tripleC 9(2): 272-277, 2011
ISSN 1726-670X
http://www.triple-c.at
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Editorial to the Special Issue: Towards a New Science of
Information – Proceedings of the Fourth International
Conference on the Foundations of Information Science,
Beijing, August 21–24, 2010
Wolfgang Hofkirchner*, Zong-Rong Li**, Pedro C. Marijuán***, Kang
Ouyang****
* wolfgang.hofkirchner@tuwien.ac.at, Unified Theory of Information (UTI) Research Group, Vienna, Austria
** zrli@hubu.edu.cn, Social Information Science Institute (SISI), Huazhong University of Science and Tech-
nology (HUST), Wuhan, P.R. of China
*** pcmarijuan.iacs@aragon.es, Bioinformation Group, Instituto Aragonés de Ciencias de la Salud,
Zaragoza, Spain
**** kouyang@mail.hust.edu.cn, Social Information Science Institute (SISI), Huazhong University of Science
and Technology (HUST), Wuhan, P.R. of China
In our times, an increasing number of disciplines are dealing with information in very different
ways: from the information society and information technology to communication studies (and rela-
ted subjects like codes, meaning, knowledge, and intelligence), as well as quantum information,
bioinformation, the knowledge economy, network science, computer science and the Internet, to
name but a few. At the same time, an increasing number of scientists in the East and the West
have been engaged with the foundational problems underlying this development, to such an extent
that it seems the time has come to integrate disciplines revolving around information. A new scien-
ce of information can be envisaged that explores the possibilities of establishing a common ground
around the information concept, of constructing a new scientific perspective that connects the diffe-
rent information-related disciplines and provides a new framework for transdisciplinary research.
In the beginning of 2010, Zong-Rong Li, Deputy Director of the Social Information Science Insti-
tute (SISI) at the Huazhong University of Science and Technology (HUST) in Wuhan, who took the
initiative, Wolfgang Hofkirchner, Board Member of the Science of Information Institute (SciI) in
Washington, and Pedro C. Marijuán from the board of Foundations of Information Science (FIS)
agreed to hold the first-ever scientific conference under the motto “Towards a New Science of In-
formation”. SISI took over the role of the host and after just 6 months the conference took place at
the Capital Normal University in Beijing as part of the 2010 Multi-Conference on Advanced Intelli-
gence (MCAI 2010) – together with the Second International Conference on Advanced Intelligence
(ICAI 2010) and the IEEE Natural Language Processing and Knowledge Engineering (NLP-KE'10)
– which was sponsored by the Technical Committee on Artificial Intelligence Theory (TCAIT) of the
Chinese Association for Artificial Intelligence (CAAI), Beijing. As the Fourth International Confer-
ence of the Foundations of Information Science (FIS 2010) it continued the series of FIS Confer-
ences (Madrid 1994, Vienna 1996, Paris 2005).
It was a great opportunity that this conference could take place in China. Generally speaking, the
theoretical study of information as in information science and the practical application of information
technology in China are in a beginning phase when compared with Western developed countries.
However, with China’s rapid development and modernisation, as well as the country’s comprehen-
sive application of information science and technology, theoretical study on foundations of informa-
tion in China is constantly extending and deepening. Scholars from universities and research insti-
tutes in Beijing, Wuhan, Xi’an and other places across China actively hold various seminars and
workshops and compile research journals to research, discuss and communicate basic theories of
tripleC 9(2): 272-277, 2011 273
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
information science, on the basis of which many works (including books and treatises) are pub-
lished. SISI was established in 2006. It is a trans-district, trans-affiliation and trans-discipline or-
ganisation of theoretical study on information science. In recent years, it held some symposiums
and workshops, accepted and granted twenty research projects in the field of social information
science proposed by dozens of domestic scholars under the support of the National Philosophy
and Social Science Innovation Base named “Scientific Progress and Humanistic Spirit” at HUST.
Furthermore, it is also actively concerned with what is termed in China “theoretical informatics and
social information problems.”
