tripleC 9(2): 644-656, 2011
ISSN 1726-670X
http://www.triple-c.at
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Theorizing Citizenships in Late Modern ICT Societies
Jakob Svensson
jakob.svensson@kau.se, Karlstad University, Sweden
Abstract: In this paper I define citizenship, participation and the political for better understanding and analyses of political
participations in late modern ICT societies. I approach the topic from a comprehensive understanding of developments both
in society and technology, how they mutually reinforce each other and are best understood in tandem. Discussions of
citizenship are concerned with normative macro-perspectives of the good society and how it should be organized often
departing from micro-empirical studies of how society and political participation are changing. This combination of macro-
and micro-perspectives together with its multi- and interdisciplinary appeal makes citizenship ideal to approach from a
transdisciplinary point of departure. In the paper I propose an understanding of citizenship as participation in political com-
munities; ensembles of people addressing the organization of society and making sense of this address in a similar way.
Citizenships are enacted in relation to the authority of a political community, an authority that streams out of the values and
norms that are constructed and renegotiated through the participation of its members. Hence, it is both through participation
that citizens and political communities are made. The paper ends with a proposal of how to categorize online participation
and citizenship(s) in late modern ICT societies.
Keywords: Transdisciplinarity, late modernity, citizenship, participation, the political, governance, network society, conver-
gence
Acknowledgement: This article has been made possible with support by the Wahlgrenska foundation, HumanIT and Karl-
stad University.
When digital information technologies become increasingly important for communicating in West-
ern and connected communities, society as well as the individual takes on new and different mean-
ings. Some scholars connect transformations of communication patterns to us entering into a new
kind of society, network society (Benkler, 2006; Shirky, 2009), which according to Castells (2001) is
governed by another form of sociability, networked individualism. With the possibility to communi-
cate many to many in digital networks, together with enhanced processes of individualization in late
modernity, it is argued that we are leaving mass society behind.
One subject area that has been discussed as particularly affected by these developments is
citizenship. The rise of digital communication and the Internet have provided rays of hope for politi-
cal engagement with new and different understandings of citizenship participation in an otherwise
dark time of representative democracy marked by civic withdrawal from parliamentary politics. In
connected societies the Internet is considered the new arena for political action, often lowering the
political threshold with new and different forms for engaging people in deliberations about the struc-
ture and organization of society. When more and more people socialize, organize, contribute, in-
form and publish their concerns and themselves on the Internet, political participation take on dif-
ferent meanings and citizenships are enacted differently and hence needs to be theorized differ-
ently.
The purpose of this paper is to contribute to the theoretical discussions of citizenship for better
understandings and analyses of political participations in late modern ICT societies. To achieve this
it is important to avoid deterministic causal approached of relationships between technology, soci-
ety and the individual and rather adopt a transdisciplinary understanding of contemporary devel-
opments and how they mutually reinforce each other.
tripleC 9(2): 644-656, 2011 645
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
1. Citizenship from a Transdisciplinary Perspective
Discussions of citizenship are per se concerned with macro-perspectives, combining behavioral
understandings of inhabitants engagement with socio-political theories of how society and politics
are changing, connecting empirical studies of participation to normative visions of the good society
and how it should be structured (see Isin & Turner, 2002; Kivisto & Faist, 2007). Citizenship has
thus been studied from different disciplines and is in this sense multidisciplinary (see Nicolescu,
2002, p. 42). Due to this multidisciplinarity, citizenship is also interdisciplinary, making use of a
variety of methods from many disciplines (ibid., p. 43) as varied as quantitative content analyses in
news studies (McNair, 2000), to more participatory observations in ethnographic studies of citizen-
ship (see Camauë r, 2000). What is interesting with the idea of transdisciplinarity is its concern of
what is between and across disciplines (Nicolescu, 2002, p. 44). Transdisciplinarity thus becomes
a new form of learning and problem solving involving cooperation among different parts of society
and academia (Thompson Klein et al. 2001, p. 7). One of the tasks of transdisciplinarity is to clarify
theoretical concepts and their value (ibid., p. 5). My aim, to define citizenship to better understand
political participation in late modern ICT societies, is in this sense transdisciplinary. Citizenship in
itself could be understood as transdisciplinary since the concept implies the individual and society
at the same time. Discussing citizenship we need to attend to individual behavior and motivations
as well as normative theories of societal organization and empirical studies of cultural, technologi-
cal and societal changes. Hence, citizenship makes a perfect subject area to study from a transdis-
ciplinary perspective.
One aim of transdisciplinarity is to understand the present world (Nicolescu, 2002, p. 46) beyond
the contemporary proliferation of disciplines (ibid., p. 33; see also Thompson Klein et al. 2001, p.
4). In Nicolescu's (2001) grand manifesto of transdisciplinarity he uses arguments from Quantum
Physics to abstract art. Even though my knowledge only spans over selected fields in the Social
and Political Sciences, I believe the transdisciplinary quest for understanding beyond strict aca-
demic disciplines is beneficial when analyzing citizenship due to changes in both technology and
culture. As I will argue in this paper, changes in technology and culture are best understood in tan-
dem, and the purpose of this paper is to understand political participations in ICT societies regard-
less if approaching this area from Information Systems, Media and Communication Studies, Soci-
ology, Political Science or Philosophy. Research within disciplines can be clarified by transdiscipli-
nary approaches and vice versa, transdisciplinarity is nourished by disciplinary research
(Nicolescu, 2002, p. 45). Hence disciplinary and transdisciplinary research are complementary (see
also Thompson Klein et al. 2001, p.4).
In this paper I will consider both socio-technological and political scientific understandings and
the dialectics between them. Before turning to technological aspects of contemporary political par-
ticipation, I will start discussing citizenship from a socio-cultural understanding of our time as late
modern.
2. Changing Participatory Patterns in Late Modernity
The victory of liberal democracy and market capitalism, symbolized with the Berlin Wall coming
down 1989 as the last reminiscent of communist society, led Fukuyama (1992) to proclaim the end
of history. Ten years later some theoreticians (Carter & Stokes, 1998; Bauman, 2001) observed the
side effects of liberal democracy; social disintegration and voter alienation. Citizens in western
liberal societies more frequently declare themselves to be dissatisfied (Bentivegna, 2006). Market
capitalism as way to organize public administration under the promise of New Public Management,
seems to have reduced citizenship to consumption, and turned citizens away from traditional are-
nas of political participation (Bauman, 2001). Boggs (2000) refers to this as the great retreat.
