tripleC 24 (2): 350-360, 2026
http://www.triple-c.at
Date of Acceptance: 11 November 2026
Date of Publication: 19 November 2026 CC-BY-NC-ND: Creative Commons License, 2026.
Review of “Content Confusion”, a Book by Michelle A. Amaz-
een
Pauline Trouillard
Center for National Scientific Research, Paris, France, pauline.trouillard@cnrs.fr
Abstract: With the advent of social media, authors in law, sociology, and political science have
widely addressed the topic of fake news. In her book Content Confusion. News Media, Native
Advertising and Policy in an era of Disinformation, Michelle A. Amazeen makes a very im-
portant argument in this debate. She argues that native advertising is “purposefully created to
blur the lines between advertising and editorial in order to mislead audiences”. The author
adopts a comprehensive methodology to understand native advertising. She offers a compre-
hensive perspective on the legal factors that explain the proliferation of native advertising and
the ineffectiveness of regulation. Her interdisciplinary methodological framework is particularly
effective for studying this phenomenon. After discussing each chapter in detail, this review
returns to two main arguments: the commercial speech doctrine as interpreted by the Supreme
Court today, and the impact of the author’s argument on the platform sector.
Keywords: native advertisement, digital news, news consumption, First Amendment,
media regulation
1. Introduction
With the advent of social media, the topic of fake news has been addressed widely by
authors in law, sociology and political science (Hasen 2007; Rosenfeld 2019). A ma-
jority of the authors take for granted that it is the democratisation of expression that
has led to the increase in the circulation of false news, thereby calling into question the
assumptions underlying the unfettered marketplace of ideas (Napoli 2018; Ho and
Schauer 2015).
In her book Content Confusion. News Media, Native Advertising and Policy in an
Era of Disinformation, Michelle A. Amazeen makes a very important argument in this
debate. In the first chapter, she argues that native advertising, defined as “the use of
textual, pictorial and audiovisual material that supports the aims of an advertiser while
it mimics the format and editorial style of the publisher that carries it”, is “purposefully
created to blur the lines between advertising and editorial in order to mislead audi-
ences” (p. 25). While she rejects (rightfully so) the term “fake news”, she offers to see
native advertisement as a form of ‘information pollution’ or “information disorder” that
has a profound impact on the way information is received by readers and their trust
towards journalists and newspapers (p. 25).
tripleC 24 (3): 350-360, 2026 351
CC-BY-NC-ND: Creative Commons License, 2026.
This argument has deep implications for the debate on fake news. First, by shifting
the focus from the recipients to the professional creators of information, she shows that
it is not only speech democratisation that is to blame for the proliferation of misleading
information. The same argument was made in the context of broadcasting by Yochai
Benkler and his co-author (Benkler et al. 2018). Second, while the debate has often
focused on unidentified actors with political goals, the book shows that inaccurate in-
formation starts with these institutions that are entrusted with the mission of creating
accurate information, for economic reasons. Third, her argument leads to a reflection
on the nature of advertising and its overall impact on the public sphere. Fourth, her
argument, made in the context of newspapers, can easily be applied to social media,
where the blurring of the lines between editorial content and advertisement is even
more widespread.
I’ll start by a summary of what appears to me as the most important arguments of
the book (Sections 1, 2 and discuss in more details some aspects of them (Sections 3
and 4).
2. How Native Advertising has Colonised the Press and the Internet
While there are several forms of native advertising (on which we’ll come back in Sec-
tion 4), the book focuses on native advertising made in the context of digital news,
where a brand pays the newspaper to publish an ad in the same format as an editorial
on the publisher’s site.
Chapter 1 gives several examples of the issue: for example, an ad designed as an
article of Teen Vogue, called “How Facebook is helping ensure the integrity of the 2020
election”. Even Teen Vogue’s verified Twitter account could not identify what it was.
The chapter traces back the history of native advertising to the 19
th
century, when
publishers were disguising ads as editorial content. In the 1970s, the New York Times
and the Washington Post reserved one-quarter of their “op-ed” page for a “premium-
paid advertisement”. However, what distinguishes native advertising today from these
previous examples is that these advertising used to be designed by advertisers and
newspapers were responsible only for selling the space. Today, many news organisa-
tions possess an in-house content studio that allows them to generate revenue from
the creation of advertising itself (p. 23). The wall that used to separate the newsroom
from the business has also been weakened. After defining native advertising, the book
starts by explaining the reasons for its dissemination, even amongst elite newspapers.
