triplC 9(2): 598-609, 2011
ISSN 1726-670X
http://www.triple-c.at
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
1
Institutional Innovation: Re-invigorating the University
through Transdisciplinary Engagement
Gale Moore
gale.moore@utoronto.ca, The Knowledge Media Design Institute, University of Toronto, Canada
Abstract: The view that ICTs-and-Society is a transdiscipline offers great potential as a way forward. As the community
moves toward a shared understanding of what constitutes transdisciplinary engagement a series of new questions are
raised. This paper reflects on one of them – the question of how transdisciplinarity can be accomplished in the university.
The argument advanced is that by re-framing the challenges of accommodating transdisciplinarity as an opportunity for
institutional innovation there is potential to increase the support for research on ICTs-and-Society in the university, and to
provide university administrators with a way to demonstrate leadership by adopting a broader innovation agenda that could
re-invigorate the university and strengthen its relationship with the broader community in which it is situated.
Keywords: Disciplines, ICTs and Society, Innovation, Institutional innovation, Internet, Interdisciplinarity, Transdisciplinarity,
Universities
Over the last two decades groups of scholars have come together in universities to conduct re-
search that takes seriously the ideas raised by the notion of the Information Society
1
. The specific
research foci, agendas and practices vary, but each is, in some way, concerned with understanding
how people interact with each other, their artifacts and their environment; the design, development,
use, and evaluation of information and communication technologies (ICTs), and the implications of
these developments in the broader social and cultural context. While socio-technical approaches
have been around since the late 1940s, access to the internet and the awareness of the penetra-
tion of ICTs into everyday life has captured the attention of a new generation of scholars. There
have been illuminating debates as well as theoretical and methodological advances in the area
broadly defined here as ICTs-and-Society. Since research in this field requires a broad base of
collaboration across existing disciplines, it is not surprising that one of the early debates was
around the form of interdisciplinarity appropriate to this area of research. Should the emerging field
be understood as a proto-discipline in which the long-term goal is to attain disciplinary status? And
if so, what should it be called? Or, alternately, is the move to disciplinise not in the best interest of
the project in the long term? These debates have generated a rich literature, for example, a special
issue of The Information Society was devoted to this question in 2005 (Baym), and this special
issue of tripleC, recognises the developments since that time and asks whether ICTs-and-Society
is a new transdiscipline?
The view of the field as a transdiscipline offers great potential as a way forward. This paper re-
flects on the challenges, both structural and intellectual, of doing transdisciplinary research in the
university, and asks how might transdisciplinarity be accomplished in this context? The argument
advanced is that by re-framing the challenges of accommodating transdisciplinarity as well as other
forms of interdisciplinarity as an opportunity for institutional innovation there is potential to increase
support for research on ICTs-and-Society in the university, and to offer university administrators a
way to demonstrate leadership by adopting a broader innovation agenda that could re-invigorate
the university and strengthen its relationship with the wider community of which it is a part.
1
As the motive forces of the advanced economies shifts from production of goods and the management of capital and
labor to an emphasis on information and knowledge as the key resource, the economic, cultural and social landscape is
being transformed. Central to this shift is a cluster of innovations in information and communication technologies (ICTs).
599 Gale Moore
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
1. Interdisciplinarity
Interdisciplinarity, the term most often used to describe activities in which individuals from two or
more disciplines are engaged, has a long history
2
(UNESCO,1982; Klein, 1990, 1996, 2000). Inter-
disciplinarity became re-invigorated in the 1960s in response to the increased specialisation evi-
dent in the disciplines combined with a growing awareness of the complex and interconnected na-
ture of many contemporary problems. The potential and value of disciplinary crossings have been
recognised by the U.S. National Academies of Science and the U.S. Council of Graduate Schools.
In a recent report the Council noted: “knowledge creation and innovation frequently occur at the
interface of disciplines” (2007, p. 18). Facilitating Interdisciplinary Research, the 2005 report of the
U.S. Committee on Science, Engineering, and Public Policy suggests that:
interdisciplinary thinking is rapidly becoming an integral feature of research as a result of four
powerful “drivers”: the inherent complexity of nature and society, the desire to explore prob-
lems and questions that are not confined to a single discipline, the need to solve societal
problems, and the power of new technologies (Facilitating Interdisciplinary Research, 2005, p.
40).
The push for interdisciplinarity initiatives in the university may be “bottom-up”; driven by scholars
whose pursuits lead them to new areas of research. The history of the emergent field of ICTs-and-
Society is a good example. There is also a history of top down initiatives, and in the U.S. this had
been a cause for concern. Jacobs and Frickel (2009) in a recent critical assessment of interdiscipli-
narity remark on the “widespread efforts to promote interdisciplinarity in U.S. universities” (p. 43)
and the increased interest on the part of U.S. public and private funders (p. 45)
in supporting such
initiatives
3
.
The concern is that these top down initiatives are motivated by recent American efforts
“to configure the research university as an engine of economic and social change” (Brint, 2005, p.
23).