Thus the purpose of the conference was to extend the basis of co-operation in the field of infor-
mation society, information science and information technology beyond the networks established
so far and
• to enable the discussion of different concepts, theories and approaches to the information field,
• to facilitate the exchange between informational disciplines concerning different but complemen-
tary tasks, objects of study, and methodologies,
• to network researchers and research institutions as well as knowledge transfer institutions in the
promotion of the new science of information,
• to create a new community of scholars and to promote a new style of scholarship, and
• to advance a new point of view on global problems.
In order to accomplish this the conference differed in many respects from previous enterprises.
Firstly, it was open to a broad range of topics:
1. The Impact of a New Science of Information on Society
2. The Position of Intelligence Science in Information Science
a. Information and Intelligence
b. Intelligence Science as an Engineering Informatics in Information Science
3. The Role of Other Applied Information Science Disciplines (Computer Science, Human Com-
puter Interaction, Computer Mediated Communication, Computer Supported Cooperative
Work, Information and Communication Technologies and Society, Library and Documentation
Science, …)
4. The Basis of a New Science of Information
a. Feasibility of a single generic concept of information
b. Concepts, Principles, and Methodology of a “General Informatics” or “Theoretical In-
formatics”
c. Knowledge Structure of a Unified Theory of Information
5. Philosophy of Information
a. Information Ethics
b. Epistemology (Information and the Scientific Method, …)
c. Ontology of Information
d. Information and Philosophy of Science (Information and the System of Sciences –
Transdisciplinarity – Consilience, …)
6. Science of Information in Real-World Systems
a. Science of Information in Physical and Chemical Systems (Quantum Information, Mo-
lecular Recognition, …)
b. Science of Information in Living Systems (Biosemiotics, Systems Biology, Bioinforma-
tion, …)
c. Science of Information in Human / Social Systems
i. Science of Information in Human Cognition (Mind-Brain Theory, Conscious-
ness, …)
ii. Science of Information in Human Communication (Linguistics, Social Network-
ing, Communication Studies, …)
iii. Science of Information in Human Cooperation (Collective Intelligence, Knowl-
edge Management, Advanced Intelligence, …)
7. Science of the Information Society / Age (Information Society Theory, Internet Research,
Social Informatics, New Media Studies, …)
Secondly, a broad range of organisations participated as co-organisers:
Wolfgang Hofkirchner, Zong-Rong Li, Pedro C. Marijuán, Kang Ouyang
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
• Beijing Institute of Graphical Communication, China
• Bertalanffy Center for the Study of Systems Science, Vienna, Austria
• BITrum Research Group, León, Spain
• Center for Information Policy Research, University of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, USA
• Faculty of Economics and Business, University of Maribor, Slovenia
• Institut für Design Science e.V., Munich, Germany
• Institute for Development of Social Responsibility, Maribor, Slovenia
• International Association for Computing and Philosophy (IACAP)
• International Center for Information Ethics (ICIE), Karlsruhe, Germany
• International Center for Transdisciplinary Research (CIRET), Paris, France
• International Society for Biosemiotic Studies (ISBS)
• Molecular Diversity Preservation International (MDPI), Basel, Switzerland
• Symmetrion, Budapest, Hungary
• Unified Theory of Information (UTI) Research Group, Vienna, Austria
• Washington Evolutionary Systems Society (WESS), Washington, USA
Thirdly, a broad range of scholars, all of them dealing with information studies, but representing
different appoaches, different institutions or networks, project groups, schools, initiatives, and dif-
ferent countries, many of them being the first time together and in contact with FIS, formed the
International Advisory Board of the conference:
• Joseph Brenner (International Center for Transdisciplinary Research, Paris, France)
• Søren Brier (Professor in Semiotics of Information, Cognitive and Communication Science, De-
partment of International Culture and Communication Studies, Centre for Language, Cognition,