Chapter 2 addresses journalism motivation for publishing native advertising. The
chapter first comes back to the history of press-funding. The author explains that in the
18
th
century, the postal system was subsidised by the government in order to ensure
the circulation of newspapers. The Postal Act of 1792 set lower postal rates for trans-
porting newspapers. By 1830, up to 95 per cent of the mail was newspapers (p. 31).
Thus, by the beginning of the 20
th
century, the US federal government was subsidising
newspapers more than it subsidises today the space agency. The essential function of
the press for democracy was regarded as too important to be left to the forces of the
352 Pauline Trouillard
CC-BY-NC-ND: Creative Commons License, 2026.
market. Newspapers were also subsidised by political parties, and advertising was
seen as a means to break free from the dependence on political sponsors (p. 33). The
development of radio and television based on private and commercial broadcasters at
the beginning of the 20
th
century enshrined the growing reliance on private parties for
funding the development of communication systems. This was only accentuated
throughout the 1980’s, with the deregulation of Telecommunications, and in 2010, with
the Supreme Court case Citizens United
1
, which rendered unconstitutional any regu-
lation of political advertising. With the advent of the commercial internet, the redirection
of advertising revenues to platforms, driven by the rise of targeted advertising, has
plunged the print media into an existential financial crisis, which can explain the exten-
sive recourse to native advertising.
As Chapter 3 explains, the advertising business is also facing crises in regard to
their (contentious) goal that is to maintain control “over the persuasive influence of their
messages” (p. 45). While they control how their products are portrayed, they have less
control over how audiences receive their messages. The history of advertisement that
Chapter 3 retraces is thus a history of the reinforcement of advertisers’ control over the
conditions of distribution of their ads, that is, control over the editorial environment (p.
46). It is well known, however, that the expansion of cable television in the 1980s and
the related fragmentation of audiences weakened advertisers' business model, as they
lost their captive audience (p. 53). The necessity of personalisation and automation
explains the development of data collection and optimisation that has produced the so-
called “surveillance capitalism” in the sector of platforms (McGuigan 2023; Zuboff
2019). However, some studies put in question the effectiveness of targeted-ads to
maintain control over people (Farahat and Bailey 2012). On the contrary, native adver-
tising gives advertisers control over where and how their ads appear. It also gives them
control over the pervasive influence of their message “by leveraging the authority and
trust associated with journalism”.
While the reasons why advertisers pursue native advertising are quite clear, the
reasons why journalists and newspapers agree to deal with native advertising are less
clear. As Chapter 4 shows, viewed from the perspective of journalistic ethics, native
advertising increases the risks of conflicts of interest. In many cases, it reduces jour-
nalistic freedom: the author shows that “the quantity of genuine reporting related to
those who purchase native advertisement is affected” in 50% of the cases, a phenom-
enon called “agenda cutting” (p. 68). It also leads to potential contradictions between
editorial content and native advertising content that risks undermining the impact of the
investigation. The author gives clear examples: The New York Times had created a
native advertisement for Exxon Mobile, presenting itself as an environmentally respon-
sible company, while the newsroom revealed at the same time that the company’s
energy wasting had increased. In this case, the native ad undermines the credibility
and the impact of the journalists’ investigation.
1
Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission, 558 U.S. 310 (2010)
tripleC 24 (3): 350-360, 2026 353
CC-BY-NC-ND: Creative Commons License, 2026.
The impact of advertising on the content produced thanks to its revenue is well-
known (Baker 2014; Habermas 1962). Advertisements, even when separate from edi-
torial activities, distort the content of such activities by subjecting them to audience
pressure and advertiser pressure. Native advertising, the author argues, goes further
“since the distortion of the news produced comes from within the industry itself”. That
is, not only does the industry undergo the pressure of advertising, but it creates it (p.
70).
This chapter is also interesting because it returns to the discourse from those (small
number of) people in the industry who support the development of native advertising.
Those people deny any erosion of the wall between advertising and editorial, but also
make the burden weight on readers to understand the distinction. One of the book's
most striking quotes comes from Gerard Butler, former editor-in-chief of The Wall
Street Journal, who described native advertising as a “Faustian pact”. When the WSJ
announced the creation of an in-house content studio, he stated that he was “confident
that our readers will appreciate what is sponsor-generated content and what is content
from our global news staff” (p.72).
