tripleC 9(2): 231-246, 2011
ISSN 1726-670X
http://www.triple-c.at
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Communicative Informatics: An Active and Creative Audi-
ence Framework of Social Media
Linda M. Gallant
1
& Gloria M. Boone
2
1
Linda_Gallant@emerson.edu
2
gboone@suffolk.edu
Abstract: Communicative informatics reflects the interactive complexity of web-based communication and a paradigm shift
away from mass communication. Three discursive spheres (database and information systems, human computer interac-
tion, and active audiences) work together to control online communication openness and its consequences for post-mass
media society’s public common. This has implications for communication freedom, creativity, and constraints in an infor-
mation-based society. Four propositions shed light on how online audience activity is encouraged by and imperative to
corporate interests; how audience creativity can create, accept, or reject messages; how the online audience is monitored;
and how online rhetoric can produce or inhibit public commons. Evidence shows that social media’s corporate interests can
be at odds with online privacy and citizen communication. This tension is explored with a unique focus on rhetoric, argu-
ment, and the communication between audience members and Internet-based corporate media by way of digitized commu-
nication feedback loops.
Keywords: Social Media, Audience, Communication Theory, Rhetoric, Internet, Commoditization, Communicative Informat-
ics, Creativity, Surveillance, Persuasion, User-Generated Content.
Acknowledgement: The authors would like to thank colleagues, reviewers, and editors for comments on this article. This
manuscript is based on a competitively selected paper presented in the Communication and the Future Division of the
National Communication Association, for San Diego, 2008 conference.
1. Introduction
Web-based interactive technologies challenge traditional frameworks for the study of human dis-
course (Kim & Weaver, 2002; LaRose & Eastin, 2004; Parameswaran & Whinston, 2007; Qvortrup,
2006; Steers, Meyer, & Sanchez-Runde, 2008). Researchers such as Benkler (2006; 2000) and
Lessig (2008; 2006; 2005; 2001) presented layered and active/passive audience models to exam-
ine Internet communication from a legal and economic perspective. A complement to these frame-
works is to examine social media using a rhetorical-based approach – communicative informatics.
Benkler states: “We are making regulatory choices at all layers of the information environment –
the physical infrastructure, logical infrastructure, and content layers – that threaten to concentrate
the digital environment as it becomes more central to our social conversation.… An open, free, flat,
peer-to-peer network best serves the ability of anyone – individual, small group, or large group – to
come together to build our information environment. It is through such open and equal participa-
tion” that we will best secure both robust democratic discourse and individual expressive freedom”
(Benkler, 2000, p. 561). Benkler continues to discuss this legal and economic layer model of online
networks in his acclaimed book, The Wealth of Networks. He discusses the enclosures that limit
communication in the Internet commons by ISP liability, regulatory requirements, patents, copy-
right, database protections, and other legal frameworks; and the openness of online communica-
tion provided by wireless networks, free software, W3C, The Creative Commons, and the wide-
spread social disdain for copyright (Benkler, 2006, p.395).
Based on Benkler’s work, Lessig, in The Future of Ideas, uses a layer communication model. He
states: “At the bottom is a ‘physical’ layer, across which communication travels. This is the comput-
er, or wires, that link computers on the Internet. In the middle is a ‘logical’ or ‘code’ layer – the code
that makes the hardware run. Here we might include the protocols that define the Internet and the
software upon which those protocols run. At the top is a ‘content’ layer – the actual stuff that gets
said or transmitted across these wires. Here we include digital images, texts, on-line movies, and
the like. These three layers function together to define any particular communications system. Each
of these layers in principle could be controlled or could be free. Each, that is, could be owned or
232 Linda M. Gallant and Gloria M. Boone
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
each could be organized in a commons” (Lessig, 2001, p. 23). Lessig continues his legal analysis
in his other books: on how code creates a legal pattern for regulation of online communication in
Code 2.0. (2006); the evolution of copyright especially in the music industry in Free Culture (2005);
and the legal differences of Read/Only and Read/Write in his book Remix (2008). In all of these
books Lessig argues for changing copyright laws to allow for more creative expression for non-
commercial use to copy or remix.
By building on the ideas of Benkler and Lessig, one could construct a new layer model of com-
munication that examines the rhetorical content of the active audience; the human computer inter-
action, and database information systems. This model, communicative informatics, focuses on
rhetoric, persuasion, creativity, advertising, and corporate control of communication in social me-
dia.
As noted by Lessig (2004, p. 185), privacy has decreased and creativity on the Internet is not as
free as possible because of regulation. However, creativity has changed in a positive direction –
more than Lessig seems to suggest. One reason is economic. Audience activity and creativity is
needed in order for corporate social media to be profitable.
Although Lessig (2006, p. 83), maintains that the Internet has not fundamentally changed peo-
ple’s lives, other research suggests that life and death decisions can occur due to online heath
persuasion (Gallant, et al, 2010; Gallant, Irizarry, & Boone, 2008).
Livingstone (2006) explains that the passive audience research models of traditional mass me-
dia research centered on the one-way reception of media messages must be replaced by an active
audience research perspective to study online two-way communication. Moreover, scholarship
confirms that online audiences are active users and not passive viewers of media (see, Aibar,
2010; Boone, 2004; Boone & Gallant, 2007; Deuze, 2006; Harrison & Barthel, 2009; Livingstone,
2004). Although theorists and researchers in the 20
th
Century were concerned with one-way mass
communication on target audiences, a new analysis of how corporate-owned social media facili-
tates, monitors, persuades, and influences active audiences and citizenry is needed today.
The communicative informatics model has a unique focus on rhetoric, argument, and the com-
munication by and to the audience. It is a generative model, which explicitly calls attention to digit-
ized communication feedback loops between audience members and Internet-based corporate
media. Three discursive spheres (database and information systems, human computer interaction,
and active audiences) work together to control online communication openness and its conse-
quences for post-mass media society’s public common. Society entered an era of post-mass media
with the creation of the online digitized feedback loop. Audience communication is an automated
two-way form of communication and can be captured, stored, analyzed, and owned by corporate
media companies. The digitized accumulation of private and public communication holds implica-
tions for consumers and citizens since the transparency of audience data use is obscured by laws
protecting proprietary corporate technologies. Communicative informatics reflects the interactive
complexity of web-based communication and is a paradigm shift away from mass communication
which, although still a vital area of study, has been subsumed by new media.
No longer can we understand personal and mass communication without considering the new
multi-channel, multi-directional, multi-modal, and multi-time (synchronous and asynchronous)
communication formats that are processed and analyzed by corporate information systems. Analy-
sis of online communication must integrate two disciplines: human communication and information
sciences. Merging these disciplines provides a more holistic understanding of how database-
driven, post-mass media have an impact on a globally networked society by facilitating human
communication through complex information systems.
To present a new communicative informatics framework, we will: define communicative informat-
ics; describe the three discursive sphere of communicative informatics (information systems and
database analysis of user data, human computer interaction design, and rhetorical communica-
tion); and present four propositions about post-mass media audience. We also will cover how an
active and creative audience is monitored and its implications for public communication and public
commons. Even though governments can control and analyze Internet communication, we primari-
tripleC 9(2): 231-246, 2011 233
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
ly focus our attention on corporate control of online communication to investigate the implications of
commoditizing private and public communication through social media.