and Mentality, Copenhagen Business School, Denmark; Executive Committee, ISBS)
• Luis Emilio Bruni (Associate Professor, Department of Architecture, Design and Media Technol-
ogy, Aalborg University, Denmark; Executive Committee, ISBS)
• Elizabeth A. Buchanan (Director, Center for Information Policy Research, University of Wiscon-
sin, Milwaukee, USA)
• Mark Burgin (Visiting Scholar, Department of Mathematics, University of California, Los Angeles,
USA)
• Rafael Capurro (Director, Steinbeis-Transfer-Institute Information Ethics (STI-IE), Germany;
Founder, ICIE)
• Jerry Chandler (Research Professor, Krasnow Institute for Advanced Studies, George Mason
University, USA; President, WESS)
• John Collier (Professor, Philosophy and Ethics, University of Kwazulu-Natal, Durban, South Af-
rica)
• György Darvas (Senior Research Fellow, Institute for Research Organization, Hungarian Acad-
emy of Sciences, Hungary; Director, Symmetrion)
• Mary Jo Deering (Board of Directors, Science of Information Institute, Washington, USA)
• José María Díaz Nafría (Visiting Professor, University of León, Spain; Coordinator, BITrum Re-
search Group)
• Dail Doucette (Director, Science of Information Institute, Washington, USA)
• Charbel Niño El-Hani (Professor of History, Philosophy, and Biology, Institute of Biology, Federal
University of Bahía, Salvador, Brazil; Executive Committee, ISBS)
• Charles Ess (Visiting Professor, Department of Information and Media Studies, University of
Aarhus, Denmark)
• Peter Fleissner (retired University Professor, Institute of Design and Assessment of Technology,
Vienna University of Technology, Austria; UTI Research Group)
• Luciano Floridi (Research Chair in Philosophy of Information, Department of Philosophy, Univer-
sity of Hertfordshire, UK; President, IACAP)
• Klaus Fuchs-Kittowski (retired Professor, Humboldt University Berlin, Germany)
• Ted Goranson (Sirius Beta, USA)
• Jifa Gu (Professor, Academy of Mathematics and Systems Science, Chinese Academy of Sci-
ences)
• Yukio-Pegio Gunji (Professor, Department of Earth and Planetary Science, Graduate School of
Science, Kobe University, Japan)
• Soraj Hongladarom (Director, Center for Ethics of Science and Technology, Chulalongkorn Uni-
tripleC 9(2): 272-277, 2011 275
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
versity, Thailand)
• Alicia Juarrero (Professor, Prince George’s Community College, USA)
• Kevin G. Kirby (Chair, Department of Computer Science, Northern Kentucky University, USA)
• Klaus Kornwachs (Professor, Philosophy of Technology, BTU Cottbus, Germany)
• Allenna Leonard (President, International Society for the Systems Sciences, Canada)
• Michael Leyton (Professor, DIMACS Center for Discrete Mathematics and Theoretical Computer
Science, Rutgers University, USA)
• An-Shun Li (President, Wuhan Wutong-Rain Culture Development Institute, China)
• Shu-Kun Lin (Molecular Diversity Preservation International, Basel, Switzerland)
• Robert K. Logan (Professor Emeritus, Department of Physics, University of Toronto, Canada)
• Ai-Nai Ma (Professor, Peking University, China)
• Shi-Long Ma (Professor, Beijing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics, China)
• Koichiro Matsuno (Professor em., Nagaoka University of Technology, Japan)
• Dong-Sheng Miao (Professor, Renmin University of China, China)
• Matjaz Mulej (former President, International Federation for Systems Research; Institute for De-
velopment of Social Responsibility, Maribor, Slovenia)
• Basarab Nicolescu (Professor, Babeş-Bolyai University, Cluj-Napoca, Romania; President, CI-
RET)
• Toru Nishigaki (Professor, Graduate School of Interdisciplinary Information Studies, University of
Tokyo, Japan)
• Michel Petitjean (MTi, INSERM, Université Paris Diderot, France)
• Stuart A. Umpleby (Professor, Department of Management, George Washington University,
Washington D.C., USA)
• Günther Witzany (telos, Philosophische Praxis, Bürmoos, Austria)
• Kun Wu (Professor, Xian Jiaotong University, China)
• Tom Ziemke (Professor of Cognitive Science and Cognitive Robotics, Cognition and Interaction
Lab, University of Skövde, Sweden)
• Rainer E. Zimmermann (Professor of Philosophy, University of Applied Sciences Munich, Ger-
many; President, Institut für Design Science, Munich)
Fourthly, 80 authors contributed, 45 from China and 35 from abroad. At the conference we could
count 63 participants, 34 from China and 29 from abroad.
