tripleC 9(2): 624-631, 2011
ISSN 1726-670X
http://www.triple-c.at
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Computer Science is not Enough
John K. Bennett
*
and S. Revi Sterling
**
* jkb@colorado.edu, ATLAS Institute, University of Colorado at Boulder, USA
** revi.sterling@colorado.edu , ATLAS Institute, University of Colorado at Boulder, USA
Abstract: Despite huge investment, and the best of intentions, most development projects fail. This is particularly true of
Information and Communication Technology for Development (ICTD) projects. We contend that a significant contributor to
this failure is the lack of breadth in project design and implementation, and in the training of project implementers. Success-
ful ICTD interventions, in addition to being based on the best computer science research has to offer, must be guided by the
relevant social, cultural, political, economic and gender factors that underlie the interaction of the technology with the com-
munity into which it is being placed. We therefore argue that efforts to distance computer science from the broader context
of ICTD scholarship and practice are misguided. ICTD should be recognized as a truly interdisciplinary area of research and
practice. We further argue that ICTD as a discipline has a particular need for academic practitioners. We close with a compi-
lation of current known ICTD academic efforts worldwide.
Keywords: Information and Communication Technology for Development
Acknowledgement: The authors acknowledge the work of another tripleC effort – the Computing Community Consortium –
an effort of the Computing Research Association, and their efforts to define technology’s role in Global Development.
There are several active debates within the ICTD active community – is ICTD becoming a standa-
lone subject? If it remains a sub-discipline, under what department(s) should it live? These argu-
ments, however, are secondary to the more important question – are we doing ICT for Develop-
ment, or ICT and Development? We push for the primacy of the former, as the intent of ICTD is
actively to promote human and community development.
1. Computer Science and ICTD
1.1. The Digital Divide
The majority of the world’s population does not have adequate access to information or communi-
cation. Roughly 2.5 billion people in the Global South live on less than two dollars a day (Collins,
Morduch, Rutherfod and Ruthven, 2009). Among this group, several countries have less than 1%
internet penetration (ITU, 2009). Illiteracy, lack of education and training, lack of power and com-
munication infrastructure, and higher priority community development objectives combine to limit
the effectiveness of efforts to introduce information and communication technology (ICT)-based
development solutions. People in developing communities usually cannot benefit from the introduc-
tion of telemedicine, distance education, e-government, and other sophisticated Internet and tech-
nology-based strategies that are prevalent in the developed world.
1.2. The Need for Breadth
Despite billions of dollars invested with the best of intentions, there is a demonstrable lack of suc-
cess in achieving global and local development objectives. This is particularly true of Information
and Communication Technology for Development (ICTD) efforts. We contend that a significant
contributor to this failure is the lack of breadth in both the implementation of development, and in
the training of those who practice development. Those who work in development tend to communi-
cate only with those most aligned with their field. For example, food security experts rarely attend
community informatics conferences; health experts rarely attend ICTD conferences. Even re-
tripleC 9(2): 624-631, 2011 625
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
searchers and practitioners within the same community rarely cross paths (especially when there
are significant geographical distances between them), and journals go unread by the communities
who have contributed to the findings reported therein, who are therefore unable to put the recom-
mended outcomes into action. It is little wonder that the needle barely moves in the overall pro-
gress of under-developed communities.
Many of these concerns have been articulated in the three ACM/IEEE ICTD conferences to date.
However, while attendance at this conference is continues to grow, many of the presenters and
attendees are the same from year to year – a predominantly computer science-oriented group of
researchers and practitioners who themselves bemoan the disconnect in ICTD between the “ICT”
and the “D.” This separation is largely the result of both legacy and timing. Development studies
has been an area of scholarship and practice for over 60 years; mass communications depart-
ments have been working in ICTD (although it is called development communications in this space)
since the 1960s. Computer science is late to the game – yet often does not adequately acknow-
ledge or build upon development’s historical foundations. The underlying view that computer scien-
tists will save the world because other development sectors have not yet been successful in doing
so is naïve and overlooks the complexities of real-world development.