2. Communicative Informatics
Communication is the basis of human organizing (Gallant, 2006) and, online, people communica-
tively engage more in cultural production than with any older more passive traditional media
(Benkler, 2006). Globally, social networks and blogs are visited by three-quarters of consumers
who go online worldwide (Nielsen, 2010a) and are the most popular web-based information spaces
when ranked by average time spent online, followed by online games, and instant messaging
(Nielsen, 2010b). Time spent using social media is surpassing online searches as evidenced by
people spending more time on Facebook than in searching on Google (ComScore, 2010). This
increase in social media use by active audience members is unleashing a torrent of user-generated
content. As Siegler (2010) notes: “Every two days now we create as much information as we did
from the dawn of civilization up until 2003…pictures, instant messages, and tweets all add to this.”
Communicative informatics is the formation of online audiences by people’s everyday private
and public communication in a continuously feedback loop between users and organizations
through corporate information systems that store and analyze audience communication. Public
communication is the expression of ideas, messages, or images to many people. Goodnight (1982)
defines the private discursive as informal everyday communication where individuals discuss per-
sonal events and topics that are ephemeral and lack preservation. For the first time in history, the
private discursive, although mediated, is accessed, stored, and analyzed by corporations. The
transitory nature of everyday discourse is transformed to one that is lasting and preserved foremost
by corporate and government interests. Thus, a more complex digitized two-way feedback loop
alters post-mass media audiences as a commodity.
Traditional one-way mass media has been a colonizer of audience “free time” which is sold to
advertisers by media corporations (Jhally, 1990, p. 183-184). This traditional mass media audience
was conceptualized by Smythe (2006, pp. 233-238) as a “commodity audience.” In a post-mass
media society, the commodity audience with rapid online two-way communication is constructed
differently. Mass media communication is a one-way communication to publics and there is a need
to gather public opinion using opinion polls and surveys. These surveys are limited to a small num-
ber of people in the sample and entail a lag time before the data can be analyzed. In contrast, cor-
porations in post-mass media society dig into their databases and analyze public opinion using
people’s online communication with family, friends, and communities in real-time. By data mining
people’s online communication, corporations have an entry into audience communication and its
meanings, which provides vital knowledge for devising persuasive messages influencing people’s
opinions and behaviors. With this shift, we must closely inspect the implications of allowing corpo-
rations to own, analyze, and monetize our private and public communication which together, as
Hauser (2007) contends, encompasses our society’s formal and informal communication patterns
that have an impact on democracy and our public common for communication activities. We define
a public common as space where citizens can freely engage in public communication.
3. Three Discursive Spheres of Communicative Informatics
To better understand the monitoring of online private and public communication, we outline how
three major discursive spheres work together to control online communication openness and its
consequences for post-mass media society’s public common. These spheres of discourse, which
combine human communication and information systems, are depicted in Figure 1.
Sphere 1 (database information systems) is where data information systems facilitate the tech-
nological means of social media to operate, as well as to collect, store, and analyze user data.
Sphere 2 (human computer interaction) is the interface between users and technology devices. If
Spheres 1 and 2 work to provide a high enough level of usability and positive user-experience with
technology interfaces, then Sphere 3 (active audiences) can be enacted and human-to-human
234 Linda M. Gallant and Gloria M. Boone
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
communication can occur in the private and public rhetorical speech situations that are vital to de-
mocracy.
Figure 1: Three spheres of communicative informatics
3.1. Sphere 1: Database Information Systems: Databases, Algorithms, and Feedback Loops
The ownership of online personal communication filtered through corporate databases is a grey
area from a legal standpoint. People provide corporations with personal demographic information,
purchase information, personal dialogues, and opinions. The information gathered in Spheres 2
and 3 is stored in databases in Sphere 1, where it is often invisible to users (see Figure 2). Woo
(2006) posits that the new concept of privacy in the information age is the right to control one’s
personal information. More data inquiry is needed to address how the immediate and unlimited
access to personal and public information by corporations confounds our understanding of the right
to control our personal information and how various communication campaigns (marketing, politi-
cal, and social advocacy), public opinion analysis, and persuasion work in a post-mass media age.
The Internet changes mediated communication feedback loops. Private online communication is
fed into corporate databases from which software programs and algorithms are used to extract and
analyze user data for symbolic meaning patterns. This changes the one-way process of mass me-
dia communication to a two-way process using the Internet as a conduit for feedback loops that
facilitate analysis of audience texts. The new mode of feedback provides an unprecedented win-
dow into audience attitudes and behaviors, the raw materials needed to influence consumers with
marketing campaigns and persuade citizens with political advocacy messages. As a result, there is
a concern about the impact of corporate ownership of information systems (specifically with social
media) on privacy, democracy, and the public common.
In the next section, we provide a fuller inspection of how Sphere 2 (human computer interaction)
holds a dialectical tension. Social media companies must promote ease-of-use to smooth the pro-
gress of user interactions and increase the collection of data; however, ease-of-use is not a priority
for companies if it will result in privacy settings that could diminish data collection.
tripleC 9(2): 231-246, 2011 235
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Figure 2. Feedback Loops. This figure illustrates the types of communication, including behaviors,
that are captured in Spheres 2 and 3 to be fed back to Sphere 1 for surveillance, analysis, and
commoditization. The data are in a continuous loop with information storage and access.
3.2. Sphere 2: Human Computer Interaction
User data is a central commodity of the Internet (Beer & Burrows, 2007; Fuchs, 2009) but what
actions and tasks are allowed by a social media is under the control of corporate owners who can
filter information to and from users. User profiles, as a commodity, increase a social media’s value
when more information is gathered on company databases. Profiles build online identities and pro-
vide demographic information, including geographic locations, demographics, settings, and friend
connections. Identity construction and creativity are important motivational factors for using social
networks such as MySpace and Facebook (Gallant, Boone, & Heap, 2007); thus, people are attitu-
dinally amenable to freely give their information to corporations. Additionally, a person can supple-
ment his or her identity construction with tags, RSS, and mobile tracking, which all increase infor-
mation about user behaviors, habits, likes, and dislikes. Identity is complicated online because
persistence of web-based communication extends the time frame of the speech act; and identity is
searchable, can be replicated, and can be seen by invisible audiences (boyd, 2007). Web-based
media companies need the masses to speak as much as possible in order to grow and increase
profitability.
The interface, or the point of interaction between user and computerized technology, is a major
component in the field of human computer interaction, which promotes theories and practices to
design user-friendly technologies. Thus, in order to raise their market value, for-profit social media
corporations must design human computer interactions to increase user information input into their
databases. Although scholars have stated that the general direction of technology development
and change gives more control to the user (Cover, 2006; Shaw, Hamm, & Knott, 2000), this is, in
part, an illusion of user-control. User-control in social media simply provides more opportunities for
users to give more information to corporations. More pointedly, social media privacy settings, which
236 Linda M. Gallant and Gloria M. Boone
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
can decrease information sharing and communication activities, may be designed to provide less
user-control.