By enquiring into “the underlying assumptions about the nature of disciplines, research commu-
nities and universities and knowledge” (p. 48) on which the promotion of interdisciplinarity is based
in the U.S., Jacobs and Frickel provide an important perspective. However, the authors fail to ad-
dress what they characterise as the terminological ambiguity in the literature on interdisciplinarity:
Some scholars draw clear distinctions between research that is cross-disciplinary or
multidisciplinary… or transdisciplinary… Others are more comfortable with looser distinctions.
We count ourselves among the latter group and in this article use interdisciplinary and inter-
disciplinarity as general terms (Frickel, 2009, p. 45).
While this may be satisfactory for their argument, this position masks other forms of disciplinary
crossings, and it is precisely through distinguishing among these different forms of interdisciplinary
practice that we uncover the potential for creativity and innovation such disciplinary border cross-
ings may afford. As well, differentiating among these forms provides a place from which to ask
questions about the ways in which each forms adds value to scholarship and to the university.
The use of the term interdisciplinary as a general descriptor of disciplinary crossings is widely
accepted. However, it is misleading as few projects achieve or even aspire to this form of discipli-
nary crossing. As Barthes notes in Jeunes chercheurs:
To do something interdisciplinary it’s not enough to choose a subject (a theme) and gather
round it two or three sciences. Interdisciplinary consists in creating a new object that belongs
to no one (James, 1986, p.598).
2
While some trace the origins of interdisciplinary back to Plato, the term was not coined until the 20th C (Klein, 1990,
p.19) and this is the history relevant to this discussion.
3
This includes, for example, the National Science Foundation, the National Institutes of Health, and the Mellon Founda-
tion. This view of interdisciplinarity as an engine of economic growth may be most common in the U.S. where ‘interdiscipli-
nary creativity’ according to Brint is seen as a strategy that may be most appealing to those institutions that “lack the re-
sources to compete for disciplinary excellence” (2005, p.23).
tripleC 9(2): 598-609, 2011 600
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
If the project of ICTs-and-Society is the creation of a new discipline there is much to be learned
from the study of interdisciplinarity. If, however, the goal is to explore complex or systemic issues
from multiple perspectives rather than to privilege any one way of knowing, multidisciplinary or
transdisciplinary practices are more relevant. Facilitating Interdisciplinary Research describes
multidisciplinary research as:
research that involves more than a single discipline in which each discipline makes a separate
contribution. Investigators may share facilities and research approaches while working sepa-
rately on distinct aspects of a problem. For example, an archeological program might require
the participation of a geologist in a role that is primarily supportive. Multidisciplinary research
often refers to efforts that are additive but not necessarily integrative (Facilitating Interdiscipli-
nary Research, 2005, p. 27, 29).
The goal in multidisciplinary research is to explore issues from multiple perspectives where each
discipline is relatively autonomous and approaches the problem according to their disciplinary
norms.
A third type of crossing – transdisciplinarity – is the most radical form of practice. Transdiscipli-
nary collaboration transcends traditional disciplinary boundaries and even transforms disciplinary
identities to some degree. Here, “the point is not just application of given methodologies but also
implication—a result of imagining entirely new possibilities for what disciplines can do” (Beyond
Productivity, 2003, p. 99). In transdisciplinary research the primary focus is not on the discipline per
se but on the generative and integrative potential of the interaction of individuals from different dis-
ciplines working together in the context of application. Figure 1 below shows this diagrammatically.
Figure 1: Multi-, inter- and transdisciplinary (Moore, 2009, p. 4)
While there is a degree of consensus on the meaning of transdisciplinary, there is not a single suc-
cinct definition that adequately describes this form. Hunsinger suggests that: “transdisciplinary re-
search attempts to approach the object of study beyond and across disciplinary and interdiscipli-
nary perspectives” (2005, p. 277).
Fuchs (2008) provides an overview of a number of attempts to characterise transdisciplinarity,
and Hofkirchner et al. set out a detailed argument and rationale for their preference for the use of
transdisciplinarity to describe ICTs-and-Society. They affirm that transdisciplinarity is an integrative
concept and that the goal of transdisciplinarity is not to dissolve disciplinary competences (2007, p.
12). In a recent paper for the 2010 CHI Conference Moore & Lottridge (2010) express a similar
view proposing the concept of disciplined transdisciplinarity to make this explicit. This framing rec-
ognises both the value of disciplinary depth as well as the need for new practices that foster and
help negotiate what are, in essence, cultural and/or epistemological differences of those coming
from different communities. It acknowledges the value of disciplinary traditions in conducting re-
search while at the same time recognises the significance and legitimacy of knowledge claims that
go beyond disciplinary norms. Most importantly, transdisciplinarity keeps the future open, and does
not risk falling into the trap of disciplinary rigidity and institutionalisation, precisely what a project of
interdisciplinarity risks if it succeeds.
