tripleC 8(2): 121-123, 2010
ISSN 1726-670X
http://www.triple-c.at
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010.
3rd ICTs and Society Meeting; Paper Session - Theorizing
the Internet; Paper 1: Toward Trust as Result. A Transdis-
ciplinary Research Agenda for the ‘Future Internet’
1
Stefano De Paoli,
2
G. R. Gangadharan,
1
Aphra Kerr,
3
Vincenzo
D’Andrea,
4
Martin Serrano,
4
Dmitri Botvich,
4
Jimmy McGibney
1
National University of Ireland, Maynooth, Sociology Department, Maynooth, Ireland
{stefano.depaoli, aphra.kerr}@nuim.ie
2
Politecnico di Milano, Department of Electronics and Informatics, Milan, Italy
gangadharan@elet.polimi.it
3
University of Trento, Department of Engineering and Computer Science and Department of Sociology,
Trento, Italy vincenzo.dandrea@unitn.it
4
Waterford Institute of Technology, Telecommunications Software and Systems Group. ArcLabs Ireland,
West Campus, Waterford, Ireland
{jmserrano, dbotvich}@tssg.org
Abstract: Trust has emerged as one of the key challenges for the Future Internet and as a key theme of European re-
search. We are convinced that a transdisciplinary research agenda - that we define to as Trust as Result - shared by Soci-
ology and Computer Science, is of paramount importance for devising sustainable Trust solutions for the (Future) Internet
stakeholders. The scope of this paper is to present some elements we consider important for building such an agenda.
Keywords: Trust, Future Internet, Trust Modelling, Trust as Result, Assemblage
Acknowledgement: The work by Stefano De Paoli, Aphra Kerr, Martin Serrano and Dmitri Botvich has received support
from the Higher Education Authority (HEA) in Ireland under the PRTLI Cycle 4 programme, in the FutureComm project
(Serving Society: Management of Future Communications Networks and Services).
The Future Internet is today one of the
main research and industry challenges in
Europe and World Wide (http://www.future-
internet.eu/). In particular the focus of Future
Internet research is to redesign several as-
pects of the original Internet in order to sup-
port the future use and continuous growth of
the Internet and the increased and increasing
number of users world-wide. Approaching the
challenges of the Future Internet requires a
common effort of different disciplines and ac-
tors, as the Future Internet does not just in-
volve technological problems but has implica-
tions for the economy, society and govern-
ance.
Trust is one of the key challenges for the
Future Internet as research focuses on the
development of resilient and trustworthy Fu-
ture Internet able to support Trust decision for
users (European Commission, 2008). We are
convinced that a transdisciplinary research
agenda - that we define to as Trust as Result -
shared by Sociology and Computer Science,
is of paramount importance for devising sus-
tainable Trust solutions for the (Future) Inter-
net stakeholders.
122
Stefano De Paoli et al.
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010.
1. Scope of the Paper
This paper outlines what we consider the
main aspects for building a Trust transdiscipli-
nary agenda. In particular, we distinguish our
agenda by comparison with one of the current
mainstream interdisciplinary approaches to
Trust, that we define to as ‘Trust Modelling’.
Trust Modelling approaches assume Trust to
be the input of the design of trustworthy ICTs,
focusing therefore on Trust as a decontextual-
ized ‘object’ (with no relation whatsoever with
situation and context). We propose a different
point of view that focuses not on taking Trust
as input, but on how we can obtain Trust as
the result (output) of the design.
Our goal is to conceive, develop and im-
plement an innovative, transdiciplinary and vi-
sionary agenda for the "design-for-social-
trust" technology whose goal is to enable a
novel, collaborative, and socially accepted
way of creating Trust for the Future Internet.
Our vision consider not bridging disciplinary
differences into an interdisciplinary approach
(like Trust modeling that takes some elements
from social sciences and some from comput-
ing), but rather building from the beginning a
shared repertoire of concepts and actions.
We believe that a good approach to con-
ceptualizing Trust would in-fact be that of see-
ing it as an effect (a result) of the interrela-
tions between social and technical elements
and not as a sort of objective (pre)condition
for interaction. Therefore, Trust has to be built
together with the interrelation of various socio-
technical entities and not as its presupposition
(as for Trust Modelling). Trust is not an es-
sence, which explains social order (ex-
planans) and that can be captured and object-
fied, but rather an outcome (explanandum) –
the result – of the relations among entities.
This perspective can lead to the design of
novel systems that supports understanding of
Trust (and also mistrust) in practice in differ-
ent Internet domains.
