tripleC 9(2): 247-271, 2011
ISSN 1726-670X
http://www.triple-c.at
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Critical Media and Communication Studies Today. A Con-
versation
Christian Fuchs
1
and Dwayne Winseck
2
1
Uppsala University, Department of Informatics and Media, Sweden. christian.fuchs@im.uu.se,
http://fuchs.uti.at
2
Carleton University, School of Journalism and Communication + Institute of Political Economy, Canada.
dwayne_winseck@carleton.ca
Abstract: This article documents a conversation between us that was first published in parallel on our two blogs
http://dwmw.wordpress.com and http://fuchs.uti.at/blog. The conversation deals with our assessments of the status of Criti-
cal Media and Communication Studies today. We discuss the work of Dallas Smythe, how to study and assess Google,
research dimensions of Critical Political Economy of the Media, how important each of these dimensions should be, the role
of ideology critique for Critical Political Economy of the Media, the commonalities and differences between Political Econo-
mies of the Media and Critical Political Economy of the Media/Critique of the Political Economy of the Media, the role of Karl
Marx for Political Economies of the Media, Nicholas Garnham's recent comments on the field of Critical Political Economy of
the Media, neoliberalism and capitalist crisis as contexts for Political Economies of the Media. Comments are very welcome
on our blogs, URLs to the specific blog postings can be found in the article sections.
Keywords: Keyword, keyword, keyword, keyword, keyword, keyword, keyword, keyword, keyword, keyword, keyword,
keyword, keyword, keyword, keyword, keyword, keyword, keyword, keyword
Introduction
http://fuchs.uti.at/596/
http://dwmw.wordpress.com/2011/08/06/critical-media-and-communication-studies-today-a-
conversation-between-dwayne-winseck-and-christian-fuchs-part-1/
We met for the first time at the International Association of Media and Communication Researchers
(IAMCR) in Istanbul, Turkey in July. We already knew each other through some collaboration in
one another’s projects and our knowledge of one another’s work.
Following the conference, we exchanged some emails and Christian put Dwayne in contact with
two authors of an excellent paper at the conference, Peter Jakobsson and Fredrik Stiernstedt, two
doctoral candidates at Södertörns University in Sweden. Having recently moved to Uppsala Uni-
versity in Sweden, Christian had organized a speakers’ symposium where Peter and Frederik re-
cently gave a talk.
Our discussion turned into a bigger conversation about different political economies of com-
munication, media and the Internet. Christian, as many readers may know, is one of the foremost
Marxist critical communication and media scholars today. If ever there was a case to demonstrate
the decisive importance of Marxist analysis today, he provides it – in spades. Marx, as he says, is
back, and not a moment too soon.
Dwayne, on the other, is no stranger to Marxian Political Economy, but argues that we must
draw from a wider range of sources than the Marxian pantheon. Other notions held dearly must be
handled with greater precision – i.e. consolidation within the Telecom-Media-Internet (TMI) in-
dustries – and more attention given to the specificity of market processes and forces, evidence and
the strategies of particular firms. Other notions need to be refined drastically or abandoned, i.e.
248 Christian Fuchs and Dwayne Winseck
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
ideology. The fact that media, information and cultural goods are fundamentally different – i.e. they
are immaterial commodities – than other goods should also be kept front and centre.
After stitching the conversation together and adding a few links here and there to some of the
people and sources we refer to, we thought it might be a good idea to post the conversation on
each of our blogs (Christian’s blog, Dwayne’s blog). As the wreckage of the global financial crisis
(2007/8ff) continues to unfold and the information sectors – as industries, sets of technological
capabilities, and vehicles of pleasure and for increasing the range of market forces – continue to be
in a heightened state of flux, the ideas raised in debates over what constitutes a critical political
economy approach to the field are arguably more important than ever. The main lines of our con-
versation follow:
Discussion Turn 1 (Dwayne Winseck): "A conversation about different political ec-
onomies of communication, media and the Internet..."
http://dwmw.wordpress.com/2011/08/06/critical-media-and-communication-studies-today-a-
conversation-between-dwayne-winseck-and-christian-fuchs-part-1/
http://fuchs.uti.at/596/
Christian, as always I hope that you’re well.
I was impressed by the work of Peter Jakobsson and Fredrik Stiernstedt on data centres (Jakob-
sson and Stiernstedt 2011a). It is a nice crystallization of geography, materiality, data and and ‘cy-
berspace’. The recent acknowledgement by Microsoft that neither it nor any other major US-based
ICT/ Internet company – think Amazon, Apple, Google, Facebook, to name just a few – are beyond
the reach of the US Patriot Act shows the global reach of US national security power, but also the
importance of place. Jakobsson and Stiernstaedt (2011a) illustrated the ties between security, the
physicality and locations of ‘cyberspace’, even the geological underpinning of data centres, by ex-
amining, among other things, how Google is building a new data centre in Finland, with local
government support through tax abatements and other enticements, out of the hulk of a retrofitted
Cold War bunker buried deep in the ground. Proximity to Russia, where Internet markets are
currently dominated by two Russian behemoths – Yandex and VKontakte – also means that the
bunker-cum-secure-data centre could serve as a launchpad for Google’s future forays into Russia
as well.
Peter and Fredrik’s paper certainly deserved the Dallas Smythe prize for best Graduate Student
paper.
Cheers, Dwayne
Discussion Turn 2 (Christian Fuchs): "The circumstance that the IAMCR has a Dallas
Smythe and a Herbert Schiller award brings up the question of what Critical Me-
dia and Communication Studies are all about today..."
http://fuchs.uti.at/596/
http://dwmw.wordpress.com/2011/08/06/critical-media-and-communication-studies-today-a-
conversation-between-dwayne-winseck-and-christian-fuchs-part-1/
Hi Dwayne.
Fredrik and Peter’s paper is very good. Indeed, all of their papers that I have read are.
The circumstance that the IAMCR has a Dallas Smythe and a Herbert Schiller award brings up
the question of what Critical Media and Communication Studies are all about today, how important
it is to be critical, what it means to be critical and what the role of Marx’s works is for Critical Media
tripleC 9(2): 247-271, 2011 249
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
and Communication Studies, i.e. what the role class and the critique of capitalism should play in
this field.
Let’s exchange some thoughts on these questions.
Best wishes, Christian
Discussion Turn 3 (Dwayne Winseck): "I do not believe that Critical Political Economy
is synonymous with Marxist Political Economy...".
http://dwmw.wordpress.com/2011/08/06/critical-media-and-communication-studies-today-a-
conversation-between-dwayne-winseck-and-christian-fuchs-part-1/
http://fuchs.uti.at/596/
Thanks a bunch for Peter and Fredrik’s email addresses.
I also just read their abstract for the talk they gave at media@UU (Jakobsson and Stiernstedt
2011b). That paper also looks impressive. I like the way they capture the materiality and sociality of
media, and how they see certain elements of media — technology, commodities, juridical forms —
being periodically unstable, then forming recurring institutional patterns. They seem to have a deft
touch.
Smythe’s (1977, 1981) concept of the audience commodity (here’s one example of its recent use
(Napoli 2008), Christian’s own use of this concept and the introduction of the notion of the Internet
prosumer commodity is documented here (Fuchs 2010)), and more importantly, his injunction that
communication and media studies were not materialist enough – i.e. they didn’t study the com-
munication and media as industries, markets, and linchpins in the capitalist economy overall – are
maybe even more valuable now then when Smythe began to unfold them 40-50 years ago.
Other ideas of his, however, can be obstacles, and a commodity analysis, while essential, only
goes so far. It is precisely the tension between the real fact that communication and media are
essential to capitalist economies – and to all command, control and decision-making structures –
versus the fact that they don’t conform to the standards of normal economics at all that makes
them so interesting. I mean, they produce immaterial things, from immaterial labour, for uncertain
markets, fickle tastes, people just being people.
The latter point brings me to the idea that the belief that media and communication can be re-
duced to instruments of domination – a stance all-too-evident in the work of Smythe, Schiller and
too many to name other political economists who have carried the ‘critical Marxist’ banner — has
far too often obliterated the intimate links of communication and media to pleasure and joy. One-
sided portraits of domination, in my view, also obscure gradations in the severity of pain, suffering
and lack of recognition suffered by marginal and otherwise disenfranchised groups (Honneth 1995)
– a set of classes of people that is, as you well know, becoming larger and larger.
Smythe and this kind of political economy, I believe, offers much, and I won’t part way for a mo-
ment with what I understand critical political economy to be. However, I do not believe that critical
political economy is synonymous with Marxist political economy. To think otherwise, I believe, con-
strains our vision too much and leaves a shallow well from which to drink.
A good concrete example is the question of how to study Google. Jarvis (2009) (in What Would
Google Do?) reveres Google, while Vaidhyanathan (2011) (in Googlization of Everything) reviles it,
but in so doing misses the positive generativity that Google creates: e.g. efficient searching, linking,
indexing, navigability, storage, a digital Alexandria, etc. These are without a doubt immensely valu-
able resources conjured up out of our resources and we need to make sense of them. In simple
terms, Google provides without a doubt a significant spur to research, development, innovation
and, undoubtedly, military security. Fredrik and Peter (Jakobsson and Stiernstedt 2011a) grasp this
kind of subtler, textured interplay between power, place and pleasure in interesting ways.
Long weekend here, and friends from out of town, so should be enjoyable. Time to go. Hope you
enjoy yours.
250 Christian Fuchs and Dwayne Winseck
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Cheers, Dwayne
Discussion Turn 4 (Christian Fuchs): "Smythe reminds us of the need to engage with
Marx and the critique of capitalism when we analyse the media today..."
http://fuchs.uti.at/596/
http://dwmw.wordpress.com/2011/08/06/critical-media-and-communication-studies-today-a-
conversation-between-dwayne-winseck-and-christian-fuchs-part-1/
Hello Dwayne,
No doubt, Fredrik and Peter are very talented writers. You will like their papers (e.g. Jakobsson
and Stiernstedt 2011a, 2011b).
The good thing about the awards at IAMCR is that they remind us of the need for Critical Media
and Communication Studies and the relevance of Smythe’s, Schiller’s (and other scholars’) works
today.
The great thing about Smythe is that for him the Political Economy of the Media was Marxist Po-
litical Economy, so he was clear on the need to abolish capitalism and class and to analyse media
communication in the context of class. I think we need much of this insight today. On the one hand
Smythe was opposed to ideology critique, which is problematic. At the same time he spoke of the
consciousness industry, so there was some ideology critique in his own work. He did not focus
extensively on alternative media, but there are such elements in his works, like the alternative
broadcasting system he suggested to the Chinese (pretty much the same idea like Brecht and En-
zensberger), documented in the paper “After Bicycles, What?” (Smythe 1994). So I do think that
there is a lot in Smythe’s works to engage with today. Dallas Smythe reminds us of the need to be
critical and to think about class when studying the media.
