
130 Francesca Musiani
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
completely theorized, technologically unbounded, and, potentially, legally unrestrained” (Katyal,
2005, p. 227). As Frances Grodzinsky and Herman Tavani (2005) point out, surveillance has taken
on such a prominent role in the debate at the crossroads of privacy, property and expression be-
cause when the burden was first placed on copyright owners to identify infringers on the network,
this legitimized somehow the rise of “an entire new industry that has content owners searching the
Internet for potential infringers” (Grodzinsky & Tavani, 2005, p. 247).
This “new surveillance”, as Katyal labels it, implies fundamental alterations of intellectual prop-
erty rights, from defensive shield into offensive weapon, in order to record consumer activity and
possibly enforce particular standards of use and expression, while proscribing activities deemed
unacceptable; thus, the conflict between privacy and piracy is important not just as a showcase of
an overlooked mode of surveillance, but also as a demonstration of the need to resolve conflicts
between them in ways that reflect and protect the relationship between modern technology and
personal freedoms (Katyal, 2004).
Along the same lines, Niva Elkin-Koren remarks (2006) that the interrelationship between law
and technology often focuses on one single aspect, the challenges that emerging technologies
pose to the existing legal regime, creating a need for legal reform; juridical measures involving
technology both as a target of regulation and as a means of enforcement should, however, take
into account that the law does not merely respond to new technologies, but also shapes them and
may affect their design (Elkin-Koren, 2006, p. 15). Surveillance systems that fail to take this into
account are likely to re-shape the technology in ways that diminish or impede their potential for
socio-economic benefits (Elkin-Koren, 2006, p. 21), or sacrifice the most valuable aspects of cy-
berspace, extracting from it fundamental principles of informational privacy for the sake of unlimited
control (Katyal, 2004; 2005).
While this conception of surveillance is not entirely attributable to the development of P2P tech-
nologies, or to the explosion of “cyberspace piracy” mostly through the use of file-sharing P2P
tools, it is especially well illustrated within this domain as a representative of the “paradoxical” na-
ture of the Internet, that “both enables and silences speech, often simultaneously” by offering “both
the consumer and creator a seemingly endless capacity for human expression (…) alongside an
insurmountable array of capacities for panoptic surveillance” (Katyal, 2005, p. 228). Privacy-related
issues concerning P2P networking illustrate this point well. Users of P2P networks share idle com-
puting resources such as free bandwidth, storage space, and computing power, and provide the
system infrastructure itself, which makes P2P systems “the economically and technologically opti-
mal vehicles for digital content distribution” (Wood, 2010, p. 6), less vulnerable to bandwidth restric-
tions and more scalable. This also means, however, direct access to the data packets in a peer’s
data stream by other peers, and therefore, that the data stream may be compromised by the other
peers in the network that are contributing to the very process of data transmission (Musiani, 2010).
So, users need to have some knowledge about the software they are using, and they need to be
aware of what types of materials and information are being shared (or those they do not want to
share), as it is “quite possible to share the entire hard drive, including sensitive information such as
mailbox and private documents” (Suvanto, 2005). The direct connection between the peers also
implies, in many cases, that in order for the connection to be established, the P2P file sharing soft-
ware needs information such as their IP address. In some of the first, most popular P2P file sharing
systems, this address has been used openly and directly exposed, thus raising anonymity prob-
lems (Suvanto, 2005). It is no surprise, then, that in order to counter such weaknesses, and their
exploitation by whatever entity willing to tamper with the stability and integrity of the network, more
recent P2P developments have been moving in two directions, content encryption and improved
anonymity (Li, 2007; Musiani, 2010).
The deployment of pervasive surveillance measures with the aim to ensure liability and respon-
sibility for a specific type of P2P traffic – measures constantly evolving and changing in parallel with
P2P tools themselves – can account for many of the most important steps in the genealogy of P2P
file sharing systems. How this has unfurled over the last ten years, and why it is relevant to under-
stand the ongoing, increasing privatization of P2P networks, is the subject of the next section.