3.2.1. User Profile Privacy – A Contradiction for Ease-of-Use
Making privacy settings visible to users is not to the advantage of social networking sites that de-
pend on gathering user-information as a commodity. As shown in the privacy settings located in
Sphere 2, social networks sites have default privacy settings that favor information sharing. To stop
information sharing, users must physically change their user-profile privacy settings. Even though
socially responsible information systems must be easy to use and transparent in how a user’s per-
sonal data is being used, stored, and transmitted (Fuchs & Obrist, 2010), the usability and infor-
mation architecture paths to privacy settings can be difficult to understand. The comprehension of
website privacy policies and the ability to configure privacy settings by users have been found to be
low, even among computer-literate people or young people (Marwick, Murgia-Diaz, & Palfrey,
2010; Proctor & Vu, 2007). These claims of obfuscation of privacy bear out in the lens of usability
and human computer interaction in Sphere 2. Not only are the meanings of individual privacy set-
tings confusing for users but, as of June 2010, Facebook had 50 privacy settings with more than
170 options (Marks, 2010). Further, Collins (2010) reports that Facebook privacy settings are scat-
tered throughout the website and that privacy settings can be conflicting, which leads Facebook to
automatically choose the least restrictive privacy setting for users.
The popular press frames Facebook as constantly seeking to subvert privacy by changing its
policies and resetting user-profile privacy setting controls back to sharing information with other
users and business partners. The goal of limiting privacy settings by Facebook is to monetize user
information with data mining for targeted marketing (Stone, 2010). Dvorak (2010) points out that
“…Facebook consistently changes the way it operates and constantly resets the privacy settings of
the users to nil, as in NO PRIVACY.” Facebook makes it difficult for average users to find and
change privacy setting to shield personal data (Lyons, 2010).
The dialectical dance of privacy settings in social media is a new way to have power over people
without their conscious consent. The legal liability is placed on individual users to change their set-
tings every time a social network changes its user interface or privacy policies. Placing this respon-
sibility on the user philosophically fits well in an individualized western society, such as the United
States, where, ideologically, personal choice should trump social, corporate, and government con-
trol. Yet, every time privacy settings are changed by a site’s owner, the original privacy a user has
chosen is taken away. Moreover, as this dialectic continues, site owners make changing privacy
settings more difficult and confusing.
Emerging empirical evidence suggests that the uses and gratification that people gain from the
use of social media results in a lax attitude, which outweighs or even ignores any potential risks to
personal privacy concerns (Debatin et al., 2009). Additionally, default setting of all software, includ-
ing web-based, are a social welfare concern (Shah & Kesan, 2008). Nascent, research suggests
that people with lower levels of income and education are less likely to change user default settings
(Shah & Sandvig, 2008). Without privacy settings being explicit and easy to use, individuals could
expose usually held private activity like dieting and sexual behavior to Google searches. “Users of
fitness and calorie tracker Fitbit may need to be more careful when creating a profile on the site.
The sexual activity of many of the users of the company’s tracker and online platform can be found
in Google Search results, meaning that these users’ profiles are public and searchable” (Rao,
2011).
Another user setting, mostly affecting mobile computing, is location awareness. Smart phones
applications, such as restaurant finder Yelp and friend-finder Four Square, log locations and
movements of users. As computing becomes more ubiquitous and entwined in everyday life, user
data on personal and public communication, user consumption behaviors, and physical movements
with geo-tagging and geographic locators, will increase user-information in corporate databases.
Upon analysis, social media companies know users’ physical movements, consumption patterns,
and with whom people meet offline. Overall, users have a choice to either become hyper-conscious
tripleC 9(2): 231-246, 2011 237
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
of checking and managing privacy settings or ignore what the company is doing with these settings
to increase data capture in Spheres 1 and 2 of communicative informatics. Since social media use
is increasing, the unintuitive and hard-to-use privacy settings have not affected usage. This is
counter to the major tenets of usability research. For example, having clear information design that
facilitates high levels of usability promotes ease-of-use and trust in a website and in its owner (Gal-
lant, Irizarry, and Kreps, 2007). For a broad selection of audiences, the uses and gratifications of
social media outweigh the potential distrust in the obscuring of privacy setting tasks. Sphere 3
brings rhetorical communication and the active audience into being online as well as the potential
for public commons.
3.3. Sphere 3: Rhetoric and The Active Audience – Online Public Commons
Audience-centered communication in the age of traditional mass media provided constricted alter-
natives for public communication due to one-way communication in which media broadcasting did
not allow audience interaction and diminished true public space where community members could
interact (Goodnight, 1987, p. 429). In contrast, social media give audiences spaces for interaction
and a platform for rhetorical invention – a key ingredient of persuasion and the democratic pro-
cesses needed for communication in a public common.
Rhetoric, at its basis, is a theory of “public speech” that recognizes the persuasive effects of con-
text upon a speech situation (Arnold, 1992). “Rhetoric may be defined as that discipline which de-
ploys the spoken or the written word to affect an evolution in the knowledge, opinion, or attitude of
an audience” (Purdie, 2003, p. 1142). Rhetoric is any attempt to influence others with words or
images.
The Internet, as a rhetorical context, provides all publics the chance to form public opinion, re-
spond to events, and challenge elite messages (Hauser, 2007). Rhetorical action with its hallmark
of the engaged audience has become more active online through “reading, shopping, voting, play-
ing, researching, writing, and chatting” (Livingstone, 2004, p. 76) and can establish public com-
mons, a rhetorical speech situation that is a vital component of democracy.
Hauser (2007) notes that rhetorical speech situations have three basic types of publics: every-
day,
1
measured
2
(opinion polls), and deliberative.
3
As a mainstay of public debate and democracy,
deliberative communication is defined by people auguring for or against a course of action (Hauser,
2007). Everyday and measured communication both affect deliberative communication as people
advance public arguments (Hauser, 2007). All three forms of communication (everyday, measured,
and deliberative) exist on the Internet and influence public debate and democracy (Hauser, 2007).
Hauser’s (2007) view that the Internet has changed the “formation and expression of public opin-
ion” (p. 338) is widely accepted but we disagree with his statement that the “Internet is not con-
trolled by corporate interests” (p. 338). With Internet monitoring techniques and post-mass media
feedback loops, corporations have unprecedented access and control over private and public
communication. Understanding online communication must focus on the symbolic complexity of
social media (Livingstone, 2006). To this end, we discuss how the centuries-old concept of audi-
ence as a rhetorical process is present in post-mass media with four propositions.
4. The Audience and Four Propositions
In ancient Athens, the audience often had an active role in legislative, judicial, and ceremonial
events. In the direct democratic periods, male citizens made legislative decisions on taxes, spend-
1
Everyday or vernacular communication of the ordinary citizen upholds social bonds and is mainly between family,
friends and acquaintances, whose interaction influences public communication. Ordinary citizen vernacular is often missed
in monitoring of traditional methods of public opinion measurement (Hauser, 2007).
2
Measured communication or public opinion polls have been a mainstay for how corporations, politicians, and govern-
ments gauge audience sentiment in order to construct persuasive messages that shape public policies and consumer con-
sumption patterns.
3
Deliberative communication is defined by people auguring for or against a course of action (Hauser, 2007).