Today we need to go somewhat beyond Smythe and see more of the positive potentials of me-
dia. However, if we stress the positive potentials too much, then we end up with the Cultural Stud-
ies celebration of commodity culture, so we have to be careful and also take a look at the political
economy of positive and negative potentials, the distribution of resources between them, etc. Alter-
native forms of communication that transcend market, capitalism and ideology are not impossible,
but more likely to be precarious, tend to have less visibility, resources, people etc. Political action is
needed in order to channel resources towards alternative media so that that they become more \
powerful, less precarious, etc.
Smythe reminds us of the need to engage with Marx and the critique of capitalism when we ana-
lyse the media today. After the rise of neoliberalism, postmodernism and the cultural turn, it has
since the 1980s become ever more uncommon to engage with Marx. The engagement with Marx
and Marxism has increasingly been replaced in universities. And by saying Marx, I do not mean the
fetishization of Marx as a person or politician, but I do mean the importance of engaging with the
concepts of class and capitalism. Ironically, while culturalists claimed that class and Marx are dead
and that we need to focus on identity politics, local reforms, etc., the antagonisms between capital
and the proletariat was becoming ever more intense (the rise of precarious labour, the increase of
unemployment, the explosion of socio-economic inequality, the differences between profits and
wages, etc.). The rise of the movement for democratic globalization showed that it is a movement
galvanizing around the topic of class. In the 1980s and 1990s new social movements were quite
separated around topics like gender, racism, peace, nature, etc. – the rise of neoliberalism resulted
since the late 1990s in a movement of movements (the anti-corporate movement/movement for
democratic globalization), class issues have been binding all the other issues together in this
movement. The result of the cumulating antagonisms of capitalism was the new global economic
crisis, which has shown the importance of the economy, class and capitalism and has brought back
an interest in Marx. Marx (i.e. the analysis of class and capitalism) was always important, but now
we are in a time in which his work has regained much of its salience.
tripleC 9(2): 247-271, 2011 251
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Enjoy the weekend. Best wishes, Christian
Discussion Turn 5 (Dwayne Winseck): "Google produces a vast range of 'public goods'
[...] Focusing on what people do with technologies, not to celebrate, but to
study the dialectic between exploitation and joy, is more compelling to me than
focusing on consciousness and ideology..."
http://dwmw.wordpress.com/2011/08/06/critical-media-and-communication-studies-today-a-
conversation-between-dwayne-winseck-and-christian-fuchs-part-2/
http://fuchs.uti.at/600/
Hi Christian,
If one thinks of Google as a general public utility (or performing such public utility like functions
in search, linking, indexing, creating the navigable web), although of course as a private company,
private in the sense that it is the extension of a few men (Brin, Page, Schmidt, through their control-
ling ownership stake) and private venture capital markets, then Google produces a vast range of
“public goods” — information itself is a public good, so that Google does this is not so surprising.
This is what I always appreciated about heterodox and critical Marxian Political Economies of
communication: namely, that they did not only look at commodities and exchange within markets,
but those things in life – public goods, common sense, gifts, free time, the sociality of everyday life
– that give value to what it means to be human.
Vaidhyanathan’s Googlization of Everything (2011), by and large, only gives a negative critique
of Google. Moreover, the argument is mostly rhetorical rather than empirically-based and well theo-
rized, i.e. it often appears to be more like random thoughts strung together over the course of a
year about Google than a systematic critique of the political economy of Google. He hardly dis-
cusses what Google generates in terms of public goods, under private control of course, although
he does lay out his grand ‘public goods’ proposal in the last chapter.
I heard the really smart American critical legal scholar Pamela Samuelson (2011) speak about
the Google Book Settlement Agreement (BSA) last year (and a podcast of her views here). She
raved about the audacity of the project and what it meant in terms of getting more books in print,
faster, more easily accessible and affordable than ever at a time when the public sector – universi-
ties in particular, especially as the situation in the UK shows – is in crisis, being pared back and
forced to tighten the purse in light of the evaporation of public funds on account of the Global Fi-
nancial Crisis, 2007/8ff. The one big problem in all this is that Google’s Book Settlement Agree-
ment essentially let Google rewrite the terms of trade and copyright law for the US in the digital
media age. Quite a coup if you could get it, eh? Funny thing is that, in this case what was good for
Google was in fact good for us, if we measured things solely in terms of being able to deliver the
goods while ignoring the consequences for the rule of law. This would be technocracy, and it is this
that Siva (Vaidhyanathan 2011) rightfully and powerful draws out for critique. Sure, it delivers the
goods, but does democracy and rule of law by citizens take a beating as a result?
While these elements are core to Vaidhyanathan’s (2011) discourse on Google, I can’t help but
feel that it all doesn’t stack up as well as it should. The economic and legal treatment is not up to
the standards set by his earlier work.
So, back to the main point regarding critical theory, Marxian Political Economy, and then a few
more words about Smythe. I like Marcuse because I think he always demonstrated the dialectic
between domination and liberation. The ultimate triumph of instrumental reason (capital, calcula-
bility, hierarchy, organization, control) in Marcuse’s work is always kept at bay by hopes for pleas-
ure, eros, love, play, aesthetic appreciation, etc. Peter and Fredrik’s papers remind me of this sen-
sibility (see Marcuse’s Eros and Civilization 1955). Their use of the Italian autonomist Marxist stuff
impressed me alot, although I don’t know enough about this perspective as I probably should.
252 Christian Fuchs and Dwayne Winseck
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
I’m a big fan of Smythe, as I said yesterday. I called him at home one day in 1988, and while he
was outside washing the car he took my call and we talked about the allocation of spectrum and
orbital slots for satellites as part of my master’s thesis for over an hour. He was an economist, al-
beit a heterodox one, maybe even a Marxian one, and his insistence on thinking about the com-
munication and media as industries was an important injunction. So too was his and Schiller’s in-
sistence that these industries are part of the C3I assemblage, or the Military Information Media
Entertainment (MIME) complex as some people now refer to it (see der Derian (2009) and here
(Geer Jr. 2011)).
However, I also think his ideas about dependency theory, nation, communication policy, China,
consciousness and many other things are very problematic. The Smythe and Schiller view of com-
munication and consciousness is classic, one-sided Marxism: “those who own the means of pro-
duction also own the means of mental production”. Well, yes, and no. His dim view of the capacity
of the audience commodity to do much meaningful with either media or their lives was miserable,
and stupor inducing.
One of the real advances of the Frankfurt School three or four decades before them was to sur-
pass this ham-fisted notion of ideology and the control of consciousness. The fact that Smythe,
Schiller and many other Critical Marxian Political Economy types still make it the centrepiece of
their analysis (or at least their tacit assumptions) is an embarrassment to the standards of what we
need to know, and indeed what many other fields do know about learning, social life, being, and
mind.
Focusing on what people do with technologies, not to celebrate, but to study the dialectic be-
tween exploitation and joy is more compelling to me than focusing on consciousness and ideology.
I think it is also implicit in the dialectic that Marcuse sets up between instrumental reason and
pleasure, etc.
And you, what do you think?
Thanks and cheers, Dwayne
Discussion Turn 6 (Christian Fuchs): "We need a synthesis of everything that is on
the 'left' side of the spectrum in Media and Communication Studies. [...] Google
has created the real conditions of its own transcendence..."
http://fuchs.uti.at/600/
http://dwmw.wordpress.com/2011/08/06/critical-media-and-communication-studies-today-a-
conversation-between-dwayne-winseck-and-christian-fuchs-part-2/
Hello Dwayne. Thank you for sharing your thoughts.
I can subscribe to a lot of what you are saying. My personal thought is probably most influenced
by Hegel, Marx and Marcuse. What I think we need is a synthesis of everything that is on the “left”
side of the spectrum in Media and Communication Studies. This entails a synthesis of the critique
of media as:
a) capital accumulation organizations,
b) advertising institutions,
c) ideology producers and disseminators, and a connection to
d) alternative media, their potentials and limits +
e) political struggles and their relations to the media +
f) media and their use in the context of domination and liberation.
I think that’s a broad spectrum. I try to set this out in a more systematic scheme in chapters 3+4
of “Foundations of Critical Media and Information Studies” (Fuchs 2011a).
tripleC 9(2): 247-271, 2011 253
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Most critical media scholars focus just on one dimension. I think we need a combination of
many. That being said, I think we need a focus on the radical critique of capitalism, and thereby
take inspiration from Marx. And I do think that Cultural Studies after Raymond Williams and E.P.
Thompson (who knew Marx very well), starting with Stuart Hall, has ever more given up the critique
of capitalism. Therefore I would make early Cultural Studies part of the approaches that I want to
bring together, but not automatically all contemporary Cultural Studies (which are to a certain ex-
tent too far away from a critique of capitalism), only Critical Cultural Studies. If one wants to focus
on pleasure+media, then I think Marcuse’s (1955) interpretation of Freud’s pleasure principle is a
good place to start and one can think about how this relates to the media. This is especially import-
ant for discussions about the relation of pleasure/play and labour (digital play labour/playbour) that
we find today in relation to discussions about digital labour (for an application of Marcuse’s pleas-
ure principle for analysing Facebook playbour, see a recent paper by me here (Fuchs 2011b). Mar-
cuse’s principle of pleasure was a radical concept opposed to capitalism. In contrast, in much cele-
bratory Cultural Studies, there is a simplistic notion of pleasure related to the concept of the active,
creative audience.
So one has to be careful not to celebrate commodity culture. The Autonomist Marxist tradition is
really interesting, I try also to draw on it, but one has to criticize their fetishization of the multitude.
They see struggles automatically emerging everywhere. It is a kind of determinism of the subject.
Nonetheless the class concept of Hardt and Negri (2000, 2004) goes in the right direction can help
us to conceptualize media+class (see a book I wrote together with a colleague about Negri’s phi-
losophy here (Fuchs and Zimmermann 2009).
It is also crucial to theorize how knowledge labour relates to class. Almost all approaches are
failures, either conceiving of knowledge work as defining a new dominant class or new proletariat.