The practices of citizenship are changing. Some claim that inhabitants are withdrawing away
from a supposedly vivid agora full of debating citizens, and becoming increasingly sceptical and
distrusting, with the result of a decrease in political participation (Fishkin, 1991). Such a dystopian
description is mostly echoed in parliamentary frameworks. For example, the EU-elections June
646 Jakob Svensson
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
2009 were claimed to be the biggest transnational elections in history. However, only 43 % of the
electorate chose to cast their vote, making participation the lowest in the 30 years of EU election
history. Low participation in elections together with a decreasing faith in politicians and membership
in political parties (Peterson, Westholm, & Blomberg, 1989; Olsson, 2006) have launched a debate
on civic disinterest, distrust and the legitimacy of parliamentary politics and its representatives.
Despite decreasing participation in parliamentary arenas, there are other sites of political debate,
not solely limiting political participation to representative democracy, suggesting new arenas for
citizenship practices. It is in this context the Internet enters into the discussion forwarding a picture
of engaged and interactive citizens under the promise of web 2.0 and emerging social media plat-
forms.
Sociologists explain changing participatory patterns in part as a result of us entering a new
phase of history: late modernity (Giddens, 1991; Beck, 1995; Bauman, 2001). Dahlgren (2006)
characterizes late modernity by identifying two interrelated cultural processes at work: dispersion of
unifying cultural frameworks and individualization. The first refers to the increasing pluralisation,
fragmentation and nichification of society along lines of ethnicity, media consumption, cultural in-
terests, life styles, interests, tastes etc (ibid.). Individualization refers to a lacking sense of social
belonging and a growing feeling of personal autonomy (ibid.). Disinterest towards political participa-
tion on the parliamentary arena and withdrawal from representative democracy can be understood
in the light of these cultural changes.
Bauman (2001), who put forward a dystopic vision of individualism in late modernity, equates the
civic withdrawal away from formal politics, with a larger withdrawal away from also collective identi-
ties and community sensibilities (se also Boggs, 2000). However, a more positive account of late
modern political participation is provided by Beck (1995, 1998) and his concept of sub-politics. He
regards individualization and dispersion of unified cultural frameworks as not necessarily inhibiting
political participation and citizenship. Supporting this more positive account is the rise of new are-
nas for political participation, such as everyday life at the home, the street or online, arenas with
activities such as signing petitions, voicing concerns and protests by creating and joining new
groups and associations outside the Parliament (Peterson, Westholm, & Blomberg, 1989; Beck,
1995; Bennett & Entman, 2001; Dahlgren, 2001). Even though these groups seem to be more
short-lived, single-issue oriented and digitally managed, they point out late modern processes of
individualization as not resulting in a general withdrawal from politics, but rather a more lifestyle-
based approach to participation (Giddens, 1991). It seems that political participation online increas-
ingly has become part of an individual self-realization project. This also underlines reflexivity as a
dominant theme in late modernity. Reflexivity implies that we consider ourselves and our practices
from different perspectives, always re-considering previously acquired knowledge (Giddens, 1991).
Before assessing the specifics of citizenship practices and political participation, I will attend to
the more technologically ascribed characteristics of contemporary late modern societies.
3. Convergence and Network Society
Almost everyone agrees that the rise of digital communication and the Internet has resulted in re-
markable changes in communication patterns and social organization at large. For example it can
be argued that the advent of the printing press is tied to the rise of mass society and mass culture.
Horkheimer (1947) and the Frankfurt School were early to discuss cultural forms as part of larger
societal structure. Today, many scholars make a similar argument, connecting digital transforma-
tions of communication to changes in Western and connected societies (see Benkler, 2006; Shirky,
2009). With the possibility to communicate many to many in digital networks, it can be argued that
we are leaving mass society behind. It is with the advent of cyberspace and virtual reality, that
Nicolescu (2001, p. 75) identifies a need for transdisciplinary approaches to science.
Here it is important to avoid causal explanations of technology and society and to be critical of
cyber-optimistic accounts. Andrejevic (2009) for example points out that only because media has
transformed, political power has not, suggesting the possibility that political communities may ad-
just to incorporate digital media in ways that preserve existing power relations and dominant eco-
tripleC 9(2): 644-656, 2011 647
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
nomic systems. But the implementation of digital technology has increased the possibility for any-
one with Internet connection to construct, join and participate in online political communities
(Benkler, 2006; Lü ders, 2007; Shirky, 2009). This is different from mass society. But what this will
lead up to in terms of changing relations of power, and how and for whom these possibilities will be
used, remains to be further researched.
One aspect of our changing society is illuminated by the concept of convergence. Convergence
became a buzzword in the 1990’s together with interactivity and the information society (Storsul &
Stuedahl, 2007). Literary, convergence means movement directed to the same point (Fagerfjord &
Storsul, 2007, p. 19). The starting point for assuming media convergence was the digitalization of
signals (ibid., p. 20). In short convergence implies that in new digital environments, consumption
and production of mediated messages are more intertwined and personalized than before.
Jenkins (2006) describes convergence as a flow of content across multiple media platforms, co-
operation between multiple media industries, but convergence also entails a migratory behaviour of
media audiences. In his book Convergence Culture (2006) he discusses the relationships between
media convergence, collective intelligence and participatory culture. He claims that convergence
encourages participation, complicating relations between top-down corporate media and bottom-up
participatory culture (ibid.). It used to be difficult and expensive to mediate images, words and
sounds from a media producer to a consumer. This favoured a complex media industry developing
its own cultures and professions, underlining the division between production and consumption of
information. With digital technology it has become easier to communicate within larger self-made
networks. This collapse of “communication costs” (Benkler, 2006, p. 212), increasingly blurs the
division between media production, media distribution and media consumption that tend to con-
verge into one. People both like to consume, produce and share media. Now having the techno-
logical tools that support all these activities, we increasingly do so in one activity. Blogging about a
news report is an example of this. Thus, the act of media consumption is increasingly intercon-
nected with media production and media sharing, making the isolated act of media consumption
rather a temporary behaviour than a permanent identity (Shirky, 2009).
