tripleC 8(1): 60-76, 2010
ISSN 1726-670X
http://www.triple-c.at
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010
Reality television, The Hills, and the limits of the imma-
terial labour thesis
Alison Hearn
Faculty of Information and Media Studies,
University of Western Ontario,
London, Ontario, Canada
ahearn2@uwo.ca
Abstract: This paper will examine the immaterial labour thesis as proposed by Michael Hardt and Antonio Negri through a
case study of reality television production practices, specifically those of the MTV program, The Hills. Because immaterial
labour is rooted in individual intelligence, affect, and social communicative capacities, Hardt and Negri contend that eco-
nomic value in the form of labour power can no longer be adequately measured and quantified and that this immeasurabil-
ity contains revolutionary potential. But, given the current global economic meltdown, and the persistent and very material
suffering of people all over the globe, how legitimate and responsible are these claims? Drawing from interviews with
reality television workers and the work of George Caffentzis, Massimo de Angelis, David Harvie and others, this paper will
test the limits of the immaterial labour thesis, arguing that, rather than disappearing, capital continues to impose meas-
urement systems to determine socially necessary labour time no matter how diffuse or social that labour might be, and
that this imposition continues to produce the alienation and exploitation of many for the benefit of a few.
Keywords: immaterial labour, reality television, television production, self-branding, value, immeasurability
Acknowledgments: Thanks to the reviewers at triple C for their extremely helpful suggestions, and to Matt Stahl, David
Hesmondhalgh, Jonathan Burston, Sasha Torres and Nick Dyer-Witheford for their thoughts and encouragement. Very
special thanks to Jonathan Handel and to the reality television workers who agreed to be interviewed for this paper.
“there is no way to get out of capitalism via a massive fraud, however tempting that might be.”
George Caffentzis 2005
1. Introduction
The claim that we live in ‘an information age’
and a ‘weightless economy’ is now axio-
matic. Since the late 1970s critics of all po-
litical stripes have written about the growing
global markets in services, symbolic prod-
ucts, personal experiences and care, and,
perhaps most importantly, knowledge, as-
serting that these developments constitute
an entirely new state of affairs. Marxist
thinkers, specifically, have worked to pro-
duce “new theories for the new reality”
(Hardt & Negri, 2004, p. 140), mapping a
shift to a “post-Fordist” mode of production
based on knowledge and service work, ad-
vanced technology, and networked, de-
centralized, and just-in-time production. Crit-
ics such as Antonio Negri and Michael Hardt
argue that the hegemonic form of labour under
post-Fordism is now “immaterial”, insofar as it
involves the application of an individual
worker’s personality and intellect to the pro-
duction of an immaterial commodity, such as
an idea or a feeling. Because immaterial la-
bour is rooted in individual intelligence, affect,
and social communicative capacities, these
critics contend, economic value in the form of
labour power can no longer be adequately
measured and quantified. In addition, immate-
rial labour inevitably produces a shared ex-
cess of human creativity, constitutes new
grounds upon which to build a revolutionary
subjectivity, and provides the potential for a
“kind of spontaneous and elementary commu-
nism” (Hardt & Negri, 2000, p. 294). Given the
61 Alison Hearn
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010
current global economic meltdown, and the
persistent and very material suffering of peo-
ple all over the globe, how legitimate and
responsible are these claims?
This paper will test the limits of the imma-
terial labour thesis with reference to reality
television programming, specifically the hit
MTV show The Hills. It will outline the origins
and substance of the thesis as posited by
Michael Hardt and Antonio Negri and will
examine its claims about the immeasurabil-
ity of value and the revolutionary potential
that allegedly accompanies this immeasura-
bility. The paper will then test these claims
through a case study of the labour per-
formed in the production of the reality pro-
gram The Hills. Drawing from a preliminary
field study of reality television workers, the
paper will examine the types of labour con-
ducted by the show’s on-air participants and
its ‘below-the line’ workers.
1
Arguing that
The Hills is a site of, both, material and ideo-
logical production, the paper contends that
the labour of the on-air participants involves
modeling how to live a perpetually produc-
tive life inside the social factory by becoming
a ‘branded self’. The labour of these partici-
pants will then be considered in relation to
the labour of the precariously employed,
non-unionized loggers, production assis-
tants, and editors who work behind the
scenes to produce these television pro-
grams. Inspired by arguments developed by
George Caffentzis, Massimo de Angelis,
David Harvie and others, the paper will ar-
gue that, while The Hills mythologizes and,
indeed, generates new forms of immaterial
labour, it remains captive to the law of value
and to strict measurement mechanisms;
every aspect of the labour involved in pro-
ducing this specific cultural commodity is, in
fact, measured and monetized and remains
1
The phrase ‘below-the-line’ originated as an ac-
counting term in early Hollywood film production and
refers to all those jobs that appear below a bold line on
a budget sheet. Stars, directors, producers are usually
‘above the line’, while those workers ‘below the line”
include the usually-unionized craft/ technical workers,
such as editors, cameramen, production assistants and
sound engineers. See Raphael (1997) and Paul and
Kleingartner (1994).
thoroughly conditioned by the edicts and val-
ues of capital.
Reality television programming like The Hills
can provide insight into these more general
claims about the changing nature of work on a
global scale because reality television is, itself,
a significant site of production. On the most
obvious level, reality programming is a product
in and of itself, to be bought and sold on the
market for television content, and, on another
level, reality programs are significant cultural
texts, which produce ranges of social mean-
ings, lessons, and ideological messages. Re-
ality programming is productive in another
sense as well; on the forefront of product
placement and integration, specifically in the
North American context, reality programming
is “advertainment” (Deery, 2004), playing a
central role as a “marketer for other goods and
services” and a conduit for the generation of
revenue streams beyond the show itself
(Burnett, 2001). But, perhaps most signifi-
cantly, and on yet another level, reality pro-
gramming provides the means for individuals
to produce their own image personae, or
“branded selves”, which, potentially, can be
traded for cash down the line (Hearn, 2008).
Insofar as the production processes of reality
programming draw on the flexible, communi-
cative and affective capacities of their partici-
pants, and, insofar as these participants work
to produce an immaterial product (a show, a
set of meanings, a product promotion, a per-
sonality), reality television has much in com-
mon with other immaterial workplaces, such as
computer software design companies or call
centers.
The hit MTV program The Hills seems the
apotheosis of these processes of immaterial
labour and production, as it tells the story of
white, privileged, twenty-somethings in Los
Angeles who live their “real” lives in front of
MTV cameras. Simultaneously “self” and “ac-
tor”, working and living, the individuals fea-
tured on The Hills are hybrid “person-
characters” (Bellafante, 2009); their work/ lives
are, apparently, one seamless flow of value
generation. Here, “being” is labour and pro-
duces value, both for the individual person-
characters and for their producers, the MTV
network. The “person-character”, or model
tripleC 8(1): 60-76, 2010
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010
62
“self-brand” produced by The Hills marks a
distinct innovation in the nature of immaterial
work, which takes place on an already well-
established site for the production of goods,
services and brands. In this way, The Hills
provides an ideal limit case for an inquiry
into the concept of immaterial labour.
2. The Immaterial Labour Thesis
2.1. Origins of the information society
Critics have been touting the rise of a ‘post-
industrial’, ‘knowledge’ economy since the
1970s. As Nick Dyer-Witheford outlines in
his book CyberMarx, early writing about the
“information society” emerged from Japan
as a “centerpiece of Japanese economic
planning” (Dyer-Witheford, 1999, p. 34) and
gained momentum in the 70s and 80s in the
West largely in response to economic re-
cession. As theories about the rise of a
“post-industrial society” attempted to move
away from the societal and environmental
crises of the 1960s, theories about a new
“information society” heralded the makeover
of industrial capitalism all together. This
makeover was credited to technological de-
velopments, such as computerization, and
involved economic and political initiatives,
such as deregulation and the privatization of
the public sector.