Information and Communication Technology is a critical component in global change strategies,
but it needs to be considered as a component of development rather than as a stand-alone devel-
opment sector. The eight UN Millennium Development Goals (none of which list ICTD access, use
and capacity building as top goals) have encouraged numerous articles about the transformative
role that ICT can and should play in attaining these goals (Gerster and Zimmerman, 2005; InfoDev,
2006). While the MDGs perhaps can be criticized for their normative approach to global iniquities,
they have galvanized and coordinated efforts across industry, academia, practitioners, multilateral
agencies and foundations, and NGOs. ICTD, especially the ICTD efforts grounded in computer
Science, would do well to be as inclusive and cohesive.
1.3. ICT for Development vs. ICT and Development
Mainstream computer science research has the potential to drive ICTD innovation, while at the
same time contributing to mainstream “First World” research and development efforts. There are
few limits to the hardware and software systems that computer science can bring to bear upon the
seemingly-limitless problems that result from sustained community and regional under-
development. The current approach – creating technologies based primarily upon our understand-
ing and standpoint – perpetuates a model of ICT and Development, where we are technical experts
whose talents can be used in development interventions. In contrast, creating technologies that
have the potential to catalyze social change, and mapping human needs to technologies that di-
rectly respond to specific development problems represents ICT for Development.
In a time of stagnant or declining enrolments matched with anxiety myths about the health of the
technology sector, ICTD is a natural draw for students and faculty who aspire to greater impact.
Yet, academic instruction and research in ICTD is limited to the extent that interdisciplinary lin-
eages exist and support ICTD done “right.” There is a critical need to develop institutional infra-
structure and funding support models for the academician who is 50% computer science; 25%
mass communication, information systems and sociology; and 25% development studies. This
need is not unique to computer science departments; social science and humanities programs that
have traditionally been the home of graduate development students cannot remain effective without
the ability to leverage the power and near-ubiquity of modern ICT. The list of known academic
ICTD efforts, listed in the Appendix, demonstrates the breadth of ICTD topics and home depart-
ments representative of this interrelated field. Master’s program designed to offer a holistic educa-
tion in the interrelated nature of development do exist – there are programs at the University of
Manchester (UK), Universidad Rey Juan Carlos, University of Stockholm, University of Salzburg,
and a joint academic program between the Hasso Plattner Institute and University of Capetown.
However, the fear of the interdisciplinary disciplinary field pervades – how can we ensure sufficient
626 John K. Bennett and S. Revi Sterling
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
depth in the presence of breadth? This argument is not new – interdisciplinary research and educa-
tion programs routinely face such questions, despite demonstrated funding and research success.
Universities tend to be conservative when it comes to organizational structure. Even as we ar-
gue against academic silos, we fight to preserve the purity and primacy of our historic intellectual
turf. This contradiction is emblematic of the need cross-cutting academic programs that can focus
the intellectual breadth of the entire campus upon ICTD education and research, and in which fac-
ulty (especially junior faculty) are rewarded for applying their domain proficiency in larger context of
development.
2. The Need for Academic Practitioners
Universities have long enjoyed a reputation for advancing learning through service, although the
reality is that many such efforts contribute to a schism between research and praxis. Given the
potential for ICTD to support a rich assortment of development strategies, universities need to
graduate experts who can help bridge the gap between the advantages of the networked informa-
tion society, and those with the greatest potential to benefit if issues of access, social equity, sus-
tainability, and appropriate design and distribution are addressed. However, the focus has to re-
main on people – if ICTD experts are not focused on actually serving human need, it’s not devel-
opment.
As a research area, ICTD is just now emerging as a clearly identifiable focus – there are perhaps
a half dozen respected ICTD journals, and the premier conference in the field is less than four
years old. A 2010 report shows that the field is growing, with several hundred academic research-
ers and several thousand graduate students working in some aspect of ICTD (Heeks, 2010). Al-
though ICTD is emerging as a formal discipline at several of universities internationally, only a few
programs related to ICTD exist in the United States. These programs primarily cater to the doctoral
student, although there is a trend towards master’s level programs, including ICTD certificate curri-
cula and the announcement of two Master’s degrees in ICTD to bring the total “practitioner” pro-
grams worldwide to six – of which five are in the European Union. Of the 100 ICTD courses taught
at Universities worldwide, only 20% are taught in computer science departments.
If computer science is late to the game, American universities are also overdue in recognizing
the value of the ICTD academic practitioner as a driving force for effective ICTD development and
deployment, whose efforts will in turn sustain ICTD research and scholarship.
