tripleC 9(2): 593-597, 2011 595
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
apparently unavoidable fragmentation and specialization of the classical disciplines which has ac-
companied technological development.
Some initial answers to this question will be found in the following articles. We consider them still
partial, since the newness of the concept shows little consensus in either the methodology or the
content of the transdiscipline that “ICTs and Society” can be considered to be. This result is not
necessarily a negative one. As noted above, the last thing that is needed today is yet another care-
fully delineated discipline or field of study adding yet another to the multitude already existing. The
following brief comments will indicate the scope of this problem, as background to a critical reading
of the articles themselves.
Hofkirchner, in his contributions to an earlier issue of tripleC (2010), has proposed a taxonomy of
theories about the relation between ICTs and society, and other articles deal with related concepts
of convergence and conceptualization from a science and technologies studies (STS) standpoint.
The current Volume can be seen as a further elaboration of the earlier transdisciplinary conception
of Hofkirchner and his colleagues (2007) of the requirements for a theory of the ICTs and society.
The “logic of transdisciplinarity” (Brenner, 2008) in the Paris school acceptation of transdiscipli-
narity (Nicolescu, 2002), further supports the proposal that the techno-social field of study of ICTs
and Society is a transdiscipline or transdisciplinary, as it also is directed, ultimately, toward a unity
of knowledge. In our view, integration into the study of the concept of transdisciplinarity in these
senses is necessary to raise the debate about the Information Society beyond the limits imposed
by naïve pragmatism and conservative (not to say neo-liberal) ideologies toward a compassionate
science.
The field or topic of transdisciplinarity, in our point of view, includes another philosophical or
meta-philosophical dimension which is by no means, however, to be considered as irrelevant to the
practical goals of this Journal, namely Cognition-Communication-Cooperation for a Global Sustain-
able Information Society. Criticisms of simplistic approaches are necessary, but they do not com-
pletely answer the question of why they are made and whether they will continue to be made. An-
other way of stating the problem is a need for the concomitant perspectives of sociology and evolu-
tionary psychology, without becoming lost in a welter of disciplinary detail. Perhaps the ‘disciplinary’
term that would be most appropriate to our conception of transdisciplinarity is that it is a ‘meta-
ethical’ approach, in which the moral consequences of the evolving ICTs are maintained in the
foreground of the analysis.
In one definition of transdisciplinarity (Raffl, 2009): Transdisciplinarity is fostered as a new mode
in research, allowing diverse groups of stakeholders, like politicians, practitioners or entrepreneurs
to participate in research and development. Such an approach bears the risk, however, of not only
being research with stakeholders, but for them and thus creating results in favor of the industry. It is
the broader transdisciplinary approach, in the view of the Editors, which is illustrated in different
ways in the Articles in this Special Issue. We may then say, logically, “ICTs and Society” is a trans-
discipline, the academic field to meet the challenges of the information society, without falling into
circularity.
4. Comments on Specific Articles in this Volume
In this Special Issue the concepts of both transdisciplinarity and transdiscipline have received a
very varied treatment, which in a sense is entirely appropriate. The relation between ICTs-and-
Society is viewed realistically, in both its positive and less positive aspects. As also seen in the
contribution by DePaoli in this issue, transdisciplinarity rather than interdisciplinarity, in which sepa-
ration between disciplines is largely maintained, should be the preferred paradigm for future re-
search.
The selected, and in this special issue collected, contributions are in line with this understanding
of transdisciplinarity. Transdiscplinarity is something distinct from interdisciplinarity in two respects:
first, as regards the scientific status, i.e. not just a “combination of existing disciplines – in the case
of “ICT and society” a mere combination of technology and social science –, but a transgression of
the traditional borders of the participating disciplines and thereby a transformation of the disciplines