The positive aspect of Italian Autonomist Marxist theory is that it allows us to conceive of non-wage
labour (like unemployment, house work, use of corporate Internet platforms, etc) as a form of ex-
ploitation and as part of class antagonism. But Italian Autonomist Marxist theory is like Cultural
Studies to a certain extent. That is, it can be a deterministic and reductionist approach, it fetishizes
the subject, sees the multitude as always and automatically revolting, it generalizes Italian experi-
ences of struggles incorrectly to the whole world, it completely ignores ideology (there is no space
of ideology critique in this theory).
The ignorance of ideology and ideology critique partly stems from the non-engagement with
Hegel because there is no space for the concept of the dialectic of essence and existence (Hegel
1812, 1874) in Autonomist Marxism. At the same time, to a certain extent Hardt and Negri are more
Hegelian than they think they are (see chapter 8 in my book “Foundations of Critical Media and
Information Studies” (Fuchs 2011a)).
I do think that ideology critique, critique of capital accumulation models, media concentration, al-
ternative media studies, social movement media studies, critical theory/philosophy of the media,
etc. has to be combined and guided by Marxist theory. I feel that most single critical approaches
(like Smythe, Frankfurt School, alternative media theory, Garnham, etc.) are not encompassing
enough and that we now need a new critical synthesis. That’s one of my basic tasks . . .
I fully agree that Google produces a lot of things that are nearly public. It is like when Lenin
spoke about central banks that are private, but which assume quasi-public status. The thing one
needs to do is to expropriate Google and use it as a good foundation for a public Internet. In a pa-
per forthcoming in Fast Capitalism (see the full paper here (Fuchs 2011c)), I try to grasp the dialec-
tic of Google in terms of a contradiction between networked productive forces and class relations of
media production.
Many popular science accounts of Google are celebratory, whereas a lot of social science ana-
lyses point out the dangers of the company. One should go beyond one-sided assessments of
Google and think dialectically: Google is at the same time the best and the worst that has ever
happened on the Internet. Google is evil like the figure of Satan and good like the figure of God. It
is the dialectical Good Evil.
254 Christian Fuchs and Dwayne Winseck
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Google is part of the best Internet practices because it services can enhance and support the
everyday life of humans. It can help us to find and organize information, to access public informa-
tion, to communicate and co-operate with others. Google has the potential to greatly advance the
cognition, communication and co-operation capabilities of humans in society. It is a manifestation
of the productive and socializing forces of the Internet.
The problem is not the technologies provided by Google, but the capitalist relations of produc-
tion, in which these technologies are organized. The problem is that to provide these services
Google necessarily has to exploit users and to engage in the surveillance and commodification of
user-oriented data. This is the foundation – the internal core in its commodity form, if you will –
upon which Google rests. Marx spoke in this context of the antagonism of the productive forces
and the relations of production. Google is a prototypical example for the antagonisms between
networked productive forces and capitalist relations of production of the information economy.
Google has created the real conditions of its own transcendence. It is a mistake to argue that
Google should be dissolved or to say that alternatives to Google are needed or to say that its ser-
vices are a danger to humanity. Rather, Google would loose its antagonistic character if it were
expropriated and transformed into a public, non-profit, non-commercial organization that serves the
common good.
I think there is indeed a dialectic of exploitation and joy today, but an unequal one, in which joy
becomes the new principle of exploitation (play labour, playbour). So joy tends to become sub-
sumed under capital accumulation as a new management strategy and it becomes more difficult to
resist. Certainly not impossible, but joy and play are antagonistically entangled with capital accu-
mulation. My personal take is that political movements are the only way for making society more
democratic and that struggles for democratic media must be connected to larger struggles in soci-
ety that struggle against the commodification of the commons. At the same time, right-wing extrem-
ism is on the rise as effect of the crisis (especially in Europe, see Norway etc. now).
So much for today.
Best wishes, Christian
Discussion Turn 7 (Dwayne Winseck): "The critique of Political Economies of Com-
munication that Nicholas Garnham offers is no holds barred..."
http://dwmw.wordpress.com/2011/08/06/critical-media-and-communication-studies-today-a-
conversation-between-dwayne-winseck-and-christian-fuchs-part-3/
http://fuchs.uti.at/602/
Christian, fascinating response to our on-going riposte here. Must say I enjoy it very much, and am
learning a lot too.
I agree that we are on the same page on a lot of things. Thanks also for helping me recall some
things about Marcuse by referring to his links to Freud’s notion of pleasure (Marcuse 1955). I have
not read this material for some time and you’ve inspired me to jump back into it. Same with respect
to the Italian Autonomist Marxists, and I think I’m in agreement here with you about how that school
turns every act of the subject into a potentially revolutionary one. Perhaps that’s pleasing to the
‘digerati’ and young guys hanging out around their Internet connections all the time, but it too easily
celebrates ‘net culture’ and is not the basis for anything politically effective.
I’m fascinated too by your reference to Lenin and the idea of banks fulfilling central public func-
tions. This is not a Leninist idea, as you well know, but rather a principle of modern banking from
the creation of the Bank of England (founded in 1694 but only nationalized in 1946) and an abso-
lute mainstay in John Maynard Keynes ideas. Of course, it is also anathema to ultra conservative
economists. Do you have the Lenin source on this point ready-to-hand? Anyway, this broad ‘infra-
structural background concept of public goods’ works well with understanding the idea that search
tripleC 9(2): 247-271, 2011 255
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
engines (Google), Social Network Companies (Facebook), ISPs, etc. provide no small range of
generalized public utility like functions.
Now here’s where the differences between us, I think, start to emerge. You make a long list of
things that need to be combined to serve as an encompassing approach for all those on the left of
communication and media studies. I’m not sure that can be accomplished, nor am I confident that
striving to achieve such a thing is either viable or desirable. We must be able to talk but not neces-
sarily expect that we’re going to agree, and not just among those who self-identify with the left but
anyone who has a voice in the things that we are talking about.
In the list of substantive areas that you suggest we should study, I would put ideology either off
the list or much further down the list to the point that it plays a bit role in things. Instead, I would
focus on ‘users’, what they do, say, think, without recourse to ideology and it’s typical functionalist
‘glue like’ notions. Ideology is dead, like Marcuse said.
That’s maybe too strong, but just to get the point out crisply. Have you seen Nicholas Garn-
ham’s (2011) new piece in the book by Wasko, Murdock, Sousa (eds): Handbook on the Political
Economy of Communication? I’m only half way done, but he is scathing about the orthodoxy of
what passes as PEC (Political Economy of Communication), bitingly saying that adherents have
“forgotten nothing, and learnt nothing”. The way he puts his case is way too strong, but throughout
the paper he goes through a list of grievances that I have some sympathy for (Garnham 2011):
(1) that Marxian analysis are disconnected from reality and empirical analysis;
(2) that a fundamental aspect of this reality is the communication, information and cultural goods
are immaterial and thus not like ‘normal commodities’ and that this has enormous implications
for how markets are structured and work, the hits and miss character of media economies, me-
dia labour, policy, etc.;
(3) that Marxian ideology and political projects are trumped up as political economic analysis, when
they are not, and moreover likely to be all the more ineffectual because of their disconnection
from an intimate understanding of the telecom-media-Internet industries that they are purport-
edly analyzing;
(4) that dead notions — ideology, cultural imperialism, cultural homogenization, etc. – should be
given up and given a decent funeral;
(5) that Marxist political economy has to recognize that it is far from the only game in town and
open itself up to more open-ended discussions with other schools of thought.
The critique of PEC that Garnham offers is no holds barred. I would part way with him in tone,
and subsequently on some of the substantive claims that he makes. Here’s an even bigger issue:
Capitalism. I’m all for many of the things that you put on the research agenda, so please don’t get
me wrong, but I worry that focusing on such a large whole, and to putting one’s political priorities at
the front end of the process of inquiry risks obscuring too much empirical detail. I think Zygmunt
Bauman (2000) and Luc Botanski (2011) represent my position well when they critique the idea
that sociology today can take the ‘whole’ as its starting point. The fragmentation of societies, social
institutions, individual life trajectories/biographies, etc. is key to understanding the complexity and
instability that not only defines capitalism but the texture, fabric, structure and feel of our everyday
lives.
This last point is way to big to pursue any further here for now. Besides, I have to go wash the
car and play hockey.
Cheers, Dwayne
Discussion Turn 8 (Christian Fuchs): "The rise of social media as a new capital accu-
mulation model was accompanied by a social media ideology..."
http://fuchs.uti.at/602/
256 Christian Fuchs and Dwayne Winseck
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
http://dwmw.wordpress.com/2011/08/06/critical-media-and-communication-studies-today-a-
conversation-between-dwayne-winseck-and-christian-fuchs-part-3/
Dear Dwayne,
Thank you for the discussion, I enjoy it very much.
I’ve attached my paper here, A Contribution to the Critique of the Political Economy of Google; it
should be online at Fast Capitalism’s site soon (Fuchs 2011c). Any comments are very welcome.
The question, which critical approaches and theories we employ or combine, is also a question
about our own work because we are influenced by certain traditions, thinkers, approaches and
draw on them for creating new critical knowledge. It is also mainly about the question, which topics
we find worth studying and how we study them. I do think that we need to bring together the critical
analysis of capital accumulation (including the role of advertising), ideology, audiences/users and
alternatives/struggles when we study media communication critically. I have no reasons to privilege
one of these dimensions of study, why should one? They are all important.
I do not see your point about why you find studying ideology least important. You were quite
critical of Dallas Smythe in one of your previous contributions in our conversation, saying that he is
too economic reductionistic (an argument, with which I disagree because I think this thoughts and
works were much more manifold than many see/say today), but both Smythe and Garnham have
argued that ideology critique (as mainly advanced by the Frankfurt School within Marxism) is un-
necessary, unimportant, idealistic, etc. This is a topic that not only concerns capital as base of capi-
talism, because ideologies are sturdily anchored in the capitalist economy, but also because they
concern the economy’s and the political system’s interaction with culture and the world of ideas. So
ideology is a crucial topic of analysis for avoiding crude economic reductionism.
By saying that ideology critique has least importance, you now sound more like Dallas Smythe
and the economism you say you are so weary of. Why should ideology be less important than capi-
tal accumulation when we study the media? I do not agree and am curious what arguments you
have in this respect. Marcuse, by the way, did not say that ideology is dead. People like Daniel Bell
(1960) were talking about the “end of ideology” and Marcuse countered that late capitalism in the
1960s and 1970s was a hyper-ideological age.
Let’s take a simple contemporary example: what is now called “social media” by some. After the
dot.com crisis in 2000, there was a need for establishing new capital accumulation strategies for
the capitalist Internet economy. So the discourse on “social media” became all about new capital
accumulation models for the Internet economy. At the same time, investors were reluctant to invest
finance capital after the crisis as venture capital into digital media companies. Nobody knew if the
users were interested in microblogs, social networking sites, etc.