More than ever, we need to develop and support programs that represent a commitment to chal-
lenge both the academic silos and chasms in development that serve to perpetuate the inequities
of underdevelopment. ICTD academic programs need to build on existing on-campus expertise and
strength in many of the core areas that define the discipline, which will provide a focal point for both
practice and research. The interdisciplinary nature of ICTD demands us to create interdisciplinary
programs that make people more capable learners, more innovative teachers, more creative think-
ers, more effective leaders and more engaged global citizens.
Instead of the focus on short-term research projects and discussions about tenure in ICTD, pro-
grams would be better served to train academic practitioners to strategically and efficiently utilize
technology to help facilitate health, education, civil service and poverty alleviation initiatives all over
the world, as well as to connect these efforts to amplify their impact. To this end, students will need
to both specialize in the technical and social aspects of ICT while acquiring a broad foundation in
development studies, public health, social sciences and assessment methods, in order to make a
positive difference in the complex and interrelated systems of community and economic develop-
ment. In order for ICT-based development interventions to succeed, technological considerations
must be balanced with social, cultural, political, gender and other issues not related to the chosen
technology. Only when students are channelling human needs into technical solutions, we can say
that we are “doing” development.
tripleC 9(2): 624-631, 2011 627
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Appendix: Known ICTD Courses
Institution
Course Title
Level
Home Department
Agder University &
Mzumbe University
ICT in Development
G(grad)
American University
Nations, Policy & Information Technology
G
Kogod School of Business
BRAC University
Development Informatics
G
Development Studies
Butler University
International Communications Systems
U (under-
grad)
Journalism
CalTech
Product Design for the Developing World
U
Carnegie Mellon Uni-
versity
Human-Computer Interaction in the Develop-
ing World
G
School of Computer Science
Carnegie Mellon Uni-
versity
Technology and Global Development
School of Computer Science
Carnegie Mellon Uni-
versity
iSTEP: Technology Field Research in De-
veloping Communities
School of Computer Science
Carnegie Mellon Uni-
versity
Technology for Developing Communities
School of Computer Science
Carnegie Mellon Uni-
versity
Technology and Global Development
U
School of Computer Science
Carnegie Mellon Uni-
versity
Technology and Policy for Disaster and
Humanitarian Response
G
School of Computer Science
Colorado State Uni-
versity
Technology in Community-Based Develop-
ment
G
Intl Institute for Sustainable
Development
Copenhagen Business
School
IT, Institutions and Development
Dominican University
Community Informatics
G
Library and Information Science
Finnish Virutal Univer-
sity
ICT for Development
George Mason Uni-
versity
Managing the Digital Divide
G
School of Public Policy
Georgia Tech
Computing for Social Good/Computing for
Good (C4G)
U/G
International Affairs and Com-
puter Science
Georgia Tech
Science, Technology & International Affairs
U
International Affairs and Com-
puter Science
Georgia Tech
Computers, Communication & International
Development
G
International Affairs and Com-
puter Science
Global Virtual Univer-
sity
ICT in Development
Indiana University
Globalization and Information
G
School of Informatics
IIT Bombay
ICT, Gender and Development
Psychology
IIT Bombay
Information and Communication Technolo-
gies For Socio-Economic Development
Indian Institute of
Technology Delhi
Electronic Governance
U
Sociology
KTH Sweden
Introduction to ICT for Development
Loyola College (MD)
Community Informatics/Community Tele-
centers
G
Computer Science
MIT
ICT4D: Information and Communication
Technologies for Development
Health Sciences, Computer
Science
628 John K. Bennett and S. Revi Sterling
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
MIT
Launching Mobile Ventures for the Next
Billion Consumers
Health Sciences, Computer
Science
MIT
Dlab II - ICT4D
Center for Developmental
Comm.
