
scientific discipline to be titled "Science of Information", built on a premise that information is also a major part of all the
universes, elements, systems, and conditions. Therefore, it is also an integral part of all the other individual disciplines and
sciences. It is essential to look beyond the limitations of how humans use and perceive information, or even how other living
organisms use information. It is proposed that information is a continuous evolving process, that exists in some simple to
complex form in every stage of development, across all scientific and academic domains, as well as being a significant part
of everything that exists. Information is a trigger mechanism, emphasis and nutrient, not only for information activities itself
but also all physical, and biological elements, systems and activities. Each existing discipline has within it a significant core
Informational Element, which helps formulate and define that discipline. The Science of Information will bring together these
core information elements in order to correlate, compare and assemble a combined theoretical base. This new discipline
should be established as a meta-discipline. It should exist equally with traditional discipline categories such as physical,
social science, arts, and humanities. It should not compete with or replace other disciplines. It should stand alongside them
and assist them, as well as conduct comparisons and consolidations amongst multiple disciplines regarding information
theories, methodologies, practices, by adding new perspectives, resources and developments.
Keywords: Science of Information, Physical Sciences, Information Science, Transdisciplinary, Meta discipline, and New
Academic Discipline
Acknowledgement: I want to thank Professor Kang Oyang and Professor E. Zin Zhong for hosting this important fourth FIS
conference on the Foundations of Information Science, and Professor Zong-Rong Li for all his work in making the confer-
ence a success. The Science of Information Institute is very pleased to be a co-sponsor. As the Executive Director of the
Institute, I can say on behalf of our Board of Directors and Scientific Advisory Committee – headed by Wolfgang Hofkirchner
– that we look forward to continued productive discussions and concrete outcomes. I appreciate that so many young people
have joined us at this conference. We dedicate our work to them and their future. The Science of Information is a Science of
and for this new age.
The purpose of this paper is to challenge the active practitioners and participants in the field of
information foundational and application studies, rather than being a standard academic paper. The
observations and suggestions presented here are my own, and do not necessarily represent any
organization. My duty here is to present some candid observations and suggestions to those ac-
tively involved in developing a new science of information.
1. Proposed Perspective
I suggest that all of you here attending this conference, members of Foundations of Information
Science (FIS), Science of Information Institute (SciI), our Chinese hosts, and the Huangzhong Uni-
versity of Science and Technology, and other distinguished professional scholars from other coun-
tries, consider establishing a new information paradigm, together we would change our focus and
activities, from the traditional studies in information science, semiotics, computer science, artificial
intelligence, social information sciences, informatics, etc. into a new broader meta-discipline and
professional domain, to be called a “Science of Information.” The focus of this new field will be to
assist in redirecting societies' current old hard, material centered culture, towards a newer softer,
more responsive, and adaptable information centered culture. We must recognize, respect, and
even support those traditional disciplines that helped us originate this evolved discipline to this
point, but we must now focus our main attention on establishing this newer macro field, and assist
in bringing it to reality.
tripleC 9(2): 278-285, 2011 279
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
At the third FIS conference on Foundations of Information Science in Paris, 2005, the need for a
science of information was recognized. We added an additional day to the conference to discuss
this topic; out of this meeting we initiated the Science of Information Institute. This new international
activity was housed in Washington, D.C., not because it represented any U.S. interests, but be-
cause that was where a support facility was initially offered. In November of 2005, at the 2nd
UNESCO Conference on The Information Society in Tunis, Tunisia, I distributed a paper entitled
"Information as a Unique and Scholarly Field” in which a Science of Information concept was pre-
sented to the United Nations and the international education and scientific communities. In both
papers it was suggested that we have evolved beyond the traditional study of Information Theory –
and – Information Science, and should consider a new term “Science of Information” in order to
broaden our scope and include the extended theories and perspectives of the physical and biologi-
cal sciences, together with arts and humanities.
I now propose that the developments in the field are at a stage where “Science of Information”
should be considered more a “meta-science” that is contributive to – and complementary with –
every other science and academic discipline rather than just a solitary traditional discipline that is
normally distinguished by a single scientific perspective. Historically, studies of Information Science
have included the fields of library and computer, science, semiotics, psychology and many social
sciences, plus management and engineering-oriented approaches; all have been oriented toward
the descriptive and manipulative aspects of information.