601 Gale Moore
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Transdisciplinarity also has a social function and accommodates what Frodeman, Mitcham and
Sacks have called deep interdisciplinary – an engagement with the non-disciplinary public
(2000/2001, p. 4). This adds a further challenge for the university as a wider public is potentially
engaged in the creation of knowledge, but as Hunsinger reminds us: “Transdisciplinary knowledge,
because it has recontextualized for the broader audience of multiple disciplines, is more accessible
and interpretable” (2005, p. 278).
From this perspective, transdisciplinarity provides an opportunity for the university to demon-
strate leadership in public access; a call increasingly being heard and funded. The public access
funds of the Canadian Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council (SSHRC) are one exam-
ple.
Transdisciplinarity – unlike interdisciplinarity – suggests a more radical and transformative en-
gagement. Transdisciplinarity doubly disrupts the traditional academy. It not only disrupts traditional
academic systems of accountability, evaluation and reward, it also disrupts the norms and values
about what constitutes legitimate knowledge, and deeply held beliefs about what we know and how
we know what we know.
2. The University as a Site of Knowledge Production and the Role of Disciplines
Universities, as institutions of higher learning and research, are a traditional site of scientific, so-
cial and cultural knowledge production and the primary employer of scholars and researchers in the
humanities, social, physical and natural sciences. Disciplines
4
are the way in which scholarship has
traditionally been organised in the academy and within each discipline there are accepted norms
and values around the production of knowledge. Squires correctly cautions that disciplines are
neither timeless nor indivisible and that what we experience as disciplinary today is to some degree
local and historically specific (1975, p. 40). As well, the social characteristics of knowledge produc-
tion vary across the disciplines. However, in each case there is shared understanding and ac-
cepted norms and values about what constitutes a legitimate knowledge claim, and how claims
should be supported, substantiated and validated.
Jacobs and Frickel point to Abbot as offering “the strongest recent statement regarding the du-
rability of disciplinary social structures in the face of interdisciplinary pressures” (2009, p. 54). Ab-
bott maintains that:
the basic disciplinary structure of the academy has changed little since the turn of the last
century and that virtually all universities and colleges have lists of departments mirroring the
original set of natural science, social sciences and humanities disciplines. Abbot traces this
resilience to a dual institutionalization whereby disciplines structure the national academic la-
bor markets as well as hiring practices at individual universities, which cannot move away
from disciplinary organisation of departments without undermining their graduate students’
opportunities to find employment at other universities (Jacobs & Frickel 2009, p. 54).
Disciplines endure, “for intellectual as well as organisational reasons” (p.55). This point is more
controversial and Turner notes that disciplinarity is conditioned by academic researchers depend-
ence on students. Outside the university where disciplinarity is weak, ”interdisciplinary and nondis-
ciplinary forms flourish” (2000)
5
. Yet it continues to be a challenge for many scholars inside the
academy to gain recognition for research that crosses current departmental boundaries. As Beth
Casey notes:
4
“A branch of learning or a field of study characterized by a body of intersubjectively acceptable knowledge, pertaining to
a well-defined realm of entities, systematically established on the basis of generally accepted principles with the help of
methodical rules or procedures” (Kockelmans, 1979, p.127).
5
We have observed this, for example, in the field of interaction design where teams are often interdisciplinary. While the
potential of this diversity to inform research on ID is recognised, and multidisciplinary groups exist in places such as
Microsoft Research and IDEO, research outcomes from such groups may not be considered a contribution that ‘counts’
within a traditional university department such as computer science (Moore & Lottridge, 2010).
tripleC 9(2): 598-609, 2011 602
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Many universities and colleges today have a bureaucratic culture that assumes consensus
and discounts controversy because it threatens organisational stability. Interdisciplinary lead-
ership taps motivational bases and creates a climate in which risks can be taken and uncer-
tainty and ambiguity are considered to be essential to the work that takes place (Casey, 1994,
p. 66).
By extension when interdisciplinarity in all its forms is not well accommodated, the university as an
institution loses an important opportunity to explore, experiment and potentially to innovate.
3. Innovation
Innovation is the creation of new social or economic value. Today, it is not uncommon to hear that
innovation is the key to economic growth and sustainability or that world-class scientific research
and technology development are essential drivers toward future prosperity. Universities increas-
ingly embrace innovation, yet they largely do so in the limited way associated with a desire to trans-
late primarily scientific and technological advances into financial returns. Less attention is paid to
other types of innovation, and the value that results from creating, finding and/or combining knowl-
edge into new or existing processes and services. The almost exclusive focus on the invention-
commercialization path to innovation ignores the possibilities inherent in what we call institutional
innovation; an opportunity for the university to re-invent itself. By highlighting the incompatibility
between existing institutional structures and the needs of scholars to create space for new and
emerging ideas, interdisciplinary activities point to the areas in which innovation is needed.
