tripleC 9(2): 566-592, 2011 587
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Kroll (2010) provides a so-called off- and online vendor integrity program in order to check exist-
ing and potential vendors whether they “have criminal records, financial troubles, or business rela-
tionships that could create costly conflicts or be deeply embarrassing“ or “could have a negative
impact on your company’s revenues and reputation”. Therefore, Kroll (2010) screens criminal rec-
ords, bankruptcy records, illegal activity allegations, civil cases, liens, as well as media coverage of
vendors. For doing so, vendors have to “complete a detailed online questionnaire that’s electroni-
cally submitted to Kroll …, Kroll’s staff screens the information provided by vendors and collect
additional intelligence“ (Kroll 2010) and publishes an online report.
In conclusion, the circuit of capital contains three stages, namely the stage of money capital, the
stage of productive capital, and the stage of commodity capital. Based on these findings, surveil-
lance in the sphere of circulation consists of applicant surveillance, screening of suppliers, property
surveillance, and surveillance of vendors. The next point of discussion is the sphere of consump-
tion.
3.2.3. Surveillance in the Sphere of Consumption
Marx (MECW 28, 30) notes that “production produces consumption: (1) by creating the material for
consumption; (2) by determining the mode of consumption; (3) by creating in the consumer a need
for the products which it first posits as objects” and concludes that production “produces the object
of consumption, the mode of consumption and the urge to consume.” Nevertheless, in order to
know which mode of production generates which mode of consumption of different consumers,
knowledge of consumption matters is required. Although the emergence of mass consumption in
modern societies promises individuality, free choice, sovereignty, and freedom of consumers, it
synchronously requires knowledge of consuming activities in order to stimulate and steer consump-
tion (Lyon 1994, 137). Advertising as a product of modern society is an important instrument for
realizing profit, because it induces people to consume more products or services through branding.
The more data are available, the more precise and effective are the targeted advertisements. Con-
sumer surveillance can be seen as a product of the capitalistic economy (Lyon 1994, 138; Gill
2003, 25ff.; Ogura 2006, 293f.; Brown 2006, 18ff.; see also Hewson 1994). In order to target adver-
tising, market research such as analyzing behaviour, preferences, and interests of consumers is
important. The basic question for market research is who buys where, when, what and why. The
overall aim is to get certain behaviours, preferences, usages, interests, and choices of customers
in order to identify, classify, and assess (Gandy 1993, 80-87) certain groups and supply them with
targeted advertisements. As Theodor W. Adorno and Max Horkheimer (2002, 96f.) put it: “Sharp
distinctions like those between A and B films, or between short stories published in magazines in
different price segments, do not so much reflect real differences as assist in the classification, or-
ganization, and identification of consumers.” So, “for the consumer there is nothing left to classify,
since the classification has already be preempted by the schematism of production.” (Adorno and
Horkheimer 2002, 98) Corporations are interested in collecting and generating as much data as
possible (qualitative level) from as many people as possible (quantitative level).
For surveillance in the sphere of consumption, the example of Google and DoubleClick can be
outlined: According to the top sites of the web by Alexa Internet, Google has the most visits on the
Internet. Google uses a wide range of methods in order to collect data on its users, namely click
tracking (to log clicks of users), log files (to store server requests), JavaScript and web bugs (to
check users visits), as well as cookies (to record individual actions) (Stalder and Mayer 2009, 102).
DoubleClick is one of the main projects of Google (Google 2008). It is a global leader in ad serving
and has developed sophisticated methods in order to collect, analyze, and assess huge amounts of
users’ data on the Internet (Campbell and Carlson 2002, 596-597). Google (2007; 2008) acquired
DoubleClick in 2008 for US$ 3.1 billion. DoubleClick is headquartered in New York City. It was
found in 1996 and works for leading digital publishers, marketers, and agencies around the world
such as About, Durex, Ford, Friendster, Optimedia, Scripps, and MTV (DoubleClick). Ad serving
companies such as DoubleClick use methods by placing advertisements on websites and analyz-
ing their efficiency. DoubleClick develops and provides Internet ad serving services that are sold