The new digital communication infrastructure challenges traditional media institutions when con-
trol over media and information is less in the hands of the media professional (Shirky, 2009). As an
example, mass media’s gate-keeping function and monopoly on news framing is challenged
through blogs and social media where communication is fast, far-reaching and networked. How-
ever convergence is an ambiguous concept since it is used differently both with regard to what is
converging and what happens when something converges (Storsul & Stuedahl, 2007). Fagerfjord &
Storsul (2007, p. 29) is calling for a more complex framework for participatory culture than conver-
gence invites.
From a transdisciplinary perspective, the socio-cultural changes, outlined in late modern per-
spectives, are happening at the same time as we experience this technological shift towards digi-
talization and convergence. This is not a coincidence but rather developments that go hand in
hand. Digital technology and processes of late modernity mutually reinforce/ are part of the same
trends towards a kind of networked individualism (Castells, 2001). Increasing individualization and
the rise of the network as a dominant model of sociability, challenges our understandings of politi-
cal participation and citizenship practices. Approaching this from a transdisciplinary framework, it is
important not take on a determinist standpoint of either technology or society (Ekelin, 2007, p. 12;
Frau-Meigs, 2007; Andrejevic, 2009; Roberts, 2009). Instead more efforts should be put into ex-
ploring the mutual co-construction of society, citizens and technology. Aspects of citizenship
change when social conditions change (Dobson, 2003, p. 35); hence technology, society and citi-
zenship develop in a dialectical relationship. The citizen is constituted as a subject of a social prac-
tice and at the same time also constitutes him/ herself as a subject of a certain social (and techno-
logical) practice. Citizens are both objects of domination as well as subjects with an ambition to
create their own field of agency (Ekelin, 2007, p. 66). It is in these dialectical practices that we
should start to theorize citizenship in late modernity for a more transdisciplinary understanding of
contemporary ICT societies.
648 Jakob Svensson
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
4. Citizenship, Participation and the Political
Citizenship is often linked to privileges of membership of a political community (most often a nation
state), privileges that consist of equal participation with fellow citizens on the making of the collec-
tive decisions that regulate social life of that political community (Barbalet, 1988, p. 2-4; Castles &
Davidson, 2000, pp. 32-33; Hoffman, 2004, p. 98; Bellamy, 2008, p. 1). Hence, citizenship is usu-
ally to describe a set of institutions, practises and identities connected to people’s aspirations for
democracy and equality (Bosniak, 2006, p. 11). Discussions of citizenship often revolve around its
substance, its location and its subjects (ibid., p. 17). Thus larger concepts of citizenships have
come to encompass a variety of elements in Social and Political Sciences, from the legal and so-
ciological to the psychological and behavioural. Today there is a huge interest in citizenship, an
interest which manifests itself not least through the many new types of citizenships continuously
proliferating (see Dobson, 2003, p. 4, Hoffman, 2004, p. 1; Kivisto & Faist, 2007, p. 2). The wide-
spread use of the notion creates confusion what it actually entails and how it could be used across
disciplines (Bosniak, 2006, p. 4). Looking through the literature it is obvious that ideas of citizenship
have not been static, understandings have changed, been reshaped and hence also extended
meanings of the concept to new disciplines and domains (Schuck, 2002, p. 131; Bosniak, 2006, p.
121). The question then arises; how is citizenship to be understood to be relevant and usable in
late modern ICT societies, marked by digitalization, pluralisation and individualization?
Discussing citizenship here I will mostly attend to its substance and location; what citizenship is
and where it takes place, addressing sociological and behavioural aspects of citizenship. This has
of course implications for its subjects, who will get included or excluded and power relations (see
Isin & Wood, 1999; Bosniak, 2006), but is not the main focus here. Questions of the changing sub-
stance and location of citizenship in late modern ICT societies will inevitably get entangled into a
discussion of our conceptions of the political and participation. Understanding citizenship(s) then is
impossible without also attending to ideas of participation and the political and their interconnec-
tions. I start with citizenship.
4.1. Citizenship
In increasingly globalised, digital and non-territorial communities, the question has been posed
whether if it is outdated and problematic to conceive of citizenship as membership in a nation state.
However, globalization does not imply equal relations of interdependence since it is an asymmetri-
cal process where some (in the south) are more dependent than others (in the north) (Dobson,
2003, pp. 12-13). For both these reasons the idea has been put forward that citizenship privileges
should be expanded to all human beings, equating the category of citizen to humans in general
(Turner, 1994; Linklater, 2002; Lister, 2002; Smith, 2002, pp. 105-106; Hoffman, 2004; Bellamy,
2008, p. 77). It is evident that the normative weight of universality attached to citizenship has made
the concept a useful tool for political struggle, to fight injustice and to claim recognition for different
and marginalized groups in society (see Cruikshank, 1999, p. 1; Lister, 2002; Bosniak, 2006, p.
35). This underlines an ambiguity within the concept; citizenship is associated with community be-
longing at the same time as it should apply to all human beings (Bosniak, 2006, p. 18). My argu-
ment is that in order to keep its relevance as an analytical tool for transdisciplinary knowledge, it is
vital to make a distinction between human beings and citizens (Svensson, 2008, p. 24). In a similar
argument Dobson (2003, p. 27) and Bellamy (2008, p. 79) underline citizenship as a specific kind
of relationship that should not be broadened to encompass human relations generally. According to
Aristotle (discussed in Dobson, 2003, p. 66), citizenship is always related to a constitution rather
than humanity.
From a similar perspective, I believe that recognizing some centre of power, and authority, is im-
portant in order for the possibility to direct right claims as a citizen as well as to accept duties and
regulations put on you as a citizen. In this sense, the practice of citizenship also entails accepting
decisions made by others, or some sort of authority (polis), as implied by Aristotle’s definition of
citizens as ruling and being ruled in turn (discussed in Bellamy 2008, pp. 32-35). Also civic republi-
tripleC 9(2): 644-656, 2011 649
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
cans recognize political authority as important for attaching civic virtues to (Dobson, 2003, p. 61).
Therefore I have argued that citizenship is best understood as participation in a relation to some
kind of authority (Svensson, 2008, p. 23). Participation in a political community also constructs the
political authority in relation to which inhabitants become citizen.