238 Linda M. Gallant and Gloria M. Boone
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
ing, war, or peace through rhetorical action. Any free male citizen could speak, ask questions, de-
bate issues, or shout down a speaker (Boone, 2004; Kennedy, 1963). Juries, composed of several
hundred male citizens, heard arguments in a single day and then rendered their verdicts based on
majority vote. A speaker would use a variety of proofs (pisteis) to appeal to the audience. Aristotle
(1960) stated: “For we have seen that persuasion can be effected only (1) by working on the emo-
tions of the audience (pathos), or (2) by giving the audience the right impression of the speaker’s
character (ethos), or (3) by convincing them all with proof (logos)” (Rhetoric, 1403b). Speakers
would not be effective unless they adapted their arguments to the audience based on proofs. With
user data, social media corporations have increased insights into the proofs (pathos, ethos, and
logos) that can persuade audiences and impact public debate. Four propositions are presented to
clarify how online audience activity is encouraged by and imperative to corporate interests; how
audience creativity can create, accept, or reject messages; how the online audience is monitored;
and how the online rhetorical situation can produce or inhibit public commons.
4.1. Proposition 1: The Audience is Active
The Internet provides an active audience with a communicative platform similar to an ancient polis
where the government is ruled by an active citizenship; however, in post-mass media society cor-
porations control important web-based public communication spaces that can influence democratic
processes. As discussed earlier, online profiles are a central commodity of the Internet. Social me-
dia profiles and online corporate representations signify character (ethos), a major rhetorical proof.
Individuals and corporations can use their ethos to persuade online.
Social media companies promote online political communication. Fuchs (2011) points out that
corporations such as Google have large amounts of money which helps to influence political power
(Fuchs, 2011). For instance, about three-quarters (74%) of U.S. Internet users went online during
the 2008 U.S. election to participate in or get campaign news and information. This represents 55%
of the entire U.S. adult population, and marks the first time the Pew Internet & American Life Pro-
ject have found that more than one-half of the American voting-age population used the Internet to
connect to the political process during the election cycle (Smith, 2009). Scherer & Newton-Small
(2008) state: “For millions of Americans, the Internet has turned presidential politics into a fully
interactive event, a chance to give money with mouse clicks and to volunteer virtually from miles
away.”
More recently and perhaps more telling of social media’s control and filtering of public debate is
President Obama’s Twitter Town Hall, jointly held and sponsored by Twitter and The Whitehouse
on July 6, 2011. The process used to choose questions from Twitter posts to be answered by the
President is representative of a post-mass media process reliant on proprietary algorithms for cor-
porate analysis of user-data. This is different than a traditional mediated town hall because active
audience members do not have to be in the same physical space and corporations act as infor-
mation gatekeepers. Twitter’s CEO Jack Dorsey read 18 Tweets for the President to answer (Jack-
son, 2011). In this example, the process of choosing questions rested largely on Twitter database
algorithms. “For just over an hour, the president answered questions submitted by the public
through Twitter. The questions were selected by Twitter staff, who relied in part on an algorithm
that measured which of thousands of proposed questions were most popular” (Meckler, 2011). A
reported 169,395 tweets were reportedly sent (Dunn, 2011). In April 2011, Facebook hosted a town
hall meeting with President Obama held at the corporation’s Palo Alto, CA, headquarters
(Weisbrod, 2011). The event was moderated by Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg. A small audi-
ence in the room asked the President questions while the event was live web-casted over Face-
book to its users. YouTube also has been part of the social media’s participation in political com-
munication. In January, two days after his State of the Union address, President Obama answered
YouTube users’ questions about his speech (Weisbrod, 2011).
As seen above, social media owned by private companies is being infused into public de-
bate with the potential for them to act as gatekeepers. Unlike traditional mass media and journal-
ism, corporate social media have no professional tenets for reporting public communication. In fact,
tripleC 9(2): 231-246, 2011 239
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
reporting public information is not the main enterprise of social media companies. For these com-
panies to grow and compete against each other for market share, they must drive audience activity
in as many aspects of people’s lives as possible. This includes people’s roles as buyers, reviewers,
and fans on recommendation and review websites (Yelp, Urbanspoon, Citysearch, CNET, and
Epinions), which span interests such as travel, restaurants, and consumer products. As users con-
sume online and offline, they write impressions about and vote on the products and services. The
active audience is an online commodity due to the creation of online audience content that is ana-
lyzed for corporate economic advantage (Fuchs, 2011).
Online audiences are influencing the public rhetoric of the consumption of goods. In turn,
social media companies provide the platform for the communication and have user data to draw on
as a commodity for advertising. Social media corporations continue to encourage more audience
engagement with new ways users can interact and display information. By providing more web-
based applications, especially those that are mobile, companies provide an incentive for people to
continuously supply data. The companies then reap increased economic benefits through advertis-
ing to users (Fuchs, 2011). In mobile computing, users provide data on their geographic locations
in exchange for learning more about their immediate environment in the way of maps, dining rec-
ommendations, finding friends, and historic landmarks. An example of a geographic location tools
friend finder is Four Square, which allows members to use mobile phones to locate friends and
view their recent activity. Overall, active audience members in the roles of consumers, political
actors, citizens, friends, colleagues, and family members provide social media corporations with
large and increasing amounts of insights into user attitudes, behaviors, and consumption patterns.
4.2. Proposition 2: The Audience is Creative
Audiences creatively structure information in the process of rhetorical intervention, which is using
the tools of symbolic meaning systems such as proofs (pathos, ethos, and logos) to communicate
with and influence others. Rhetorical invention, a creative process of developing persuasive mes-
sages for audiences, is a core process in online communication (Boone, 2004). The “first act of
rhetorical invention is to invent the Self” (Medhurst, 2004, p. 569). Sphere 3 gives rise to the medi-
ated rhetorical invention and is infused with social presence, the awareness of other people. Since
people online “have a sense of audience in every mediated conversation, whether on instant mes-
senger or through blog comments” (Marwick & boyd, 2011, p. 115), the online rhetor is conscious
of his or her audience in creating meaningful and persuasive messages as in a traditional rhetorical
situation.
More than depositing demographic information in social media databases, people build rhetorical
texts that expose attitudes and behaviors to corporate interests. Moreover, the argument strategies
that people use with proofs (pathos, ethos, and logos) are readily available to corporate monitoring
and analysis. Based on analysis of user communication, corporations can better target persuasive
marketing or political messages. Additionally, as corporations filter, analyze, and influence user
communication, they become part of the rhetorical invention process by way of the Internet’s digi-
talized post-mass media feedback loop, which continuously links audience communication with
corporate databases. For example, 40% of online advertising allows real time feedback, enabling
marketers to buy known audiences (Economist, 2011). “Click to open a web page and an automat-
ed auction begins. Firms bid to serve an advertisement, taking into account where it will appear
and what they know about the presumed viewer from digital traces he has inadvertently left around
the web. The winner serves the advertisement, often customising [sic] it—so you may see more
ads for convertible cars on a sunny day. The whole process generally takes some 150 millisec-
onds, or less than half the blink of an eye” (Economist, 2011).