The rise of social media as a new capital accumulation model was accompanied by a social me-
dia ideology: that social media are new (“web 2.0″), pose new opportunities for participation, will
bring about an “economic democracy”, enable new forms of political struggle (“Twitter revolution”),
etc. The rise of new media once more was accompanied by a techno-deterministic techno-
optimistic ideology. This ideology was necessary for convincing investors and users to support the
social media capital accumulation model. The political economy of surplus value generation on
social media and ideology have heavily interacted here in order to enable the rise of “social media”.
So why should ideology here be rather unimportant? It is just as crucial as surplus value genera-
tion. The ideology of techno-determinism and techno-optimism were in this case (as in other cases
of the introduction of new technologies) mainly spread by management gurus, uncritical academics
and new media company managers. Isn’t it the task of critical academics to understand and criti-
cize this ideology just like to understand and criticize media capital accumulation models?
You say one should be critical of focusing on society as a whole. But doing so is not lacking
complexity, it is based on the insight that it is possible to understand, conceptualize, analyse, criti-
cize and transform the societal totality and to see how class interacts in this whole with other forms
and lines of stratification, i.e. how exploitation interacts with domination and what role the class
antagonism and non-class antagonisms play. Of course this is complex, it is necessarily complex,
tripleC 9(2): 247-271, 2011 257
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
complex, but the problem today is that the culturalist turn has resulted in simplistic/cultural
reductionistic analyses that neglect class and the economy. Why analysing the totality is important
is also the prospect of changing the whole and replacing capitalism by democracy and equality.
What are the alternatives to that? Are we not again in the situation of facing the potential futures of
socialism or barbarism(s)?
I have read Nicholas Garnham’s (2011) contribution in the Handbook of Political Economy of
Communication. Here are three observations from my reading:
1. Garnham(2011) suggests using the term “Political Economy of Information” instead of “Political
Economy of Media/Communication/Culture”. I think that information-communication-culture-
media are so interlinked, that it is really just a question of choice, which name we employ.
2. Garnham (2011) says that Political Economy is often a gestural, self-satisfied, paranoid radical
Marxism and is often based on a crude and romantic Marxist rejection of the market. He also
speaks about the alienated nature of all human relations and alienation as aspect of human
species-being. I could not disagree more. Critical Media and Communication Studies is not
strongly shaped by Marxism today because the engagement with Marx has had an institutional
setback in the past three decades due to the rise of neoliberalism, postmodernism and cul-
turalism. At the same time, socio-economic inequality and the crisis-proneness of capitalism has
intensified, culminating in the 2008ff crisis, which is the reason why the interest in Marx’s
thought is coming back. So I would say that Critical Media and Communication Studies is not
Marxist enough and should become more Marxist, the historical opportunity and analytical ne-
cessity (the objective necessity of the need of analysing class, capitalism, exploitation and crisis
now) is here now.
3. I found it surprising, given this context, that Garnham (2011) to a certain extent seems to be
turning away from Marxist analysis. Many of his passages are quite unclear, so more clarifica-
tions were indeed needed from him on these points. When he says that alienation is part of the
nature of humans and society, then he either uses a non-Marxist concept of alienation (he gives
no definition) or he makes a fetishistic argument that naturalizes class relations. For Marx, al-
ienation is at the heart of class relations, not only for the young Marx, but the very same notion
can be found in the works of the older Marx (the notion of “double-free wage labour” in “Capi-
tal”). And why is it crude and romantic when Marxists reject the market? Exchange value is the
heart of each market, and Marx was clear on the necessity to sublimate exchange value ec-
onomies in order to create a just society. Everywhere we find exchange value, we find in-
equality. Has Garnham given up the basic assumptions of Marxist theory? And if so, what are
the alternatives for him today?
These are my thoughts for today.
Best, Christian
Discussion Turn 9 (Dwayne Winseck): "So, this is why I speak of Political Economies
of Communication..."
http://dwmw.wordpress.com/2011/08/08/critical-media-and-communication-studies-today-a-
conversation-between-dwayne-winseck-and-christian-fuchs-part-4/
http://fuchs.uti.at/628/
Christian, as always I hope that you’re well.
Wow, you’ve certainly put a lot out there for consideration. Let me do my best to respond to
some of what you’ve said about ideology, alienation and Garnham’s critique of what he sees as the
Critical Marxian Political Economy of Communication School.
258 Christian Fuchs and Dwayne Winseck
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
First of all I need to clarify that I have not criticized Smythe for being too reductionist but actually
praised him for his point that traditional communication and media studies’ focus on ideology, texts
and effects has distracted us from two fundamental elements that help to constitute a critical ma-
terialist (Marxist or otherwise) political economy of media and communication: first, the economic
importance of media industries and specific firms in their own right and, second, the provision of
communication infrastructure, news and information flows, and advertising, that serve as central
coordinating mechanisms in the capitalist economy as a whole. So, the critique here is that so-
called ideology critique has too often served – past and present – to divert our attention from these
economics realities.
Based on this, I’m afraid that I have to disagree with the example that you offer using social me-
dia in an attempt to illustrate why ideology is as important as economic considerations to a political
economy approach. You say that a “techno-deterministic techno-optimistic ideology” has been ne-
cessary to turn social media into a new site of capital investment and accumulation, in other words,
to turn things like Facebook, Twitter, Flickr, LinkedIn, etc. into hot new markets and sites for in-
vestment. Given that, you say that our task is as much to understand and critique this ideology as it
is to focus on economic arrangements and media capital accumulation models?
I do not agree that ideology has been essential to the emergence of social media as significant
new markets and sources of financial investment. Indeed, the notion that techno-optimistic ideology
serves as the handmaiden of capitalism and is behind speculative booms followed by, first, the
dot.com crisis and then the Global Financial Crisis is misguided in my view. I think that several of
our colleagues have done extremely impressive work that helps shed light on how ideas, know-
ledge circulation and, if you will, a more modest conception of ideology that goes by some other
name works. I have in mind the work of Peter Thompson, Aeron Davis, Wayne Hope and Marc-
Andre Pigeon (see Winseck and Jin 2011).
Each of them have focused closely on knowledge flows and the role of very specialized, high
end financial market and business news services and databases among a trilogy of groups – insti-
tutional and high end financial investors/traders/analysts, corporate insiders and financial jour-
nalists. In its most basic of outlines, knowledge and data flows among the first two groups far more
quickly before it ever reaches mass media channels such as CNN, MSNBC, Wall Street Journal,
Your Hometown Daily News Outlet, etc. Financial journalists play the role of switching nodes here,
but the differences in who is speaking to whom, the narrow vs. mass audience, and vast differ-
ences in temporality (ie. insiders get stuff in milliseconds and zero time delay and trades are exe-
cuted in a flash) mean that it is what is happening inside the elite groups and the narrow conven-
tions that they share and subscribe too rather than techno-optimistic hyperbole/ideology that gets
attached to all new media.
Instead of ideology, then, I think we need to pay attention to specialized, elite knowledge and
channels of communication, on the one hand. The rhetoric, language, myths and uses of media
and ICTs are important in their own right, and are structured by class, primarily greasing the slide
of new media from novelty to part of the furniture. This is similar to the Abercrombie, Hill and
Turner (1984) critique of the ‘dominant ideology’ thesis in 1980. It is not the ideology is irrelevant,
but rather that its grip is mostly present among elites and diffuse across other social classes as a
whole (a point that C. Wright Mills also made). Much more could be said along these lines, but my
basic point is that vast flows of capital investment into media doesn’t involve ideology but rather
‘fast circuits’ of data and knowledge production, which, from analysts and consultants of the
dot.com era (analysts/snake-oil sales reps, H. Blodget, M. Meeker, etc.) and standards and rating
agencies (Fitch, Standard and Poor, Moodys), have systematically torqued their data and sold in-
vestors (and the political class) a bill of goods that later turned out to be little more than Ponzi-like
schemes.
To move on to the points you made about social totality, I think we may be closer on this than
might initially appear. I think that the ambition of trying to make the connections between media
and ICTs and capitalist modernity as a whole is one that gives political economy some of its im-
pressive reach and allows it to provide compelling accounts of our times, sometimes. I agree with
tripleC 9(2): 247-271, 2011 259
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
you that the Culturalist Turn has resulted in simplistic/cultural reductionistic analyses that neglect
class and the economy, and lead to fragmented portraits of the contemporary condition that then
recursively feed into, and reproduce, the fragmentary character of contemporary societies that are
our objects/subjects of study to begin with.
Again though, I think the thrust of my work is more towards, lets say, a better sense of the inter-
play between top-down macro-level, deductive approaches that aim to synthesize complexity into a
portrait of the social totality based on propositions derived from Marx versus a bottom-up examin-
ation of what Boltanski (2011) calls ‘situations’, or ‘contexts of action’, where emergent properties
and how people actually think, act and so on arises out of empirical observation. Discovering such
emergent properties through empirical observation means that you have to bracket aside, at least
for the moment, your own politics and agendas, lest you superimpose that on the conditions and
‘subjects’ (people) at hand.
Time and again I’ve discovered this to be true when I observe what people do with the me-
dia/Internet, or pay close attention to what others who study such things have to say. That is, I’ll
discover that people actually employ elaborate, even if unreflective, practices that tell us about how
they feel about others with whom they communicate, privacy and surveillance, etc. People can tell
you about these experiences too, reflexively. The expressions that emerge from what people are
actually doing often clash with the reigning practices and strategies of Facebook, ISPs, Google,
etc., as one can see in their Acceptable User Agreements/Policies, etc. The fact that you spend a
lot of time looking at these things all the time in your work is one, among many things, that has
impressed me so much with your work.
So, key point on this? We need to focus more on textured interplay between macro and micro
level analysis, theoretico-deductive approaches versus inductive but still theory-grounded empirical
observation. There are too many ungrounded analyses that regurgitate politico-theoretical proposi-
tions in light of each new round of communications media (Internet, web 2.0, etc.) as if that consti-
tutes analysis.
Let me turn, quickly because this is becoming far too long, to some points you raise about Garn-
ham (2011). First, you say that you want to insist on a “Critique of the Political Economy of X” or
“the Critical Political Economy of X”, and do not personally want to be associated with Neoliberal
Political Economy of X.