Examples and models exist; several of which will be discussed in the next section, but much
more could be done. Faculty and students engaged in research on ICTs-and-Society with an
agenda increasingly defined as transdisciplinary are well-positioned to help the universities inno-
vate. The expertise, as well as the subject, is increasingly not only relevant, but strategic to the
future of the university. Re-framing what is required to accommodate new forms of knowledge pro-
duction as a need for institutional innovation could potentially give scholars and university adminis-
trators a way to talk about re-inventing processes. Such a re-framing might also direct the attention
of senior administrators to the consequences of the current institutional processes and structures
and encourage support for experimentation. This could create a space within the university for new
opportunities to emerge – opportunities that are missed when traditional structures, culture and
values are too tightly entwined.
4. Institutional Innovation
Issues of institutionalisation and the legitimation of knowledge claims for transdisciplinarity have
received little attention in the literature on interdisciplinarity. Yet, clarity on these points is important
for the future development of projects and programs given the role of disciplines and departments
in the creation and production of scholarly careers. The university also has a responsibility for edu-
cating future scholars and practitioners. Innovations in pedagogy and learning could go a long way
toward developing more broadly educated and well-rounded individuals without the loss of discipli-
nary expertise or isolating them from the traditional academic labour markets.
We use Abbot’s notion of ‘dual institutionalization’ to structure the next section on institutional
structures and processes and to focus on the intellectual issues raised by interdisciplinary prac-
tices, in particular transdisciplinarity. These are areas critically in need of more research as well as
the sharing of innovative strategies and practices. The goal is to enable leading edge research in
emerging fields to find an intellectual home in our universities, in particularly in the elite institutions,
at least in North America, where discipline and department are often closely aligned. Creative ways
of working that are minimally disruptive to existing processes and practices are required if we are to
advance this agenda quickly and to engage junior colleagues and graduate students.
603 Gale Moore
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
4.1. Structure and Process
Despite the challenges facing faculty whose research interests draw them into a form of interdisci-
plinary engagement, such activities continue to emerge. These may arise internally, or in response
to external stimuli from government, or industry, for example. In this paper we are concerned with
those communities in which scholars are drawn together because of shared intellectual interests in
a particular set of questions.
One response by scholars has been to form a research centre or institute. Jacobs and Frickel
estimate that in 2007 there were nearly 10,000 research centres in colleges and universities in the
United States with nearly 100 per school at the 25 leading research universities (2009, p. 53); they
observe that
strong disciplines combined with the flexibility to create diverse research centers as needed
may be an attractive organizational solution to the challenges of organizing rapidly growing
bodies of research and knowledge… (Jacobs & Frickel, 2009, p.54).
We concur. The question of how to insert such centres or institutes into existing structures is an
important one. While funding is always necessary, it is often not sufficient to assure either short-
term viability or long-term sustainability. For example, members of these communities may not
have the experience, the time, or the visibility within the larger university to compete with estab-
lished departments and faculties with the result that the centre may become isolated institutionally.
This may be especially true in a field such ICTs-and-Society where, until recently, the significance
of the research has not been always been well understood in the broader community.
In the spring of 2002 the author undertook a series of case studies on the experiences of five in-
terdisciplinary scholarly communities in universities in Europe and the United Kingdom (Moore,
2004). The results provided one of the first systematic explorations of a number of interdisciplinary
groups in universities that had emerged to take up, in various ways, the challenges raised by the
notion of a Knowledge Society, and whose agendas were very similar to what is here called ICTs-
and-Society. The study was dually motivated. The first motive was pragmatic and the objective
was to see if there were strategies or best practices that others had developed that could be de-
ployed by the University of Toronto’s Knowledge Media Design Institute (KMDI)
6
with which the
author was associated. The second motive was an interest in understanding more about the na-
ture of the research questions that had initially brought each group together; what had led them to
create a formal structure; how they determined the organisation form this has taken; and how they
were situated in relation to the larger university structures, that is to say how the institute or center
was institutionalised. We were curious to see if we could identify specific advantages or disadvan-
tages inherent in the various organisational forms deployed that were independent of the local con-
text or local opportunities.
The European setting was of special interest for a number of reasons. First, KMDI had emerged
in part, out of the Ontario Telepresence Project, a project that had close relationships with a num-
ber of labs in both the United States and Europe active in the design, creation and use of
audio/video mediated environments or ‘media spaces’ (Moore, 1997). Second, when KMDI was
founded in 1995, we had adopted a human-centered design perspective in order to differentiate
this new institute from other North American academic programs where the emphasis at the time
was more techno-centric. Our goal was to bring a more nuanced understanding of people and their
interactions with each other, with their tools and their environment into the design of ICTs, and to
situate this within specific social/cultural contexts. The European philosophy of human-
centredness, mapped well to Canadian sensibilities and longstanding social policy concerned with
the public good. Third, we were aware that the European Union RTD (Research and Technology
Development) had identified socio-economic research as a focus of activities to be carried out
6
The history of the development of KMDI, the first scholarly community in this field in Canada, and the University of
Toronto’s first virtual institute, are in Moore & Baecker, 2006.
tripleC 9(2): 598-609, 2011 604
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
since the Fourth Framework Programme (1994 – 1998)
7
. From a North American perspective this
was a progressive research agenda with funding opportunities for what was emerging as a new
area of interdisciplinary engagement.