Ultimately, the audience decides if the speakers (individuals, organizations, or governments) are
effective. If an audience is influenced by communication, they can act upon it to affect change in
the world (Arnold, 1992). Online rhetorical influence leads people to experience emotions and
make actionable judgments (Segal, 2009). Online audiences through rhetorical creation can sup-
port, resist, rearrange, or ridicule any messages. They can take corporate message sent out to
240 Linda M. Gallant and Gloria M. Boone
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
them in Sphere 2 and bring the corporate communication into Sphere 3, where audiences debate,
discuss, create messages, construct identities, or take action. These rhetorical actions can be posi-
tive, neutral, negative, profound, or superficial; thus, marketing and political messages can be ac-
cepted or rejected. The potential for audiences to carry out communication that has an impact on
social, economic, and political areas begets monitoring.
4.3. Proposition 3: The Audience is Monitored
While scholars have written about the implications of free labor by online users, there is less em-
phasis on how the monitoring and analysis of symbolic meaning patterns can equip corporations
and governments with insights for persuasive messages without warning to users. The audience
has rhetorical freedom with surveillance. Increases in communication freedom leads to less privacy
online because more data are available for monitoring. Many disciplines, such as computer sci-
ence, psychology, computational linguistics, and pedagogy have devoted significant research ef-
forts to studying how users classify information online (Panke & Gaiser, 2009). User-data analysis
is employed by corporations mostly to sell advertising. Global online advertising is an economic
powerhouse and MagnaGlobal (2011) reports it will account for $70.9 billion during 2011 and
$117.5 billion by 2016.
The central corporate surveillance threat on the Internet is online advertising which accumulates
user’s personal data to sell to advertisers (Fuchs, 2011). Online advertising promotes ideological
messages by presenting limited views of reality to audiences (Fuchs, 2011). User analysis is com-
prised from five processes: tagging, search,
4
contextualization,
5
semantic analysis,
6
and behavioral
advertising.
7
The latter four analysis types are indiscernible to online technology users; automated
database-driven analysis techniques are regularly hidden from users in contrast to tagging activity
for which users actively build topical areas and lists.
A critical dilemma with these four discrete analysis types (search, contextualization, semantic
analysis, and behavioral tracking) is that users can be unaware of these processes performed on
their online communication activities. This brings about an illusion of free online communication
that is often unknowingly paid for with users’ private and public communication that is analyzed by
corporations who can develop persuasive messages based on user sentiments and behaviors. The
data-rich push and pull feedback loop between audience members and social media corporations
is shown in Figure 3. As computer algorithms gain more accuracy in analyzing online talk and texts,
the predictive and representational power of surveillance and intelligence on people’s public opin-
ion can increase.
Besides monitoring for commoditization, social media is a platform for tensions in geopolitics.
Globally, governments, often with help from corporate technology partners, impose restrictions on
Internet communication in many ways such as web blocking, censorship, denial of access, infra-
structure control, attacks on exile-run sites, malware attacks, state cybercrime, and Internet kill
switches (O’Brien, 2011). Rhetors through social media have brought visions of war-torn countries
and revolutions in countries such as Tunisia, Egypt, and Libya to web-based and traditional media
4
Search advertising is based on the search terms or phrases that people put into search boxes. This is typical of Google
search. Users receive search results while simultaneously their queries are automatically logged into corporate databases
and attached to users’ profiles and IP addresses.
5
Contextual advertising is an analysis of specific words in a text. Words appearing in an email, chat discussion, or social
media message will be analyzed by an algorithm which deduces what products and their advertisements most closely
match user interests based on words in a text. Advertisements are served-up and displayed on users screens. For instance,
if a message has the word shoes in it, advertisements for shoes will most likely appear on user screens.
6
Semantic analysis, still in its early development stages, applies an algorithm to perform an automated content analysis
of text, which helps to determine topical meaning patterns in data. This is different than analyzing one word like in contextu-
al advertising. Here algorithms are built to distinguish topical sentiments of positive and negative valence in user-generated
unstructured (not tagged) text. This process seeks to identify people’s attitudes and opinions, which are vital to effective
persuasion campaigns.
7
Behavioral advertising is based on tracking users’ behaviors as they move through and across websites. Based on
websites people visit, inferences are made on users’ likely consumption patterns.
tripleC 9(2): 231-246, 2011 241
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
audiences (Etling et al., 2010; Gaystolberg, 2011). During the Iranian student protests in 2009, a
27-year-old student protester was shot and died in the street. A viral Internet video of Neda Agha
Soltan’s death symbolized Iranian protests (see, Barnett, 2009; Fathi, 2009). The video was used
as proof in continued protest, even though Iran continuously blocked Internet connections.
Given the networked and non-linear nature of the Internet, users often get around government
surveillance and blockages, freeing themselves temporarily from limitations. Far more than a pas-
sive media audience, an active and creative audience has the potential to subvert control. Breaking
through constraints with the use of communication is a hallmark of rhetoric, which recognizes the
potential of constitutive power in which communicative action can counter-balance domineering
power (Goodnight, 1987).
4.4. Proposition 4: The Mediated Rhetorical Situation Creates the Public Common
Social media bring about participatory democracy through communicative action (Carty, 2010) and
create a public common for citizens. As people consume and create online content, they actively
identifying audiences and formulate arguments (Beach & Doerr-Stevens, 2009, p. 467; Sheridan &
Hart-David, 2008). If people employ audience identification strategies and argument formation,
there is a keen awareness of online audience presence and the potential for deliberative communi-
cation and a public common, a hallmark of the democratic process. Deliberative democracy can
occur online (see, Maynor, 2009; Schlosberg, Zavestoski, & Shulman, 2007; Vromen, 2008) and
with any deliberative communication, there must be an accounting for power relationships (Dahl-
berg, 2007). Deliberative communication is affected by how open and free communication is in a
society. Social media platforms can affect filtering of communication and the degree of communica-
tion openness in a public common. See Figure 3.
242 Linda M. Gallant and Gloria M. Boone
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Figure 3. Openness of social media platform as a public common. The complexity of post-mass
media is depicted through: the increased feedback loops of pull and push data; user data collection
and analysis in databases; message generation by people and corporations; and how open or lim-
ited communication can be based on tasks allowed by a technological design.
The degree of communication openness in social media is used not only for business strategy but
also for political and governmental power, which sometimes leads to control and shutting down
online public communication. Political censorship online with the help of social media companies
diminishes free access to online communication. Corporation such as Google, Yahoo!, and Mi-
crosoft bend to pressures of governments to monitor and filter communication in order to conduct
business within certain countries. For instance in order to continue conducting business in China,
Google cedes to China’s demand to censor Internet searches to comply with government sanc-
tioned websites (Hoffman, 2010). A Paris-based humanitarian group, Reporters Without Borders,
has criticized Google, Yahoo!, and Microsoft, for censoring Internet searches and communication
for governments such as China and Egypt (MacMillan, 2009). The censorship extends beyond
governmental requests. Yahoo! and Google are increasingly censoring Internet searches and web-
site linking for entertainment industries (TorrentFreak, 2011). Censorship is part of social media
business practices. Governments also repress Internet activity by shutting down Internet access.