Despite these good intentions, the author illustrates in Chapter 5 how, by accepting
to blur the lines between editorial and advertising content, newspapers agree to submit
themselves to the game of who will “blur the lines the most”. Despite the FTC require-
ment that advertisements would be disclosed clearly, they accept to amplify this con-
tent as “editor choices” on their websites, or to reduce the size of the disclosure and
adopt less explicit language to designate native advertising. Expressions such “From
our partner” (p.85) replace the more explicit “advertisement”. This is because audience
reception to native advertising is bad. The author shows, by her empirical research,
that one-third of people interrogated “offered an array of negative reaction involving
credibility and trustworthiness” when confronted to native ads. Furthermore, when peo-
ple recognise native advertisements, they are more likely to view the message nega-
tively because of the label. This is why, when newspapers decide to engage in native
advertising, they also have an interest in making the disclosure less evident, since the
disclosure can affect the advertisement's negative reception (p. 89). This illustrates, in
my view, one of the book's most important contributions: the hypocrisy of newspapers
claiming, on the one hand, that their readers will appreciate sponsor-generated content
while, on the other hand, reducing the possibility that readers will notice the difference.
In Chapter 6, the author addresses the broader impact of native advertising on de-
mocracy. She rightly notes that native advertising gives entrée to a disinformation or-
der, defined as a “systemic disruption of authoritative information flows due to a stra-
tegic deception”. Because readers have been deceived by the confusion native adver-
tising creates, they lose their ability to trust the real news presented to them by jour-
nalists.
Chapter 7 comes back to the regulation of native advertising in the US. It traces the
history of regulation back to the 1912 Newspaper Publicity Act, which was intended to
reduce unfair business practices. In the context of government subsidy of the press
354 Pauline Trouillard
CC-BY-NC-ND: Creative Commons License, 2026.
through lower postal rates (see Chapter 2), the act prohibited publications composed
primarily of advertising from benefiting from these subsidies. The act also forced pub-
lishers to label advertisements, because it considered that masked advertising had “a
competitive advantage over advertising that employs overt promotional messages” (p.
119). Enforcement of this Act soon became selective, however: it was mainly based
on investigations of complaints filed by competitors, highlighting that the impact of ad-
vertising and false information on consumers was seen as a secondary concern com-
pared to protecting competition. In 1938, the negative impact of deceptive advertising
on consumers was first acknowledged through a modification of the Federal Trade
Commission Act that gave the FTC the power to protect consumers from “unfair or
deceptive acts or practices”. However, deceptive practices were only defined precisely
45 years later, in a 1983 Commission policy as “a representation, omission, or practice
that is likely to mislead the consumer acting reasonably in these circumstances, to the
consumer’s detriment”. The author highlights that this definition emphasises harm to
“consumers” in the market for goods, while setting aside the reader’s environment and
what she calls “content confusion”.
In 2015, with the emergence of digital technologies, the Commission issued a new
statement called “Statement on deceptively formatted advertisement”. The statement
emphasises that “messages that are not identifiable as advertising to consumers are
deceptive if they mislead consumers into believing they are independent, impartial or
not from the sponsoring advertiser itself”. While the statement suggests that, when
republished by others, the disclosure should subsist. The author’s research shows that
more than half of the time, “the disclosure disappears when native ads from a news
publisher are shared on Facebook or Twitter” (p. 122).
Native advertising is also addressed by self-regulation adopted by industry actors.
In particular, the American Society of Magazine Editors insists in its formal guidelines
on the necessary distinction between editorial content and marketing messages that
should be clear to the reader regardless of platform or format. On the one hand, the
guidelines seem to consider that native advertising is, by essence, bad. It states that
“advertisements that mimic the ‘look and feel’ of the print or digital publication in which
they appear should be avoided”. On the other hand, the guidelines recommend that
“native advertisement should be clearly labelled”, which seems to legitimise its exist-
ence (p. 131).
The contradiction that appears here is representative of the entire author’s mes-
sage: while everyone (readers, publishers, journalists) seems to acknowledge that na-
tive advertising is bad for journalism’s credibility and journalism’s ethics, and, in fine,
for democracy, the economic interests at stake are such that those people who should
be the gatekeepers of journalism’s ethics resign themselves to its widespread use.