Information seems to have four interacting properties of information that we need to explore
more fully.
A. It is descriptive (humans most often think of information in this mode)
B. It has manipulative, computative, relativeness capabilities (mathematics, computer science are
more aware of this aspect of information)
C. It has prescriptive directive, capabilities (physics, cosmology, managers, and motivators are
more aware of this property of information)
D. It performs these properties upon informational energy and elements as well as physical en-
ergy and elements
These properties seem to be somewhat common across the informational world of physical, social
and applied sciences.
The concepts presented by Erwin Schrödinger in his publication "What is Life, with Mind and
Matter" (1992), and Carl Fredrich von Weizsäcker, while at the Max Planck Institute, plus physicists
John Wheeler, Anton Zeilinger, Hans Christian von Baeyer, and philosopher Luciano Floridi all
have shown how information in physical sciences additionally includes a "prescriptive" element that
initiates and contribute to the development of information. In a similar manner, in addition to the
more traditional descriptive and manipulative perspectives, the science of information must also
now have a strong inclusion of the physical and biological science approaches. In sociology, there
is a distinction between the smaller nuclear family and the larger extended family. What is pro-
posed here is that the study of information follows this analogy of an extended family, and includes
all the other disciplines' studies and developments as contributive elements of information studies
— all under one science of information umbrella.
2. The Current Structure of Academia and Disciplines of Science
If we consider the Science of Information as an evolving field of study and development, a ques-
tion for those interested in this field is, how to place or categorize information as a unique field of
study, within the current academic and science disciplines.
Although Wikipedia is not the most authoritative reference on the subject, it is easier to use, and
more indicative of a contemporary broad perspective than the detailed UNESCO classification of
280 Dail Dewitt Doucette
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
sciences. The following is a summary list from Wikipedia of 58 standard science and academic
disciplines, grouped in 8 standard academic/science clusters.
Science Specializations:
1. Natural/Physical Sciences (some cultures refer to this as material sciences)
1.1. Astronomy
1.2. Chemistry
1.3. Cosmology
1.4. Earth Sciences
1.5. Environmental Science
1.6. Physics
2. Formal Sciences
2.1. Computer Science
2.2. Logic
2.3. Mathematics
2.4. Statistics
2.5. System Sciences
3. Natural Life Sciences
3.1. Anatomy
3.2. Biology
3.3. Botany
3.4. Ecology
3.5. Evolution
3.6. Genetics
3.7. Neurology
3.8. Physiology
3.9. Zoology
4. Cognitive Sciences
4.1. Communication and Journalism
4.2. Informatics
4.3. Information Science
4.4. Library Science
4.5. Linguistics
4.6. Neuroscience
4.7. Philosophy
4.8. Psychology
5. Social Science
5.1. Anthropology/Archaeology
5.2. Area Studies
5.3. Economics
5.4. Ethics
5.5. Geography
5.6. Political Science
5.7. Sociology
6. Applied Professional Science
6.1. Agriculture
6.2. Architecture
6.3. Business
6.4. Education
6.5. Engineering
6.6. Law
6.7. Management
tripleC 9(2): 278-285, 2011 281
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
6.8. Military Science
The list of academic disciplines adds two more categories to traditional science:
7. Humanities
7.1. Creative Writing
7.2. History
7.3. Linguistics and Language
7.4. Literature
7.5. Logic
7.6. Metaphysics, Philosophy and Applied Philosophy
7.7. Religion
7.8. Semiotics and Semantics
8. Arts
8.1. Dance
8.2. Music
8.3. Painting
8.4. Performing Arts, Acting and Movies
8.5. Sculpture
8.6. Skilled Design and Crafts
8.7. Visual Arts, Movies, New Media (Video-computer Art)
These are the academic disciplines that are normally supported by most, but not all of western
higher education. Most of these disciplines were developed, revised, and/or formalized in the 19th
and 20th centuries. There is no overall consensus on how academic disciplines should be classi-
fied; every educational and science institution is free to adapt them to their own unique conditions.
The current developments in both science and academia are becoming heavily influenced by in-
ter and transdiscipline approaches to exploration and development. This tendency will undoubtedly
increase over the next ten years.
