
tripleC 9(2): 689-701, 2011
ISSN 1726-670X
http://www.triple-c.at
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Social Networking and Transnational Capitalism
David Kreps
d.g.kreps@salford.ac.uk, Organisations and Society Research Centre, Salford Business School, University of
Salford, Salford, UK
Abstract: Social Networking Sites (SNS) have become a key component of users’ experience of the internet. Whilst much
has been made of the social dynamics of online SNS, the influence of the structures and operations of these sites – and the
business models behind them – on users is rarely accounted for. This paper argues that behind the social behaviours sup-
ported by SNS, there is a growing shift towards viewing online communities as commodities, and SNS as an extension of
mainstream capitalist ideologies fostered by existing patterns of commercialization and consumption. Using the works of
Gramsci, Gill and Hardt & Negri to provide a critical grounding, this paper explores the popular SNS site ‘Facebook’ and
suggests that SNS may feel to the users to be free, social, personal, but in fact SNS are business as usual.
Keywords: Social networking, virtual communities, culture, politics, transnational capitalism
Social Networking Sites (SNS) – especially Facebook – continue to grow, yet the balance be-
tween the technological features of such sites which support social networking and those which
facilitate online advertising remains precarious, and frequently makes national and international
news. Whilst much has been written about the implications of social networks themselves, there
has been little research into the nature and activities of those who develop and maintain the plat-
forms upon which these networks rest. In particular, the venture capital which often seeds the
growth of these sites is often treated as an anonymous and unremarkable part of the process.
This paper seeks to interrogate these aspects of SNS using cultural concepts originally devel-
oped by Antonio Gramsci, recently furthered by post-Gramscians such as Stephen Gill, and set into
a new global context by the ground-breaking work of Hardt and Negri. Gramsci’s cultural reworking
of Marxist understandings of the nature of society, and particularly of capitalist societies, has given
us the notion of hegemony. In the reading of Facebook offered in this paper, this author will further
be positing a poststructuralist view of both the Gramscian and post-Gramscian analysis, influenced
by such authors as Hardt & Negri, and their reformulation of Foucauldian ideas in a political mien.
The first section of the paper introduces Facebook, the most popular social networking site, with
a very brief overview of some of the literature about it and about social networking in general. This
is followed by a section introducing the work of Antonio Gramsci, Stephen Gill, and Hardt & Negri,
connecting Gramsci’s notion of hegemony through more recent analysis of transnational historical
blocs into a more poststructuralist notion of the contemporary distributed Empire of transnational
capitalism. The next section then points out the connections, making it clear that the world of social
networking, far from being the free, new, different and virtual world uncritical analyses persist in
imagining it to be, merely reproduces offline political and social realities online. In the final discus-
sion and conclusion, some thoughts as to what this analysis might teach us about the future devel-
opment of SNS are shared.
1. Facebook
Whilst there has been a fair amount of scholarship concerning SNS, much of it has focused on the
interactions and networking of such sites, and much of the criticism upon the meaning of friendship
there: for example, does competitive ‘friending’ turn these so-called friends into mere cyber-
acquaintances? Such ‘friendliness’ is no substitute for genuine friendship, according to Professor
Ray Pahl, co-author of Rethinking Friendship (Spencer & Pahl, 2006), and only leaves us feeling
dissatisfied. In his opinion, Facebook is a form of immaturity, "It's not a real social network," he