While I want to consider what I do as fitting within the ‘critique of the political economy of com-
munication’, I do not have the same qualms as you do with respect to other strands of political ec-
onomy on offer. I put this out in more elaborate form in a long introductory essay (Winseck 2011) to
our new edited collection to which you contributed, The Political Economies of Media (Winseck &
Jin 2011), which just came out last month.
The key point that Garnham (2011) is making, it seems to me, is that critical Marxist political ec-
onomists have spent more time denouncing markets and commercialization than studying how they
actually work, are structured, change over time, etc. Of course, there are exceptions to this, and
your work is among such exceptions. However, the rule remains . . . .
One thing that I’ve done recently is joined with Eli Noam, a Professor of Finance and Economics
at Columbia University, and also an expert from within the mainstream of economics in all aspects
of telecom, media and Internet economics. He’s also recently published the authoritative Media
Ownership and Concentration in America (2009). I’ve learned a great deal from the work that I’ve
done with him on the International Media Concentration Research Project. I’ve produced reams of
evidence on all manner of the telecom-media-Internet industries in Canada covering the past 25
years as part of this project. Simply gathering, organizing and trying to make sense of this data,
from the bottom, over such a long span of time, has allowed things aplenty to emerge that I could
not have anticipated or derived from propositions drawn from Marxist political economy.
I can’t go any further here into this, but on this point let me just say that there are others who you
and I also know well and I think respect as heterodox, if not Marxist political economists, such as
Paschal Preston, Guillermo Mastrini and Martin Becerra. They are also part of this project. Even
Robert McChesney and Eli Noam, from what I understand, are on the phone or sharing emails
260 Christian Fuchs and Dwayne Winseck
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
once in a while to compare notes and update data for both of their purposes, and in particular the
important work that McChesney spearheads by way of his powerful advocacy organization in the
US, Free Press.
And we must remember too that it was others such as the institutionalist Joseph Schumpeter
(1942) in Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy (see part I) as well as the radical American soci-
ologist C. Wright Mills (1962), in The Marxists, who argued that the point when it comes to Marx, is
that first and foremost we need to know our Marx. They both, each in their own way, praise Marx
the sociologist and economist, but condemn him, again for their own reasons, as political theorist
and prophet. We must each have our Marx, so to speak, carefully and judiciously selecting the
things from him that we think still apply – expansionary and dynamic tendencies of capitalism,
pressures toward consolidation, congenital instability and crisis tendencies, power and class dis-
tinctions – while rejecting other elements that we don’t believe work: e.g. base/superstructure
model of society, ideology, labour theory of value, etc.
So, this is why I speak of political economies of communication. It is meant to (1) prise away this
approach from its conflation with a Marxist analysis in many circles, (2) to reflect that there are
several schools of thought (e.g. Marxian, liberal, institutional, heterodox, etc.), (3) that rather than
the whole of society being subordinated to the universal rule of exchange value (the market), we
still see multiple economies (as Aristotle said) where we produce things for ourselves (DIY, self-
sufficiency, Wikipedia, YouTube videos), for others and our neighbours (gifts, social economy) and
for the market (exchange); (4) that communication, media and information goods are atypical
commodities, as Garnham but also the Cultural Industries School never fails to stress, that can only
be forcefit into the commodity mold by force of the state, law and intellectual tyranny of conserva-
tive Chicago School economics that works to achieve in the realm of thought (ideology) what can-
not be achieved in the ‘real world’: the sublimation of everything to the principles of market ex-
change.
Whilst I am aware of the power of Chicago School thought and how it has buttressed the imposi-
tion of a neoliberal template on many areas of life and the world (and dictatorships throughout Latin
America), we have not yet seen the universalization of the market as the measure of all things, as
Marx felt, and as those who still subscribe to his views and speak uniformly of neoliberalism tend to
think.
I agree with you about the globalization of capitalism generating increased socio-economic in-
equality, especially in the heartlands of capitalist modernity (Europe and North America). However,
elsewhere – China, India, Russia, Turkey, Brazil, South Africa, etc. – the embrace of capitalism has
not just aggravated social economic inequality, but fuelled incredible levels of growth and develop-
ment to the extent that what used to be the periphery now serves as the outposts of new, in many
cases, authoritarian, unbridled capitalist states that increasingly look to one another for ‘models of
development’ and inspiration rather than the liberal ideals of capitalist modernity. This can be seen
especially with respect to China and how it is viewed now in Africa and Latin America. It was also
clear at our conference in Istanbul, where the speakers on the plenary made it absolutely clear that
the political masters in that city and Turkey’s political capital of Ankara no longer kowtow to the
west and sing from the hymn sheets of liberal democracy that go along with capitalist modernity but
reject that in favour of some new mélange of politico-religious-hyper-technologized iron-state view
of capitalism.
So, this points to one other thing that I have found problematic with the main lines of Critical
Marxian Political Economies of Communication, and that is the notion that neoliberalism constitutes
a uniform horizon in which nations around the world are simply folded into capitalism. I don’t think
that there is one capitalism but rather a variety of capitalisms with their own specific characteristics
that need to be understood and, once again, studied at two levels: first, in terms of distinctive quali-
ties but also, and second, in relation to the common fundamentals that harmonize things.
Again, it is the interplay between the two dimensions that is key, and it is the uniform preoccupa-
tion with the generic characteristics of capitalism that those who invoke notions of neoliberalism lay
all their stress that seems like an overly easy short hand for real observations. It also struck me as
tripleC 9(2): 247-271, 2011 261
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
odd too that whilst neoliberalism was supposedly remaking the world in the singular image of An-
glo-American capitalism, the number of regulatory institutions within just our field alone exploded
worldwide, from something like 14 in 1990 to 90 a decade later and around 150 or so today. Regu-
lators translate the general ‘logics’ of markets, technology and rule-making in specialized domains
into the specific rules and procedures that compose the local political economy to which they are
being adapted, as Saskia Sassen (2006) puts it. There’s a lot of ‘translation’ work that goes on in
this and I think it belies the overly generic notions implied by the rhetoric of neoliberalism.
And besides, just as neoliberalism was seen to be triumphant circa 2000, what happened? A
decade of crises, that’s what, starting with the collapse of the dot.com bubble in 2000 and instability
ever since, coming to a head once again since the Global Financial Crisis of 2007/8ff. And unlike
what David Harvey says, the crisis didn’t start on the margins, or get displaced there, but in the
core and wreaked its havoc in Europe and the U.S.
So Marx should be back in light of Global Financial Crisis. Indeed, the instabilities of capitalism
are visible all around us and sharp jolts and crisis tendencies emerge one day, disappear the next,
and reassert themselves the day after that. This is crazy instability, precarity. However, the under-
lying universalist notion that many interpret as leading to economic, social and cultural homoge-
neity does not follow. This is another one of the key points that Garnham (2011) makes when he
likewise advises that we reject notions that the media are bound up with forces of cultural ho-
mogenization, cultural imperialism, etc.
I agree, and think it is important to remember the other side of Marx, who stated that, in the face
of the tumultuous, disruptive dynamism of capitalism, “all that is solid melts into air”, by which he
meant the break down of traditional societies and ossified ways of life and thinking. The upshot of
that, however, is not the superimposition of a higher level of homogenous integration (again, contra
what notions of ideology often suggest) but greater levels of sociological differentiation, as sociolo-
gists from Tarde, to Parsons, to Habermas, Giddens, Bauman and many others in between have
insisted upon. And that is mirrored in the domain of media and ICTs because it seems to me what
we are seeing is not total integration and convergence under an ever smaller number of corporate
rulers, but simultaneously and paradoxically, both consolidation in some dimensions, generally
those with general utility like functions (Google, Facebook, etc.) and where economies of scale (but
not scope) are strong, ie. integration between TV and film, but not TV, film and Carriers/Internet, to
wit the misfortunes/calamities of AOL Time Warner, News Corp/MySpace, Vivendi Universal, etc.
(with exception of recent Comcast NBC-Universal merger). Garnham in his school marmy way is
admonishing us to understand this reality and seems to believe that until we reject our dogmatic
ways, we won’t even be able to see things clearly, let alone understand them. I have some sympa-
thy but . . . .
Finally, I do not agree with you that alienation is a unique pathology of capitalism. Of course, it
was the task of Critical Theory, in particular Eric Fromm (1961) and Herbert Marcuse (1964) to lay
out a theory of alienation combining Freud with Marx to understand alienation under capitalism.
That bore some fruit, but try raising it with most feminists today. It ain’t gonna go anywhere, as far
as I know. The bottom line on this for me is that alienation is not a capitalist problem, but an exi-
stential one. Here, Marx does not offer much of value. We must read our Soren Kierkegaard, J. P.
Satre, Lu Xun, and Albert Camus for insights on that.
That, in my view, is not an indictment of Marx, but rather a marker of the scope and limits of his
thoughts. I hope that the above ideas clearly indicate that I am no turn-coat enemy of Marx and
some of the many important thinkers who have translated his ideas into central pillars in the Critical
Marxian Approach to the Political Economy of Media and Communication. I continue to be inter-
ested in this work and draw on it often and extensively, while still hoping that I may make some
modest contributions to it. However, I do not believe that such an approach holds the magic key to
understanding our times, and in fact believe that adhering too closely to a Marxian view of Political
Economy will only impoverish us.
Well, Christian, this has really gotten out of hand. It’s dragged up a whole ton of ideas that I’ve
been thinking about for a long time now. There’s obviously much more to say, but I think I’ll leave it
262 Christian Fuchs and Dwayne Winseck
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
here for now and await your response. I’d say that we wrap it up after that, perhaps returning some
time in the future to pick up where we leave off.
Cheers and all the best, Dwayne
Discussion Turn 10 (Christian Fuchs): "To talk about Political Economies of Media
must mean to talk at the same time about the political economy of the Political
Economies of Media..."
http://fuchs.uti.at/634/
http://dwmw.wordpress.com/2011/08/08/critical-media-and-communication-studies-today-a-
conversation-between-dwayne-winseck-and-christian-fuchs-part-5/
Hello Dwayne,
Thank you for your detailed and interesting response. I will try to answer on a more general level
by (1) taking up some points about ideology, (2) making 7 thematic sets of hypotheses about Criti-
cal Media and Communication Studies today, and (3) commenting on the status of the field of Po-
litical Economy/Economies of the Media. Except for some comments about ideology critique (1), I
do not come back to every single unresolved question that relates to our previous conversation, but
rather focus on the larger context of our discussion – the status of Critical Media and Communica-
tion Studies today (2+3).