Discussing citizenship as a form of membership practice, it is important to keep in mind that in
contemporary globalised ICT societies, political community does not have to come in the shape of
a nation state. The notion of political community does not imply per se that the community has to
be bounded to territoriality (Dobson 2003, p. 72) or predetermined. Defining community around
boundaries of interest and meaning-making instead makes more sense in a reflexive and late
modern society with digital communication that in many cases transcends state territory and unites
users around cultural interests, life styles and tastes. In a similar fashion Bruns (2009, p. 11) dis-
cusses online communities as groups of people with a set of shared values, beliefs, norms and
ideas. These shared values, norms and ideas then constitute the core of the political community,
out of which authority is constituted and claimed. Adherence to, and socialisation into, community
values then becomes important for determining relations and power mechanisms within a commu-
nity (Bruns, 2009, p. 5). For example, joining an online petition against the destruction of nearby
bath- house, I soon realized that online visibility through activities such as facebooking and twitter-
ing would get me closer to the core of the activist group. By echoing popular argument through
#twittering and through posting encouraging entries on the Facebook fan page, I was not only
showing my sympathy for the participatory and expressive values of the activist group, but I also
reinforced these values and the authority of certain other active group members by commenting
and re-tweeting their tweets.
However community norms and values are not fixed but subject to constant renegotiation and
gradual change (Bruns, 2009, p. 11). Hence, communities in late modern ICT societies are porous,
casual and debated constellations (Delanty 2002, pp. 171-172) and thus far from predetermined. A
citizen’s relation to the political community cannot be fixed and needs constant renegotiation. In
late modernity we should also consider a network of more discursive political communities that
citizens are potential members in (Dobson, 2003, p. 74). Meaning-making as the defining character
of political community enables us to theorize about citizenship in a late modern ICT society across
disciplines, making citizenship relevant even in a society characterised by reflexivity, physical and
communication mobility and reach. An analysis of citizenship from this perspective implies that
what we should look for, in order to understand citizenship, are processes of value negotiation and
other meaning-making conditions that give ground for community authority in relation to which citi-
zenships are enacted. As I mentioned in the previous section, the loci for such meaning making
processes are changing in late modern ICT societies.
4.2. Participation
Analyses of citizenships will almost always enter into a discussion of rights and duties (Pocock,
1995). The rights that define citizenship are undergoing continual process of redefinition, not least
through the political participation of citizens themselves. Given the fluidity of (political) communities
in digital late modernity, civic rights and duties cannot be conceived of as fixed or stable entities.
Accepting such structuring and dialectic relationship between community, participation and civic
rights, participation becomes entangled into the very core of the concept of citizenship. In this
sense citizenship as membership with rights and benefits attached to it, cannot be sustained with-
out members participating for the forth living of the community. Citizenship thus implies the capac-
ity to participate and the duty to use this capacity on which our other rights and democracy depend
(Bellamy, 2008, pp. 13, 17, 25). Participation thus becomes so fundamental to citizenship that it is
discussed both as a right and a duty.
Bellamy (2008, p. 3) claims that the mere possibility for equal participation affects how citizens
regard their other duties such as abiding laws, paying taxes et cetera. From this perspective justice
and equality becomes important as the social bonds that ties community members together as
citizens. Dobson (2003) forwards justice rather than charity as defining the civic bond, and by doing
650 Jakob Svensson
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
this, distinguishes political from human community and citizenship from humanity. The promise of
just and equal participation motivates us to collaborate with our fellow citizens. Nicolescu (2001, p.
89) discusses transdisciplinarity as the science discovering powerful social ties for finding our place
in this world. A civic bond consisting of a promise of justice and equality could very well be such a
social tie between people.
Discussing participation from a perspective of justice and equality we need to attend to issues of
power and its relation to participation. Cruikshank (1999, p. 2) argues that modes of constituting
and regulating citizenship, transform individual subjects into citizens. The will to empower through
regimes of participatory democracy is both enabled and constrained by relations of power. The
discussion board on a municipal webpage for example, is enabled by democratically elected repre-
sentatives and their wish to be in dialogue with the citizenry. However, since these representatives
also hold the decision-making power, what comes out of these deliberations is in their hands.
Cruikshank (1999, p. 34) points out that contemporary non-participation and political disinterest
places a strain upon liberal democratic government. The municipal discussion board may very well
be a way for politicians to increase participation with the only purpose of solidifying the platform
political representatives legitimates their exercise of power from. In Cruickshank’s (1999, p. 3)
analysis, the quest for empowering the poor and self-governing programmes for disenfranchised,
are embedded in a liberal discourse of governance with all its asymmetrical power relations at-
tached to it. In this way she argues that citizens are not born, but made through democratic modes
of governance. Governance is defined here as relations of power that aim to guide and shape the
actions of others (citizens), rather than force control and domination (ibid., p. 4), and hence a more
subtle and sophisticated way of exercising power. ICT can very well be used for these purposes as
municipal discussion boards online are examples of. Cruikshank thus underlines that democratic
relations, also in a late modern, many-to-may and digitalized society, still constitute relations of
power. Power should thus be constitutive to every analysis of citizenship and not just an add-on
(see also Dobson, 2003, pp. 21, 62). Citizens are envisioned by political stakeholders that set up
technologies for citizens’ participation departing from their idealised visions of them. Inhabitants are
therefore subject to power even as they participate as citizens in their own right (Cruikshank, 1999,
pp. 20, 24).
Cruikshank (1999, pp. 32, 45) claims that power can both be voluntary and coercive at the same
time, and she discusses political power as an ongoing result of forming and reforming authority. As
discussed previously when defining community, authority is claimed through shared values and
norms that constitute the core of the political community. It is then in the claiming of community
authority, through negotiation of its values and norms, that power manifests itself.
From these discussions on participation, power and community, it becomes evident that citizen-
ship is best understood as an activity, the act of doing something, rather than a fixed status, mem-
bership merely ascribing certain people as citizens and non-citizens (see also Svensson 2008, p.
23). From a discursive framework, citizenship is also best analyzed as a process, conflating politi-
cal participation with citizenship so it becomes almost the same thing. Also community and partici-
pation becomes hard to separate from this perspective. Turner (1994, p. 159) for example uses a
definition of citizenship as an ensemble of meaning making practices that constitutes individuals as
members in a community. The character of political community is influenced by peoples’ participa-
tion, which in turn is influenced by the political authority in relation to which citizens participate.