Daniel Bell, Alvin Toffler and other pro-
ponents of the “information age” celebrate
this transition, claiming that it signals an en-
tirely “new stage of civilization […] compara-
ble to the earlier shift from agrarian to indus-
trial society”(Dyer-Witheford, 1999, p. 38).
They argue that growing scientific knowl-
edge and technological innovation has
shifted the terrain of human production away
from concrete material products toward
ideas, theories, data and symbols; knowl-
edge and ideas increasingly become the
source of wealth. According to Toffler and
others, this new economy based on com-
puterization and conceptual innovation over-
comes the strife and alienation characteristic
of more traditional forms of work, in the ma-
terial world of the factory for instance. The
rise of the information society, these writers
claim, ends the exploitation of physical la-
bour, labour disputes and class divisions. Be-
cause work in the information society relies on
worker’s unique intelligence and creative ca-
pacities, workers will experience “new dimen-
sions of autonomy and job-satisfaction” (Dyer-
Witheford, 1999, p. 49). In effect, “the informa-
tion economy is eliminating the factory – and
with it, Marxism’s historical protagonist” (Dyer-
Witheford, 1999, p. 47). Advocates of the in-
formation society proclaim the global triumph
of capitalism and with it “the end of history”.
To be sure, it is difficult to dispute the fact
that computerization and new technologies
have made over the world of work in profound
ways over the past several decades and that
knowledge and symbolic production have be-
come central sites for wealth production. But, it
is also clear that exploitative working condi-
tions and class struggle have not disappeared.
Many critics on the left, such as Antonio Negri,
Michael Hardt and others, highlight this fact,
parting ways with celebratory advocates of
“the information society” as well as with more
traditional Marxist views about the progressive
march of human history and technological de-
velopment. These critics, often affiliated with
what is called ‘autonomist Marxism’, view the
struggles between labour and capital to be the
driving force of history and view the position of
the worker as “ the active subject of produc-
tion, the well-spring of the skills, innovation
and cooperation upon which capital must
draw” (Dyer-Witheford, 1994, p. 89). Hardt,
Negri and other critics from this tradition argue
that workers’ efforts to resist capital’s control,
and capital’s ever more ingenious methods to
capture and contain these efforts produce cy-
cles of struggle; struggles which can be found
in many different sites of ‘immaterial’ produc-
tion - call centres, software design firms, retail
stores, maquiladoras, digital ‘gold- farming’
operations
2
, universities, and reality television
production companies to name only a few. So,
2
‘Gold-farming’ involves playing a specific video game
repeatedly in order to acquire virtual goods and gold,
which are then sold to other players for ‘real-world’ money.
Recent studies show that over 400,000 people were em-
ployed as gold-farmers in 2008, the majority of them in
China. These workers typically earn around 250$ a month
and work 10-12 hours days. See Heeks (2008) and Davis
(2009).
63 Alison Hearn
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010
while these critics agree that digitization and
computerization have transformed the econ-
omy, they remain convinced that the plight
and the potential power of the worker is as
present as ever, perpetually adapting itself
to larger societal changes. They have set
about, then, to formulate an understanding
of the transformed world of work with an eye
to “confronting information age capital with a
radically alternative vision of community and
communication” (Dyer-Witheford, 1994, p.
52).
2.2. Immaterial Labour
A central component in these new formu-
lations is the concept of immaterial labour,
which originated in the late 1990s in the
work of autonomist Marxist critics writing in
and around the journal Futur Anterieur. Anx-
ious to contend with the changing composi-
tion of the post-Fordist workplace, these crit-
ics attempt to define a “new revolutionary
subject that might succeed the craft worker
and the mass worker” (Dyer-Witheford,
2001, p. 70).
Michael Hardt, Antonio Negri, Mauricio
Lazzarato, Paolo Virno and others argue
that post-Fordist capital has seen the reali-
zation of the processes originally described
by Marx in the Grundrisse, where knowledge
and sociality have become “the lifeblood of
fixed capital” (Wright, 2005). In the age of
heavy industry, Marx writes: “the social indi-
vidual appears as the great foundation stone
of production and of wealth” and “labour
time ceases and must cease to be the
measure of value” (Marx, 1993, p. 705).
These conditions mark, what Hardt and
Negri call, “the social factory” (Hardt &
Negri, 2000), where labour extends far be-
yond the temporal and spatial limits of tradi-
tional workplaces, eluding effective meas-
urement, and capital’s productivity pene-
trates ever more deeply into all, including
the most intimate, aspects of our lives. With
the diffusion of work and the production of
value across all areas of life and increas-
ingly conditioned by computer networks
“whose abstract, digitalized operations ren-
der intellectual activity directly productive”
(Dyer-Witheford, 1994, p. 95), we see the rise
of the ‘socialized’ worker.
The productive activity in which the ‘social-
ized’ worker is primarily engaged involves im-
material labour, which, as Maurizio Lazzarato
has famously written, “produces the cultural
content of the commodity (and) involves a se-
ries of activities that are not normally recog-
nized as “work” – in other words the kinds of
activities involved in defining and fixing cultural
and artistic standards, fashions, tastes, con-
sumer norms, and […] public opinion” (Laz-
zarato, 1996, pp. 133-34). Hardt and Negri
outline three general forms of immaterial la-
bour: industrial labour processes which have
been transformed by computerization, analyti-
cal, symbolic or linguistic work, which can in-
clude creative work or routine symbolic tasks,
and affective labour, which “produces and ma-
nipulates affects, such as a feeling of ease,
well-being, satisfaction, excitement or passion”
(Hardt & Negri, 2004, p. 108; Hardt & Negri,
2000, p. 293). Most immaterial labour involves
some combination of these three forms. Hardt
and Negri stipulate that the term “immaterial”
refers to the product of the labour – “knowl-
edge, information, communication, a relation-
ship or an emotional response” (Hardt & Negri,
2004, p. 108) - not to the labour itself, which is
always in some sense physical, mental, and
material (Hardt & Negri, 2004, p. 109).
Immaterial labour is flexible, precarious, and
mobile, as it works within the increasingly de-
centralized “global dispersal of productive
processes and sites” (Hardt & Negri, 2000, p.
297) and the global mobility of capital. Immate-
rial labourers, or socialized workers, are cyber-
subjects, integrated into machines and interac-
tive networks (Hardt & Negri, 2004, p. 146),
even as their work often involves the manipu-
lation of their emotions, bodies, creativity, and
communicative capacities. Immaterial labour-
ers can include everyone from software de-
signers to waitresses, sex trade workers to
academics. Information, computer and knowl-
edge workers, performers, artists, technicians,
service workers, and even those who do not
receive a wage, such as care givers within and
outside families, are immaterial labourers.
Influenced by the work of Michel Foucault,
Gilles Delueze and Felix Guattari, Hardt and
tripleC 8(1): 60-76, 2010
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010
64
Negri argue that immaterial production is, at
its core, biopolitical. As it draws on the sub-
jective attributes of workers, such as creativ-
ity, intelligence, caring and linguistic skills,
immaterial labour produces distinct commu-
nities and relationships, social networks,
social meanings, “and ultimately social life
itself” (Hardt & Negri 2004, p. 109); it blurs
the lines between the economic, the social,
the political and the cultural. Most often,
immaterial labour is strictly shaped and dis-
ciplined by dominant economic and political
interests, producing capital’s docile bodies.
In the global social factory we see “a ration-
alization of the totality of human activities
and its subordination to the M-C-M (money-
commodity-money) circuit.” (de Angelis cited
in Dyer-Witheford, 2001b, p. 168). Hardt and
Negri, however, argue that, in the case of
immaterial labour, the disciplinary equation
is not always so clear; while the interests of
capital have collided with human affect, so-
ciality and communication, “communication
has not been impoverished, but production
has been enriched to the level of complexity
of human interaction” (Hardt & Negri, 2000,
p. 293). Significantly, they contend that all
immaterial labour involves communicative
action that is not imposed from above, but,
rather, is “immanent to the labouring activity
itself” (Hardt & Negri, 2000, p. 295).