The results from the five cases were encouraging in that each of the communities had found
ways to accomplish their objectives within the institutions in which they were embedded. Yet, at the
same time the ways in which each was institutionalised varied widely, and depended in most cases
on local opportunities, initiatives, or a senior administrative champion. A worthwhile project going
forward would be a more extensive study of the institutionalisation of the university groups engaged
in ICTs-and-Society today, almost a decade after this project was completed, and to reflect deeply
on the strategies that have worked and why. The development of a taxonomy of models, would not
only be instructive for other groups facing these challenges, but collectively might stimulate the
thinking required to create more innovative solutions.
There is also a need to define what constitutes success. The appropriate benchmarks and met-
rics for evaluation of an interdisciplinary institute, and the assessment of scholarly work in this con-
text are likely to be significantly different from those used by traditional disciplinary units. While the
strengths of individual members in any group is important, a set of measures that merely repeats
and aggregates the academic quality indicators used in the disciplines would not capture or dem-
onstrate the value of a network of people and resources that are generated through collaboration.
As long as evaluation and reward systems for faculty in an institute are controlled externally and
dependent on the goodwill of faculty deans and department chairs, this is not unexpected. But it
may not be sustainable. This too is a worthwhile a project that could potentially be undertaken with
other scholarly communities such as those reviewed here.
Transdisciplinary approaches present the greatest challenge to the dominant mode of knowl-
edge production as transdisciplinarity disrupts traditional academic systems of accountability,
evaluation and reward. In the university a new way to assess or to evaluate these practices is re-
quired if the area is to be accepted as legitimate, and to enable wider participation in this type of
research by faculty and graduate students. This is a complex challenge both for individuals and for
the institution. On the one hand, those engaged in transdisciplinary practices need to shoulder
some of the responsibility for developing an alternative evaluation scheme, and it is in their interest
to do so. They have the expertise to enumerate what is most valuable in these new forms and to
describe what constitutes success. However, this type of accounting activity is seldom of interest to
researchers and scholars. On the other hand, unless there are senior administrators who recognise
the innovative potential of various forms of interdisciplinarity there is little incentive for the university
to undertake the development of schemes to accommodate and evaluate the outputs of these
forms of research practice.
The development of metrics was an activity KMDI identified in its 2003 strategic plan. Our objec-
tive was to define measures that tell us something about the strength of interdisciplinary collabora-
tions and the role that KMDI plays in nurturing them; the institute’s ability to provide a coherent
intellectual framework for inter-, multi- and transdisciplinary work; and our ability to create and lead
a broader intellectual community. Examples include the extent to which KMDI members sit on doc-
toral committees in departments or faculties other than their own; the number of grants and refe-
reed publications per year co-authored by KMDI members from two or more different academic
units, and cross-disciplinary citations of the work of KMDI members – i.e., citations in papers that
are published in a different discipline from the KMDI work they cite. However, much work remains
to be done to establish the validity and utility of such measures, and to create more innovative
ways to assess inter-, multi- and transdisciplinary activities. This is another project that the ICTs-
and-Society scholars might undertake collectively.
Research is also needed on new models of accommodation – models that are reasonably low
risk for the institution but that provide sufficient stability for the interdisciplinary teams for an ade-
quate length of time. If there is no risk to the institution, it is unlikely there will be innovation. If there
7
This direction was extended in the Fifth Framework (1998-2002) with the establishment of the Information Society
Technologies (IST) and continued to be a thematic priority in the Sixth Framework Programme (2003-2006).
605 Gale Moore
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
is no stability for interdisciplinarity, these communities are less likely to form or to be sustainable. In
addition, the institution must innovate in terms of the professional and administrative structures –
structures that assist and encourage faculty as well as departments and faculties to participate. It
will not be easy, and those who advocate interdisciplinarity need to pay attention to the ways in
which interdisciplinarity challenges the basic institutional structure and processes of the university.
Innovation is a disruptive process.
There is also need for structures to support graduate education in fields such as ICTs-and-
Society. For transdisciplinary research centres or institutes that have graduate programs, the ques-
tion of how students will fit into the academic labour markets on graduation is a question that must
be answered. KMDI was fortunate in this respect as the Collaborative Program model administered
by the University of Toronto’s School of Graduate Studies provided an institutional process that
supported our ambitions to offer graduate education in which students from more than one disci-
pline could participate. Non-degree granting collaborative programs emerge from cooperation be-
tween two or more graduate departments, centres, and institutes and provide students with a
broader base from which to explore a novel interdisciplinary area or developments in another disci-
pline to complement their degree studies.
8
In 2002, KMDI launched the Collaborative Masters and
Doctoral Program in Knowledge Media Design, and today there are ten academic units participat-
ing. The model has been excellent in many ways in that it provides an administratively lightweight
way for the institute to build a graduate program as the student’s relationship with the university is
coordinated through their home department while at the same time giving students access to fac-
ulty from across a large number of disciplines. There is a reciprocal benefit for faculty engaged in
projects requiring broad participation, and at the same time, assures that students will graduate
with a degree from a recognised discipline. In general, students enrolled in the program identify
strongly with the institute and with the research in this area. The disadvantage at the present time
is that there is not a standard approach to cost recovery from the students’ home departments and
the cost is borne by the institute out of the small base budget received from the university.