To sum up the discussion of citizenship then, it is claimed to consist of three components; mem-
bership, participation, rights and duties, components that stand and fall together (Bellamy, 2008,
pp. 16, 25), but where participation become so entangled into the other two components that you
may equate citizenship with participation. Citizenship (participation) is tied to a political community.
Rights (to participate) and duties (to participate) are attached to this community. Citizenship as
participation also fits very well a transdisciplinary perspective since cooperation among different
parts of society is difficult without participation (see Thompson Klein, 2001, pp. 7, 195).
tripleC 9(2): 644-656, 2011 651
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
4.3. The political
The previous definition of citizenship makes the notion of the political relevant to the theoretical
framework. Some argue that citizenship could refer to any group, not only political ones or the na-
tion state (see Smith, 2002; Bosniak, 2006). But the spheres where citizenships will be enacted are
commonly understood as political (Bosniak, 2006, p. 20), or they become political when certain
actions and identities are performed there (which is increasingly the case in late modernity which
ideas of sub-, and life-politics underline (see Giddens, 1991; Beck, 1995)). The crucial question
then is what the political consists of? What differentiates political communities from ordinary com-
munities? What types of actions and identities differentiate a community so it can be considered
political? What differentiates political participation from ordinary participation? Does the political
merely connote a collective dimension and a dimension of shared common purposes (as the re-
publicans would have it, see Dobson, 2003, p. 59)? Is then political participation the same as
members’ practices that are directed towards collective goals for the common good of the mem-
bership collective? A too narrow definition of the political may be limiting our perspectives, but on
the other hand a too broad definition makes it useless as an analytical tool for understanding con-
temporary citizenship(s) across disciplines.
The political has a normative dimension because it deals with how society should be structured
(Nord, 2008, p. 36). But our visions of good society are constantly changing, this pointing towards a
definition of the political as a social and discursive construction, continuously being defined by citi-
zens’ practices (see Cruikshank, 1999, p. 17; Dahlgren 2001, pp. 40, 42). The practices of politics,
understood here as the address of issues concerning the organization of society, are most often
based in a principle of equality, an equal division of society’s common goods (Rancière, discussed
by Arsenjuk, 2005, pp. 88, pp. 91-92). Also according to Dobson (2003, p. 29) the principle of equal
share entails a political type of obligation, opening up for a conception of citizenship beyond the
state and beyond some kind of universal humanity. Different groups/ communities may have diver-
gent opinions on the equal division of society’s common goods and thus enter into debate with
each other. Justice and equality seem to be entangled deep into the concept of the political.
The organization of society many times concerns the everyday life. Thus the political is also re-
constituted at a micro-level (Cruikshank, 1999, p. 5). There citizenships are negotiated in the
therapeutic, disciplinary, programmatic, institutional and associational activities of everyday life
(ibid., p. 28), hence the private sphere constitutes a site of power relations and political struggle
(Dobson, 2003, pp. 53, 56) where ideas of the structure and organization of society are expressed
and put into practice. Identity politics, such as the feminist and gay movements, are examples of
this. In this way the dichotomy private versus public becomes inadequate for defining the political.
In a similar manner Nicolescu (2001, p. 22) forwards a multilevel understanding of reality that only
a transdisciplinary perspective can grasp. He claims that interior and exterior faces are two facets
of the same world (ibid. 89). Similarly Beck (1995, p. 143) underlines that the individual, not only
social and collective agents, also shapes politics. For example, choosing to stay home with the kids
is in this sense a political decision.
Citizenship transcends a divide between the public and private. Citizenship rights for example
are attached to individuals, but the argument for having those rights has an important collective
dimension (Bellamy, 2008, pp. 14-15). They appeal to certain goods for human beings leading a
life together with others, they appeal to how society should be structured in an equal and just man-
ner. It is a political community of members who can grant rights, in which members (citizens) seek
fair terms of association to secure those goods necessary for them to pursue their doings on just
and equal terms with fellow members (Pocock, 1995, p. 33; Bellamy, 2008, p. 16). Society and the
individual are thus not in a dichotomised relation to each other, both are central for the political.
Governance for example is a way of framing agency from an individual as well as a collective per-
spective (Cruikshank, 1999, p. 9). Hence it makes no sense to speak of the political, the social, the
technological, the private or the public as separate domains. In this manner changes in both the
social and the technological open up for new possibilities for political agency.
652 Jakob Svensson
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Combining the discussion of the political with a definition of community based in an idea of simi-
lar practices of meaning-making, we end up with an understanding of political community as an
ensemble of people addressing the organization of society and making sense of this address in a
similar way, at the same time constructing and renegotiating values and norms out of which the
authority of the community streams, in relation to which citizens are made. When people then par-
ticipate and act upon shared meanings, address issues of the structure of society in relation to an
authority, they enter into the practice of citizenship. In this way we can distinguish between political
participation from other kinds of activities.
Political participation does not have to be purposeful engagement (as civic republicans would
argue, see Bosniak, 2006, p. 92). In digital late modernity the political may occur outside of the
Parliament and all over the socio-cultural landscape. Citizenship practices do not have to originate
from within a self-proclaimed political community such as for example on hockey fan-pages where
immigration is discussed as valuable for recruiting skilful players (Svensson, 2010). Digital technol-
ogy and its uses for political, democratic and participatory practices, influence behaviours of both
citizens and elected representatives, setting up new norms of what may be considered and valued
as appropriate topics and practices in these communities. These digital changes of location and
thus also norms and values of political communities in late modernity inevitably impact the sub-
stance of citizenship and our conceptions of the political. The political thus becomes entangled with
citizenship and participation, implying that an attempt to understand participation and citizenship in
an increasingly digital society, at the same time is an inquiry into the changing construction of the
political. In other words, when citizenship practices are changing together with its arenas and
emerging new communities, the conceptions of the political are also changing. For example blog-
ging about your life as a home wife could be considered political.
Why spending so much time trying to sort out definitions of citizenship, participation and the po-
litical? In the debate on the Internet and its democratic and citizenship potential, cyber-optimists
tend to equate every link, every social forum as a sign of political participation, whereas others
dismiss online political participation as narcissistic self-promotion. Interactivity is not automatically
political it has to be made political (Andrejevic, 2009), hence it is important to know what we are
talking about when we delineate practices as political or not. A definition of citizenship as practices
in relation to some kind of political community with authority attached to it (in the form of construct-
ing and negotiating community values and norms) is important in order to distinguish political par-
ticipation online from other kinds of online activities.