This was seen when the Egyptian government of Hosni Mubarak shut down ISPs to prevent the
continued organization of protest rallies and to prevent news of protests getting out of the country
(Mitra, 2011).
Some companies battle with governments who seek information to combat crime. The tension
between corporate social media control over user data and privacy is exacerbated when govern-
mental agencies ask Internet companies to provide user data to monitor crimes. Such is the case
with sex trade and slavery. Facebook and Google have joined forces legally against the French
government. The French group Association of Internet Community Services, established in 2007 by
AOL, Dailymotion, Google, and Yahoo has sought to fight the French government’s regulations on
the retention of users’ personal data such as passwords, e-mails, addresses, and telephone num-
bers (Whitney, 2011). Social media corporations resist attempts by governments to have access to
user data for criminal investigations. When they can battle for user privacy against governments,
corporations frame themselves as protectors of public privacy. Corporations need to protect data
privacy only for economic gains. When people perceive technologies as untrustworthy, they are
less likely to use them (Gallant, Irizarry, and Kreps, 2007). If users believe the use of a social me-
dia can be used in police investigations, they might be less willing to use the technology.
The dialectical tension between censorship and open Internet access will continue to have impli-
cations for public communication. Collecting and storing user data for economic gain while sup-
pressing the use of the same data for a public potential good such as criminal investigations, plac-
es interactive media companies at the core of an Internet age’s dilemma, which is who owns the
online public common. When social media companies provide a “public common,” the active audi-
ence’s communication is, at least in part, owned and filtered by the corporations. When Internet
companies shut down access to parts of the Internet for certain countries, people do not have a full
range of rhetorical proofs to engage in open communication. Thus, online audiences can draw only
on information supplied through Internet censorship based on political or business goals.
5. Conclusion
Social media are a platform for personal and public rhetoric where individuals, groups, corpora-
tions, governments and social movements attempt to influence people and the public. The use of
social media shows social bonds; whether, people are in agreement or dissention such as in politi-
cal communication, product uses, or health advocacy communication. In social media people talk
about everything from everyday events to persuasion about personal and public matters of im-
portance. Communicative informatics as a rhetorical framework examines how three discursive
spheres (database and information systems, human computer interaction, and active audiences)
tripleC 9(2): 231-246, 2011 243
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
operate in post-mass media society. Meanings are not determined by technology. Rather, it is the
active audience in communication with its members and communication filtered by social media
companies that use, expand, and sometimes change, the original intent of messages.
User-generated content can be monitored as never before in real-time by corporations and gov-
ernments. The private and public information learned from online audiences holds potential for
promoting open debate and understanding in society and also manipulation and surveillance of
public communication filtered through organizational databases. It is a tension pitting a utopian
open communication model against a dystopian perspective, which warns of surveillance and pri-
vacy invasion. In an open model, people produce culture online in the free flow of user-generated
texts. Contrasting this is the enclosure of the public’s information in corporate databases where
dystopian invasion of privacy and social surveillance are realized in the tracking, storage, and anal-
ysis of socially-produced online communication. Four propositions (the audience is active; the au-
dience is creative; the audience is monitored; and the mediated rhetorical situation creates the
public common) are presented to clarify how online audience activity is encouraged by and impera-
tive to corporate interests; how audience creativity can create, accept, or reject messages; how the
online audience is monitored; and how the online rhetorical situation can produce or inhibit public
commons.
We need continued examination of corporate and government trends that promote or impinge on
online communication freedom essential in identifying democratic freedoms in a post-mass media
era. More specifically, research is needed in this area with an eye on how post-mass media can
influence deliberative communication and have an impact on the public common to better under-
stand how freedom of speech in post-mass media can be a commoditized and controlled for corpo-
rate and political power. This is important in an era where, as Fuchs (2011) points out, corporations
such as Google have large amounts of money which helps to influence political power (Fuchs,
2011). This process is indicative of what Fuchs (2009) describes as the well-established “social
struggles over the public or private character of information” (p. 80).
Questions for the future might look to how the tensions between web-based speech and its sur-
veillance can affect individual privacy, crime fighting, public debate, and public advocacy. Future
research could empirically examine if online communication has shifted the western concept of
privacy. For this to be undertaken, research would first need to investigate people’s awareness
level of online monitoring. Once people are aware, what is their view of being monitored online?
Secondly, whether or not social media users care if their communication is under surveillance by
organizations and governments should be determined. Do people want the right to be left alone as
traditional privacy laws dictate or, as Woo (2006) theorizes, is the new definition of privacy the right
to be anonymous? Other future research could examine what social media systems have higher
levels of creativity, higher levels of discourse, or different levels of influence. What rhetorical tech-
niques are used by different types of online audiences? A rhetorical viewpoint would examine the
arguments, emotional terms, the credibility of different rhetors, and the responses of different audi-
ences who use social media.
References
Aibar, E. (2010). A critical analysis of information society conceptualizations from an STS point of view. Triple-C: Cognition,
Communication, Cooperation, 8(2), 177-182.
Aristotle. (1960). The rhetoric of Aristotle. (L. Cooper, Trans.). Englewood Cliffs, NY: Prentice Hall.
Arnold, C. C. (1992). Oral rhetoric, rhetoric, and literature. Philosophy & Rhetoric, Supplement, 25, 48-67.
Barnett, R. (2009). ‘Shot Girl’ In Video Named On Mousavi Site. Sky News. Retrieved on July 27, 2011 from
http://news.sky.com/skynews/Home/World-News/Neda-Woman-Allegedly-Killed-In-Iran-Protests-Named-As-Neda-
Agha-Soltan-On-Mousavi-Facebook-Page/Article/200906415314153
Beach, R., & Doerr-Stevens, C. (2009). Learning argument practices through online role-play. Toward a rhetoric of signifi-
cance and transformation. Journal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy, 52(6), 460-468.
Beer, D., & Burrows, R. (2007). Sociology and, of and in Web 2.0: Some Initial Considerations. Sociological Research
Online, 12(5), Retrieved on March 27, 2011 from http://www.socresonline.org.uk/12/5/17.html
Benkler, Y. (2000) From consumers to users: Shifting the deeper structures of regulation toward sustainable commons and
user access. Federal Communications Law Journal, 52(3), 561- 579.
244 Linda M. Gallant and Gloria M. Boone
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Benkler, Y. (2006). The wealth of networks: How social production transforms markets and freedom. New Haven, CT: Yale
University Press.
Boone, G. (2004). How the rhetorical tradition informs web design, information architecture and usability. International Jour-
nal of the Humanities, 2(3), 2223-2228.
Boone, G. M., & Gallant, L. M. (2007, July). Active, creative and monitored: The audience transformed in online media.
International Association for Media and Communication Research. Conference conducted at the meeting of IAMCR in
association with UNESCO, Paris.
boyd, danah. (2007). Why youth (heart) social network sites: The role of networked publics in teenage social life. In D.
Buckingham (Eds.), Youth, identity, and digital media volume. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Carty, V. (2010). New information communication technologies and grassroots mobilization. Information, Communication &
Society, 13(2), 155-173.
comScore. (2010, September 9). Facebook inches past Google for Web users' minutes. Retrieved on September 10, 2010
from http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5jxi8CbGDQ2gGetuc2d5Nz-RoK76gD9I4QAH82
Collins, J. C. (2010). Fortify your Facebook settings: Don’t let the window into your personal life sully your professional
reputation. Journal of Accountancy, June, 42-44.