“The immateriality of labour implies an ac-
tivity that emphasizes and is self-aware of its
cooperative nature that is biopolitical, that
produces affects; hence a cooperation that
is far more likely to be of a horizontal, rhi-
zomatic nature, organised on the basis of
informal workgroups, networks, peer-to-peer
relationships, social ties even…” (de Angelis
& Harvie 2006, p. 2).
In their book Mulitude, Hardt and Negri
argue that immaterial labour has changed
the conditions and grounds for the organiza-
tion and structure of all work around the
globe; we have moved “from the linear rela-
tionships of the assembly line to the innu-
merable and indeterminate relationships of
distributed networks” (Hardt & Negri, 2004,
p. 113). Today, both, work and society as a
whole have to “informationalise, become
intelligent, become affective” (Hardt & Negri
2004, p. 109). In this way, they assert that im-
material labour has become “hegemonic in
qualitative terms”(Hardt & Negri 2004, p. 109).
2.3. Subjectivity and Immaterial Labour
The strategic deployment of affect, expressive
self, or personality is central to the concept of
immaterial labour. Jason Read defines imma-
terial labour as “the production of subjectivity
(tastes, desires, concepts) by subjectivity”
(Read, 2003, p. 11). Virno and Lazzarato see
individual virtuosity, defined as a capacity for
linguistic and communicative improvisation
and innovation, and the continual self-
(re)creation of subjects, as core components
(Virno, 2004; Lazzarato, 1996). Many other
critics from other theoretical traditions, includ-
ing Brian Holmes, Ernest Sternberg, Luc Bol-
tanski, Eve Chiapello and David Harvey, also
note the ways in which flexible self-
performance and image construction have be-
come central features of the post-Fordist
workplace. Elsewhere I have made the case
that dominant forms of impression manage-
ment, or self-branding, constitute a new, dis-
tinct form of labour (Hearn, 2008, p. 194).
Insofar as “subjectivity […] becomes directly
productive” and “productive labour, in its total-
ity, appropriates the special characteristics of
the performing artist” (Virno, 2004, pp. 54-55),
the work of the culture industries becomes
centrally important; they are “generalized and
elevated to the rank of canon”, paradigmatic of
the post-Fordist mode of production (Virno,
2004, p. 28; Lazzarato, 1996, p. 142). In addi-
tion to being significant sites of production
themselves, the culture industries, such as
television production, provide templates for the
communicative and image skills required for
profit-generating self-performance in all sec-
tors of the economy. It is to a specific example
from the culture industries, then, that we will
soon turn in order to test some of these claims
about immaterial labour.
2.4. Immeasurability and the end of the
law of value?
A central element of Hardt and Negri’s imma-
terial labour thesis is the claim that immaterial
labour is fundamentally immeasurable and
65 Alison Hearn
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010
that, as a result, the labour theory of value is
no longer tenable
3
. As the nature of labor
changes, so does the constitution of value; if
work is dispersed across bodies, subjectiv-
ities, communicative actions, and machines
then value can no longer be determined by
the socially necessary labor time required to
produce commodities. Under the new he-
gemony of immaterial labour, value has
moved both outside of, and beyond, meas-
ure. On the one hand, global capitalism can
never fully calculate and order production,
especially immaterial production, because it
is so diffuse and individualized. On the other
hand, because immaterial labour creates
“not the means of social life but social life
itself”, and “because capital can never cap-
ture all of life” (Hardt & Negri, 2004, p. 146),
this new form of labour has the capacity to
exceed capital and, potentially, re-
appropriate the means of production. Under
these conditions, Hardt and Negri contend,
“the ontological terrain of Empire, completely
plowed and irrigated by a powerful, self-
valorizing, and constituent labor, is thus
planted with a virtuality that seeks to be real”
(Hardt & Negri, 2000, p. 259). In this way,
the socialized worker becomes a part of the
“multitude” (Hardt & Negri, 2004).
Debates about Marx’s labour theory of
value have been raging in some form or an-
other for a very long time (See Caffentzis,
2005; Kiciloff & Starosta, 2007; De Angelis,
2007; Dinerstein & Neary, 2002), and it is
well beyond the scope of this paper to re-
view them all. Hardt and Negri’s assertions
about the impossibility of retaining Marx’s
labour theory of value in the new world of
immaterial commodity production, however,
have produced much recent criticism
4
even
among the ranks of other autonomist Marxist
thinkers. Some of the critical arguments of
writers such as George Caffentzis, Massimo
de Angelis, David Harvie, and Steve Toms
will inform the analysis of reality television
production taken up here.
3
To be fair, Hardt and Negri (2004) claim that Marx
himself predicted this in the Grundrisse.
4
See Balakrishnan (2003) and Pasavant and Dean
(2004).
Leaving aside the fact that there is no con-
sensus about the ‘correct’ meaning of Marx’s
law of value in the first place, many critics ar-
gue that the global reach of biopower and the
blurring together of sociality and labour do not
magically result in an end to capital’s meas-
urement and imposition of socially necessary
labour time. As George Caffentzis contends
with reference to Eudoxus’ and Euclid’s theory
of proportions, “the ‘irrational’ is perfectly
measurable (a.k.a. ‘rational’), the problem is
simply that the methods of measurement can-
not be limited to ratios and whole number
units” (Caffentzis, 2005, p. 101). In other
words, as labour becomes more diffuse and
‘immaterial’ capital’s attempts to quantify and
measure it will not end but will simply become
more ‘innovative’ and ‘complex’.
While Hardt and Negri would not dispute
that capital continues to impose abstract
measurement mechanisms where it can, they
remain convinced that value inheres in each
one of us as creative, thinking subjects and in
our collaborative, communal activities; our ac-
tions not only produce value for capital, but
also produce an ‘excess’ of sociality, which
has emancipatory potential. In this characteri-
zation of contemporary work, however, Hardt
and Negri conflate labour with all human ac-
tion. Steve Toms and George Caffentzis point
out that human agency and the power to act
are not new problems for capitalists and cer-
tainly do not imply that workers’ creativity re-
sists measurement. This fact is evidenced by
the whole history of ‘human resource’ man-
agement (HRM) controls and strategies, spe-
cifically the human relations tradition, which
includes such programs as total quality man-
agement, organizational seduction, or job ‘en-
richment’ programs (See Dulebohn, Ferris &
Stodd, 1995; Lewicki, 1981; van Maanen,
1978; Toms, 2008). These mechanisms ac-
tively work to condition and align individual
worker’s creativity and subjectivity with the
goals of the employer and the results of these
management strategies are handily tracked,
measured and quantified. Indeed, as De An-
gelis and Harvie (2006) argue, the category of
socially necessary labour time is, itself, fluid
and contested as workers’ struggles take
place exactly at the point where these meas-
tripleC 8(1): 60-76, 2010
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010
66
urement mechanisms are imposed. The
conflation of labour with all human activity,
then, produces a contradiction in which
Hardt and Negri “retain a notion of socially
created value” but “reject the notion that
there is some amount of labour that is so-
cially necessary for that value to be created”
(Toms, 2008, p. 3). As Caffentzis points out,
Hardt and Negri reject Marx’s law of value
while hanging on to a notion of value that is
“both immeasurable and beyond measure”
(Caffentzis, 2005, p. 96).