In Chapter 8, the author discusses the legal framework beyond the United States.
As a legal scholar working on media law, I particularly enjoyed her discussion of the
Universal Declaration of Human Rights and its implications for native advertising, alt-
hough it should be noted that the Declaration has no binding mechanism (such as a
tripleC 24 (3): 350-360, 2026 355
CC-BY-NC-ND: Creative Commons License, 2026.
Court of Law). The author argues that freedom of information provided by Article 19 is
infringed by native advertising, because freedom of information involves a duty for the
State to regulate manipulative actors and their deceptive behaviour. But native adver-
tising, the author argues, is misleading by design, and publishers who engage in native
advertising could be considered manipulative actors.
This argument is quite important. As mentioned in the introduction, most of the po-
litical discourse surrounding manipulative actors concerns 1) foreign actors 2) who pur-
sue a political goal and 3) who are generally difficult to identify. However, as news
consumers, we are, in our day-to-day lives, more frequently exposed to disinformation
coming from advertisers that is from 1) local actors 2) who pursue an economic goal
and 3) who are quite easy to identify. It’s striking that the political discourse surrounding
manipulative actors focuses on foreign actors with a political goal, as if economic-
based misinformation were less dangerous – or economic issues at stake too high.
Such a legal reasoning finds some sort of concretisation, however, in the European
Union’s Unfair Commercial Practices Directive, which prohibits hidden advertisements
in media. Article 6 of the so-called e-commerce Directive (from 2000) also requires that
advertisements and their sponsor should be disclosed. Canada represents another
interesting example. As in the US, government regulation, such as the Competition Act
of 1985, prohibits false or misleading representations to the public that involve influ-
encing consumer purchase decisions. As in the US, governmental regulations are sup-
plemented by a self-regulatory code of conduct. A code of Canadian advertising stand-
ards was published in 1963 and sets criteria by which advertising is evaluated when
consumers or competitors submit a complaint (p. 159). Despite several judgements
from the Ad Standards Council, the body enforcing the code, some publishers keep on
concealing the sponsors behind native advertisements. Which leads the author to af-
firm unambiguously that “Voluntary codes seem to do little to deter stealth advertising
practices that continue to generate revenue, particularly when enforcement involves
nothing more than a compilation of annual reports listing violators and their infraction”
(p. 159). The Quebec Charter of Rights and Freedom gives room for hope, however.
It provides explicitly for freedom of information, which led l’Union des consommateurs
(Consumers’ Union) to state that native advertising affects citizens’ right to independ-
ent and quality information as protected by the Charter of Rights.
Chapter 9 proposes some form of regulation to mitigate the harm caused by native
advertising. The main argument of the Chapter is that the ineffectiveness of the regu-
lation is consistent with “the ascendence of a market-driven media system” that goes
in contradiction with the public interest. Regulatory efforts should be addressed at dif-
ferent stages of the creation process. At the level of content production, regulatory
frameworks should request transparency more aggressively regarding sponsored con-
tent, including information about who is paying for it. Based on a requirement from the
European Union’s Digital Services Act, the author offers to create an efficient and
searchable repository containing the ads, their creators and their funders. Regarding
content distribution, the author notes that when native ads migrate from a newspaper
356 Pauline Trouillard
CC-BY-NC-ND: Creative Commons License, 2026.
website to platforms, their labelling tends to disappear. She suggests that platforms’
terms of service should require publishers to clearly label advertisements when they
are published on their platforms. Regarding content consumption, the author suggests
that media literacy initiatives are essential, as they foster “an understanding not just
that content may be commercial in nature, but also of who created it and for what
motives” (p. 173). Therefore, people with stronger media literacy background are more
likely to identify native advertising and other forms of misleading information. But the
author also warns of external negative consequences of media literacy, which could
increase scepticism towards all media content, even accurate content. The methodol-
ogy used to teach media literacy is crucial to mitigate these risks (p. 177).