Cover, R. (2006). Audience inter/active: Interactive media, narrative control and reconceiving audience history. New Media
& Society, 8(1), 139-158.
Dahlberg, L. (2007). The Internet, deliberative democracy, and power: Radicalizing the public sphere. International Journal
of Media and Cultural Politics, 3(1): 47-64.
Debatin, B., Lovejoy, J. P., Horn, A., & Hughes, B. N. (2009). Facebook and online privacy: Attitudes, behaviors, and unin-
tended consequences. Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication, 15(1), 83-108.
Deuze, M. (2006). Participation, remediation, bricolage: Considering principal components of a digital culture. The Infor-
mation Society, 22(2), 67-75.
Dunn, M. (2011). Recap of Obama’s Twitter town hall meeting. Digital trends. Retrieved on July 7, 2011 from
http://www.digitaltrends.com/social-media/recap-of-obamas-twitter-town-hall-meeting/
Dvorak, J. C. (2010). Why Facebook privacy settings don't matter. PC Magazine, 29(7), 1. Retrieved on March 27, 2011
from http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2365866,00.asp
Economist. (2011, May 5). Mad Men are watching you: How real-time bidding will affect media companies. Retrieved on
July 27, 2011 from http://www.economist.com/node/18651104
Etling, B., Kelly, J., Faris, R., & Palfrey, J. (2010). Mapping the Arabic blogosphere: Politics and dissent online. New Media
& Society, 12(8), 1225-1243.
Fathi, N. (2009). In a death seen around the world, a symbol of Iranian protests. New York Times. Retrieved on July 27,
2011 from http://www.nytimes.com/2009/06/23/world/middleeast/23neda.html
Fuchs, C. (2009). Information and communication technologies & society: a contribution to the critique of the political econ-
omy of the Internet. European Journal of Communication, 24 (1), 69-87.
Fuchs, C. (2011). Web 2.0, prosumption, and surveillance. Surveillance & Society, 8(3), 288-309.
Fuchs, C. & Obrist, M. (2010). HCI and society: towards a typology of universal design principles. International Journal of
Human-Computer Interaction, 26(6), 638-658.
Gallant, L.M., Irizarry, C., Boone, G.M., & Ruiz-Gordon, B. (2010). Spanish content on hospital websites: An analysis of
U.S.hospitals’ in concentrated Latino communities. Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication, 15(4), 552-574.
Gallant, L.M., Irizarry, C., & Boone, G.M. (2008). Chapter XV: Exploring the Technology Adoption Needs of Patients Using
E-Health. In Wilson, E. V. (Ed.), Patient-Centered E-Health, (pp. 201-216). Hershey, PA: Information Science Refer-
ence (IGI Global).
Gallant, L. M., Boone, G. M., & Heap, A. (2007). Five heuristics for evaluating Web-based communities. First Monday,
12(3). Retrieved September 26, 2010 from http://firstmonday.org/article/view/1626/1541
Gallant, L.M., Irizarry, C., & Kreps, G. (2007). User-centric hospital websites: A case for trust and personalization. e-Service
Journal, 5(2), 5-26.
Gallant, L. M. (2006). An ethnography of communication approach to mobile product testing. Personal and Ubiquitous Com-
puting, 10(5), 325-332.
Gaystolberg, S. (2011). Shy U.S. intellectual created playbook used in a revolution. New York Times. Retrieved May 1,
2011 from http://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/17/world/middleeast/17sharp.html?_r=2&hp=&pagewanted=all
Goodnight, G. T. (1987). Public discourse. Critical Studies in Media Communication, 4, 428-431.
Harrison, T., & Barthel, B. (2009). Wielding new media in Web 2.0: Exploring the history of engagement with the collabora-
tive construction of media products. New Media and Society, 11(1), 155-178.
Hauser, G. A. (2007). Vernacular discourse and the epistemic dimension of public opinion. Communication Theory, 17(4),
333-339.
Herold, D. K. (2010). Imperfect use? ICT provisions and human decisions: An introduction to the special issue on ICT adop-
tion and user choices. Information Society, 26(4), 243-246.
Hoffman, S. (2010). Google caves to China: Halts Hong Kong search redirect. CRN. Retrieved on July 27, 2011 from
http://www.crn.com/news/applications-os/225701843/google-caves-to-china-halts-hong-kong-
searchredirect.htm;jsessionid=up-kQx4ukCQSuYAiSsfrLg**.ecappj03
Jackson, D. (2011). Obama welcomes Twitter to White House. USA Today. Retrieved on July 14, 2011 from
http://content.usatoday.com/communities/theoval/post/2011/07/obama-welcomes-twitter-to-white-
house/1?csp=34news
Jhally, S. (1990). The codes of advertising: Fetishism and the political economy of meaning in the consumer society. New
York: Routledge.
Kennedy, G. (1963). The art of persuasion in Greece. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Kim, S. T., & Weaver, D. (2002). Communication research about the internet: A thematic meta-analysis. New Media &
Society, 4(4), 518-538.
tripleC 9(2): 231-246, 2011 245
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
LaRose, R., & Eastin, M. S. (2004). A social cognitive theory of Internet uses and gratifications: Toward a new model of
media attendance. Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media, 48(3), 358-377.
Lessig, L. (2001). The Future of Ideas. New York: Random House.
Lessig, L. (2006). Code 2.0. New York: Basic Books.
Lessig, L. (2005). Free Culture: The Nature and Future of Creativity. New York: Penguin Books.
Lessig, L. (2008). Remix. New York: Penguin.
Livingstone, S. (2004). The challenge of changing audiences: Or, what is the audience researcher to do in the age of the
Internet? European Journal of Communication, 19(1), 75-86.
Livingstone, S. (2006). Drawing conclusions from new media research: Reflections and puzzles regarding children's experi-
ence of the internet. The Information Society, 22(4), 219-230.
Lyons, D. (2010). The high price of Facebook. Newsweek, 155(21/22), 22. Retrieved on March 27, 2011 from
http://www.newsweek.com/2010/05/15/the-high-price-of-facebook.html
MacMillan, D. (2009). Google, Yahoo Criticized Over Foreign Censorship. Bloomberg Businessweek. Retrieved on July 27,
2011, from http://www.businessweek.com/technology/content/mar2009/tc20090312_381922.htm
MagnaGlobal (2011). 2011 advertising forecast. Retrieved on July 27, 2011, from http://www.magnaglobal.com/wp-
content/uploads/downloads/2010/12/2011-MAGNAGLOBAL-Advertising-Forecast-Abbreviated.pdf
Marks, P. (2010). Social networks must heed the human element. New Scientist, 206(2763), 9.
Marwick, A. E., & boyd, d. (2011). I tweet honestly, I tweet passionately: Twitter users, context collapse, and the imag-
inedaudience. New Media Society, 13(1), 114-133.