As I will attend to next, the discussion of changing loci of discussions of how to structure society
(the political) implies that citizenship practices do not have to take place from within self- pro-
claimed political communities. I will end this paper with a suggestion of how to categorize participa-
tion and citizenship online.
5. Categorizing the Field of Political Participation and Citizenships in Late Modern
ICT Societies
One framework for categorizing citizenship practices and political participation is to make distinc-
tions between online political communities based on initiative and locality. First of all we have what
I chose to label parliamentary communities, a top-down initiative localizing political participation
within a representative democratic community. Within parliamentary communities the Internet (e-
democracy, e-governance, e-administration) is used to promote and revitalize representative de-
mocracy. This has been labelled e-democracy from above (Coleman & Blumler, 2009) since it is
done from a top-down perspective with politicians or governmental officials launching different ini-
tiatives to engage and interest the citizenry in its doings. The municipal forums online for discus-
sions with politicians are examples of parliamentary online communities.
The political system also includes civic organizations outside the Parliament, such as NGO’s
(non-governmental organizations) as well as individual citizens in loosely organized gatherings and
groupings. These more bottom-up activist communities are different from parliamentary communi-
ties, where citizens themselves (or together) engage in, or initiate, political activities and collective
tripleC 9(2): 644-656, 2011 653
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
action through and with the help of digital tools. The activist group protesting against the destruc-
tion of the neighbourhood bathhouse is an example of an activist community. Coleman & Blumler
(2009) label this as e-democracy from below
Having outlined a constructivist understanding of the political and citizenship practices in late
modernity, it is also important to include more popular or cultural communities where the political
(and hence also citizenship) may pop up everywhere in the popular and cultural sphere, not primar-
ily set up for political or citizenship purposes. The Internet is the life- and sub-political medium par
excellence, heightening cultural processes such as pluralisation, fragmentation, nichification and
individualization. Hockey fan pages online are examples of cultural communities (Svensson, 2010).
A distinction of online participation and citizenship practices between parliamentary, activist and
cultural communities I believe is beneficial for analytical purposes separating and classifying differ-
ent political practices online. However from a transdisciplinary perspective it is important to keep in
mind that these communities may blur into each other, intersect in networks and sometimes difficult
to separate. As Ekelin (2007, pp. 68-69) underlines, exercising citizenship by electronic means,
could be regarded as a continual activity, based on co-construction, blurring boundaries between
parliamentary authorities, activist, private actors and inhabitants. Politics and power are properties
of relationships between these actors (Ekelin, 2007, p. 74).
From an activist community perspective the Internet is a more egalitarian platform for communi-
cation that transcends territoriality and state censorship. This is widely discussed by Shirky in his
book Here Comes Everybody (2009). From an activist point of view, the more free and less authori-
tarian infrastructure online networks provides, the more democratic potential they have, such as
political actions opposing election results in countries such as Iran have bear witness on (Christen-
sen, 2009). Jenkins (2006) is also theorizing Internet participation from a bottom-up perspective,
but he is discussing participation in a more popular cultural community setting. What digital tech-
nology does for activist and popular cultural communities is to remove barriers to collective action:
locality of information and barriers to group action (Shirky, 2009, p. 153). Digital technology en-
hances cooperation and coordination for group action towards ends that is sometimes hard to pre-
dict. Loosely structured groups are often coordinated without managerial supervision. However a
shared digital platform may conclude with cooperation and even collective action. In order for this
to happen shared beliefs and values (community) are important (Shirky, 2009, p. 163). Awareness,
beliefs and values are communicated on digital platforms today. Especially from an activist com-
munity perspective, digital platforms enable like-minded people to act collectively without having to
go through official organizations, territorial barriers and state censorship. Prominent examples are
the protests and gatherings against election results in Moldova and Iran 2009. But there are also
examples from Western democracies of this kind of activism. In Sweden, for example, online com-
munities of bloggers managed to put issues of surveillance, integrity and privacy to debate in con-
nection to the passing of a law giving the state rights to record its citizens (FRA). The politicians
largely framed the issue in an anti-terrorist discourse, but through the bloggers and web-pages
opposing the passing of this law, they managed to create an opinion and get the initial proposal
turned down in the Parliament.
Parliamentary online communities often depart from a deliberative understanding of democracy
consisting of debating and public spirited citizens, attentive to the interests of others, and willing to
transform their preferences in process of deliberation (Dryzek, 2000). Within parliamentary online
communities there are also more instrumental understandings of e-government as aiming at ra-
tionalizing and modernizing public administration and its relations with citizens, enabling to realize
a better and more efficient administration (Ekelin, 2007, p. 1). Side by side with this instrumental
discourse Ekelin (2007) discusses e-government as also considering citizens active contribution. In
this almost contradictory discourse, e-participation is described as processes of governance
through deliberative discussions with the dual purpose of both empowering citizens and helping to
renew the representative democratic model of democracy and fight the perceived growing democ-
ratic deficit (Ekelin, 2007, p. 22). Within such deliberative discourses, e-participation is envisioned
to benefit citizens, raise their interest for politics, open up for increased direct civic involvement,
654 Jakob Svensson
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
active citizen participation, and the overall modernisation of the governmental sector (Ekelin, 2007,
p. 21). Internet practices within this framework are often envisioned as form of virtual agora of
ideas and rational discussion.
Important to keep in mind that even though e-government slips between an instrumental dis-
course of administrative rationalisation and a deliberative discourse of e-participation (Ekelin, 2007,
p. 23), it is almost always framed from a top-down perspective within parliamentary communities, in
the service of representative democracy (as opposed to activist and popular cultural communities).
Within parliamentary communities, e-government tends to reinforce the consultation aspect rather
than empowerment and direct decision-making (see Ekelin, 2007, pp. 26-27). However, there are
examples of top-down e-participatory initiatives that aim for bottom-up participation. Local issues
discussion forums (see Smith, 2009) for example aspire to generate a permanent local issue-based
deliberative debate that invigorates local democracy from the bottom-up.
