• On November 20
th
, the Dow Jones Industrial Average closed at 7,552.29 points, which was the
lowest value in six years.
• On December 19
th
, the US government approved a bailout of 13 billion US$ for Chrysler and
General Motors.
• On January 19
th
, 2009, the Royal Bank of Scotland made public that it made the largest losses
in UK history in 2008. The results were huge share losses of UK banks.
• On March 9
th
, 2009, the Dow Jones closed at 6,469.95 points, the lowest value since April 1997.
There is a group of authors that argues that the crisis is a result of regulation failures and de-
regulated finance markets (Gowan, 2009; Stiglitz, 2008, 2009, 2010; Krugman, 2009) and another
group of authors that argues that the crisis is a systemic and structural crisis of capitalism caused
by structural crisis tendencies inherent in the capitalist system and the stagnation of wages resul-
ting from the class struggle fought by economic and financial elites against the working class (Bis-
choff, 2008; Brenner, 2009; Callinicos, 2010; Foster and Magdoff, 2009; Hardt & Negri, 2009; Har-
man, 2010; Harvey, 2009, 2010; Lapavitsas, 2009; Moseley, 2009; Wolff, 2008). Depending on
which of these two analyses one shares, there will be different policy conclusions. The first group of
authors argues that a more regulated, neo-Keynesian economy is needed, in which especially fi-
nancial speculation is controlled, the second group of authors says that the crisis shows that capi-
talism is inherently creating misery through crisis and therefore needs to be replaced by a system
of participatory grassroots socialism. Notwithstanding which position one takes, it is interesting to
observe how most hardcore neoliberal politicians, journalists, managers, bankers, and financial
consultants turned there back on Friedrich August von Hayek and Milton Friedman over night and
suddenly emerged as neo-Keynesians (many of them even claimed that they had always been
Keynesians).
It is not an unrealistic possibility, but – given for example the latest election results in Europe,
which do not signify a shift towards the political left, but towards the political right – rather a quite
likely political development, that the capitalist crisis will work, as Naomi Klein (2007) says, as a
shock doctrine that ideologically legitimates the establishment of even more brutal forms of capi-
talism. “That is how the shock doctrine works: the original disaster – the coup, the terrorist attack,
the market meltdown, the war, the tsunami, the hurricane – puts the entire population into a state of
collective shock. The falling bombs, the bursts of terror, the pounding winds sere to soften up the
whole societies much as the blaring music and blows in the torture cells soften up prisoners. Like
the terrorized prisoner who gives up the names of comrades and renounces his faith, shocked
societies often give up things they would otherwise fiercely protect” (Klein, 2007, p. 17). But the
resurgence of neoliberalism and capitalism is only one possible outcome of the crisis. Authors like
Slavoj Žižek (2009a, 2010) remind us that ideology plays a role in the reactions to crises, but that
there are at the same time potential alternatives.
The current crisis is not simply a crisis of finance or a housing crisis, but a crisis of capitalism.
Žižek (2010) suggests in this context in his book Living in the end times that capitalism is in crisis
and “is approaching an apocalyptic zero-point. Its ‘four riders of the apocalypse’ are comprised by
the ecological crisis, the consequences of the biogenetic revolution, imbalances within the system
itself (problems with intellectual property: forthcoming struggles over raw materials, food and wa-
ter), and the explosive growth of social divisions and exclusions” (Žižek, 2010, p. x). Whereas in
Living in the end times, Žižek does not engage in a deeper analysis of this crisis and the common
features of the four dimensions, he has pointed out in other publications that the crisis has to do
with the exploitation of the commons: Zižek (2009a, b) says that the privatization and exploitation of
the commons of culture, external nature, and internal nature, and the exclusions of humans from
wealth dispossesses them of the foundations of life, it “renders us all proletarians”, who are “in
danger of losing everything” (Zižek, 2009a, p. 92). Žižek (2010) applies Elisabeth Kübler-Ross’s
five stages of grief (denial, anger, bargaining, depression, acceptance) to capitalist crisis-reactions.
Although it is problematic to suggest, as Žižek does, that reactions to the crisis run subsequently
through stages and thereby go from ideological denial via anger, attempted reforms, and depres-
sion after failed reforms, towards a new beginning, he makes an important point when suggesting