And last not least, at the conference a committee was established to prepare the founding of an
International Society for Information Studies (ISIS) that shall advance global and collaborative stud-
ies in the sciences of information, information technology and information society as a field in its
own right, elaborate common conceptual frameworks and implement them in practice so as to con-
tribute to mastering the challenges of the information age, and hold conferences in the field every
two years. Meanwhile the preparatory committee ended its work and ISIS is to become operative at
the same time when these proceedings are published.
Thus we can conclude that the conference was a success. It formed a milestone in the devel-
opment of the field.
Submissions for the conference underwent a two-step peer review process. Thanks to MDPI
who had already sponsored FIS 2005 in Paris, we were provided with an electronic submission and
review system. In a first step, only abstracts needed to be uploaded. When accepted, the submit-
ters were invited to upload their full papers for review. Each submission was reviewed by two
scholars as a rule. Only in case of doubt a third reviewer was asked. While Wolfgang Hofkirchner
was in charge of non-Chinese submissions, Zong-Rong Li established an 8 scholars review com-
mittee for Chinese submissions.
For the proceedings presented here all authors of accepted papers were invited to resubmit their
papers after the conference. Those who did not seize that opportunity are not included. Several
papers had to undergo severe changes. Anthony Hoffmann from the University of Wisconsin, Mil-
waukee, took the bulk of responsibility in editing the contributions. Finally, we have gathered a
number of 31 papers authored by 41 scholars from nearly all over the world (from West to East:
USA; Spain, Switzerland, Denmark, Germany, Austria, Sweden, Russia; South Africa; China, Ja-
pan).
Wolfgang Hofkirchner, Zong-Rong Li, Pedro C. Marijuán, Kang Ouyang
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
We present them in two groups. The first group of papers contribute to the overall theme of the
conference and concern questions such as the possibility of unifying approaches, philosophy of
information and philosophy of science considerations. The first paper comes from Dail Doucette
who introduced to the current discourse the term of a “science of information”. The paper is about
the future role of such a new transdiscipline in the edifice of scientific disciplines, including social
sciences and humanities and arts. In order to implement a science of information José María Díaz
Nafría and Francisco Salto Alemany propose a transdisciplinary framework aimed at bridging
domains, views, and communities.
John Collier describes the major uses of notions of information in various branches of science
and orders them along a nested hierarchy. Miranda Kajtazi and Darek Haftor build upon a com-
prehensive literature survey of scholarly publications and identify four kinds of information.
A number of contributions try to generalise a certain perspective in order to give an integrative
account of information.
One of the most abstract perspectives is the philosophical perspective. In that context it is inter-
esting to learn that China has a tradition of philosophy of information so far not known abroad.
Guowu Li describes the lifework of Chinese philosopher of information Kun Wu. Wolfgang
Hofkirchner elaborates on a philosophical stance that is requested for a unified theory of informa-
tion.
While Joseph Brenner’s contribution is well founded in philosophy as well, it takes a logical per-
spective that is on the edge of dialectical logic and formal logic. Another logical approach – with a
rather mathematical touch – is pursued by Tian-Qing Qiao.
Mathematician Mark Burgin has developed a general theory of information. His paper discusses
mathematical models that establish relations with physics.
Besides philosophical, logical and mathematical perspectives, there are generalisations from
natural science angles. After presenting, in a first contribution, a critique of philosopher Fred
Dretske’s approach to cognition, Díaz Nafría and Mario Pérez-Montoro resort, in a second contri-
bution, to the physics of observation. Also Marcin J. Schroeder stresses the interaction between
philosophy and science, when reviewing methodologies for a science of information. In particular,
he sees a promising potential in relating to studies of consciousness. Physicist Igor Gurevich
gives a physcial account of information. The paper of Jorge Navarro and Pedro C. Marijuán from
the Bioinformation and Systems Biology Group at the Aragon Institute of Health Sciences
(Zaragoza, Spain) “sees” the world from the point of view of a single cell.
