tripleC 9(2): 247-271, 2011 261
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
odd too that whilst neoliberalism was supposedly remaking the world in the singular image of An-
glo-American capitalism, the number of regulatory institutions within just our field alone exploded
worldwide, from something like 14 in 1990 to 90 a decade later and around 150 or so today. Regu-
lators translate the general ‘logics’ of markets, technology and rule-making in specialized domains
into the specific rules and procedures that compose the local political economy to which they are
being adapted, as Saskia Sassen (2006) puts it. There’s a lot of ‘translation’ work that goes on in
this and I think it belies the overly generic notions implied by the rhetoric of neoliberalism.
And besides, just as neoliberalism was seen to be triumphant circa 2000, what happened? A
decade of crises, that’s what, starting with the collapse of the dot.com bubble in 2000 and instability
ever since, coming to a head once again since the Global Financial Crisis of 2007/8ff. And unlike
what David Harvey says, the crisis didn’t start on the margins, or get displaced there, but in the
core and wreaked its havoc in Europe and the U.S.
So Marx should be back in light of Global Financial Crisis. Indeed, the instabilities of capitalism
are visible all around us and sharp jolts and crisis tendencies emerge one day, disappear the next,
and reassert themselves the day after that. This is crazy instability, precarity. However, the under-
lying universalist notion that many interpret as leading to economic, social and cultural homoge-
neity does not follow. This is another one of the key points that Garnham (2011) makes when he
likewise advises that we reject notions that the media are bound up with forces of cultural ho-
mogenization, cultural imperialism, etc.
I agree, and think it is important to remember the other side of Marx, who stated that, in the face
of the tumultuous, disruptive dynamism of capitalism, “all that is solid melts into air”, by which he
meant the break down of traditional societies and ossified ways of life and thinking. The upshot of
that, however, is not the superimposition of a higher level of homogenous integration (again, contra
what notions of ideology often suggest) but greater levels of sociological differentiation, as sociolo-
gists from Tarde, to Parsons, to Habermas, Giddens, Bauman and many others in between have
insisted upon. And that is mirrored in the domain of media and ICTs because it seems to me what
we are seeing is not total integration and convergence under an ever smaller number of corporate
rulers, but simultaneously and paradoxically, both consolidation in some dimensions, generally
those with general utility like functions (Google, Facebook, etc.) and where economies of scale (but
not scope) are strong, ie. integration between TV and film, but not TV, film and Carriers/Internet, to
wit the misfortunes/calamities of AOL Time Warner, News Corp/MySpace, Vivendi Universal, etc.
(with exception of recent Comcast NBC-Universal merger). Garnham in his school marmy way is
admonishing us to understand this reality and seems to believe that until we reject our dogmatic
ways, we won’t even be able to see things clearly, let alone understand them. I have some sympa-
thy but . . . .
Finally, I do not agree with you that alienation is a unique pathology of capitalism. Of course, it
was the task of Critical Theory, in particular Eric Fromm (1961) and Herbert Marcuse (1964) to lay
out a theory of alienation combining Freud with Marx to understand alienation under capitalism.
That bore some fruit, but try raising it with most feminists today. It ain’t gonna go anywhere, as far
as I know. The bottom line on this for me is that alienation is not a capitalist problem, but an exi-
stential one. Here, Marx does not offer much of value. We must read our Soren Kierkegaard, J. P.
Satre, Lu Xun, and Albert Camus for insights on that.
That, in my view, is not an indictment of Marx, but rather a marker of the scope and limits of his
thoughts. I hope that the above ideas clearly indicate that I am no turn-coat enemy of Marx and
some of the many important thinkers who have translated his ideas into central pillars in the Critical
Marxian Approach to the Political Economy of Media and Communication. I continue to be inter-
ested in this work and draw on it often and extensively, while still hoping that I may make some
modest contributions to it. However, I do not believe that such an approach holds the magic key to
understanding our times, and in fact believe that adhering too closely to a Marxian view of Political
Economy will only impoverish us.
Well, Christian, this has really gotten out of hand. It’s dragged up a whole ton of ideas that I’ve
been thinking about for a long time now. There’s obviously much more to say, but I think I’ll leave it