
tripleC 9(2): 551-565, 2011
ISSN 1726-670X
http://www.triple-c.at
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Can Environmental Governance Benefit from ICT-Social
Capital Nexus in Civil Society?
Subas P. Dhakal
Institute for Sustainability and Technology Policy
Murdoch University, Western Australia
subasdhakal@gmail.com
Abstract: Although the potential of Information and Communication Technologies (ICT) to foster social capital in civil soci-
ety has been duly acknowledged, few studies have empirically explored the ICT-social capital nexus in the context of com-
munity organizations. Huysman and Wulf (2004) consider the lack of interest in the area of ‘ICT and social capital’ as worri-
some in today’s increasingly network-centric society. Since the prospect of ICT furthering social capital is simply too signifi-
cant to ignore, this paper responds to this gap by reporting on one aspect of a 2008 survey of environmental community
organizations (ECOs) undertaken to develop a broader understanding of the linkages between organizational social capital
and information and communication technologies in the Perth region of Western Australia. By exploring the trend of ICT
uptake, pattern of intra-organizational as well as inter-organizational interactions, and the association between ICT uptake
and organizational interactions, this paper critically engages in the ‘ICT and social capital’ debate and discusses the implica-
tions of ICT-social capital nexus in the context of environmental governance.
Keywords: Civil society, environmental governance, ICT, social capital
Acknowledgement: This research was conducted within the Australasian CRC for Interaction Design (ACID), which is
established and supported under the Australian Government's Cooperative Research Centres Program. The author is
thankful to Dr. Ian Barns and Dr. Ingrid Richardson of Murdoch University for their incessant guidance during the research
and the leaders of Environmental Community Organizations in Perth who kindly participated in the survey.
1. Introduction
The potential of information and communication technologies (ICT) in transforming the ways civil
society e.g. community organizations shape various societal outcomes, ranging from the recent
political uprising in the Middle East (Dunn, 2011; Ritter & Trechsel, 2011) to the protection of local
environment (Hawken, 2007; Dhakal, 2008) has been increasingly recognised in recent years.
Consequently, although community organizations are not recognized as leaders in adoption of ICT,
policy level as well as pragmatic initiatives to strengthen these organizations from the effective
utilization of ICT has gained momentum in recent decades (Castells, 1997; Burt & Taylor, 1999;
Kvasny & Lee, 2003; DCITA, 2005; Kavanaugh et al., 2007). The premise behind such initiatives is
that ICT can enable a variety of community organizations to function at lower transaction cost as
well as level the playing field between traditional and emerging intermediaries (Bimber, 1998; Ed-
wards, 2006) within environmental governance mechanism.
In the context of community organizations, Pickerill (2001) identifies three particular benefits as-
sociated with the effective utilization of ICT; these include increasing outreach and mobilization
capabilities, fostering social capital (interaction capabilities), and enhancing the repertoire of envi-
ronmental protest capabilities. Nevertheless, the issue of benefits associated with ICT is contested
in the context of social capital. On the one hand, Putnam (2000) fears that excessive reliance on
ICT-mediated interactions (instead of face-to-face interactions) decreases social capital. On the
other hand, Wellman et al. (2001) and Hampton (2003) suggest that by providing an additional
avenue for interactions, ICT-mediated interactions actually supplement social capital. However,
although the potential of ICT to increase the social capital of community organizations has been