Michigan State Uni-
versity
ICT for Development
U
Department of Telecommunica-
tion
Michigan State Uni-
versity
ICT Global Corps Field Study
U
Department of Telecommunica-
tion
Monash University
Social informatics
G
Faculty of Information Technol-
ogy
MOP Vaishnav Col-
lege for Women
Information & Communication Technologies
G
Communications
National University Of
Singapore
State & Civil Society In The Information Age
Communications and New Media
Programme
National University Of
Singapore
ICTs & Development
Communications and New Media
Programme
NYU
Information and Communication Technolo-
gies (ICT) for Developing Regions
Computer Science
NYU
New Approaches to Digital Learning (Educa-
tional Technologies in Global Context)
Educational Communications
Örebro University
Egovernment Systems in Developing Count-
ries
G
School of Business
Queen's University
Advanced Studies in Information and Com-
munication Technology
U
Sociology
Royal Holloway, Uni-
versity of London
Information and Communication Technolo-
gies for Development
U
Geography
Royal Holloway, Uni-
versity of London
ICT4D Short Courses
Royal Institute of
Technology in Stock-
holm
Doctoral seminar on Social and community
informatics
G
SUNY - Albany
Social and Community Informatics
U
Department of Information Stud-
ies
Syracuse
Technology as Public Good
G
Community and Information
Technology Institute
Teri University (India)
Science, technology and sustainable devel-
opment
G
MDP Program
Texas State University
International Communication Issues
G
Journalism
Tulane University
Information Technology and International
Development
U
Payson Center for International
Dev.
Tulane University
Information and Communication Technolo-
gies for International Development: Global
Digital Divide
G
Payson Center for International
Dev.
U Capetown
ICT4D
U
Computer Science
U Indiana
Globalization and Information
G
School of Informatics
U Michigan
Digital Government I: Information Technology
and Democratic Politics
G
School of Information
U Michigan
Digital Government II: Information Technol-
ogy and Democratic Administration
G
School of Information
U Michigan
Community Information Corps Seminar
G
School of Information
U Michigan
Information Use in Communities
G
School of Information
University of Missouri
St. Louis
Development Communication
tripleC 9(2): 624-631, 2011 629
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
U Toronto
Community Informatics
G
School of Information
U Toronto
Digital Divides
G
School of Information
U Wisconsin
Linking Information Technology and Com-
munity Organization Information Practices
U
Sociology
UC Berkeley
Social Entrepreneurs in ICTD
School of Information
UC Berkeley
ICT for Development: Context, Strategies and
Impacts
School of Information
UC Berkeley
Graduate Reading Seminar on ICT and
Development
G
School of Information
UC Berkeley
Information and Communications Technology
for Development
School of Information
UC Berkeley
User Interface Design and Development
G
School of Information
UC Berkeley
Governanace of the E-conomy
U
Political Science
UC Berkeley
Designing Rural Computing Applications
G
School of Information
UC Berkeley and CMU
An Information and Communications Tech-
nology (ICT) Framework for Developing
Regions
U
UC Santa Cruz
Technology Targeted at Social Issues
Computer Science
UC Santa Cruz
Information and Computing Technology for
Development
Computer Science
Universidad Católica
Boliviana
ICT for Development
Universidad Com-
plutense de Madrid
Las Tecnologías de Información y Comuni-
caciones como herramientas de Desarrollo
Humano: Brechas y oportunidades digitales
Universidad
Politécnica de Madrid
TIC y Desarrollo Humano
University of Brighton
Information and Communications Policy
University of Brighton
Communications and Development
University of Brighton
Community Informatics
University of Brighton
The Network Society
University of California
at Los Angeles
Information Services in Diverse Cultural
Communities
U
Dept of Information Studies
University of Colorado,
Boulder
Graduate Seminar on ICTD
G
ATLAS Institute
University of Colorado,
Boulder
ICTD Projects Course
G
ATLAS Institute
University of Colorado,
Boulder
Fieldwork Methods for ICTD Practitioners
G
ATLAS Institute
University of Exeter
Building Sustainable Communities: Regen-
eration and Development
G
Geography
University of Illinois
(UIUC)
Digital Divide: Policy Research and Com-
munity Empowerment
G
Library and Information Science
University of Illinois
(UIUC)
Community Informatics Concepts
G
Library and Information Science
University of Illinois
(UIUC)
Community Informatics Research and Theory
1
G
Library and Information Science
630 John K. Bennett and S. Revi Sterling
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
University of Illinois
(UIUC)
