tripleC 9(2): 141-153, 2011 145
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
2. Audience Commodity of New Media
Thanks to the rapid advancement of media technologies, media audiences now can enjoy various
kinds of media content and forms. However, using the notion of political economy, media scholars
(e.g., Andrejevic, 2006, 2009; Cohen, 2008; Terranova, 2000; van Dijck, 2009) argue that today’s
most popular websites, including Facebook, YouTube, and Google, lead to the extensive commodi-
fication of their users in diverse ways.
Recent interactive media technologies, such as remote controls, digital video recorders (DVR),
and the Internet, seemed to have transformed media “audiences” into “users” who can control and
even produce the media content they consume to a greater degree than ever before. For example,
thanks to these technologies, media users no longer have to passively view the advertisements
delivered to them along with media content. Therefore, some suggest that these new media tech-
nologies challenge the forced advertisement-viewing assumptions of TV (as reviewed by Carlson,
2006), which was considered to be the basic premise of “labor” under the political economy per-
spective. Ironically enough, however, the more agency media technologies render to users, the
more intensified and diversified is the free labor that users provide to media industries. In other
words, passive advertisement viewing is not the only “commodifiable labor” in modern media indus-
tries because the interactive nature of new media makes it possible to commodify various user
activities, especially the information users produce by such activities.
One notable difference of Web 2.0 from that of traditional media (e.g., television) is that the dis-
tinction between producers and consumers has become obscured. There is no clear cut between
what is being produced and sold on the Internet (Bermejo, 2009). This led to recent controversial
debate on whether or not Smythe (1981)’s audience commodification model can be equally applied
to the new media environment (McQuail, 2010). Unlike most traditional media, Web 2.0 largely
depends on content, information, and even networks that are created and uploaded by users. For
example, media audiences voluntarily produce and distribute self-created media content via You-
Tube, actively input personal information on their MySpace profiles, and construct and display their
social networks on Facebook. Such voluntary and excessive activity performed on the Internet not
only generates sellable personal information but also cultural content, including personal tastes and
preferences, and other forms of user-generated content, from which Internet companies create
capital value (Terranova, 2000) by attaching ads to this content and facilitating market research.
Coté and Pybus (2007) defined such free labor in which “subjects engage in on a cultural and bio-
political level” (p. 90) in social networking sites as “immaterial labour 2.0.” Obviously, in this case,
user labor enters the system much earlier than in traditional media. Because users of social net-
working site are producers and consumers of cultural components that such websites provide, it
can be said that their labor in Web 2.0 begins during, not after, the production and broadcast of
media content (Cohen, 2008).
The interactive nature of the Internet not only requires and encourages users to provide exten-
sive labor for creative activities, but it also facilitates surveillance—the fundamental mechanism of
audience commodification in new media. As mentioned before, interactive websites commodify
socio-cultural components that users voluntarily create and input in almost every activity on social
network sites. Therefore, commercially oriented surveillance of user activity on websites is the most
crucial and fundamental mechanism that enables companies to establish profitable business mod-
els. For instance, Facebook—the most popular social networking site in the United States—
commodifies its user through extensive surveillance (Cohen, 2008). According to Cohen, surveil-
lance enables web service providers not only to aggregate but also render its users’ information for
third-parties so they can perform precisely targeted marketing activities.
In sum, compared to other traditional types of media, the interactive nature of the Internet both
allows for and depends on its users to be engaged in extensive—and perhaps economically ex-
ploitative—uploaded activities from providing personal information to the production of content.
Also, media companies create capital value out of web user activities via the extensive surveillance
that is enabled by current computer technologies. That is, user data generated by interactive activi-
ties on the web are stored in mass storage devices, and then the stored data are processed to