6. Conclusion
Convergence, predicting a loss of control of old media institutions, together with bottom up per-
spectives on political participation and municipal deliberative experiments, all suggest more possi-
bilities for ordinary citizens to express themselves and organize group action, in a sense implying
that everything is in the hands of the connected user. However, we need to be aware of that proc-
esses of governance sometimes preserves existing power relations and we also need to be aware
of the ways commercial interests increasingly are monetizing on the information we generate about
ourselves in for example social media. Some claim (see Terranova, 2004; Andrejevic, 2007) that
the blurring of the categories of consumer and producer is a way to exploit free labour. It is also
important to keep in mind that non-benevolent authorities and commercial interests may also use
digital platforms in order to gather information about their citizens and potential consumers (Andre-
jevic, 2007; Christensen, 2009). As Andrejevic (2009) points out, Google will provide me with a free
e-mail address if I let them data-mine my messages. Facebook will help me keep in touch with
friends if I let them use information I post to learn about me and eventually target market to me
(ibid.). Thus, theorizing citizenship(s) in ICT societies it is important not to put the issue of power
aside, since communication in networks also will be unequal, divisive and stratifying, with certain
nodes in the networks of online communities being more important than others (Dobson, 2003, p.
19). Digital technology may very well be used from a top-down perspective, as was also the case in
Iran with authorities gathered information about who was interacting with foreign servers and acting
upon this information (Christensen, 2009). Not only the citizens have more information and net-
working possibilities available than ever before to act upon, monitoring capabilities of digital tech-
nology combined with increasing possibilities for data storage and sorting, marketers and nation
states have access to unprecedented amounts of information about customers and citizens (Andre-
jevic, 2009).
On a positive note, I observe that in connected societies, the Internet is considered and used, as
a new arena for political participation and action, both by established political communities, as well
as by activist communities, resulting in lowering the threshold for participation and action, with new
and different forms for engaging in politics, sometimes with the political even popping up in other
non outspokenly political communities all over the socio-cultural landscape.
From the perspective of transdisciplinarity, our goal is to understand the present world
(Nicolescu, 2001, p. 46). I claim that the concept of citizenship is vital in this quest to understand
contemporary societies with its power relations and political struggles. Nicolescu (2001, p. 73) ar-
gues in his manifesto that individual and social evolution condition each other. The meaning and
direction of this co-evolution I believe is impossible to address without attending to citizenship and
its meanings. Understanding citizenship as participation in political communities, with communities
as ensembles of people addressing the organization of society and making sense of this address in
a similar way, emphasize meaning-making. Nicolescu (2001 p. 95) laments the dawn of human
history when science and culture were inseparably united with questions of the meaning of life and
human organization. Late modern reflexivity is about reclaiming meaning in a time with diminishing
tripleC 9(2): 644-656, 2011 655
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
importance of traditions and religion. Instead we turn to ourselves as individuals constructed and
given meaning through the networks and communities we adhere to. Citizenship and political
communities is one facet of this meaning making practice in late modernity and should be studied
as such.
References
Andrejevic, M. (2007). I spy: Surveillance and power in the interactive era. Lawrence, KS: University Press of Kansas.
Andrejevic, M. (2009). Critical media studies 2.0: An interactive upgrade. Interactions.Studies in Communication and Cul-
ture, 1(1), 35-52.
Arsenjuk, L. (2005). Introduktion till Jacques Rancière. Fronesis. Det politiska, 19-20, 86-95.
Barbalet, J. M. (1998). Citizenship: Rights, struggle and class inequality. Milton Keynes, UK: Open University Press.
Bauman, Z. (2001). The individualized society. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press..
Beck, U. (1995). Att uppfinna det politiska: Bidrag till en teori om reflexiv modernisering. Göteborg, SE: Daidalos.
Beck, U. (1998). Risksamhället: På väg in i en annan modernitet. Göteborg, SE: Daidalos.
Bellamy, R. (2008). Citizenship: A very short introduction. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
Benkler, Y. (2006). The wealth of networks: How social production transforms markets and freedom. New Haven, CT: Yale
University Press.
Bennett, L. W., & Entman R. M. (2001). The big spin: Communication and the transformation of pluralist democracy. In L. W.
Bennett, & R. M. Entman (Eds.), Mediated politics: Communication in the future of democracy (pp. 279-298). Cam-
bridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Bentivegna, S. (2006). Rethinking politics in the world of ICT. In European Journal of Communication. 21(3), 295-309.
Boggs, C. (2000). The end of politics: Corporate power and the decline of the public sphere. New York, NY: Guilford Press.
Bosniak. L. (2006). The citizen and the alien: Dilemmas of contemporary membership. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University
Press.
Bruns, A. (2009). Social media: Tools for user-generated content: Social drivers behind growing consumer participation in
user-led content generation: Volume 2: User Engagement Strategies. Everleigh, UK: Smart Services CRC.
Camauêr, L. (2000). Feminism, citizenship and the media: An ethnographic study of identity processes within four women’s
associations. Stockholm, SE: Institutionen för Journalistik Medier och Kommunikation (JMK).
Carter, A., & Stokes G. (1998). Liberal democracy and its critics. In A. Carter, & G. Stokes (Eds.), Liberal democracy and its
critics: Perspectives in contemporary political thought (Introduction). Cambridge, UK: Polity Press.
Castells. M. (2001). The internet galaxy: Reflections on the Internet, business and society. Oxford, UK: Oxford University
Press.
Castles, S., & Davidson, A. (2000). Citizenship and migration: Globalization and the politics of belonging. London, UK:
MacMillian Press.
Christensen, C. (2009, July 28). Iran: Networked dissent. Le Monde Diplomatique.
Coleman, S., & Blumler, J.G. (2009). The Internet and democratic citizenship: Theory, practice and policy. Cambridge, UK:
Cambridge University Press
Cruikshank, B. (1999). The will to empower: Democratic citizens and other subjects. Ithaca, NY: Cornwell University Press
Dahlgren, P. (2001). The public sphere and the net: Structure, space and communication. In L. W. Bennett, & R. M. Entman
R. M. (Eds.), Mediated politics: Communication in the future of democracy (pp. 33-55). Cambridge, UK: Cambridge
University Press.