In the next section we consider the intellectual issues transdisciplinarity raises. Here too, innova-
tive new models are emerging, in particularly in the area of pedagogy. And once again, more needs
to be done, and this too is a topic that could be added to a collective research agenda for ICTs-
and-Society.
4.2. The Intellectual Challenges Posed by Transdisciplinary Engagement in the University
A critical first step in responding to the challenges interdisciplinary crossings pose to traditional
forms of knowledge production is to differentiate among the forms of interdisciplinarity each of
which has merit. The difference among the forms is instructive in terms of the intellectual chal-
lenges each poses for the university. Some interdisciplinary programs have successfully institu-
tionalised as a new discipline – e.g., cognitive science or women’s studies. In these cases the new
discipline largely reproduces the well-understood apparatus of knowledge production. Multidiscipli-
nary approaches are also minimally disruptive and do not require significant institutional reform to
accommodate them as the participants continue to be part of their disciplinary culture. It is the
transdisciplinary approaches that are the least familiar that present the greatest challenge to the
dominant mode of knowledge production, not because there are multiple disciplines involved, but
because of the generative nature of the process, and because the nature of the knowledge pro-
duced does not fit neatly into individual disciplinary categories or cultures.
Transdisciplinarity disrupts not only traditional academic systems of accountability, evaluation
and reward, but challenges the norms and values around the production of knowledge in funda-
mental ways. By accepting that there are irreconcilable notions of truth, transdisciplinarity has the
potential to create deeper understandings, to enhance creativity and to intellectually enrich those
participating. The development of scholars and practitioners who can engage in this way should be
central to the work of the academy. Why is it so difficult?
8
Source: http://www.gradschool.utoronto.ca/programs/collaborative.htm.
tripleC 9(2): 598-609, 2011 606
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
As a shared understanding of transdisciplinarity and what constitutes it is still evolving, we return
to the formulation by Gibbons et al. (1994) that sets out four distinct features of transdisciplinarity,
as these make clear the challenges this type of knowledge production raise.
First, it develops a distinct but evolving framework to guide problem solving efforts. … Al-
though elements of existing knowledge must have entered into it, genuine creativity is in-
volved and the theoretical consensus, once attained cannot easily be reduced. …Second, be-
cause the solution comprises both empirical and theoretical components it is undeniably a
contribution to knowledge, though not necessarily disciplinary knowledge. … Third, …the dif-
fusion of the results is initially accomplished in the process of their production. Subsequent
diffusion occurs primarily as the original practitioners move to new problem contexts rather
than through reporting results in professional journals or at conferences. Fourth, transdiscipli-
narity is dynamic. A particular solution can become the cognitive site from which further ad-
vances can be made. … New knowledge produced in this way may not fit into any one of the
disciplines that contributed to the solution. Nor may it be easily referred to particular discipli-
nary institutions or recorded as disciplinary contributions (Gibbons et al., 1994, p. 5).
This is virtually orthogonal to traditional disciplinary institutional values. Yet, transdisciplinarity is
especially valuable when the issues are complex or systemic – the kind of issues of interest to
scholars working in ICTs-and-Society.
We can see why this is so difficult in the traditional university. Academics engaging in research
in ICTs-and-Society or other transdisciplinary fields may produce work where well-understood dis-
ciplinary standards do not apply. Promotion and tenure committees as well as granting agencies
rely on “well known” or “familiar” disciplinary standards in the epistemic community to recognize the
value of the research. Scholars, engaging in interdisciplinary projects may produce work that does
not conform to the traditional norms of the discipline that is evaluating them. For example, the re-
sults may be published in a journal outside the discipline, or an altogether different means of dis-
semination altogether may have been found to be more suitable. How then can their contributions
be evaluated? What kind of innovation in the tenure and promotion process might be required to
recognise a more diverse range of contributions? Klein, Jacobs and Frickel note that:
the criteria for judgment constitute the least understood aspect of interdisciplinarity, in part be-
cause the issue has been the least studied and in part because the multiplicity of tasks seems
to militate against a single standard (Klein, Jacobs & Frickel, 2009, p. 52).
If the field is to attract young scholars, what modifications to the processes of tenure and promotion
might be required to recognise these contributions?
