tripleC 9(2): 624-631, 2011 625
CC: Creative Commons License, 2011.
searchers and practitioners within the same community rarely cross paths (especially when there
are significant geographical distances between them), and journals go unread by the communities
who have contributed to the findings reported therein, who are therefore unable to put the recom-
mended outcomes into action. It is little wonder that the needle barely moves in the overall pro-
gress of under-developed communities.
Many of these concerns have been articulated in the three ACM/IEEE ICTD conferences to date.
However, while attendance at this conference is continues to grow, many of the presenters and
attendees are the same from year to year – a predominantly computer science-oriented group of
researchers and practitioners who themselves bemoan the disconnect in ICTD between the “ICT”
and the “D.” This separation is largely the result of both legacy and timing. Development studies
has been an area of scholarship and practice for over 60 years; mass communications depart-
ments have been working in ICTD (although it is called development communications in this space)
since the 1960s. Computer science is late to the game – yet often does not adequately acknow-
ledge or build upon development’s historical foundations. The underlying view that computer scien-
tists will save the world because other development sectors have not yet been successful in doing
so is naïve and overlooks the complexities of real-world development.
Information and Communication Technology is a critical component in global change strategies,
but it needs to be considered as a component of development rather than as a stand-alone devel-
opment sector. The eight UN Millennium Development Goals (none of which list ICTD access, use
and capacity building as top goals) have encouraged numerous articles about the transformative
role that ICT can and should play in attaining these goals (Gerster and Zimmerman, 2005; InfoDev,
2006). While the MDGs perhaps can be criticized for their normative approach to global iniquities,
they have galvanized and coordinated efforts across industry, academia, practitioners, multilateral
agencies and foundations, and NGOs. ICTD, especially the ICTD efforts grounded in computer
Science, would do well to be as inclusive and cohesive.
1.3. ICT for Development vs. ICT and Development
Mainstream computer science research has the potential to drive ICTD innovation, while at the
same time contributing to mainstream “First World” research and development efforts. There are
few limits to the hardware and software systems that computer science can bring to bear upon the
seemingly-limitless problems that result from sustained community and regional under-
development. The current approach – creating technologies based primarily upon our understand-
ing and standpoint – perpetuates a model of ICT and Development, where we are technical experts
whose talents can be used in development interventions. In contrast, creating technologies that
have the potential to catalyze social change, and mapping human needs to technologies that di-
rectly respond to specific development problems represents ICT for Development.
In a time of stagnant or declining enrolments matched with anxiety myths about the health of the
technology sector, ICTD is a natural draw for students and faculty who aspire to greater impact.
Yet, academic instruction and research in ICTD is limited to the extent that interdisciplinary lin-
eages exist and support ICTD done “right.” There is a critical need to develop institutional infra-
structure and funding support models for the academician who is 50% computer science; 25%
mass communication, information systems and sociology; and 25% development studies. This
need is not unique to computer science departments; social science and humanities programs that
have traditionally been the home of graduate development students cannot remain effective without
the ability to leverage the power and near-ubiquity of modern ICT. The list of known academic
ICTD efforts, listed in the Appendix, demonstrates the breadth of ICTD topics and home depart-
ments representative of this interrelated field. Master’s program designed to offer a holistic educa-
tion in the interrelated nature of development do exist – there are programs at the University of
Manchester (UK), Universidad Rey Juan Carlos, University of Stockholm, University of Salzburg,
and a joint academic program between the Hasso Plattner Institute and University of Capetown.
However, the fear of the interdisciplinary disciplinary field pervades – how can we ensure sufficient