Hardt and Negri’s claim that value is no
longer measurable as socially necessary
labour time neglects the connected and
global character of capitalist production in
general. While it may be true that production
is increasingly networked and socialized and
that this might lead to a reduction of de-
pendence on the extraction of surplus value
in some areas of the economy, “this situa-
tion will not automatically lead to a funda-
mental breakdown in capitalism” (Caffentzis,
2005, p. 105). Rather, the ability of some
sectors of the economy to disengage the
price of their commodities from the meas-
ured labour time needed to produce them is
entirely dependent on the “surplus value
created in other branches of production”
(Caffentzis, 2005, p. 106), usually in other
parts of the world where labour can be more
intensely exploited:
“In order for there to be an average rate
of profit throughout the capitalist system,
branches of industry that employ very little
labour but a lot of machinery must be able to
have the right to call on the pool of value
that high-labour, low-tech branches create. If
there were no such branches or no such
right, then the average rate of profit would
be so low in the high-tech, low-labour indus-
tries that all investment would stop and the
system would terminate” (Caffentzis, 2005).
The analysis that follows will take up these
criticisms of Hardt and Negri’s immaterial
labour thesis in its exploration of the labour
behind the reality television program The
Hills.
3. Reality television: The Hills
In the simplest sense, “reality television”
names a set of cost-cutting measures in
broadcast television production enacted by
management as a response to the economic
woes faced by broadcast television trans-
nationally in the late 1980s and 1990s: in-
creased competition in media markets and
growing audience fragmentation, legislative
deregulation, the weakening of public broad-
casting, and, specifically in the case of Ameri-
can-based broadcast television, spiraling costs
associated with the inflated demands of al-
ready existing media celebrities. The produc-
tion and business models of reality television
offer radically lower production costs by reduc-
ing the labour time required to make television
programs; productions not only cut out the
work of actors and writers and bypass union
labour, they also summon participants to ‘be
themselves’ on television for free by mytholo-
gizing the processes of creative, innovative,
virtuosic self-performance and highlighting the
television industry’s centrality to these same
processes. Reality television’s production
practices are ground zero for the socialization
of labour - a prime example of capital’s “per-
ennial attempt to free itself from dependence
upon labour” (Wright, 2005) and the wage re-
lation. Reality television can be read, then, as,
both, a representational expression of, and
ideological legitimation for television’s eco-
nomic rationalizations and post-Fordist capi-
tal’s desire to externalize its labour costs.
With the advent of reality television we also
see Dallas Smythe’s claims about the audi-
ence commodity, whose attention is bought
and sold by advertisers and brokered by tele-
vision networks, evolve one step further. Here,
audiences are not only working as they watch
but are clamoring to labour at being watched
by others. In this way the labour of watching
television is intensified as audiences watch in
order to learn how to be seen by television
cameras, which might be parlayed into profit-
producing work in the future. As Mark Andre-
jevic reminds us, with the rise of reality televi-
sion programming we see consumers sum-
moned to participate in the “rationalization of
their own consumption”, which is then sold
67 Alison Hearn
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010
back to them “as empowerment” (Andre-
jevic, 2004, p. 15).
5
3.1. The participants/ performers of
The Hills
The Hills, a hybrid or semi-scripted reality
show, is a unique example of these prac-
tices; it not only produces the ultimate blend
of life and work, it works to narrate and my-
thologize the hegemony of immaterial la-
bour. MTV’s most highly rated program,
drawing over 3.9 million viewers regularly by
its second season (Zetchik, 2007) and more
than 5 million online (Gay 2008, 42), The
Hills follows the lives of four young, twenty-
something women as they work and live in
Los Angeles. The Hills, which premiered in
2006 and is now in its sixth season, is a
spin-off of MTV’s first hybrid-reality series,
Laguna Beach, which followed the lives of
white, privileged high school students in
Laguna Beach, California. MTV president of
entertainment, Brian Graden, asserts that
The Hills is “the most influential show
(they’ve) ever had” (Gay, 2008, p. 40).
The Hills’ story arcs are pre-planned
with the cast members at the beginning of
each season and are based on anticipated
events in the participants’ lives. Cast mem-
bers are filmed from 12 to 14 hours a day,
approximately four days a week, with multi-
ple digital cameras. The Hills does not at-
tempt to look like a documentary, however;
the show’s glossy, filmic presentation, com-
5
In his excellent book Reality TV: The Work of Being
Watched (2004), Mark Andrejevic explores the ways in
which reality television performs important cultural work
within a surveillance society based on ‘mass customization’
and ‘hyper individuation’. He argues that reality television
“serves …as a form of acclimatization to an emerging eco-
nomic regime predicated on increasingly unequal access to
and control over information” (p. 111). The analysis under-
taken here is indebted to Andrejevic, but focuses explicitly
on the labour relations of reality television production, argu-
ing that these programs, both, narrativize and enact the pro-
ductive conditions of the social factory. Reality television
production practices encourage participants to engage in their
own objectification as branded personae and to align their
interests with the authorizing institutions behind these proc-
esses. As a result, reality television production actively con-
tributes to the enclosure of subjectivity by capital and to what
Christian Fuchs calls its “infinite exploitation” (Fuchs 2010,
p. 144).
plete with the latest L.A. bands as soundtrack,
is as slick as its Hollywood setting. In fact, the
style of the show, with its “cool-evening look”,
is based on the films of Michael Mann (Gay,
2008, p. 44). A senior editor interviewed for
this paper who has chosen to remain anony-
mous describes the way The Hills captures
“lightening in a bottle” by having “a character
find out some jaw-dropping piece of news,
while the perfectly lit steadycam circles around
them as the sun goes down” (Anonymous 2).
In this way, The Hills expresses the ultimate
blend of the television industry’s aesthetic de-
terminations with individual affective flow - this
is how life is lived “inside” television. The pro-
duction practices behind The Hills (and all re-
ality television programming for that matter)
are heavily guarded secrets, protected by iron
clad non-disclosure agreements, which every-
one, from the executive producer to the lowly
logger, is forced to sign.
Although the “drama” of these young
women’s lives is intended to feel like a soap
opera, nothing much ever happens on The
Hills. The show is remarkably boring and
events move at a glacial pace. The girls shop
and gossip and talk on their cell phones. They
work, although their jobs at places like Teen
Vogue, Bolthouse Productions, and Epic Re-
cords are “producer-arranged”; the girls drop
in as “freelancers” and are given a project to
do whenever MTV can arrange for the cam-
eras to be there (Gay, 2008, p. 46). Most im-
portantly, the girls go to clubs and restaurants
(the names of which are promoted at the bot-
tom of the television screen), talk about their
relationships, party, fight with each other, and
then talk some more. They are wealthy,
young, beautiful and deeply uninteresting, but
narrative is not really the point here. Lauren,
Heidi, Whitney and Audrina are showing view-
ers how to successfully “live” on camera in a
way that reflects and promotes the values of
consumption and image savvy now dominant
in the West. Not only are these women the
very incarnation of Hardt and Negri’s hyper-
socialized cyber-subjects, they are promo-
tional objects for the ostensibly labour-free
world of the attention economy. The spectacu-
larized lives of the girls on The Hills are com-
parable to the model kitchens or living rooms
tripleC 8(1): 60-76, 2010
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010
68
on display at Ikea or Pottery Barn. Like
these marketing displays, the directive to
viewers is simple: insert your “self” here.
The Hills chronicles these women’s quo-
tidian ups and downs, but the real story is
happening beyond the show, as they de-
velop their own person-character, image-
commodity, or self-brand. Elsewhere I have
defined the “branded self” as an entity that
works and, at the same time, points to itself
working, striving to embody the values of its
working environment. The self as commodity
for sale on the labour market must also gen-
erate its own rhetorically persuasive packag-
ing, its own promotional skin, within the con-
fines of the dominant corporate imaginary. It
is, in the words of Andrew Wernick, a self
“which continually produces itself for public
consumption” (Wernick, 1991, p. 192). Self-
branding is a form of affective labour that is
purposefully undertaken by individuals in
order to garner attention or notoriety; it is
often intended as a way to establish some
form of security in the extremely precarious
work world of 21st century capitalism
(Hearn, 2008, p. 200). The goal of self-
branding is to produce profit.
Self-branding has much in common with
Barry King’s concept of “becoming modular.”