It is helpful to understand the difference in the similar but quite different terms used here:
“multidisciplinary” refers to a non-integrative mixture of disciplines in that each discipline retains its
methodologies and assumptions without change or development from other disciplines within the
multidisciplinary relationship; “Interdisciplinary” is a field of study that crosses traditional boundaries
believed academic disciplines or schools of thought, as new needs and professions have emerged;
“Transdisciplinary” connotes a research strategy that crosses many disciplinary boundaries to cre-
ate a holistic approach. In German speaking countries it refers to integration of diverse forms of
research and includes specific methods for relating scientific knowledge and problem solving
(Brand, Schaller, & Völker, 2004). Given this new direction of science and academic development,
it is suggested that the traditional categorization of disciplines include a new category to be in-
cluded in the list above as: C inter/transdisciplinary studies. Within this new C category, it is sug-
gested we include a science of information, plus some new multi-disciplines, such as cybernetics,
history of science, neuro-psychology, artificial intelligence, social information science, information
economics all which will contribute to this new trans-disciplinary field. This is illustrated in the
graphic below.
282 Dail Dewitt Doucette
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Figure 1: Chart of Contributing Information Studies: Toward Development of a New Science of
Information
The new information transdisciplinary category is parallel to the physical, and social sci-
ences/humanities divisions of academic subjects. What makes a difference is that this science of
information discipline complements, assists and adds to the other disciplines by assembling and
correlating all the information-related activities of the other disciplines. Eventually, we want the
science of information to be developed well enough that colleges and universities will be willing to
develop faculties and departments built around this subject.
In establishing the new evolved information categories, there should be some initial awareness
that information is also a part of all elements, systems, and conditions. Therefore, it is also an inte-
gral part of the other individual disciplines and sciences. In studying the information phenomena, it
is essential to look beyond the limitations of how humans use and perceive information, or even
how other living organisms use information. It is proposed that information is a continuously evolv-
ing process, that exists in some simple to complex form in every stage of development, across all
science and academia domains, as well as being a significant part of everything that exists. Infor-
mation is a trigger mechanism, emphasis and nutrient, not only for information activities itself but
tripleC 9(2): 278-285, 2011 283
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
also, all physical, and biological elements, systems and activities. This infers that we need to seri-
ously study the possibility that there is a reality beyond the traditional understanding of the “physi-
cal universe.”
In Paul Davies and Niels Henrik Gregersen's Book "Information and the Nature of Reality"
(2010), Chapters 4, 5, and 6 Paul Davies, Seth Lloyd, and Henry Pierce Strapp challenge some
widely held assumptions about physical reality. Davies asks what happens if we do not assume
that the mathematical relations of the so-called laws of nature are the most basic level of descrip-
tion, but rather if information is regarded as the foundation on which physical reality is constructed.
Davies suggests that instead of taking mathematics to be primary, followed by physics and then
information, the picture should be inverted in our explanatory scheme, so that we find the concep-
tual hierarchy: information laws of physics matter. Lloyd's view of the computational nature of
the universe develops this understanding by treating quantum events as 'quantum bits', or qubits,
whereby the universe 'registers itself'. Lloyd approaches this subject from the viewpoint of quantum
information science, which sets as a major goal the construction of a quantum computer – a device
that can process information at the quantum level, thereby achieving a spectacular increase in
computational power. The secret of a quantum computer lies with the exploitation of genuine quan-
tum phenomena that have no analogues in classical physics, such as superposition, interference,
and entanglement. Quantum computation is an intensely practical programme of research, but
Lloyd uses the concept of quantum information science as the basis for an entire worldview, declar-
ing that the universe as a whole is a gigantic quantum computer. In other words, nature processes
quantum information whenever a physical system evolves.
It may be helpful to see chapter 2 of the Oxford University Press book “Every Thing Must Go:
Metaphysics Naturalized” by James Ladyman, Don Ross, David Spurrett, and John Collier (2007).
The Science of Information should take a lead in developing information as a new unique field,
different, but in partnership with physical reality. This is a functional perspective, not a statement of
philosophy or cosmology.
I suggest those actively engaged in this new field begin a current discussion with their associ-
ates, to derive specific activities and steps that are needed to assist in integrating this evolving
discipline into a new science/academic category. It is suggested that the new science of informa-
tion category be designated within a new category C “multi-disciplines” and be number 9 on the
prior list. Moreover, we as colleagues should seriously study, suggest and share with each other
how this new field could now actively be included in both the scientific and academic communities.