(1) The Concept of Ideology
Allow me to note that I did not say that ideology is “behind the dot.com crisis and then the Global
Financial Crisis”, but that crisis results and expresses itself in an intensified presence of certain
ideologies. I think that your positive assessment of Smythe’s and Garnham’s assumption that ide-
ology critique diverts “our attention from economic realities” risks economism, neglecting how cul-
ture and the world of ideas always interacts with the economy. But you also talk about the role of
“elite knowledge” and ICT/media myths in capitalism. But that is exactly part of the domain of ideol-
ogy. What we have to add is that there are also attempts to make everyday citizens follow ideolo-
gies and that ideology can be (and often is, but not automatically) a site of struggle. If dominant
ideas are ideas of the dominant, then it is likely that they do use media to reproduce their he-
gemony. This does not mean that they always are successful in doing so, but that it is likely that we
find hegemonic ideas in mainstream media. This is contradicted by the possibility (and reality) of
alternative interpretations and alternative media, which are ways of challenging hegemonic ideas.
But of course counter-hegemonic projects are facing power asymmetries. I would also add that
academia is a site of ideological struggle. Isn’t it also the task of Critical Political economy to ques-
tion myths about media and capitalism that are advanced in Media and Communication Studies? If
we understand ourselves as critical scholars, then our critique has an object within academia and
in society and we are the subjects conducting this critique. All of this is part of struggles relating to
ideology.
Ideology critique tries to show differences between essence and existence and between claims
about reality and reality itself. Take as example for ideology critique your analysis in the introduc-
tion to the book “The Political Economies of Media”, pp. 43f (Winseck and Jin 2011)) that shows
with statistics that the music industry is growing and not in decline, whereas the International Fed-
eration of Phonographic Industries continues to state the lack of profitability of the recording in-
dustry due to file sharing. What we have here is the empirical testing of the correspondence or
difference of claim and reality that as a result shows the falseness of the claims. Add to this an
analysis of the linguistic ways that the recording industry employs for making its claims about its
dwindling profits and how it identifies file sharers as enemies in order to criminalize them so to
make even more profits, then you have an excellent ideology critique. Dwayne, you are more into
ideology critique than you think you are, so there is no need to understate the importance of this
tripleC 9(2): 247-271, 2011 263
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
dimension of Critical Media and Communication Studies. The question to which extent the public
believes the industry claims or not is another task of ideology critique.
You can of course interpose to my arguments that ideology is a philosophical idealistic phenom-
enon and that the field of Political Economy/Economies of Media should focus on studying materi-
alistic phenomena. But this is a crude separation of base and superstructure, and does not take
into account that the base and superstructure always interact, put pressures on each other, are
dialectically interconnected. The German philosopher Hans Heinz Holz speaks of dialectics as
Übergreifen of categories (encroaching). The economy and the world of ideas necessarily dialecti-
cally encroach upon one another in complex ways. You cannot split the world of ideas off from the
economy (the role of ideology, cultural industry as the collapse between the boundaries of base
and superstructure, knowledge work as interconnection between the two, etc.).
Allow me to note that for Marx ideology certainly was a dimension of Political Economy. The
chapter, “The Fetishism of Commodities and the Secret Thereof” in Capital, Volume 1 (Marx 1867),
which is probably one of the most difficult chapters in the book, makes this clear. Marx points out
the logical mistake of taking historical circumstances as natural for all societies (naturalization),
stresses that the thinkers of the Classical Political Economy frequently make this mistake, that the
same mode of thinking can also be found in everyday thinking, that this fetishistic thinking stems
from the very structure of capitalist production itself, i.e. has a material grounding, that ideologies
are not just ideas, but at the same time social and material practices grounded in the economy, and
that overcoming fetishism requires a fundamental transformation of society. I think this chapter is,
where we should start the discussion when we talk about the role of ideology for Political Econ-
omy/Economies of the Media.
We will not be able to go into it in any more detail on these questions now, but we can see from
our discussion that the question of ideology in capitalism is a hotly debated issue within Critical
Media and Communication Studies. We should also note that when discussing ideology, we need
an understanding of what ideology is. And there is no consensus on this. Terry Eagleton (1991)
has noted six core understandings of the concept of ideology:
a) The general material process of production of ideas, beliefs and values in social life.
b) Ideas coherently symbolize the conditions and life-experiences of a specific group or class.
c) The promotion and legitimatization of the interests of a group or class in the face of opposing
interests.
d) The promotion and legitimatization of the interests of a dominant social group in order to unify a
social formation.
e) Ideas and beliefs which help to legitimate the interests of a ruling group/class with the help of
distortion and dissimulation.
f) False and deceptive beliefs arising from the material structure of society as a whole.
There are differences in the ideology concepts of say e.g. Georg Lukács (and based on him the
Frankfurt School), Karl Mannheim, Antonio Gramsci or Louis Althusser and these differences are
based on specific interpretations of Marx.
We can think about Eagleton’s six concepts of ideology as variously interlinked levels of ideol-
ogy. The differentiation between levels allows us also to see that false consciousness is not a ne-
cessary element of ideology; it may be just one outcome of ideological strategies, but can also be
resisted (although there is no automatism of resistance and the means for producing hegemonic
ideology and counter-hegemony are unequally distributed). Ideology is not necessarily a state of
consciousness of dominated groups. It can be, but it is more a process, in which dominant groups
communicate dominant ideas, to which others react in certain ways or do not react. Dominant ideas
impact the culture of the dominant itself (e.g. neoliberal work norms – the new spirit of networked
capitalism – that impact not only what is expected of the behaviour of workers, but also managers).
264 Christian Fuchs and Dwayne Winseck
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
(2) 7 Sets of Hypotheses about Critical Media and Communication Studies Today
(H1) The Task of Critical Media and Communication Studies
The task for Critical Media and Communication Studies is to focus on the critique and analysis of
the role of communication, culture, information and the media in society in the context of
a) processes of capital accumulation (including the analysis of capital, markets, commodity logic,
competition, exchange value, the antagonisms of the mode of production, productive forces, cri-
ses, advertising, etc.),
b) The promotion and legitimatization of the interests of a group or class in the face of opposing
interests.
c) class relations (with a focus on work, labour, the mode of the exploitation of surplus value, etc),
d) domination in general,
e) ideology (both in academia and everyday life) as well as the analysis of and engagement in
f) struggles against the dominant order, which includes the analysis and advancement of
g) social movement struggles and
h) social movement media that
i) establishing a democratic socialist society that is based on communication commons as part of
structures of commonly-owned means of production. The approach thereby realizes that in capi-
talism all forms of domination are connected to forms of exploitation.
Critical Media and Communication Studies has the potential for combining all or at least several
of these dimensions of analysis and in doing so to bring together Critical Theory, Critical Political
Economy, Critical Cultural Studies, Alternative Media Studies, etc. This is again mainly a resource
questions and as a result we find a division of labour in Critical Media and Communication Studies.
We should draw on the vast history of critical traditions in Critical Media and Communication Stud-
ies and bring them together in interdisciplinary research programmes. So there should not be one
project of Critical Media and Communication Studies, but a diversity of projects. But they should be
networked and their diversity be united (unity in diversity) by the critical outlook and a theoretical
and philosophical connection. Critical philosophy and social theory have a particular role in such
research programmes and in establishing unity in diversity because due to their operation on a
meta-level of analysis and as meta-theory they can help researchers to communicate with each
other and allow research to be contextualized in a broader context.
(H2) The Form of Critical Media and Communication Studies
Critical Media and Communication Studies best operate as combination of critical social theory,
critical empirical social research and critical ethics. Resource limitations make it frequently not pos-
sible to combine theory, empirical research and critical ethics in single projects/papers/research.
The result is a division of labour (critical media theorists, critical empirical media researchers, criti-
cal information/media ethics). The goal should be to build interdisciplinary teams, research pro-
grammes and projects that pool resources and bring together theory, empirical research and ethics
in conducting Critical Media and Communication research and that draws on knowledge from vari-
ous disciplines. Such research structures reflect Max Horkheimer’s vision of a critical interdiscipli-
nary research programme formulated in 1930 (see Horkheimer 1931).
(H3) Critical Media and Communication Studies and Philosophy
There is a lack of social philosophical and social theoretical grounding of Critical Media and Com-
munication Studies. One of the reasons is that the division of labour results in institutional limits
and a neglect of philosophy. Critical philosophy and social theory can provide systematic guidance
tripleC 9(2): 247-271, 2011 265
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
for engaging with questions relating to which society we live in and what role media and communi-
cation play in contemporary societies.
(H4) Critical Media and Communication Studies and Dialectical Philosophy
Dialectical philosophy can provide a strong philosophical and theoretical grounding of Critical Me-
dia and Communication Studies (see chapters 2+3 in my book “Foundations of Critical Media and
Information Studies” (Fuchs 2011a)). This type of philosophy can provide us with tools of thought
that allow us to systematically conceive, analyze and criticize the contradictions, relations, dynam-
ics, positive and negative potentials, as well as struggles relating to media, communication, culture,
information and technology. Dialectical philosophy can be an extremely helpful guide for theoreti-
cal, methodological and practical-political aspects of Critical Media and Communication Research.
Frankfurt School Critical Theory is the tradition of Critical Cultural Analysis that has most thor-
oughly and systematically engaged with dialectical philosophical and theoretical foundations. Such
foundations have for example been elaborated in Herbert Marcuse’s (1941) “Reason and Revolu-
tion: Hegel and the Rise of Social Theory“ and Theodor W. Adorno’s (1993) “Hegel: Three Stud-
ies”. The dedication of the Frankfurt School to profound philosophical questions (although not ne-
cessarily the content of its theories) can inspire us today to create a dialectical-philosophical foun-
dation of Critical Media and Communication Studies.
Social theories of media and communication in society need to start by providing an understand-
ing of questions like: What is society? How is a society made up? How does social transformation
work? What is the role of structures and agency in society? What is the relationship of the human
individual and society? Dialectical philosophy is well suited for helping to bridge gaps in the field of
Critical Media and Communication Studies (between the focus on structure and agency, subject
and object, reason and experience, technology and society, economy and culture, pessimism and
optimism, risks and opportunities, work and pleasure/joy, alienation and self-actualization, etc.) and
for avoiding one-sided approaches.
(H5) The analysis of capitalism
Capitalism is a system characterized by the dialectical unity of diversity in its political economy. It
has at the same time a unified political economy and diverse political economies; it is at the same
time capitalism and many capitalisms. Capitalism is today at the same time to various degrees
finance capitalism, hyperindustrial capitalism, crisis capitalism, new imperialistic capitalism, me-
dia/informational/communicative capitalism, capitalist patriarchy, a racist mode of production, etc.