Social informatics
G
Library and Information Science
University of Kuopio
Information and Communication Technology
for Development
University of Manches-
ter
ICTs for Development
G
IDPM
University of Manches-
ter
ICTs and Social Economic Development
G
IDPM
University of Manches-
ter
E-Government
G
IDPM
University of Manches-
ter
ICTs in Practice
G
IDPM
University of Maryland
- Baltimore County
Women, Gender and Information Technology
University of Missouri
Digital Divide: Race, Class, Education and
Technology
G
Law
University of Oslo,
Norway
Implementing Health Information Systems
Programme from Anthropological Perspective
G
Department of Informatics
University of Oxford
ICT for Development
G
Oxford Internet Institute
University of Salzburg
Technologies and Humanities I
CASRICTS
University of Salzburg
Technologies and Humanities II
CASRICTS
University of Salzburg
Politics & ICTs
CASRICTS
University of San
Francisco
International Telecomm Technology
School of Business and Man-
agement
University of San
Francisco
Telecommunication Policy and Strategy
School of Business and Man-
agement
University of San
Francisco
Special Topics
School of Business and Man-
agement
University of Southern
California
Research Seminar on Mobile phones, On-
Line Community, and Social Change
G
University of the
Philippines
Special Topics - ICTD
U
Public Administration and Gov-
ernance
University of Toledo
Community Informatics
U
Sociology
University of Trento
CT4SD: Information and Communication
Technologies for Sustainable Development
G
School of Information and Tele-
communicaiton
University of Washing-
ton
Digital Games Research for ICTD
Technical Communication (Engi-
neering)
University of Washing-
ton
Capstone Projects for ICTD
U
Computer Science & Engineer-
ing
University of Washing-
ton
Technology for Low-Income Regions
U
Computer Science & Engineer-
ing
University of Washing-
ton
Information in Social Context
G
School of Information
University of Washing-
ton
ICTD Seminar
G
Computer Science & Engineer-
ing
University of Washing-
ton
Mobile/Cloud Applications for Emerging
Regions
U/G
Computer Science & Engineer-
ing
University of Washing-
ton
ICTD Design Experience
U
Computer Science & Engineer-
ing
University of Washing-
ton
Computing for the Developing World
G
Computer Science & Engineer-
ing
University of Washing-
ton
International Communication and National
Development
tripleC 9(2): 624-631, 2011 631
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
Wageningen Univer-
sity
Technography, Researching Technology and
Development
References
Collins, D., Morduch, J., Rutherford, S. & Ruthven, O. (2009). Portfolios of the Poor. How the World's Poor Live on $2 a
Day. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Gerster, R. & Zimmerman, S. (2005). Up-scaling pro-poor ICT-policies and practices. Swiss Agency for Development and
Cooperation. Retrieved 20 October, 2008 from
http://www.choike.org/2009/eng/informes/3010.html#ICT%20role%20in%20achieving%20the%20MDGs
Heeks, R. (2010). ICT-for-Development Research. Size and Growth. Retrieved 9 February, 2010 from
http://ict4dblog.wordpress.com
InfoDev. (2006). Improving health, connecting people. The role of ICTs in the health sector of developing countries. Re-
trieved February, 2010 from http://www.asksource.info/pdf/framework2.pdf
ITU. (2009). The World in 2009. ICT Facts and Figures. Retrieved 14 January, 2010 from http://www.itu.int/ITU-
D/ict/material/Telecom09_flyer.pdf
About the Authors
John K. Bennett
Dr. Bennett is the Director of the ATLAS Institute and Archuleta Professor of Computer Science at the University of Colo-
rado at Boulder. From 2002 to 2007, he served as the Associate Dean for Education in the College of Engineering and
Applied Science. He joined the CU-Boulder faculty in 2000, after serving on the faculty of Rice University for 11 years. He
received his Ph.D. in 1988 from the University of Washington. Bennett's primary research interests are broadly in the area of
distributed systems, and more narrowly in distributed information management, distributed robotic macro-sensors, and the
use of information and communication technology to positively impact developing communities. He is the past President of
the Governing Board of Engineers Without Borders – USA.
S. Revi Sterling
Dr. Sterling is the Faculty Director of ICTD graduate studies at the ATLAS Institute. Her research interests include Com-
munity ICT readiness, ICT curriculum development, Gender and ICTD, informed consent in ICTD research, fieldwork meth-
ods, value-centric design, and the practical application of ICTD to basic service engineering (BSE) initiatives, working with
UN-GAID and other cross-sector ICTD initiatives. She has ongoing fieldwork in East Africa, India, and the Peruvian Ama-
zon.