Dahlgren, P. (2006). Civic identity and net activism: The frame of radical democracy. In L. Dahlberg, & E. Siapera (Eds.),
Radical democracy and the Internet: Interrogating theory and practice (pp. 55-72). London, UK: Palgrave MacMillan.
Delanty, G. (2002). Communitarianism and citizenship. In E. F. Isin, & B. S. Turner (Eds.), Handbook of citizenship studies
(pp. 159-174). London, UK: Sage.
Dobson, A. (2003). Citizenship and the environment. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
Dryzek, J. (2000). Deliberative democracy and beyond: Liberals, critics, contestations. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Ekelin, A. (2007). The work to make eParticipation work. Blekinge Institute of Technology Doctoral Dissertation Series No
2007: 11. Karlskrona: Blekinge Institute of Technology.
Fagerfjord, A., & Storsul, T. (2007). Questioning convergence. In T. Storsul, & D. Stuedahl (Eds.), Ambivalence towards
convergence: Digitalization and media change. Göteborg, SE: Nordicom.
Fishkin, J.S. (1991). Democracy and deliberation: New directions for democratic reform. New Haven, CT: Yale University
Press.
656 Jakob Svensson
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Frau-Meigs, D. (2007). Convergence, Internet governance and cultural diversity. In T. Storsul, & D. Stuedahl (Eds.), Am-
bivalence towards convergence: Digitalization and media change. Göteborg, SE: Nordicom.
Fukuyama, F. (1992). The end of history and the last man. New York, NY: Maxwell Macmillan International.
Giddens, A. (1991). Modernity and self-identity: Self and society in the late modern age. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press.
Hoffman, J. (2004). Citizenship beyond the state. London, UK: Sage.
Horkheimer, M. (1947). Eclipse of reason. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
Isin, E. F., & Wood, P. (1999). Citizenship and identity. London: Sage.
Isin, E. F., & Turner, B. S. (Eds.). (2002). Handbook of citizenship studies. London: Sage.
Jenkins, H. (2006). Convergence culture: Where old and new media collide. New York, NY: New York University Press.
Kivisto, P., & Faist, T. (2007). Citizenship: Discourse, theory and transnational prospects. Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishing.
Linklater, A. (2002). Cosmopolitan citizenship. In E. F. Isin, & B. S. Turner (Eds.), Handbook of citizenship studies (pp. 317-
332). London, UK: Sage.
Lister, R. (2002). Sexual citizenship. In E. F. Isin, & B. S. Turner (Eds.), Handbook of citizenship studies (pp. 191-208).
London, UK: Sage.
Lüders, M. (2007). Convergent forms of communication? In T. Storsul, & D. Stuedahl (Eds.), Ambivalence towards conver-
gence: Digitalization and media change. Göteborg, SE: Nordicom.
McNair, B. (2000). Journalism and democracy: An evaluation of the political public sphere. London, UK: Routledge.
Nicolescu, B. (2002). The manifesto of transdisciplinarity. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.
Nord, L. (2008). Medier utan politik. En studie av de svenska riksdagspartiernas syn på press, radio och TV. Stockholm, SE:
Santérus Förlag.
Olsson, A. R. (2006). När medborgarna tystnar. In B. Djörke, L. Ilshammer, P. Karlberg, K. Klein, L. Niklasson, T. Ohlin, A.
R. Olsson, K.-E. Tallmo, G. Watt, & I. Åhman-Eklund (Eds.), Med- eller Motborgare? Nåt jävla inflytande ska man väl
ha i en demokrati (pp. 67-79). Sundsvall, SE: Offentliga Rummet.
Peterson, O., Westholm, A., & Blomberg, G. (1989). Medborgarnas Makt. Stockholm, SE: Carlsson Bokförlag.
Pocock, J. G. A. (1995). The ideal of citizenship since classical times. In R. Beiner (Ed.), Theorizing citizenship (pp. 29-52).
Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.
Roberts, B. (2009). Beyond the ‘networked public sphere’: Politics, participation and technics in web 2.0. FibreCulture, 14.
Retrived from http://journal.fibreculture.org/issue14/issue14_roberts.html.
Schuck, P. H. (2002). Liberal citizenship. In E. F. Isin, & B. S. Turner (Eds.), Handbook of citizenship studies (pp. 130-144).
London, UK: Sage.
Shirky, C. (2009). Here comes everybody: How change happens when people come together. London, UK: Penguin.
Smith, R. M. (2002). Modern citizenship. In E. F. Isin, & B. S. Turner (Eds.), Handbook of citizenship studies (pp. 105-116).
London, UK: Sage.
Smith, S. (2009). Mediated citizenship in local issues discussion forums. Paper presented at the Mediated Citizenship con-
ference, University of Leeds, 17-18 September 2009.
Storsul, T., & Stuedahl, D. (2007). Introduction: Ambivalence towards convergence. In T. Storsul, & D. Stuedahl (Eds.),
Ambivalence towards convergence: Digitalization and media change. Göteborg, SE: Nordicom.
Svensson, J. (2008). Kommunikation, medborgarskap och deltagardemokrati. En studie av medborgarutskotten i Helsing-
borg, Lund Studies in Media and Communication 10. Lund: Sociologiska institutionen.
Svensson, A. (2010). Young men, ICTs and sports: Fan cultures and civic cultures. In T. Olsson, & P. Dahlgren (Eds.),
Young people, ICTs and democracy: Theories, policies, identities, and websites. Göteborg, SE: Nordicom
Terranova, T. (2004). Network culture: Politics for the information age. London, UK: Pluto Press.
Thompson Klein, J., Grossenbacher-Mansuy, W., Häberli, R., Bill, A, Scholz, R. W., & Welti, M. (Eds.). (2001). Transdisci-
plinarity: Joint Problem Solving among Science, Technology, and Society. Basel: Birkhauser Verlag.
Turner, B. S. (1994). Postmodern culture/ modern citizens. In B. van Steenberger (Ed.), The condition of citizenship
(pp.153-168). London, UK: Sage.
About the Author
Jakob Svensson
Dr. Jakob Svensson (Karlstads universitet) has a PhD in Media and Communication Studies (12 June 2008). His particular
interest is in Civic Communication and the construction of citizenship through communicative practices. Jakob is currently
holding a position of an assistant professor in Media and Communication Studies at Karlstad University and is the director of
the research network HumanIT (www.kau.se/en/humanit).