The study of Information as a Science could very well become the most revealing and applicable
scientific development of the Twenty-First Century.
3. Antecedents of this Approach
It may be helpful to understand how this particular concept of Information, as a Science, has
evolved over my 70 years of work experience with the commercial, industrial, governmental and
academic world, since it somewhat parallels the development of this evolving concept. In 1939 as a
youth, I started working for a newspaper in California, which included working both the rear printing
activity and then moving to the front publishing activity during my apprenticeship. In 1954, after
completing a series of advanced courses on communications, information systems, and technol-
ogy, I was tasked to start editing and publishing an internal federal government newsletter on in-
formation, and technical cultural developments. In 1955, I was appointed to a small team of system
engineers, scientists and developers, who were tasked by the U.S. Government Advanced Re-
search Projects Agency (ARPA) to look at newer ways to conceive, develop and use technical or-
ganizational information. A few of the recommendations of that research team have continued to
influence information research and development, and included: (1) focusing of funding on digital
rather than analog compilers, (2) develop, and correlate technical information, where possible, in
integrated, outputs and display systems, rather than for a singular purpose. (3) Move the handling
and processing of information from the existing batch processing, to a more interactive real time
process (4) ensure that more members of the using organizations be involved in information related
284 Dail Dewitt Doucette
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
activities, rather than just relying on outside assistance and (5) move beyond traditional science
and engineering technical specializations, and use a multidisciplinary conceptual, and planning
approach, for all information system, application and developments.
In 1962, at University of California in Los Angeles (UCLA) a group of fellow lecturers and I pre-
pared the second graduate seminar on Information Display Systems. We suggested to the Dean of
Engineering that it would be preferable to approach technical information from a multi-discipline
and user point of view, and add to the traditional scientific and engineering approaches, the tech-
niques and perspectives of human factors, social sciences, arts, and humanities. In addition, we
suggested the field of information processing and display were in essence, part of a larger interdis-
ciplinary study and practice of information studies. The Dean agreed, and he adopted this new
approach.
In 1970, Klaus Otten at National Cash Register Company, in Dayton, Ohio, and Anthony
Debons, at Information Science Department, University of Dayton (who I later worked with) pub-
lished a paper in the Journal of American Society for Information Science, entitled "Towards a Me-
tascience of Information," (Journal of the American Society for Information Science, January-
February 1970, Page 89), in which they summarized contemporary developments in the field. This
had considerable influence on development of the emerging field of information science. Much of
this paper is still relevant at the beginning of the 21st century.
Further expansion of a unified study and development of information was presented during the
first and second international conferences of the FIS (Foundations of Information Science), which
took place in Madrid in 1994, and Vienna in 1996. Wolfgang Hofkirchner summarized and ex-
panded those concepts in his edited volume “The Quest for a Unified Theory of Information”
(1999).
In 1989, the American Physicist John Wheeler delivered a famous lecture entitled “it from bit”,
which stated in part “all things physical are information – theoretic in origin – and that, this is a par-
ticipatory universe”. Hans Christian von Baeyer, in his book “Information: the New Language of
Science“ (2003), and later Luciano Floridi, an information philosopher at Oxford University, in his
book, “Information: A Very Short Introduction” (2010), indicated that the study of information should
include the conceptual addition of physical science’s contributions to the traditional Information
Science studies.
These are the experiences that contributed to my suggesting that, all of these developments
have led to a new, evolved “Science of Information.”
4. The Challenge Before Us Today
In 2010, there is enough research, discussion, and interest in this subject to now begin the process
of developing a new Science of Information, as a formal discipline, and academic specialty.