Marwick, A. E., Murgia-Diaz, D. & Palfrey, J. G. (2010) Youth, privacy and reputation (Literature Review). Berkman Center
Research Publication No. 2010-5; Harvard Public Law Working Paper No. 10-29. Retrieved November 2, 2010 from
http://ssrn.com/abstract=1588163
Maynor, J. W. (2009). Blogging for democracy: Deliberation, autonomy, and reasonableness in the blogosphere. Critical
Review of International Social and Political Philosophy, 12(3), 443-468.
Meckler, L. (2011). Obama Takes Twitter Queries: President Fields Public Questions on Issues Including Economy and
Debt Ceiling. The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved on July 7, 2011 from
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702303544604576430082812040322.html?mod=googlenews_wsj
Medhurst, M. J. (2004). Filled with the spirit: Rhetorical invention and Pentecostal tradition. Rhetoric & Public Affairs, 7(4),
555-572.
Mitra, K. (2011). 21st Century Revolution. Business Today, 20(5), 119.
Nielsen Company. (2010a). Social networks/blogs now account for one in every four and a half minutes online. Retrieved on
June 20, 2010 from http://blog.nielsen.com/nielsenwire/online_mobile/social-media-accounts-for-22-percent-of-time-
online/
Nielsen Company. (2010b). Led by Facebook, Twitter, global time spent on social media sites up 82% year over year. Re-
trieved on January 24, 2010 from http://blog.nielsen.com/nielsenwire/global/led-by-facebook-twitter-global-time-spent-
on-social-media-sites-up-82-year-over-year/
O’Brien, D. (2011). The 10 tools of online oppressors. CJP: Committee to protect journalists. Retrieved on May 2, 2011 from
http://www.cpj.org/reports/2011/05/the-10-tools-of-online-oppressors.php
Panke, S., & Gaiser, B. (2009). “With my head up in the clouds”: Using social tagging to organize knowledge. Journal of
Business and Technical Communication, 23(3), 318-349.
Parameswaran, M., & Whinston, A. B. (2007). Research issues in social computing. Journal of the Association for Infor-
mation Systems, 8(6), 336-350.
Proctor, R. W., & Vu, K. (2007). A multimethod approach to examining usability of Web privacy policies and user agents
forspecifying privacy preferences. Behavior Research Methods, 38(2), 205-211.
Purdie, D. W. (2003). Classical Greek and Roman rhetoric and the modern audience. Medical Education, 37(12), 1141-
1144.
Qvortrup, L. (2006). Understanding new digital media: Medium theory or complexity theory? European Journal of Communi-
cation, 21(3), 345-356.
Rao, L. (2011). Sexual activity tracked by Fitbit shows up in Google search results. Retrieved on July 27, 2011 from
http://techcrunch.com/2011/07/03/sexual-activity-tracked-by-fitbit-shows-up-in-google-search-results/
Scherer, M., & Newton-Small, J. (2008). Why Democrats rule the web. Time. Retrieved on April 22, 2008 from
http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1731879,00.html
Schlosberg, D., Shulman S., & Zavestoski, S. (2007). Democracy and e-rulemaking: Web-based participation and the po-
tential of deliberation. Journal of Information Technology and Politics, 4(1), 37-55.
Segal, J. Z. (2009). Internet health and the 21st-Century
patient: A rhetorical view. Written Communication, 26(4), 351-369.
Siegler, M. (2010). Eric Schmidt: Every 2 days we create as much information as we did up to 2003 tech crunch. Retrieved
on April 20, 2011 from http://techcrunch.com/2010/08/04/schmidt-data/
Shah, R. C., & Kesan, J. P. (2008). Setting online policy with software defaults. Information, Communication & Society,
11(7), 989-1007.
Shah, R. C., & Sandvig, C. (2008). Software default as de facto regulation: The case of the wireless internet. Information,
Communication & Society, 11(1), 25-46.
Shaw, D. L., Hamm, B. J., & Knott, D. L. (2000). Technology change, agenda challenge and social melding: Mass media
studies and the four ages of place, class, mass, and space. Journalism Studies, 1(1), 57-79.
Sheridan, D. M., & Hart-David, W. (2008). Just for fun: Writing and literacy learning as forms of play. Computers and Com-
position, 25(3), 323-340.
Smith, A. (2009, April 15). The internet's role in campaign 2008. Retrieved April 16, 2009 from
http://pewresearch.org/pubs/1192/internet-politics-campaign-2008
Smythe, D. W. (2006). On the audience commodity and its work. In M.G. Durham and D.M. Kellner (Eds.), Media and Cul-
tural Studies Key Works (pp. 230-256). Malden, MA: Blackwell.
246 Linda M. Gallant and Gloria M. Boone
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Steers, R. M., Meyer, A. D., & Sanchez-Runde, C. J. (2008). National culture and the adoption of new technologies. Journal
of World Business, 43(3), 255-260.
Stone, B. (2010). Sell your friends. Bloomberg Businessweek; 64-72. Retrieved on March 27, 2011 from
http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/content/10_40/b4197064860826.htm
TorrentFreak (2011). Yahoo! Messenger censors FilesTube links. TorrentFreak. Retrieved on July 27, 2011, from
http://torrentfreak.com/yahoo-messenger-censors-filestube-links-110329/
Vromen, A. (2008). Building virtual spaces: Young people, participation and the internet. Australian Journal of Political Sci-
ence, 43(1), 79-97.
Weisbrod, E. (2011). Obama and social media. CNN. Retrieved on July 14, 2011 from
http://whitehouse.blogs.cnn.com/2011/07/06/obama-and-social-media/
Whitney, L. (2011, April 6). Net trade group protests French data retention rules. CNET News. Retrieved on March 27, 2011
from http://news.cnet.com/8301-1009_3-20051320-83.html
Woo, J. (2006). The right not to be identified: Privacy and anonymity in the interactive media environment. New Media &
Society, 8(6), 949-967.
About the Authors
Linda M. Gallant, Ph.D.
is an assistant professor and graduate director in the department of communication studies at Emerson College. Having
professional experience in usability and a Ph.D. in communication, Gallant brings a trans-disciplinary background to the
burgeoning areas of user-experience design and social media. Specifically, she investigates how new media facilitate hu-
man communication by investigating Internet-based technologies as social artifacts. A central interest in her research and
teaching is how a technology's design and development (information architecture, usability, and rhetorical strategies) has an
impact on its social and cultural uses, especially public communication. She is published in Journal of Computer-Mediated
Communication, Personal and Ubiquitous Computing, Qualitative Research Reports in Communication, First Monday, and
e-Service Journal.
Gloria M. Boone, Ph.D.
is a professor of communication at Suffolk University in Boston, Massachusetts. Her research focuses on new media, espe-
cially social media, for different demographic groups and how people respond and manipulate technology for their own
needs and desires. As a classically trained rhetorician, she believes that the arts and the humanities inform new develop-
ments in web design, technology, and communication. Boone is published in leading communication journals such as the
Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication, Journal of Communication and Religion, and Public Relations Review. Her
research also is in interdisciplinary international journals such as Revista DOXA Comunicacion: Revista Interdisciplinar de
estudios de Comunicacion y Ciencias Sociales, and the International Journal of the Humanities. Her website is
http://infoacrs.com