Bin You, educated in bioinformatics, and Zong-Rong Li, working in the field of informatics,
compare systems biology and theoretical informatics – the latter term signifies general theories that
are part of a science of information. They conclude that systems as well as evolutionary thinking
are an essential ingredient of the new science. In the same vein, two Japanese papers from the
Graduate School of Interdisciplinary Information Studies at the University of Tokyo – where Toru
Nishigaki developed an approach called “Fundamental Informatics” – connect to complex thinking.
Wataru Hashimoto tries to redefine the notion of information from a systems perspective, in par-
ticular, from the perspective of autopoiesis, and Yohei Nishida discusses the relationship between
systems theory and semiotics.
Informatics is more than computer science. So it does not come as a surprise that there are
several other authors that start from the paradigm of informatics when heading for the illumination
of the phenomenon of information. Kevin Kirby, James Walden, Rudy Garns and Maureen
Doyle from Northern Kentucky University look upon the pancomputational turn as modern counter-
part of the “great chain of being” originating with Plato. Gerhard Luhn develops an ontology of
information that might have implications for computer science. And Konstantin Kolin stresses the
importance of dealing with the philosophical problems of informatics.
A second paper of Kolin discusses the social aspects of informatics in a broad sense, called
“social informatics” as many Western scholars are accustomed to doing. Vladimir Kinelev high-
lights the intrinsic relationship between information and education in and for the information society.
He sheds a new light on the modern Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs). Another
tripleC 9(2): 272-277, 2011 277
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
important aspect of information is brought to the fore when Luis Emilio Bruni focusses on the
relationship of the development of ICTs and sustainability. Also Peter Fleissner sketches a big
picture of information society, showing the economic dynamics of information processes in society.
These papers demonstrate that the social science approach towards information too is relevant for
the further development of a science of information.
Those contributions that deal with particular questions such as those related to specific logical,
complexity science, technological or social issues make up the second group. Moto Kamiura
analyses abduction as different from deduction and induction articulated by Charles Sanders
Peirce with mathematical tools. Eugene S. Kitamura and Yukio-Pegio Gunji’s paper uses lattice
theory to analyse the behavioural dynamics of characters in literary texts. Lattice theory is also
used for analysing double image illusions by the same authors together with Kohei Sonoda, Iori
Tani and Tomohiro Shirakawa. Jason T. Hewitt uses the rubric of fundamental informatics, a
theory of the commons derived from Michael Hardt and Antonio Negri, and Edwina Taborsky’s
description of the historical transformation of the cultural syntax of museums for humanistic pur-
poses. Bin Yu’s contribution is about the social aspects of computer-mediated communication.
Yun-Feng Xia characterises the communication system of the internet as a self-organising system.
Carlos Aguilar, Lidya Sánchez and Manuel Campos, finally, show how the channel theory of
Jon Barwise and Jerry Seligman can be used to describe how audiences extract information from
audio-visual contents.
About the Authors
Wolfgang Hofkirchner
Board member, Science of Information Institute, Washington, DC, USA; Head, Unified Theory of Information (UTI) Research
Group, Vienna, Austria; President, Bertalanffy Center for the Study of Systems Science, Vienna, Austria
Zong-Rong Li
Deputy Director, Social Information Science Institute (SISI), Huazhong University of Science and Technology (HUST),
Wuhan, P.R. of China
Pedro C. Marijuán
Bioinformation Group, Instituto Aragonés de Ciencias de la Salud, Zaragoza, Spain; Board, Foundations of Information
Science
Kang Ouyang
Director, Social Information Science Institute (SISI), Huazhong University of Science and Technology (HUST), Wuhan, P.R.
of China; Vice-President, HUST, Wuhan, P.R. of China