2. The Assemblage Theory
We begin by conceptualizing Trust as a col-
lective socio-technical product (which is based
both and at once on an array of humans and
non-humans entities). For addressing this
human/non-human symmetry we need con-
cepts able to cut across the common as-
sumed distinction between technology and
society. For our specific work we rely on the
concept of Assemblage as developed in the
work by Manuel DeLanda, (2002 and 2006).
The concept of assemblage considers that
social and technological entities should be
characterized not on the basis of their essen-
tial properties and necessary relations as
happens with for example the concept of 'sys-
tem'. The dynamics of an assemblage are dif-
ferent from that of a system as the entities
composing the assemblage are characterized
on the basis of what they are capable of doing
when they interact with one another. These
capacities depend on the entity properties but
cannot be reduced to them since they involve
an interrelation with other interacting entities.
The concept of assemblage is in particular
useful to investigate the processes and inter-
relational dynamics encompassing changes
according to the different roles of entities in
different assemblages. In other words, what
we have is a flat ontology – as opposed to a
hierarchical ontology of systems - in which the
relations of an assemblage can change at any
time and the parts can withdraw from one as-
semblage and enter into other assemblages
even with different roles.
3. Trust as Result Agenda
We summarize now the main aspects of the
research agenda proposed here. Our intention
is to further develop these aspects in future
writings and collaborations in concrete pro-
jects. For us moving toward a transdisciplinary
agenda for Trust for the Future Internet re-
quires re-articulate and re-conceptualize the
following elements of current design of Trust:
I. It is important to focus on Trust as the
outcome of the design (Trust as Result),
and not on Trust as a precondition (as
input) embedded in a model, subse-
quently implemented in computer sys-
tems. This Trust as Result can be
achieved not just by integrating different
disciplines, but rather with a movement
that transcends disciplinary boundaries.
II. It is important for disciplines to work and
collaborate on the creation and en-
tripleC 8(2): 121
-123, 2010 123
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010.
hancement of a transdisciplinary con-
ceptual framework for Trust as Result
grounded on a shared repertoire of con-
cepts. This can be achieved by identify-
ing since the beginning concepts that
can serve this scope.
To achieve the previous goals:
III. it is important to focus on the hybrid na-
ture of Trust, that involves already a
mixture of technical and social, and
therefore to reject a separation between
a technical and a social object and the
disciplinary differences implied by the
existence of different objects of study.
IV. Finally it is important to rely on concepts
that transcend common assumed sepa-
rations. In our case we argue for a flat
ontology based on the Assemblage
Theory for designing Trust.
In conclusion, we are aware that arguing for
a possible paradigm shift – as proposed in our
agenda - in the design of Trustworthy ICT for
the Future Internet requires more than just re-
shaping a few assumptions of the design,
leaving intact the current core elements of
systems design theories. Shifting from Trust
Modelling (Trust as Input) to Transdisciplinary
Trust (Trust as result) implies also a politics of
transdisciplinarity. Indeed, we live in a world
populated by Epistemic Cultures (Knorr-
Cetina, 1999), in which how we know and
what we know is often difficult to change. Cur-
rent thinking in term of Trust as it relates to
ICTs is strongly bounded with a core set of
assumptions that cannot just be modified on
the basis of pure technology success. There-
fore enhancing a transdiciplinary Trust
agenda for the Future Internet is also a politi-
cal problem. We do not have yet an answer
on how to solve the techno-political chal-
lenges we are facing, but we are convinced of
the importance of working toward this goal
and this paper is a first concrete effort in this
direction.
References
DeLanda, M. (2002). Intensive Science and Virtual Philosophy. London: Continuum.
DeLanda, M. (2006). A New Philosophy of Society: Assemblage Theory and Social Complexity. London: Continuum.
European Commission (2008). Future Internet Compendium of Research Projects. Retrieved from:
ftp://ftp.cordis.europa.eu/pub/fp7/ict/docs/ch1-g848-280-future-internet_en.pdf
Knorr-Cetina, K. (1999). Epistemic Cultures: How the Sciences Make Knowledge. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
About the Authors
Stefano De Paoli: http://www.nuim.ie/nirsa/people/postdocs/stefano_de_paoli.shtml
G. R. Gangadharan: http://sites.google.com/site/geeyaar2/
Aphra Kerr: http://sociology.nuim.ie/AphraKerr.shtml
Vincenzo D’Andrea: http://disi.unitn.it/users/vincenzo.dandrea
Martin Serrano: http://www.tssg.org/people/jmserrano/
Dmitri Botvich: http://www.tssg.org/people/dbotvich/
Jimmy McGibney: http://www.tssg.org/people/jmcgibney/