In my opinion, the last mitigation measures that the author proposes, what she calls
content context, are the most important: they regard the larger political economy of
media and aim at reducing the reliance of media organisations on the market alto-
gether. This, of course, requires other sources of funding. The author focuses in par-
ticular on the Journalism Competition and Preservation Act introduced in 2019 (but not
yet adopted), which aims at “facilitating the ability for news organisations to jointly ne-
gotiate fair compensation for access to their content by Google, Facebook and other
dominant platforms” (p. 178). The author highlights that the bill, like the regulation sub-
sidising newspapers through lower postal rates, is content-neutral. This means that
advertising disguised as news may benefit from the compensation. She also notes that
the largest newspaper chains may be the main beneficiaries of the compensation. Un-
fortunately, they are also the ones responsible for the process of concentration and job
suppression in the press sector. Furthermore, she argues that it rests on a fundamental
misunderstanding of how platforms are leveraging news content. The links posted on
the platforms, when clicked, take the users to the news outlet where the article is pub-
lished. As a result, it is contradictory to make platforms pay when they send users away
and redirect them to the news website (p. 181). The author argues that we should focus
on regulatory measures that would subsidise the creation of news, especially at the
local level. She places trust in particular in the non-profit media sector which reinvests
excess revenue into the creation of news (p. 183). Overall, she argues, and I think this
is a pretty convincing statement, that the best way to mitigate content confusion is to
reinforce public media structures and their independence, and to safeguard them from
the pressure of commercial or governmental interest (p. 184).
3. Commercial Speech Doctrine and the Legal Legitimation of Content Confusion
The author, a professor of mass communication, adopts a comprehensive methodol-
ogy to understand the phenomenon of native advertising. From a sociology of commu-
nication perspective, she is interested both in the creators of information (Chapters 2,
3, 4) and in the receptors of information (Chapters 5 and 6). She is also interested in
the regulation of native advertising (Chapters 7,8 and 9). Although she’s not a law
researcher, she presents a comprehensive perspective on the legal factors explaining
the proliferation of native advertising and the ineffectiveness of regulation. Such an
tripleC 24 (3): 350-360, 2026 357
CC-BY-NC-ND: Creative Commons License, 2026.
interdisciplinary methodology is essential to understand the factors leading to the ex-
istence of a widespread journalistic practice, and this methodology is, in itself, one of
the great contributions of the book.
I’d like to come back to one legal aspect that the author touches on briefly, and that
is the focus of my own work, as a legal scholar (Trouillard 2027): changes of the doc-
trine of “commercial speech” in the Supreme Court’s case law. The author mentions
that some aspects of native advertising are difficult to regulate because they “borrow
from both product and institutional advertising and are considered a paid commercial
announcement designed to present ideas about controversial issues” (p. 126). Be-
cause they engage issues of the public debate, these types of ads (such as editorial
advertising) are considered to fall into the values that the First Amendment aims to
protect, and are thus protected by the First Amendment. The distinction between purely
commercial ads and editorial ads, which were considered to fulfil the goals that the
First Amendment aims to protect, stemmed from a 1942 Supreme Court’s ruling Val-
entine vs Chrestensen
2
. However, this distinction between political speech and com-
mercial has been largely undermined. In Virginia State Board of Pharmacy (1976)
3
, the
Supreme Court uses the right of the listeners to receive commercial speech in order to
declare the incompatibility of a State regulation that aimed to regulate advertisement
with the First Amendment. This is a considerable departure from the previous doctrine
that used to protect commercial speech to a lesser extent. The previous doctrine used
to consider that commercial speech did not further the values that the First Amendment
aims to protect, that is, discussion of public interest.
On the contrary, with the new commercial speech doctrine, the possibility for indi-
vidual consumers to make choices on the market (thanks to advertising) is seen as a
First Amendment goal. While the listeners used to be considered through the lens of
the public that is a collective group that had an interest in self-governance or self-
determination (Weiland 2022; Weiland 2017), they are now perceived as mere con-
sumers, whose main role in society is to make informed choices in the market. To do
so, they have to be exposed to as much information as possible, regardless of the
quality of such information: “People will perceive their own best interests if only they
are well enough informed, and that the best means to that end is to open the channels
of communication rather than to close them”
4
. Any attempt at state regulation is con-
sidered by the Court as “paternalistic”. The new commercial speech doctrine refuses
to see consumers as potentially vulnerable when they are exposed to “content confu-
sion”: they can only benefit from this speech.
As noted by legal scholars, this new doctrine confuses the right of the listeners with
the right of corporations. Listener rights and corporate interests are presented by the
Court as aligned (because listeners are considered as always benefiting from
2
Valentine v. Chrestensen (316 U.S. 52, 1942)
3
Va. State Bd. of Pharmacy v. Va. Citizens Consumer Council, Inc., 425 U.S. 748 (1976).