King critically examines the widely-used
metaphor of “actorly performance” and the
values and meanings attached to it, which
include ideals of personal “expressive lati-
tude”, glamour, and “intrinsically rewarding
work” (King, 2007, pp. 320-321). When ap-
plied to the work of labourers, such as call
centre workers or waitresses, King argues,
the metaphor of performance and its atten-
dant connotations serve to mythologize the
real conditions and constraints of immaterial
labour, where “the exercise of ‘personality’ is
closer to the fulfillment of a task specification
than a process of expression” (King, 2007,
p. 320). As the performance of personality
and job-appropriate selfhood becomes a
form of commodity labour power, immaterial
workers are encouraged to see themselves
as image entrepreneurs (Hearn, 2006). “Be-
coming modular” describes a performance
of selfhood that conforms to a format dic-
tated by external disciplinary structures: “to
perform to a format”, King writes, “is to seek to
be a functional unit, or a module.” In the case
of The Hills, the performance of selfhood en-
acted by Lauren, Whitney et. al is completely
conditioned by television’s narrative conceits,
aesthetic concerns, production exigencies,
and sponsorship imperatives. As King con-
tends, “to be modular is not about self-
expression”; it is “to be a model of a model
that has been intensively structured for mass
approval” (King, 2007, p. 335).
The young women on The Hills are mod-
els of models, offering their lives up week after
week to the MTV cameras, becoming profit-
able self-brands and modeling how effective
self-branding might be done. Their lives are
rendered perpetually productive, serving as
extended promotions for the MTV network and
their own celebrity brand; Lauren, Whitney and
Heidi have all developed their own clothing
lines, Heidi has made a pop album, Audrina is
now appearing in feature films, and Whitney
recently debuted her own spin-off reality show
on MTV entitled The City. Lauren Conrad has
also become a New York Times best-selling
author with her novel L.A. Candy about the life
of a young reality television star and her girl-
friends living in Los Angeles. In addition, all
the performers make money by appearing at
various events around the country (Laporte,
2009).
As with many other forms of reality televi-
sion, The Hills brand is also highly productive
in its own right as it is elaborated and dis-
persed across media platforms and para-texts,
such as websites, blogs, youtube parodies,
and gossip magazines geared toward captur-
ing the lucrative 14-25 market. The show has
a virtual world and online community, where
fans can interact with cast avatars who offer to
help them develop their own “in-world story
arcs and virtual experiences” (Mayberry,
2007). The Virtual Hills also has relationships
with various consumer brands and participants
can earn “in-world” virtual dollars by watching
ads for these sponsors (Siklos, 2006). The
Hills has launched numerous musical careers;
it includes several pop songs per episode, with
the song and artist names posted on a graphic
super in the corner of the screen. It has also
spawned a wildly popular ‘aftershow’ hosted
69 Alison Hearn
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010
by MTV vee-jays, who confab with the audi-
ence, rehashing the show and replaying
events with all the precision of sports an-
nouncers, complete with tele-strators.
The Hills Aftershow regularly features
cast members as special guests, simultane-
ously extending and contradicting the illu-
sion of The Hills’ “reality” for any benefits the
young women of The Hills receive as a re-
sult of their television celebrity are resolutely
repressed in the diegesis of the show itself.
There is never any mention of the other act-
ing jobs, fashion lines, or red carpet events
that the women enjoy, never any self-
reflexive moment where they discuss how
their lives have changed as a result of living
on television for the past four years. These
women’s job is simply to “be” on camera
and, in their mocked-up jobs as stylists,
event planners and music industry promot-
ers, to model the fabulousness of life as im-
material labourers. As Barry King writes,
“the new social relations that descend from
the new work order dictate that the simula-
tion of commitment must not be revealed in
itself to be a simulation” (King, 2007, p.
339).
But, are these girls really immaterial la-
bourers or do they just play them on TV?
While there is no doubt that the labour of the
young women is affective, drawing from
emotion, life energy, or personality, it can be
argued that the nature of the affect has been
completely disciplined over time by the
presence of the television camera and its
own instrumental, aesthetic and economic
interests. As Audrina, herself, states, ”be-
cause it’s for TV, you push yourself to do
things that you normally wouldn’t” (Gay
2008, 46). A reality editor who has worked
on The Hills insists that insofar as “the act of
observation influences the result […] (the
participants) become the persona the show
creates for them” (Anonymous 3). Lauren
Conrad has happily surrendered her life en-
ergy to capital’s standards of measure for
the past 7 years, agreeing to do so in ex-
change for the chance to “grow” her self-
brand into a lucrative business. What is ulti-
mately privileged in the text of The Hills,
then, “is the discourse of authority that rati-
fies the stylizing of the self” (King, 2007, p.
339), in this case the discourses and promo-
tional values of the MTV network and, by ex-
tension, broadcast television in general. As
King argues, “modular selves are locked in a
life space in which the market is the dominant
reality term” (King, 2007, p. 339). Lauren
Conrad is not an “actorly performer”, or “wild
transgressor of romanticism,” but is, rather,
“an exemplary conformist who (has) accepted
managerial objectives as the equivalent of a
central life purpose” (King, 2007, p. 327). She
is not a “star” in the traditional sense of the
word, but is, instead, MTV’s “star employee”.
Indeed, nothing gives the lie to the ‘reality’
of The Hills’ person/characters more than the
impressive wage now paid to its cast mem-
bers. Recent contracts reveal that the show’s
original star Lauren Conrad, earned 125,000$
an episode in her last season, and that other
show regulars are paid between 80,000$ to
100,000$ an episode (Laporte, 2009). These
high wages not only recognize the value-
producing labour involved in creating these
self-brands but also clearly demonstrate that
MTV has no problem measuring and monetiz-
ing this highly socialized form of work based
on audience ratings and consumer demand.
The fact is that the labour of the women on
The Hills is, both, exploitative and exploited.
Insofar as the show pays these women well
and allows them to create and build equity in
their own self-brands, it places them in an ex-
tremely privileged position similar to other
‘above-the-line’ actors in Hollywood. Also, as
we shall soon see, the show’s narrative cele-
bration of the work-free world of celebrity-living
plays a role in generating its own precarious
and badly paid below-the-line workforce and in
this sense can be deemed exploitative. But,
insofar as these performers are not legally
considered actors but are paid a generic ‘fee’
for each episode, they have no access to any
of the rights or protections afforded by The
Screen Actor’s Guild or AFTRA. In addition, if
the contracts of The Hills performers resemble
other reality television contracts
6
, then these
6
Extensive attempts to locate detailed information
about The Hills contracts proved fruitless. Contracts for
other reality television shows, which rely on changing
tripleC 8(1): 60-76, 2010
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010
70
young women’s right to publicity – their legal
right to their names, voices and public per-
sonae – are closely monitored and con-
trolled by MTV.
A celebrity’s public persona is consid-
ered to be a form of property right under the
law because the celebrity has laboured to
produce it. As such, it is fully alienable and
appropriable by others (Madow, 1993). Most
participants on reality television sign away
their right to publicity to the producers for
several years during and after the show’s
airing. So, while these young women may
develop other businesses or make money
from appearances, chances are these must
be vetted by MTV, which might also take a
percentage of the money earned (Hearn,
2006). As entertainment labour lawyer,
Jonathan Handel, describes it, “the producer
has all the leverage and the participant has
none. If I made these kids, why shouldn’t I
capture a portion of the economics and
make sure that they don’t degrade the ex-
clusivity of the show?” (personal communi-
cation, May 7, 2010).