The danger for analyses of media, information, culture and communication in capitalism today is to
overstate the relevance of specific phenomena of informational capitalism and to neglect the other
capitalisms as contexts of informational capitalism and the interaction of these dimensions.
Informational/Media/Communicative capitalism is a tendency, and a relative one, in the devel-
opment of contemporary capitalism. This does not mean that it is the only or the dominant ten-
dency. Capitalism is many things at the same time, it is to a certain degree informational, but at the
same time to a certain degree finance, and all the other kinds of capitalisms that I just listed. Capi-
talism is contradictory, it contains in itself to certain degrees different modes of production, such as
pre-modern production forms and voluntary, self-managed, non-commercial, or non-profit projects
and organizations, and an articulation of different modes of production. It is the task of research to
find out which capitalism is present to which extent in which context.
The unity of all capitalisms is that they are all oriented to capital accumulation by exploiting sur-
plus value in class relations. The diversity of capitalisms is united, capitalism needs to be dynamic,
complex, multidimensional and diverse in order to maintain the continuity of capital accumulation
and to create ever newer spheres and spaces of commodification, production, circulation, con-
sumption and accumulation. Debates about media in the information society are often stuck in ei-
ther stressing pure continuity or pure discontinuity of capitalism. We need to grasp and analyse the
dialectics of capitalism.
266 Christian Fuchs and Dwayne Winseck
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
(H6) The analysis of media communication in capitalism
Informational/media/communicative capitalism as one of the dimensions of contemporary capi-
talism is itself internally shaped by the dialectical unity of diversity. It is many-sided, contradictory,
multifaceted, multidimensional. Capitalist media are, in complex and contradictory ways, but to
varying historical and changing degrees, connected to non-capitalist media. Analysing media
communication in contemporary society requires us to see the dialectics of structure and agency,
object and subject, opportunities and risks, work and play/pleasure, continuity and discontinuity,
commodity and gift, and other dialectics. At the same time, we should be under no illusion that the
dialectic is symmetrical. Instead, we must look for the asymmetries in power relations and strat-
egies in order to politically empower alternative and critical forms of communication where need it
most.
(H7) The analysis of exploitation and domination in Critical Media and Communication Stud-
ies
The rise of neoliberalism in society and of Postmodernism, Cultural Studies, Post-Marxism and
Constructivism in academia have worked on decentering theory from class analysis and focusing
on non-class based domination and discrimination. Identity politics tended to be substituted for
class politics. The neoliberal phase of capitalism was/has been/is an intensification of class strug-
gle-from-above, at the top of the power hierarchy, by capital. This has resulted in a strong increase
of socio-economic inequality and an extension and intensification of precarious living and working
conditions. At the same time that academia was saying goodbye to class, material reality brought
class back in. The rise of the movement for democratic globalization showed that it is a movement
galvanizing around the topic of class, in the 1980s and 1990s new social movements were quite
separate around topics like gender, racism, peace, nature, etc. – the rise of neoliberalism resulted
since the late 1990s in a movement of movements. The global capitalist crisis has finally brought a
return to the economy and class, not only in society, but also in academia.
Class needs to be conceived today in a form that takes non-wage labour (like unemployment,
house work, use of corporate Internet platforms, etc.) as forms of exploitation and as part of the
class antagonism into account. Theorizing class as a foundation for understanding knowledge work
and “digital labour” on the Internet needs to be attuned to the idea of multiple class positions: the
flexibilization, dynamization and pluralization of class positions, and the antagonistic class charac-
ter of knowledge production/producers themselves.
These diversities find their unity in the production and exploitation of value. There is a dialectical
unity of diversity in class analysis. If we think dialectically about class, then necessarily the class
antagonism is maintained by an internal dynamic change of class positions. Attention needs to be
given also to the circumstance that an individual can occupy multiple class positions at the same
time and that these positions shift. Knowledge work is today often overstated and it is often con-
ceptualized as being too homogenous, although from a class perspective it is quite heterogeneous,
fragmented, and ruptured by internal class antagonisms.
Various forms of domination in capitalism are always articulated with class. Capitalism can in
principle be ecologically sustainable, respectful of gender differences, minorities, immigrants, etc
as long as capital accumulation is guaranteed, but it can never be socio-economically just. Class is
the key to understanding and criticizing domination and exploitation in capitalism. Domination can-
not be reduced to class, but exploitation always prefigures, exerts pressure, conditions and sets the
context and limits for various forms of domination.
(3) The Field of (Critical) Political Economy/Economies of the Media
You on the one hand use the term political economies for saying that we have multiple economies,
i.e. you want to stress the complex and contradictory character of capitalism. To a certain extent I
agree (see H5+H6). I would only add that there is a unity in this diversity and a predominance of
the capitalist mode of production. On the other hand you use the term Political Economies of the
tripleC 9(2): 247-271, 2011 267
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Media (see Dwayne’s introduction (Winseck 2011) in the important collected volume “The Political
Economies of Media” (Winseck & Jin 2011)). You want to stress the importance of the plurality of
schools of Political Economy of the Media and to also express that to a certain extent one should
leave aside “one’s own politics and agendas” in academia and engage in broad academic collabor-
ations. Implicitly you also thereby say or want to warn that being too critical can be a barrier to
communication and can advance separation.
I really recommend everyone interested in contemporary Media and Communication Studies to
read this introduction and the book. Your introduction is excellent. It is a convincing empirical an-
alysis, deeply informed by knowledge of different theoretical traditions.
You provide a mapping of the landscape of Political Economy research in Media and Communi-
cation Studies by identifying four approaches and speaking of Political Economies of Media:
a) Neoclassical Political Economy of the Media
b) Radical Political Economy of the Media
c) Schumpeterian Institutional Political Economy of the Media
d) The Cultural Industries School.
You stress the diversity of the field that conducts inquiries of the social, political and economic
contexts of media communication. Your classification is very helpful for distinguishing Critical Politi-
cal Economy from other approaches (a distinction that is frequently missing in other accounts and
creates a lot of confusion). It is perfectly feasible and welcome that scholars from all four ap-
proaches work together on interesting topics and that we should definitely look for and be open to
such co-operation.
The methodological differences are probably also not larger between the four approaches than
within the approaches. The big difference is that the second approach is the one most likely to ask
and engage with philosophical, ethical, political and theoretical questions about power structures, a
just society and a just media system, whereas the three others are more likely (of course to varying
degrees and depending on contexts) to find such questions and engagements inappropriate, un-
necessary, and to argue for value free research — that such questions, essentially, lie outside of
academia. The question, however, is what do we want: Good analyses only? Or good analyses
that help advance a more just society as context for media communication?
By focusing on the diversity of approaches, your classification risks neglecting the political econ-
omy of the Political Economies of Media, i.e. the power structures and power distribution that char-
acterize this field and limits its diversity. Radical and Marxist scholarship is bound up with the sec-
ond approach. What does it mean to be a Marxist/critical scholar today (especially for younger
scholars; I do think we have to stress and take into account that career opportunities and academic
work conditions are in many countries today much more precarious than twenty or thirty years ago;
and let’s assume that by critical we here do not mean Popper’s understanding of the term, but the
more political notion of the critique of society)?
It means that you are less likely to get your papers accepted in established mainstream journals,
that you will have a more difficult time getting funding for your research, for attaining tenure or find-
ing a permanent position; that you are more likely of having to face prejudices, negative prejudge-
ments and demonizations of your work, that you are more likely to loose your job and to be a pre-
carious academic worker; that you are likely to have to engage in permanent discussions about
what Marx actually wrote and what others claim he wrote and stands for, etc.
Being a Marxist scholar is the best guarantee for a difficult academic life. Marxists likely have to
work more and harder, to be more witty and creative than representatives of the other three ap-
proaches and of having to exploit themselves more intensively in order to be recognized, to estab-
lish themselves and to be successful academics. The notion of a diverse field obscures the internal
power structures of Media and Communication Studies and Political Economy and of what it means
to be a critical scholar today. It is luring and structurally feasible to stop (or never start) being criti-
cal and to follow mainstream administrative research in order to avoid the stony academic way that
268 Christian Fuchs and Dwayne Winseck
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
critical scholars frequently have to go. Another strategy is to think that one conducts administrative
research first and critical research later once one is established and tenured. The problem of this
strategy is that the more one becomes part of institutionalized administrative research, the more
difficult it becomes to do something different.
Media and Communication Studies and Political Economies of Media are NOT diverse fields,
they are fields shaped by power structures – liberal diversity turns in reality out to be not so liberal
at all. And yet going the stony way and conducting critical research as part of the second paradigm
is the only way for intellectuals to work towards a truly participatory, democratic, commons-based
and public media system and for a just society. Therefore it is politically necessary and academi-
cally perfectly feasible to go the stony way and to be critical. One may have to go more difficult
ways, but these ways and their outcomes are more meaningful. Networks of critical scholars that
can give mutual support are quite important and a power in itself on this way.
What distinguishes the second approach from the other three is the connection of theory and
empirical research to normative judgements that are critiques of asymmetric power structures and
to the struggle for a just society and a just media system. Under neoliberal capitalism, we are not
only facing the privatization and commodification of large parts of the media and rising inequality, it
is for various reasons also difficult and a challenge to be critical. The intensification of different
inequalities and neoliberal hegemony require a specific focus on the Critical Political Econ-
omy/Critique of the Political Economy of Media. The second approach you identify has special rel-
evance today. It needs to be especially nourished and supported, more than all other approaches
in your typology.
Neoliberalism has brought about a deep-seated institutional and structural discrimination of
scholars, who find Marx’s analyses inspiring and use them for formulating contemporary critiques.
The 1960s and 1970s were decades that resulted in a relative institutionalization of scholars who
were critical of capitalism. The rise of neoliberalism brought a reversal. Not only was it no longer
en-vogue to talk about class and capitalism, doing so has — in the era of neoliberalism — not been
conducive for an academic career, to say the least. Academics out of fear to loose their jobs or not
being promoted adapted to the new neoliberal mainstream and this also impacted the topics and
methods of research, the way universities and departments are organized and that especially
brought heavy pressures for younger scholars, who have to a large degree been facing precarious
employment relations.