There are, however, reasons for optimism. Faculty and students have been engaged in what is
called here ICTs-and-Society for fifteen to twenty years. Despite the institutional challenges faced,
a succession of research centres, labs and institutes have formed in this area, and a growing body
of knowledge has been created and disseminated formally as part of the corpus of several disci-
plines, through the creation of new interdisciplinary publications, through new forms of digital distri-
bution, and informally within the community. Second, the university as a traditional site of knowl-
edge production has invested in infrastructure, in terms of its libraries and computer networks, and
more recently has been experimenting with a variety of projects around open access and open
innovation. The turn to the digital is enabling scholars to participate in novel ways in new configura-
tions and in rethinking the nature of scholarly communication itself. Third, federal funding programs
now exist in Canada that require participation in the community, for example, the Community-
University Research Alliances (CURA) research grants
9
and public outreach funds mentioned ear-
lier that support knowledge transfer, or knowledge mobilisation activities in the community.
9
The purpose of the program is to support the creation of alliances between community organizations and postsecon-
dary institutions which, through a process of ongoing collaboration and mutual learning, will foster innovative research,
training and the creation of new knowledge in areas of importance for the social, cultural or economic development of Ca-
nadian communities.
607 Gale Moore
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
This is not to suggest that this achieves or even approximates the kind of change that is required
if significant transdisciplinary engagement is to take place in the university. However, it does sug-
gest that the timing may be right to launch more ambitious and novel explorations and experiments.
ICTs-and-Society in its aspiration to transdisciplinarity and its broad substantive concerns is well
positioned to start a dialogue on how to systematically recognize the challenges and opportunities
raised by transdisciplinary research in the university generally and in terms of ICTs-and-Society
specifically. Taking an innovation perspective, the question is not whether the university can ac-
commodate this engagement of disciplines and intellectual traditions in ways that make it possible
for a field such as ICTs-and-Society to evolve in the university, but how it can be accomplished.
There is value both in diversity and in discipline. Training future scholars and practitioners who
wish to engage in transdisciplinarity is an essential part of the way forward. Gerhard Fischer argues
that there is a need to develop transdisciplinarity competencies that “refer to knowledge and skills
required to identify, frame and address important scientific and practical problems that cut across
disciplinary boundaries” (2003, p. 3). With Fischer we see innovations in pedagogy as critical in
preparing the next generation of graduate students for the challenges they will face as researchers
and as practitioners. Innovations on this front may be easier to achieve. The stakes are high. If
transdisciplinarity cannot be accomplished within the academy, or junior scholars cannot partici-
pate, then much will be lost – both intellectually and to the universities who are looked to for new
thinking and innovative ideas.
5. Conclusion
Universities are traditional institutions with long established structures such as departments, fac-
ulties and schools organised around disciplines that manage and control the distribution of rewards
and the orderly production of a scholarly career. Knowledge production takes place within well-
understood parameters, and while there are differences between fields, the legitimation of knowl-
edge claims within any field is held to be the responsibility of the disciplinary or epistemic commu-
nity of which it is a part. In terms of pedagogy, the lecture and seminar are traditional forms used
across the institution in the production of high quality personnel. These structures and processes
have served well for decades, if not centuries, and continue to serve well in parts of the academy.
However, the increased complexity, uncertainty, and connectedness of contemporary societies,
new capabilities with the turn to the digital, and the centrality of knowledge to future well-being and
sustainability requires new models. A transdisciplinary approach appears to offer a way forward for
ICTs-and-Society. In the context of the university can this move be articulated in ways that the insti-
tution is able to adopt?
Innovation and the creativity that drives it are understood to be strategic in bringing the univer-
sity into the 21st century. By framing the institutional reform required to accomplish transdisciplinar-
ity as institutional innovation we call for a re-invention of the university. This re-invention has the
potential to create new social value and to highlight the creative, generative and integrative nature
of transdisciplinary practice. It is precisely in working through the tensions of working across disci-
plines, across boundaries of practice and theory, and working collaboratively through community
engagement, where the potential for the re-invigoration of the university lies.
ICT-and-Society scholars are part of consciously inventing the way to a transdisciplinary future.
The relevance of the 21st century university may just depend on their ability to find creative solu-
tions to this challenge.
tripleC 9(2): 598-609, 2011 608
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
References
Baym, N. K. (2005). Introduction: Internet Research as It Isn't, Could Be, and Should Be. The Information Society 21(4),
229-232.
Brint, S. (2005). Creating the future: ‘new directions’ in American research universities. Minerva 43(1), 23-50.
Casey, B. A. (1994). The Administration and Governance of Interdisciplinary Programs. In J.T. Klein & W.G. Doty (Eds.),
Interdisciplinary Studies Today (pp. 53-67). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Facilitating Interdisciplinary Research (2005). Committee on Facilitating Interdisciplinary Research, Committee on Science,
Engineering, and Public Policy, National Academy of Sciences, National Academy of Engineering, and Institute of
Medicine. Washington, D.C.: National Academies Press.
Fallman, D. (2008.) The Interaction Design Research Triangle of Design Practice, Design Studies and Design Exploration.
Design Issues 24(3), 4-18.
Fischer, G. & Redmiles, D. (2008). Transdisciplinary Education and Collaboration. Contribution to the Human Computer
Interaction Consortium (HCIC) Workshop 2008; Education in HCI; HCI in Education. Retrieved from
http://l3d.cs.colorado.edu/~gerhard/papers/hcic2008.pdf
Frodeman, R., Mitcham, C. & Sacks, A.B. (2000/2001). Questioning Interdisciplinarity. Science, Technology and Society
Newsletter, 126 & 127, 1-5.