In the case of the labour performed by
the women of The Hills, then, it is impossible
to determine the line between what might be
“internal to labour itself and external to capi-
tal” (Dowling, 2006, p. 1), what might consti-
tute an immanent form of self-valorization
“beyond measure”, and what might possibly
serve as the grounds for the creation of
some “elementary form of communism”
(Hardt & Negri, 2000, p. 294). The example
of The Hills seriously throws into question a
central theoretical presupposition of the
immaterial labour thesis that “affect” is some
kind of pure human energy that exists prior
to its forms of expression. It also challenges
any claim that immaterial labour draws from
our “autonomous subjectivity,” understood to
arrive on the scene of work untouched or
unconditioned by other social relations. In
the case of The Hills “creativity is the crea-
casts of contestants, such as American Idol or The
Bachelor, have surfaced online over the years. The
Hills cast, however, has a vested interest in protecting
the details of their contracts; they would not want to
undermine the purported ‘reality’ of the ‘struggling to
make it’ storyline of the show.
tivity of capital. This creativity is free insofar as
it has introjected the needs of capital, the ob-
jective constraints of the market and its laws”
(Aufeheben, 2006, p. 35). Any affect, emotion,
or personality on display is truly “lightening in a
bottle”. It arrives already highly disciplined,
anticipating the demands and expectations of
its producers and audience and existing in dia-
lectical tension with its conditions of possibility.
The immaterial labour/life/sociality of The
Hills’ person-characters is monetized in terms
of market share quantification systems and
their related fee structures, and advertising
revenue, and is, therefore, easily measurable.
Insofar as reality television conditions individ-
ual behaviour, affect, and self-concept through
its lessons about, and production of self-
brands, it must also must be seen to play a
part in the reproduction of labour power and,
therefore, to constitute one link in the complex
value chains of transnational capitalism (Dyer-
Witheford, 2001b, 168).
3.2. At the bottom of The Hills: reality
television’s below-the-line labourers
and production practices
As mentioned above, The Hills’ narrative about
the glamour of life as labour and its partici-
pants’ promotion of self-promotion is mirrored
in the motives of many of reality television’s
below-the-line immaterial labourers. As a sen-
ior editor describes them, young industry
worker-wannabes, “come to LA in droves
every year, some use it as a stepping stone,
most are enticed by the glamour of being as-
sociated with it, but in reality it’s like working at
Starbucks” (Anonymous 3). In another mir-
rored inversion, just as the recognition of the
changed material circumstances of The Hills’s
participants is repressed in the diegesis of the
show, the conditions and nature of the labour
that goes into making reality shows are ac-
tively disavowed by executive producers and
broadcasters in the production processes of
the shows themselves.
Reality television producers insist that these
shows are “unscripted” and do not involve
writers or story editors, but then proceed to
ask editors to “build the story in the editing
bay” (Anonymous 3), or simply re-name writ-
71 Alison Hearn
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010
ers “segment producers” or “field producers”
(Elisburg, 2008). Executive producers do
this in order to avoid having to provide in-
dustry-standard wages, benefits, and appro-
priate working conditions. Indeed, reality
television’s entire raison d’etre is to bypass
traditional production formats and business
models in order to increase profit for pro-
ducers and networks. Any insistence that
“reality” refers to radical innovations in tele-
vision show formats, or innocently depicts
unstructured, free-flowing, improvised action
is a red herring. As J. Max Robins writes,
reality programs are “cast, plotted and ed-
ited as carefully as The King of Queens or
Law and Order” (Robins, 2005, p. 3). And,
as Patrick Verone, president of the Writers
Guild of America West, argues, “every one
of these shows falls under long-existing
categories in the MBA (Minimum Basic
Agreement), such as Quiz and Audience
Participation, Comedy-Variety, Non-dramatic
and Documentary” (Verone, cited in Heath,
2009). The deployment of the phrase “real-
ity” is simply a promotional strategy that
works to mask cheap, just-in-time production
practices, which avoid unionization and at-
tempt to extract as much unregulated labour
as possible from workers. In this sense then,
“reality” simply refers to the on-going reality
of worker exploitation in the television indus-
try.
The exploitative, sweatshop conditions
that prevail in most reality production begin
at the top of the television food chain, with
broadcasters who develop concepts and
then contract out their production to the low-
est bidder. As a result, production compa-
nies are regularly competing with, and un-
dercutting, each other; “everyone is pinching
pennies everywhere. It’s very difficult to
score contracts with the networks, so pro-
ducers are under constant pressure to de-
liver top quality product under ever shrinking
budgets and delivery timeframes” (Anony-
mous 2). Of course, the effects of this com-
petition are downloaded onto below-the-line
workers, such as production assistants,
drivers, segment producers, assistant edi-
tors, and loggers. These employees are of-
ten asked to work 18 hour days, seven days
a week, and to go without lunch and dinner
breaks, healthcare, benefits, pensions or over-
time pay (Elisberg, 2008; Heath, 2009). A re-
cent study by Goodwin Victoria Research enti-
tled Harsh Reality shows that the supposedly
non-existent writers on reality television work,
on average, sixty hours per week and do not
receive overtime pay (Writers Guild of Ameri-
can West, 2007; Elisberg, 2008). These ex-
ploitative conditions threaten the safety of all
involved in the productions. For example, the
non-union drivers employed on these shows
also work eighteen-hour days and do not re-
ceive alcohol or drug testing (Elisberg, 2008).
Reality workers are forced to accept pre-
carious short-term contracts, which can be
easily terminated without cause. A former
American Idol production assistant reports
that, when he averaged his wage over the
hours he was forced to work, it came to 4.50$
an hour. He goes on to state that “when I even
mentioned the possibility of getting a raise I
was threatened with losing my job, told that I
was replaceable, and that I'd be blacklisted
from working on any other show if I spoke out”
(Writers Guild of America West, 2007). An as-
sistant editor, who worked on The Hills and
has chosen to remain anonymous, describes
the situation:
these reality houses are making a lot of
money, but the person who owns the
company is making the money, whereas
the production company people aren’t
getting health insurance and they’re
working their asses off. They’re willing to
do it because it’s a norm. MTV, espe-
cially, if they see a problem coming
where they have to spend money they’ll
just cancel a show” (Anonymous 1).
Producers know they have a steady supply
of young workers who see the industry as
glamorous and are willing to put up with the
abuse to get a foot in the door. Even though “it
takes a toll on them as people […] with a
young workforce, a bunch of people say they
are going to kick butt and they’re cool with
that, and so…just go full into it” (Anonymous
2). As a result of strict non-disclosure agree-
ments, the lack of any traditional job protec-
tions, and a very informal economy of job dis-
tripleC 8(1): 60-76, 2010
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010
72
tribution based on word of mouth, show pro-
ducers are able to pressure these young
people into silence and simultaneously de-
mand they do “whatever it takes to get the
job done” (Writers Guild of America West,
2007).
The implications of this new bargain
basement production model extend beyond
the shop floor of reality productions; argua-
bly, they work to undermine the entire televi-
sion industry. As Verone points out: “the
growth of this low cost genre has also meant
a decrease in the TV shelf space devoted to
programming, which undermines our health
and pension funds and diminishes writers’
bargaining leverage, collective and individ-
ual” (Verone, cited in Heath, 2009). In effect,
the production practices of reality production
function to de-stabilize the labour relations
of the industry by producing a whole new
bottom tier of industry worker who is willing
to suffer under precarious and exploitative
conditions in order to get their foot in the
door. During the recent strike by the Writers
Guild of America, the production of reality
programming functioned as the equivalent of
scab labour, helping the networks fill their
hours and attract advertising dollars while
undermining the bargaining power of the
union. Ironically, organizing reality workers
was one of the original demands of the
WGA that they were forced to drop in order
to reach a settlement (McNary, 2007).
