356 Pauline Trouillard
CC-BY-NC-ND: Creative Commons License, 2026.
website to platforms, their labelling tends to disappear. She suggests that platforms’
terms of service should require publishers to clearly label advertisements when they
are published on their platforms. Regarding content consumption, the author suggests
that media literacy initiatives are essential, as they foster “an understanding not just
that content may be commercial in nature, but also of who created it and for what
motives” (p. 173). Therefore, people with stronger media literacy background are more
likely to identify native advertising and other forms of misleading information. But the
author also warns of external negative consequences of media literacy, which could
increase scepticism towards all media content, even accurate content. The methodol-
ogy used to teach media literacy is crucial to mitigate these risks (p. 177).
In my opinion, the last mitigation measures that the author proposes, what she calls
content context, are the most important: they regard the larger political economy of
media and aim at reducing the reliance of media organisations on the market alto-
gether. This, of course, requires other sources of funding. The author focuses in par-
ticular on the Journalism Competition and Preservation Act introduced in 2019 (but not
yet adopted), which aims at “facilitating the ability for news organisations to jointly ne-
gotiate fair compensation for access to their content by Google, Facebook and other
dominant platforms” (p. 178). The author highlights that the bill, like the regulation sub-
sidising newspapers through lower postal rates, is content-neutral. This means that
advertising disguised as news may benefit from the compensation. She also notes that
the largest newspaper chains may be the main beneficiaries of the compensation. Un-
fortunately, they are also the ones responsible for the process of concentration and job
suppression in the press sector. Furthermore, she argues that it rests on a fundamental
misunderstanding of how platforms are leveraging news content. The links posted on
the platforms, when clicked, take the users to the news outlet where the article is pub-
lished. As a result, it is contradictory to make platforms pay when they send users away
and redirect them to the news website (p. 181). The author argues that we should focus
on regulatory measures that would subsidise the creation of news, especially at the
local level. She places trust in particular in the non-profit media sector which reinvests
excess revenue into the creation of news (p. 183). Overall, she argues, and I think this
is a pretty convincing statement, that the best way to mitigate content confusion is to
reinforce public media structures and their independence, and to safeguard them from
the pressure of commercial or governmental interest (p. 184).
3. Commercial Speech Doctrine and the Legal Legitimation of Content Confusion
The author, a professor of mass communication, adopts a comprehensive methodol-
ogy to understand the phenomenon of native advertising. From a sociology of commu-
nication perspective, she is interested both in the creators of information (Chapters 2,
3, 4) and in the receptors of information (Chapters 5 and 6). She is also interested in
the regulation of native advertising (Chapters 7,8 and 9). Although she’s not a law
researcher, she presents a comprehensive perspective on the legal factors explaining
the proliferation of native advertising and the ineffectiveness of regulation. Such an