Fuchs, C. (2008.) Introduction to the Special Issue on ICTs and Society: PhD Students’ Transdisciplinary Research Pro-
jects. tripleC 6(2), i -viii.
Gibbons, M., Limoges, C., Nowotny, H., Schwartzman, S., Scott, P. & Trow, M. (1994). The New Production of Knowledge:
The Dynamics of Science and Research in Contemporary Societies. London: Sage.
Hofkirchner, W., Fuchs, C. Raffl, C., Schafranek, M., Sandoval, M. & Bichler, R. (2007). ICTs and Society: The Salzburg
Approach. Towards a Theory For, About and by Means of the Information Society. ICT&S Center Research Paper
No. 3. Retrieved from http://icts.sbg.ac.at/media/pdf/pdf1490.pdf
Hunsinger, J. (2005). Toward a Transdisciplinary Internet Research. The Information Society 21(4), 277-279.
Jacobs, J. A. & Frickel, S. (2009). Interdisciplinarity: A Critical Assessment. Annual Review of Sociology 35, 43-65.
James, C. (1986). Introduction: Partial Truths. In P.A. Erickson & L.D. Murphy (Eds.), Readings for a History of Anthropo-
logical Theory (pp. 598-630). Lancashire: Broadview Press.
Klein, J.T. (2000). A Conceptual Vocabulary of Interdisciplinary Science. In Weingart, P. & Stehr, N. (Eds.), Practising Inter-
disciplinarity (pp. 3- 24). Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Klein, J.T. (1990). Interdisciplinarity: History, Theory and Practice. Detroit, MI: Wayne State University Press.
Klein, J.T. (1996.) Crossing Boundaries: Knowledge, Disciplinarities and Interdisciplinarities. Charlottesville: University
Press of Virginia.
Kockelmans, J. J. (1979.) Why Interdisciplinarity? In J.J. Kockelmans (Ed.), Interdisciplinarity and Higher Education (pp.
123-160). University Park: The Pennsylvania State University Press.
Mitchell, W. J., Inouye, A. S. & Blumenthal, M. S. (Eds.) (2003). Beyond Productivity: Information, Technology, Innovation,
and Creativity. Washington, DC: National Academies Press.
Moore, G. (2003). Researching the Knowledge Society: Interdisciplinarity and Innovation in the University. Presented at the
4th International Conference on Technology, Policy and Innovation, Monterrey, Mexico, June 2003. (Published as
KMDI Working Paper, KMDI-WP-2003-3).
Moore, G. (2009). Re(defining) Interdisciplinarity: Re(forming) Universities. In Interrogations: Creative Interdisciplinarity in
Art & Design Research (pp. 13-24). Loughborough: Interrogations Conference Committee, DeMontfort University
Faculty of Art and Design & Loughborough University School of Art and Design.
Moore, G. (1997). Sharing Faces, Places and Spaces: The Ontario Telepresence Project Field Studies. In Finn, K., Sellen,
A.J. & Wilbur, S. (Eds.), Video-Mediated Communication (pp. 301-321). Mahwah, N.J.: Lawrence
Erlbaum Assoc.
Moore, G. & Baecker, R.M.B. (2006). The Knowledge Media Design Institute: An Adventure in Interdisciplinarity. In: Eibl, M.,
Reiterer, H., Stephan, P., Thiessen, F. (Eds.), Knowledge Media Design: Theorie, Methodik, Praxis (pp. 409-420).
2d.ed. Munich: Oldenbourg Verlag.
Moore, G. & Lottridge, D. (2010). Interaction Design in the University: Designing Disciplinary Interactions. CHI 2010, April
10-15, 2010, Atlanta, GA. [in press].
Nowotny, H., Scott, P. & Gibbon, M. (2003). Introduction: `Mode 2' revisited: The New Production of Knowledge. Minerva,
41(3), 179-194.
Turner, S. (2000). What are Disciplines? And How is Interdisciplinarity Difference? In: Weingart, P. & Stehr,N. (Eds.), Prac-
tising Interdisciplinarity (pp.46-65). Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
UNESCO. European Centre for Higher Education (1983). Interdisciplinarity in Higher Education: A Study. Bucharest: Euro-
pean Centre for Higher Education.
609 Gale Moore
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
About the Author
Gale Moore
is a member of the graduate faculty, Dept. of Sociology, University of Toronto; Senior Fellow and former director of the
University of Toronto’s Knowledge Media Design Institute, and adjunct faculty in OCAD University’s graduate program in
Strategic Foresight & Innovation. Her primary interests for the past 20 years have been the social impacts of ICTs in every-
day life, and on bringing an understanding of peoples’ experience and interaction with technology into the design of techni-
cal artifacts. She has a longstanding interest in institutional innovation and the ways various forms of interdisciplinarity
enhance creativity and foster innovation.