There can be no doubt that the work of
lowly loggers and assistant editors is a cen-
tral component of the fiscal, and ultimately
aesthetic, rationale for reality programming
and, therefore, is exploited as a matter of
course. Assistant editors and loggers work-
ing on The Hills view and log thousands of
hours of tape of Audrina’s and Lauren’s
branded lives. They are often locked into
rooms for hours at a time in order to protect
the secrecy of the show’s plotlines. They
work on short-term contracts, with no job
security, benefits, or access to union organi-
zation, and can be fired on a moment’s no-
tice should they complain; there are always
other young workers to take their place
(Anonymous 1). So, where the narrative of
The Hills and its profit-producing person-
characters appears to promote the ultimate
socialization of labour and the collapse of la-
bour time as the measure of value, producers
extract as much labour time as possible from
the below-the-line workers who make the
show. Ironically, show producers rely on the
purposefully generated myth of the glamour of
creative labour (the ideological message of
The Hills) to procure their workers, who are
then forced to tolerate exploitative and pre-
carious working conditions in order to create
greater profit.
4. The Limits of the Immaterial Labour
Thesis
As Marx argues in The Grundrisse, “(c)apital
…is a moving contradiction in that it presses to
reduce labour time to a minimum, while it pos-
its labour time, on the other hand, as the sole
measure and source of wealth” (Marx, 1993, p.
706). This moving contradiction gives us a
“knowledge economy” and “immaterial labour”
in the West, and the intensification of older,
harsher and more exploitative forms of labour
elsewhere, for example in the Free Enterprise
zones of the developing world. As George Caf-
fentzis argues, given the fact that the average
rate of profit across the globe had been rising
until very recently, we must assume that sur-
plus value from labour-intensive sectors of the
economy underwrites those sectors marked by
immaterial labour: “the computer requires the
sweatshop, the cyborg’s existence is premised
on the slave” (Caffentzis, 2005). While it may
not have the scope or moral force of Caf-
fentzis’ example, the case of The Hills exem-
plifies his point in microcosm; the immaterial
work of this “hybrid of semiprofessional per-
sonalities who play themselves camera” (Stan-
ley, 2007) is under-girded and made possible
by extremely exploitative labour practices be-
hind the scenes. So, even while it may appear
as though labour has become socialized to the
point where it can no longer be measured and
must cease to be the measure of value, capital
continues to be “value valorizing itself through
the exploitation of labor” (Aufeheben, 2006, p.
33).
The labour of the participants on The Hills il-
lustrates the limits of Hardt and Negri’s claims
73 Alison Hearn
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010
about the creative and autonomous “com-
mon” lurking behind immaterial labor. While
the labor of these women appears to draw
from affect and creativity “immanent to the
labouring activity” itself (Hardt & Negri,
2000, p. 295) and seems to be autonomous
and self-valorizing, it is, in actuality, a prime
illustration of the processes of self-branding,
or modularity; it simply illustrates a situation
where “professional or creative workers
identify so much with the aims and interests
of their business that they […] become
managers of it themselves” (Aufeheben,
2006, pp. 33-34). No matter how socialized
or affective the labour that constitutes The
Hills might be, then, in the end it is still sub-
ject to “specific measuring processes, the
rationale of which is the maximization of
profit […] and the correspondent minimiza-
tion of cost” (Dowling, 2006, p. 10).
Over the last few years the Hollywood
television industry has seen several labour
disputes, including the Writers Guild of
America strike in 2007-8 which attempted to
organize reality television editors as writers,
and lawsuits brought against the producers
of such reality programs as American Idol
and the Amazing Race by workers (Jolson,
2008). Clearly the imposition of measure-
ment mechanisms for the determination of
socially necessary labour time is alive and
well in reality television production and have
produced conflict over “the whats, hows,
how muches, whys and whos of social pro-
duction” (de Anegelis & Harvie, 2006, p. 12).
Indeed, this conflict has occurred over forms
of immaterial labour that are marginalized
and exploited as a matter of course and
whose normalized exploitation (the intensity
of which would likely not be tolerated in any
other field of work in the West, with the pos-
sible exception of domestic and migrant la-
bour) appears to be directly tied to the ideo-
logical message of the immaterial commod-
ity being produced – a message that cele-
brates the complete socialization of labour
where simply ‘living’ has become one seam-
less flow of revenue generation. The labour
practices and disputes that have arisen in
relation to reality television production un-
derscore Massimo de Angelis’ and David
Harvie’s claim that the category of socially
necessary labour time does not simply ex-
press “a past given quantum of labour”, but is
also marked by current struggles over proc-
esses of measurement (de Angelis & Harvie,
2006, p. 5).
The work of The Hills’ branded selves and
below-the-line labourers are inextricably bound
together in a logic that actively extracts value
wherever it can, even while it might narratively
repress and contractually disavow the labor
that constitutes this value. As it mythologizes
and fetishizes the end of labour and the he-
gemony of immaterial work in its narratives, as
a cultural product the The Hills simply reca-
pitulates a well-established truth dressed up in
high heels and designer duds: “capital needs a
class of people who materially benefit from the
daily alienation of others” (Aufeheben, 2006, p.
33). In the end, “immaterial production needs
the capitalist in order to stay in existence”
(Aufeheben, 2006, p. 33). Contrary to what
Hardt and Negri might have us believe, the
measure of the value of this immaterial prod-
uct remains utterly dependent on socially nec-
essary labor power. In its cynical appropriation
of life and living, emphasis on the necessary
development of a persuasive, value-
generating self-brand, and continued exploita-
tion of below-the-line workers, The Hills sacri-
fices any possibility for self-valorization and
communal solidarity on the altar of promotional
self-advantage.
A focus on the radical potentialities of imma-
terial labour obscures the fact that socialized
labour and intellect “are not invitations to go
beyond capital, but have always been part of
the work capital has exploited whether it is
waged or not” (Caffentzis 2005a, p. 106).
Capital has always depended on generalized
creativity and intelligence to develop new
forms of production. Indeed, nobody can pro-
duce anything without using the results of
someone else’s labour; arguably labour has
always been socialized. While there can be no
doubt that recent developments within capital
have seen the conflation of work and identity
in new formations, such as the work of the
branded selves on The Hills, it seems obvious
that this new form of labour is not the well-
spring of radical communal potential. Indeed
tripleC 8(1): 60-76, 2010
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010
74
claims of this sort neglect history and ignore
the dialectical relationship between individ-
ual subjectivity and objective historical
forces, assuming some notion of a free, pure
and unfettered human essence, or ‘affect’. In
the wake of the current economic crisis, pre-
cipitated by immaterial labourers producing
fictional financial instruments with no real
“value”, we are all now experiencing the lim-
its of the immaterial labour thesis in very
material ways. And so we might cheekily sug-
gest, as Caffentzis does, that the immaterial
labour thesis and its claims about the im-
measurability and potential communal excess
of immaterial labour, constitute a fraud - noth-
ing more than theoretical razzle-dazzle. Could
it be that the immaterial labour thesis, much
like The Hills itself, is myth making of the high-
est order?
References
Andrejevic, M. (2004). Reality TV: The work of Being Watched, Lanham, Maryland: Rowman and Littlefield.
Anonymous Editor 1, Personal Interview, March 25, 2008.
Anonymous Editor 2, Personal Interview, April 1, 2008.
Anonymous Editor 3, Personal Interview, April 14, 2008.
Aufeheben. (2006). Keep on Smiling: Questions on immaterial labour, Aufeheben, 14, 23-44.
Balakrishnan, G. (Ed.) (2003). Debating Empire. London and New York: Verso.
Bellafante, G. (2009, January 4). West Coast Fashonista Takes on Manhattan, Manolos in Tow. New York Times. Re-
trieved April 15 2009 at http://www.nytimes.com/2009/01/05/arts/television/05city.html
Biter, H. (2008). WGA Faces Reality. LAist.com. Retrieved April 30, 2009 from
http://laist.com/2008/07/17/wga_faces_reality.php
Burnett, M. (2001, July)). What I have learned. Esquire Magazine, July. 136, 1.
Caffentzis, G. (2005). The End of Work or the Renaissance of Slavery? A Critique of Rifkin and Negri. Multitudes: Revue
politique, artistique, philosophique. Retrieved March 12, 2007 at
http://multitudes.samizdat.net/spip.php?article1927
Caffentzis, G. (2005a). Immeasurable Value? An Essay on Marx’s Legacy. The Commoner , 10(21), 87-114.