4
Va. State Bd. of Pharmacy, at 770
358 Pauline Trouillard
CC-BY-NC-ND: Creative Commons License, 2026.
corporations’ speech). As the book we are currently commenting on shows, it is not
always the case. In many cases, listeners might benefit from legislative enactment
based on public welfare determinations that might reduce corporations’ speech. In his
dissent in another case involving corporations’ spending for referendum campaigns,
Justice White argued that “the right to hear or receive information to protect the ex-
change of ideas […] does not establish that the right of the general public to receive
communications financed by means of corporate expenditures is of the same dimen-
sion as that to hear other forms of expression”
5
. He added that “It is clear that the
communications of profitmaking corporations are not 'an integral part of the develop-
ment of ideas, of mental exploration and of the affirmation of self.' They do not repre-
sent a manifestation of individual freedom or choice”
6
. The Supreme Court did not re-
tain his argument. Chapter 4 of the book, which focuses on readers' reception of native
advertising, presents compelling arguments that call into question the validity of the
Court’s reasoning based on empirical research.
Overall, I argue that the commercial speech doctrine has only legitimised the content
confusion that the author is describing in her book. If the Supreme Court presents
commercial speech as furthering the First Amendment goal as much as political
speech, there is no justification for limiting it, or even for strictly separating commercial
speech from political speech.
4. Content Confusion as Platforms’ Mere Business Model
Another point I would like to comment on is the implications of the author’s research
for the platform sector. As the author explains in the introduction (p. 11), there are
several forms of native advertising. While the focus of the book is “native content” that
takes the appearance of a newspaper article, the type of native advertising that ap-
pears the most on social media platforms is “in-feed-ads” that appear as promoted
posts in a user’s social media feed. While there is no set number of ads shown per
user on Instagram, as the algorithm adjusts the frequency based on your activity, my
own experience is that there are ads shown every 4 to 5 posts in the feed and every 3
or 4 in stories. Ads in the feed can be particularly deceiving. As the user scrolls quickly
through her feed, it can be difficult to tell the difference between a post from a real
person and an ad. Like native content described by the author in the context of news-
papers, in-feed ads can copy the appearance of the post. The name of the brand is
presented as the name of the Instagram profile, with the same “reaction” section below
the post. The conditions of enunciation of an Instagram post as well can be copied as
well. The person represented in the ad can sometimes tell a (fake) story about her
(fake) life to try to sell the product, which can be difficult to distinguish from an influ-
encer. In the context of native content, a disclaimer is required by law (Article 26 of the
Digital Services Act). However, this disclaimer is usually written in very small
5
Bellotti, 435 U.S. at 804-05 (White, J., dissenting)
6
Id, at 805
tripleC 24 (3): 350-360, 2026 359
CC-BY-NC-ND: Creative Commons License, 2026.
characters which, in the context of scrolling, can make the identification difficult. With
the flowering of influencers whose posts are now widely amplified by platforms (boyd
2026), the blurring of the line between cultural discourse (Balkin 2004) and commercial
discourse has gone a step further. In the influencers’ thread, product placement (by
definition, a financial transaction between the influencer and the brand) is woven into
the influencer’s posts about their everyday life (Riefa and Clausen 2019). The Digital
Fairness Act, whose proposal was published by the European Commission on Novem-
ber 11
th
2026, targets these practices directly
7
. Article 11, called “Influencer marketing”,
states that “traders carrying out influencer marketing shall disclose the commercial in-
tent of communication in a clear, prominent and unambiguous manner”. Such disclo-
sure shall be made explicit, for each commercial communication, through the term “ad-
vertisement” or “commercial collaboration”. It forbids traders carrying out influencer
marketing to “create the impression that they are not acting for commercial purposes
when they are”. The Digital Fairness Act thus seems to respond directly to the author’s
critics, especially regarding the diverse language newspapers use to euphemistically
qualify “advertisement”. However, I doubt these transparency measures will be suffi-
cient to mitigate the fundamental risks arising from the proliferation of advertising and
other commercial placements to our right to information as citizens. Indeed, as put by
danah boyd, platforms which used to be social media are now “para-social media”,
because most of us have become passive scrollers of content professionally curated
in order to sell products. The issue is not only that we are placed in a condition where
our brains can hardly distinguish between commercial products and cultural content. It
also overwhelms users' attention with trivial information, leaving little room for reflection
as citizens (Habermas 2023; Sunstein 2009). A more structural reform, inspired by the
limitations on advertising in broadcasting
8
, would be to limit the number of ads shown
to an individual user per day on a platform.