Being critical in a neoliberal environment is structurally difficult. Neoliberalism limits the degree
and possibilities of being critical by university reforms, cutting of budgets, centralization of bureau-
cracy, coupling of university to industry, downsizing or elimination of departments and fields that
are not considered as being in line with economic interests, etc. So how to be critical in 21
st
century
academia? My take is that critical thinking has been marginalized and discriminated for too long
and that we have to demand our rights to be heard, to be present, to have resources. And for doing
so, we have to challenge the neoliberal mainstream. The project of Political Economies that you
suggest must take power relations of the field into account, not bracket out the questions of power
and neoliberalism for the sake of being on good terms with scholars from other traditions, and must
especially work for strengthening resource allocation (as a form of affirmative action) for critical
scholarship and overcome structural discrimination. It needs a true diversity, not a pseudo-
diversity. And this question of diversity of a field is crucial and complicated in a largely neoliberal
context that shapes academia. To talk about Political Economies of Media must mean to talk at the
same time about the political economy of the Political Economies of Media.
The interest in Marx is returning today due to the explosion of inequality and the capitalist crisis.
It is a historical moment that needs to be seized and embraced as opportunity. There is a new le-
gitimacy crisis of capitalism, there is tendency that the tide is turning – the tendency is that increas-
ingly you no longer have to explain why you are critical of capitalism and why you talk about class,
the need of justification and explanation tends to lie today rather on the side of those who are not
critical of capitalism and who refuse to talk about class. It is of crucial importance today to conduct
research that is connected to the struggle for a just society.
tripleC 9(2): 247-271, 2011 269
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
There is much confusion about how to name the second approach in your typology. Terms that
have been used by scholars who share the critical approach for naming their field have for example
been Political Economy of Communication, Political Economy of Communications, Political Econ-
omy of Culture, Political Economy of Information, Political Economy of Mass Communication, or
Political Economy of the Media. “Political Economy” is not necessarily critical. This is also an impli-
cation of your mapping of Political Economies of Media. Marx’s book was not called “Capital. A
Political Economy”, but “Capital. A Critique of Political Economy” because he was critical of the
classical political economy of Malthus, Mill, Petty, Ricardo, Say, Smith, Ure, etc.
Just like Marx, I think we should engage with the contemporary mainstream of political economy
(of the media) – neoliberal political economy – in order to criticize and establish a critique of this
political economy and an alternative/critical political economy. I am worried about the circumstance
that scholars tend to speak of “Political Economy of X” and not of “Critique of the Political Economy
of X/Critical Political Economy of X” when the actually mean the latter. There is also a Neoliberal
Political Economy of X. The imprecise usage of terms can easily result in a lack of differentiation
and a confusion of Critical Political Economy with Neoliberal Political Economy. In order to avoid
confusion and be more precise, I suggest to either use the term Critical Political Economy of Com-
munication/Culture/Information/Internet/Media or the term Critique of the Political Economy of
Communication/Culture/Information/Internet/Media. I think that your differentiation of four ap-
proaches helps making such distinctions clearer as they sometimes appear. At the same time, I
disagree with your stress on a diverse field because what we have is a stratified field characterized
by power asymmetries.
One thing we can learn from Marx for Critical Media Studies(?) is his mode of dialectical thinking,
which allows looking for the contradictions of media communication in capitalism. I think dialectical
philosophy is very worthwhile for our field because it allows us to think beyond gaps, beyond tech-
no-optimism and techno-pessimism, beyond structure and agency, etc. and to analyse media
communication in contemporary society as complex, dynamic and contradictory (I stress this espe-
cially in my book “Foundations of Critical Media and Information Studies” (Fuchs 2011a)). But one
can apply dialectical thinking also for understanding what (critical) Political Economy of the Media
is all about. Dialectics is not only thinking in terms of negations and contradictions, but it is also a
mode of thinking and practice oriented on Aufhebung (the bad English translation of this Hegelian
concept is “sublation”), a German word that has a simultaneous threefold meaning and therefore
signifies the threefold process of preservation (1), elimination (2) and uplifting (3).
Marx deeply engaged with Classical Political Economy. As a result, he preserved (1) the best
elements of it in his approach, so his approach was also (classical) political economy. The thor-
ough engagement with Classical Political Economy allowed Marx to formulate a Critique of Political
Economy, he showed the mistakes and ideological naturalizations of the political economists. This
critique was the attempt to eliminate (2) the dominance of classical political economy and to re-
place its dominance by a new quality of political economy (3) in society and thought. It is this third
level of Aufhebung, where Marx not only engaged with political economy and established a critique
of it, but worked out an alternative/critical political economy that was based on the concepts of sur-
plus value and class.
So Marxian Political Economy is a) engagement with traditional political economy, b) critique of
traditional political economy, c) alternative/critical political economy. What is true for a Marxist po-
litical economy in general is just as true for a Marxian Political Economy of the Media specifically.
This is a thoroughly dialectical process. I think we need to be primarily dialectical and critical today
when conducting Political Economy of the Media.
References
Abercrombie, N., Turner B.S. & Hill, S. (1984). The Dominant Ideology Thesis. London: George Allen & Unwin.
Adorno, T. W. (1993). Hegel: Three Studies. Boston: MIT Press.
Bauman, Z. (2000). Liquid Modernity. Cambridge: Polity Press.
270 Christian Fuchs and Dwayne Winseck
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Bell, D. (1960). The End of Ideology: On the Exhaustion of Political Ideas in the Fifties. New York: Collier.
Boltanski, L. (2011). On Critique: A Sociology of Emancipation. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Der Derian, J. (2009). Virtuous War. Mapping the Military-Industrial-Media-Entertainment-Network. 2
nd
ed. New York: Rout-
ledge.
Eagleton, T. (1991). Ideology. An Introduction. London: Verso.
Fromm, E. (1961). Marx’s Concept of Man. New York: Frederick Ungar Publishing.
Fuchs, C. (2010). Labor in Informational Capitalism and on the Internet. The Information Society, 26(3), 179-196.
Fuchs, C. (2011a). Foundations of Critical Media and Information Studies. New York: Routledge.
Fuchs, C. (2011b). An Alternative View of Privacy on Facebook. Information, 2(1), 140-165.
Fuchs, C. (2011c). A Contribution to the Critique of the Political Economy of Google. Fast Capitalism, 8(1).
Fuchs, C. & Zimmermann, R. E. (2009). Practical Civil Virtues in Cyberspace: Towards the Utopian Identity of Civitas and
Multitudo. Salzburg/Munich: Munich Series in Design Science.
Garnham, N. (2011). The Political Economy of Communication Revisited. In J. Wasko, G. Murdock & H. Sousa (Eds.), The
Handbook of Political Economy of Communications (pp. 41-61). Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell.
Geer Jr., D.E. (2011). Eisenhower Revisited. Retrieved from http://geer.tinho.net/ieee/ieee.sp.geer.1107b.pdf
Hardt, M. & Negri, A. (2000) Empire. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Hardt, M. & Negri, A. (2004) Multitude. War and Democracy in the Age of Empire. New York: Penguin Press.
Hegel, G. W. F. (1812). The Science of Logic. Trans. A. Miller. London: Allen & Unwin.
Hegel, G. W. F. (1874). The Logic of Hegel. Trans. from the Encyclopaedia of the philosophical sciences by William Wal-
lace. 2nd ed. London: Oxford University Press.
Honneth, A. (1995). The Struggle for Recognition. The Moral Grammar of Social Conflicts. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Horkheimer, M. (1931). The Present Situation of Social Philosophy and the Tasks of an Institute for Social Research. Trans-
lation from M. Horkheimer Between Philosophy and Social Science: Selected Early Writings (pp. 1-14). Boston: MIT
Press.
Jakobsson, P. & Stiernstedt, F. (2011a). Time, Space and Clouds of Information: Data Center Discourse and the Meaning of
Durability. Paper presented at the IAMCR 2011 Conference, Istanbul.
Jakobsson, P. & Stiernstedt, F. (2011b). Media Regulation as Recurring States of Exceptio. Paper presented at the Me-
dia@UU Lecture Series, Spring 2011, Uppsala.
Jarvis, J. (2009). What Would Google Do? New York: HarperCollins Publishers.
Marcuse, H. (1941). Reason and Revolution. Hegel and the Rise of Social Theory. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Marcuse, H. (1955). Eros and Civilization: A Philosophical Inquiry into Freud. Boston: Beacon Press.
Marcuse, H. (1964). One-Dimensional Man. Studies in the Ideology of Advanced Industrial Society. Boston: Beacon Press.
Marx, K. (1867). Capital: Volume I. London: Penguin.
Mills, C. W. (1962). The Marxists. New York: Dell Publishing.
Napoli, P. (2008). Revisiting “Mass Communication” and the “Work” of the Audience in the New Media Environment. Work-
ing paper retrieved from
http://fordham.academia.edu/PhilipNapoli/Papers/175959/Revisiting_Mass_Communication_and_the_Work_of_the_A
udience_in_the_New_Media_Environment
Noam, E. M. (2009). Media Ownership and Concentration in America. New York: Oxford University Press.
Samuelson, P. (2011). Legislative Alternatives to the Google Book Settlement. Retrieved from
http://people.ischool.berkeley.edu/~pam/LegislativeAlternativesToGBSS.pdf
Sassen, S. (2006). Territory, Authority, Rights: From Medieval to Global Assemblages. Princeton: Princeton University
Press.
Schumpeter, J.A. (1942). Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy. New York: Harper & Row.
Smythe, D. (1977). Communications: Blindspot of Western Marxism, Canadian Journal of Political and Social Theory 1(3),
1-27.
Smythe, D.W. (1981). Dependency Road: Communications, Capitalism, Consciousness and Canada. Norwood, NJ: Ablex
Publishing.
Smythe, D. (1994) After Bicycles, What? In T. Guback (Ed), Counterclockwise: Perspectives on Communication (pp. 230-
244). Boulder: Westview Press.
Vaidhyanathan, S. (2011). Googlization of Everything. Berkeley/ Los Angeles: University of California Press.
Winseck, D. R. (2011). The Political Economies of Media and the Transformation of the Global Media Industries: An Intro-
ductory Essay. In Winseck, D. R. & Jin, D.Y. (Eds.) The Political Economies of Media: The Transformation of the Glo-
bal Media Industries (pp. 3-48). London: Bloomsbury Academic.
Winseck, D. R. & Jin, D.Y. (Eds.) (2011). The Political Economies of Media: The Transformation of the Global Media In-
dustries. London: Bloomsbury Academic.
tripleC 9(2): 247-271, 2011 271
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
About the Authors
Christian Fuchs
Christian Fuchs is chair professor for Media and Communication Studies at Uppsala University's Department of Informatics
and Media and editor of tripleC.
Dwayne Winseck
Dwayne Winseck is a professor at the School of Journalism and Communication, with a cross-appointment in the Institute of
Political Economy, Carleton University, Ottawa, Canada.