
tripleC 9(2): 668-688, 2011
ISSN 1726-670X
http://www.triple-c.at
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
From Seven Years to 360 Degrees:
Primitive Accumulation, Recording Contracts, and the
Means of Making a (Musical) Living
Matt Stahl
mstahl@uwo.ca, Faculty of Information and Media Studies, University of Western Ontario, London, Ontar-
io, Canada
Abstract: This article examines the apparent paradox of the persistence of long-term employment contracts for cultural
industry ‘talent’ in the context of broader trends toward short-term, flexible employment. While aspirants are numberless,
bankable talent is in short supply. Long-term talent contracts appear to embody a durable axiom in employment: labor
shortage favors employees. The article approaches this axiom through the lens of recent reconsiderations of the concept of
primitive accumulation. In the case of employment, this concept highlights employers’ impetus to transcend legal and cus-
tomary barriers to and limits on their capacity to capture and compel creative labor, and to appropriate the products of con-
tracted creative labor. The article supports this argument through the analysis of contests between Los Angeles-based
recording artists and record companies over the California and federal laws that govern their power and property relations.
These struggles reveal a pattern of attempts by record companies to overcome or change laws that limit their power to
control, compel and dispossess recording artists. The article suggests that as contractual forms change under digitalization,
familiar political dynamics continue to characterize the relationships between recording artists and the companies that de-
pend on their labor and output.
Keywords: Primitive accumulation, social common, recording industry, RIAA, contract, popular music, labor law, injunction,
bankruptcy law, copyright, work for hire, Olivia Newton-John.
Acknowledgement: Thanks to the Faculty of Information and Media Studies at UWO for a research grant that supported
part of this research and to members of the Digital Labour Group at UWO for comments. Thanks to GRAND-NCE for addi-
tional funding and to Leslie Meier for research assistance. An earlier version of this article appeared in Ephemera: Theory &
Politics in Organization.
1. Introduction
Binding, long-term employment contracts for creative labor (or ‘talent’, in industry jargon) are impor-
tant to the recording industry and have featured in legislative and courtroom battles between re-
cording artists and record companies for decades. Today, points of contractual friction are shifting
as artists and companies explore new contracting conventions in response to challenges stemming
from digitalization and the unauthorized distribution of music via the Internet. Where record compa-
nies and recording artists often argued before lawmakers and judges over the allowable duration of
their contracts, they are increasingly concerned with negotiating the contract’s coverage of formerly
off-limits recording artist activities such as touring and merchandising.
Drawing mainly on legislative and judicial documents and trade journal reportage, this article ex-
amines ongoing changes in contracting conventions. It traces late 20
th
century contests over laws
that governed recording contracts, and considers the “360 deal,” the main contractual response to
the early 21
st
century destabilization of the recording industry. The article links the political-
economic logics of contracting under the old and emergent regimes through the lens of primitive
accumulation, a Marxian concept that highlights capitalists’ ongoing drive to overcome legal and/or
traditional limits to the extension of the capital relation (De Angelis, 2004; 2001; Bonefeld, 2001;
Midnight Notes Collective, 1990; Perelman, 2000). It argues that even in the contemporary context
of labor’s increasing casualization, the impetus of cultural capitalists toward contractual capture