References
Baker, C. Edwin. 2014. Advertising and a Democratic Press. Princeton University Press.
https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctt7zvk6t
Balkin, Jack M. 2004. Digital Speech and Democratic Culture: A Theory of Freedom of Ex-
pression for the Information Society. New York University Law Review 79: 1-55.
Benkler, Yochai, Rob Faris, and Hal Roberts. 2018. Network Propaganda: Manipulation, Dis-
information, and Radicalization in American Politics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780190923624.001.0001
7
Digital Fairness Act proposal, November 11
th
2026, COM(2026) 1100 final (2026/0356 (COD)
8
See article 18 Directive 2007/65/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 11
December 2007 amending Council Directive 89/552/EC on the coordination of certain provi-
sions laid down by law, regulation or administrative action in Member States concerning the
pursuit of television broadcasting activities limiting to 20% per hour the proportion of adver-
tisement within a given clock hour.
360 Pauline Trouillard
CC-BY-NC-ND: Creative Commons License, 2026.
boyd, danah. 2026. Social Media Is Now Parasocial Media. Social Media + Society, 1-5.
https://doi.org/10.1177/20563051261437487
Farahat, Ayman, and Michael Bailey. 2012. How Effective Is Targeted-Ads. In Proceedings
of the 21st International Conference on World Wide Web.
https://doi.org/10.1145/2187836.2187852
Habermas, Jürgen. 1962. The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere: An Inquiry into
a Category of Bourgeois Society. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.
Habermas, Jürgen. 2023. A New Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere and Deliber-
ative Politics. English edition. Translated by Ciaran Cronin. Cambridge: Polity.
Hasen, Richard L. 2007. Cheap Speech and What It Has Done (to American Democracy).
First Amendment Law Review 16 (2): 200-231.
Ho, Daniel E., and Frederick Schauer. 2015. Testing the Marketplace of Ideas. New York
University Law Review 90: 1160-1228.
McGuigan, Lee. 2023. Selling the American People: Advertising, Optimization, and the Ori-
gins of Adtech. Distribution Matters. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.
https://doi.org/10.7551/mitpress/13562.001.0001
Napoli, Philipp. M. 2018. What If More Speech Is No Longer the Solution? First Amendment
Theory Meets Fake News and the Filter Bubble. Federal Communication Law Journal 70:
55-104.
Riefa, Christine, and Laura Clausen. 2019. Towards Fairness in Digital Influencers’ Market-
ing Practices. Journal of European Consumer and Market Law 8 (2): 54-74.
Rosenfeld, Sophia A. 2019. Democracy and Truth: A Short History. Philadelphia, PA: Univer-
sity of Pennsylvania Press.
Sunstein, Cass R. 2009. Republic.Com 2.0. 2. Princeton, NJ: Princeton Univ. Press.
Trouillard, Pauline. 2027. Le Grand Détournement Médiatique. La Liberté d’expression à
l’épreuve Des Chaînes d’information. Marseille: Vents contraires.
Weiland, Morgan. 2022. First Amendment Metaphors: The Death of the ‘Marketplace of
Ideas’ and the Rise of the Post-Truth ‘Free Flow of Information’. Yale Journal of Law and
the Humanities 33: 366-410.
Weiland, Morgan N. 2017. Expanding the Periphery and Threatening the Core : The Ascend-
ant Libertarian Speech Tradition. Stanford Law Review 69: 1389-1472.
Zuboff, Shoshana. 2019. The Age of Surveillance Capitalism: The Fight for a Human Future
at the New Frontier of Power. First edition. New York: PublicAffairs.
About the Author
Pauline Trouillard is a researcher in Law at the Center of Internet and Society of the Center for
National Scientific Research (CNRS) in France. She holds a PhD in comparative public law
and an LLM from Yale Law School. She is an associate fellow of the Information Society Pro-
ject of Yale Law School. Her research interests are freedom of speech, and the regulation of
traditional media and social media.