63 Alison Hearn
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010
while these critics agree that digitization and
computerization have transformed the econ-
omy, they remain convinced that the plight
and the potential power of the worker is as
present as ever, perpetually adapting itself
to larger societal changes. They have set
about, then, to formulate an understanding
of the transformed world of work with an eye
to “confronting information age capital with a
radically alternative vision of community and
communication” (Dyer-Witheford, 1994, p.
52).
2.2. Immaterial Labour
A central component in these new formu-
lations is the concept of immaterial labour,
which originated in the late 1990s in the
work of autonomist Marxist critics writing in
and around the journal Futur Anterieur. Anx-
ious to contend with the changing composi-
tion of the post-Fordist workplace, these crit-
ics attempt to define a “new revolutionary
subject that might succeed the craft worker
and the mass worker” (Dyer-Witheford,
2001, p. 70).
Michael Hardt, Antonio Negri, Mauricio
Lazzarato, Paolo Virno and others argue
that post-Fordist capital has seen the reali-
zation of the processes originally described
by Marx in the Grundrisse, where knowledge
and sociality have become “the lifeblood of
fixed capital” (Wright, 2005). In the age of
heavy industry, Marx writes: “the social indi-
vidual appears as the great foundation stone
of production and of wealth” and “labour
time ceases and must cease to be the
measure of value” (Marx, 1993, p. 705).
These conditions mark, what Hardt and
Negri call, “the social factory” (Hardt &
Negri, 2000), where labour extends far be-
yond the temporal and spatial limits of tradi-
tional workplaces, eluding effective meas-
urement, and capital’s productivity pene-
trates ever more deeply into all, including
the most intimate, aspects of our lives. With
the diffusion of work and the production of
value across all areas of life and increas-
ingly conditioned by computer networks
“whose abstract, digitalized operations ren-
der intellectual activity directly productive”
(Dyer-Witheford, 1994, p. 95), we see the rise
of the ‘socialized’ worker.
The productive activity in which the ‘social-
ized’ worker is primarily engaged involves im-
material labour, which, as Maurizio Lazzarato
has famously written, “produces the cultural
content of the commodity (and) involves a se-
ries of activities that are not normally recog-
nized as “work” – in other words the kinds of
activities involved in defining and fixing cultural
and artistic standards, fashions, tastes, con-
sumer norms, and […] public opinion” (Laz-
zarato, 1996, pp. 133-34). Hardt and Negri
outline three general forms of immaterial la-
bour: industrial labour processes which have
been transformed by computerization, analyti-
cal, symbolic or linguistic work, which can in-
clude creative work or routine symbolic tasks,
and affective labour, which “produces and ma-
nipulates affects, such as a feeling of ease,
well-being, satisfaction, excitement or passion”
(Hardt & Negri, 2004, p. 108; Hardt & Negri,
2000, p. 293). Most immaterial labour involves
some combination of these three forms. Hardt
and Negri stipulate that the term “immaterial”
refers to the product of the labour – “knowl-
edge, information, communication, a relation-
ship or an emotional response” (Hardt & Negri,
2004, p. 108) - not to the labour itself, which is
always in some sense physical, mental, and
material (Hardt & Negri, 2004, p. 109).
Immaterial labour is flexible, precarious, and
mobile, as it works within the increasingly de-
centralized “global dispersal of productive
processes and sites” (Hardt & Negri, 2000, p.
297) and the global mobility of capital. Immate-
rial labourers, or socialized workers, are cyber-
subjects, integrated into machines and interac-
tive networks (Hardt & Negri, 2004, p. 146),
even as their work often involves the manipu-
lation of their emotions, bodies, creativity, and
communicative capacities. Immaterial labour-
ers can include everyone from software de-
signers to waitresses, sex trade workers to
academics. Information, computer and knowl-
edge workers, performers, artists, technicians,
service workers, and even those who do not
receive a wage, such as care givers within and
outside families, are immaterial labourers.
Influenced by the work of Michel Foucault,
Gilles Delueze and Felix Guattari, Hardt and