Davis, R. (2009, March 5). Welcome to the New Gold Mines. The Guardian. P. T1.
De Angelis, M. and Harvie D. (2006). Cognitive Capitalism and the Rat Race: How capital measures ideas and affects in
U.K. Higher Education. Retrieved April 15, 2009 from https://lra.le.ac.uk/handle/2381/2680
Deery, J. (2004). Reality TV as Advertainment. Popular Communication, 2(1), 1-20.
Dinerstein, A. and Neary, M. (Eds.). (2002). The Labour Debate: Aninvestigation into the theory and reality of capitalist
work. Aldershot: Ashgate.
Dowling, E. (2006). Formulating New Social Subjects? An Inquiry into the realities of an affective worker. Retrieved March
15 2008 from
http://www.geocities.com/immateriallabour/dowlingpaper2006.html
Dulebohn,J, Ferris, G. and Stodd, J. (Eds.). (1995). The History and Evolution of Human Resource Management. Hand-
book of Human Resource Management (pp. 18-41). Cambridge/Oxford: Blackwell.
Dyer-Witheford, N. (1994). Autonomous Marxism and the Information Society. Capital and Class, 18(1), 85-125.
Dyer-Witheford, N. (1999). Cyber-Marx: Cycles and Circuits of Struggles in High Technology Capitalism. Champaign-
Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
Dyer-Witheford, N. (2001a). Empire, Immaterial Labour, the new combinations and the global worker. Rethinking Marx-
ism, 13(3-4), 70-80.
Dyer-Witheford, N. (2001b). The New Combinations: Revolt of the Global Value Subjects. CR: The New Centennial Re-
view, 1(3), 155-200.
Elisberg, R. (2008). The Amazing Reality of “Reality” TV. Huffington Post. Retrieved May 12, 2009 at
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/robert-j-elisberg/the-amazing-reality-of-re_b_118433.html
Franklin, N. (2008, April 21). On Television: Frenemy Territory. The New Yorker, 136-137.
Fuchs, C. (2010). Class, Knowledge and new media. Media, Culture and Society, 32(1). 141-150.
Gay, J. (2008, May 15). Are They For Real?!. Rolling Stone, 40-48.
75 Alison Hearn
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010
Hardt, M and Negri. A. (2004). Multitude: War and Democracy in the Age of Empire. New York: Penguin Books.
Hardt, M and Negri. A. (2000). Empire. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Hearn, A. (2006). John, a 20-year-old Boston native with a great sense of humour”: On the spectacularization of the self
and the incorporation of identity in the age of reality television. International Journal of Media and Cultural Politics,
2(2), 131-47.
Hearn, A. (2008). Variations on the branded ‘self’: theme, invention, improvisation and inventory. In Hesmondhalgh and
Toynbee (ed.), The Media and Social Theory (pp. 194-210). London: Routledge.
Heeks, R. (2008). Current Analysis and Future Research Agenda on “Gold-Farming”. Working paper in the Centre for
Development Informatics, University of Manchester, UK. Retrieved April 13, 2010 from
http://www.sed.manchester.ac.uk/idpm/research/publications/wp/di/di_wp32.htm
Jolson, J. (2008, April 7). “American Idol”, other Reality Show Workers to Sue for Better Pay, Conditions. Hollywood To-
day, Accessed April 27, 2010 at http://www.hollywoodtoday.net/2008/04/07/american-idol-other-reality-show-
workers-to-sue-for-better-pay-conditions/
Kiciloff, A. and Starosta, G. (2007). Value Form and Class Struggle: A critique of the autonomist theory of value. Capital
and Class. 31(2). 13-40.
King, B. (2007). Modularity and the Aesthetics of Self-Commodification. In Beaumont, Hemingway, Leslie and Roberts
(Eds.), As Radical as Reality Itself: Essays on Marxism and Art for the 21rst Century, Oxford/ Bern/Brussels/ Frank-
furt/ New York: Peter Lang. 319-346.
Laporte, N. (2009, Sept. 27). The Hills Salaries Exposed. The Daily Beast. Retrieved April 17, 2010 from
http://www.thedailybeast.com/blogs-and-stories/2009-09-27/these-hills-are-paved-in-gold/
Lazzarato, M. (1996). Immaterial Labour. In P. Virno & A. Negri (Eds.), Radical Thought in Italy: A potential politics (pp.
133-150), Minneapolis and London: University of Minnesota Press.
Lewicki, R. (1981). Organizational Seduction: Building Commitment to Organizations. Organizational Dynamics, 10, 5-21.
Madow. M. (1993). Private Ownership of Public Image: Popular Culture and Publicity Rights. California Law Review.
81(1), 127-240.
Marx, K. (1993). Grundrisse. London: Penguin Books.
Mayberry, C. (2007, Jan. 16 - Jan. 22). MTV’s “Hills” has virtual eyes. Hollywood Reporter, 397, 8.
McNary, D. (2007, Oct. 23). WGA gives up on non-scripted effort. Variety. Accessed February 2, 2009 at
http://www.variety.com/article/VR1117974582.html?categoryid=10&cs=1
Passavant, P. and Dean, J. (2004). Empire’s New Clothes: Reading Hardt and Negri. New York and London: Routledge.
Paul, A, and Kleingartner, A. (1994). Flexible Production and the Transformation of Industrial Relations in the Film and
Television Industry. Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 47(4), 673-678.
Raphael, C. (1997). Political Economy of Reali-TV. Jump Cut, 41, 102-109.
Read, J. (2003). The Micropolitics of Capital: Marx and the Prehistory of the Present. Albany: State University of New
York Press.
Robins, J. M. (2005, June 27). The Reality of Reality TV. Broadcasting and Cable. 135(26), 3.
Siklos, R. (2006, Sept. 13). Not in the Real World Anymore. New York Times. Retrieved April 15, 2009 at
http://www.nytimes.com/2006/09/18/business/media/18avatar.html#
Stanley, A. (2007, Dec. 2). The Classless Utopia of Reality TV. New York Times. Accessed February 12, 2009 at
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/12/02/arts/television/02stan.html
Toms, S. (2008). “Immeasurability: A Critique of Hardt and Negri”. Retrieved April 15, 2010 from
https://lra.le.ac.uk/handle/2381/3592
Van Maanen, J. (1978). People Processing: Strategies of Organizational Socialization. Organizational Dynamics. Sum-
mer. 19-36
Virno, P. (2004). A Grammar of the Multitude. New York: Semiotexte.
Wernick, A. (1991). Promotional Culture. Thousand Oaks, London/ New Delhi: Sage.
Wright, S. (2005). Reality Check: Are we living in an immaterial world? Mute, 2, 1. Accessed April 1, 2007 at
http://info.interactivist.net/node/4952
Writers Guild of American West (2007), Harsh Reality: WGA Report on Standards in Reality Television, Accessed April
17, 2008 at www.wga.org/uploadedfiles/news_and_events/.../harsh_reality.pdf
Writers Guild of America West (2008), The Truth About Freemantle: Freemantle Workers Speak Out. Accessed April 17,
2008 at http://www.truthaboutfremantle.com/pg3.html
Zeitchick, S. (2007, Sept. 17- Sept. 23). MTV’s “Hills” has eyes again. Variety. 408(5), 6.
tripleC 8(1): 60-76, 2010
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010
76
About the Author
Alison Hearn is an associate professor in the Faculty of Information and Media Studies at the University of Western On-
tario, Canada. Her work is included in such journals as Topia, Continuum, The Journal of Consumer Culture and Bad
Subjects and in edited volumes including The Celebrity Culture Reader, and The Media and Social Theory. She is co-
author of Outside the Lines: Issues in Interdisciplinary Research (McGill-Queens University Press, 1997) and is currently
completing a book entitled Real Incorporated: reality television, promotional culture and the will to image.