The new Science of Information must now be assembled by combining the work from multiple
disciplines regarding information as a science; this then should assist in opening up expanded per-
spectives and opportunities within the traditional contributing discipline, as well as the new Science
of Information. It should continue to recognize, honor, and assist, the traditional disciplines that
have contributed to its beginning. It is important to continue to expand more deeply each of these
contributing disciplines' contributions to all knowledge. It is not a purpose here to replace these
traditional disciplines, but rather to create a new combined meta-science, to stand with and along-
side them, in order to collaborate and enhance their activities. It is important to understand this
meta-science would enhance what all disciplines and areas of scientific and academic research
can contribute, by adding new perspectives, resources and insights. It should be a driving force in
actively moving our old materially focused cultures toward a newer more responsive and enlight-
ened information culture. It should take a leadership role in helping Science reintegrate its views
via multi- and transdiscipline approaches toward a more holistic perspective of Science in our more
contemporary society.
tripleC 9(2): 278-285, 2011 285
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
All living species, systems and academic developments need to go through adaptation and tran-
sition periods in order to meet new developments, changing conditions, and challenges. So should
the new study of information. We need to step out beyond where we have been up to now, and into
a newer evolved combined macro challenge. The emergence of the field of “Life Science,” has
shown that the development of a new categorization of science and academia can be accom-
plished. It is important in forming the science of information, that we are aware, and cautious of, the
influence of historical, cultural, political, economic and academic self interests. These wish to main-
tain the status quo, drain off focus, and shift resources so as to diminish the open, unified, coopera-
tive, participation that will be needed to form this new field.
What we need most is personal commitment and action by each individual involved in some as-
pect of the disciplines involved in this new macro science, as well as the participants of this 2010
conference in Beijing. It is now up to all of you, the activists, to assist in moving this science of in-
formation into a viable field of scientific and academic research and study. It is possible that all our
combined efforts can help not only establish a valuable new field of study and research, but also, to
assist in understanding, adapting to civilization's increased rate of change, better offer perceptual
understandings, and reduce misunderstanding of universal information principles, misuse of infor-
mation perspectives, and then advance our capabilities to achieve other, yet currently unknown
benefits for humanity.
References
Brand, F., Schaller, F., & Völker H. (Eds.). (2004). Transdisziplinarität: Bestandsaufnahme und Perspektiven: Beiträge zur
THESIS-Arbeitstagung im Oktober 2003 in Göttingen. Göttingen: Universitätsverlag Göttingen.
Davies, P., & Gregersen, N. H. (2010). Information and the Nature of Reality: From Physics to Metapysics. Cambridge, UK:
Cambridge University Press.
Floridi, L. (2010). Information: a very short introduction. Oxford, UK; New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
Hofkirchner, W. (Ed.). (1999). The Quest for a Unified Theory of Information. Amsterdam, NL: Gordon and Breach Publish-
ers.
Ladyman, J., Ross, D., Spurrett, D., & Collier, J., (2007). Every Thing Must Go: Metaphysics Naturalized. Oxford, UK; New
York, NY: Oxford University Press.
Otten, K., & Debons, A. (1970). Towards a Metascience of Information: Informatology. Journal of the American Society for
Information Science 21(1), 89.
Schrödinger, E. (1992). What is life? With Mind and Matter and Autobiographical Sketches. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge
University Press.
von Baeyer, H.C. (2003). Information: the New Language of Science. London, UK: Weidenfeld & Nicolsen.
Wheeler, J. (1990). Information, Physics, Quantum: The Search for Links. In W. H. Zurek (Ed.), Complexity, Entropy, and
the Physics of Information. Redwood City, CA: Addison-Wesley.
About the Author
Dail Dewitt Doucette
Dail Doucette, a scientist and systems designer, works in the area of interoperability, interconnection of Information Science
and Technology issues between different academic, federal government departments and research disciplines. He has
taught advanced information theories and display systems for the Engineering School at the University of California at Los
Angeles, the American University Center for Technology (Washington, D.C.), and the NATO Science division (Brussels,
Belgium). He was guest lecturer on the information aspects of cultural anthropology at the University of Kyoto (Japan), the
American University in Beirut, the University of Southern California (USC), Cambridge University (United Kingdom), and the
Fulbright Scholarship recipients orientation program for west coast U.S. universities. He assisted in formation of a joint
Masters and Ph.D. program between USC and the University of Teheran (Iran). He was also Executive Vice President of
ComFac, a commercial telecommunications corporation. He is a long-time active member of the American Association for
the Advancement of Science, “Section T” (information, computing, and communications). He was an NGO delegate to the
UNESCO World Summit on the Information Society in Geneva, Switzerland in 2003, and the second session in Tunis, Tuni-
sia, in 2005. He was a member of the committee that founded the Society of Information Display, helped start the World
Future Association, and is assisting in establishing the Science of Information Institute.